Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nirvana baby to sue…

281 replies

Toffu · 25/08/2021 08:38

I’ve just read an article about the man who’s photo as a baby was used on the cover of Nevermind.

He is planning to sue the band for violating pornography laws and claims that his parents never signed a release allowing Nirvana to use the photo.

He alleges Nirvana "used child pornography depicting Spencer as an essential element of a record promotion scheme commonly utilized in the music industry to get attention, wherein album covers posed children in a sexually provocative manner to gain notoriety, drive sales, and garner media attention, and critical reviews." He says he’s suffered and will co it is to suffer lifelong damages.

While a lot of people (judging by online comments) seem to think it’s a money grab, I’m inclined to agree with him. Imagine if Michael Jackson or Take That had done this? Is it considered ok because it’s rock music, an arty shot and he’s a boy? Am I being unreasonable to think actually it’s really not ok?

OP posts:
QuirkyUsername · 25/08/2021 10:07

A) It was airbrushed out for years and years. You may not have noticed it because it wasn't there for a long time.

B) The reason it has potentially 'damaged' his reputation is because he's the one yelling from the roof tops it was him

C) He was never concerned about it being pornographic while he was earning money with interviews and recreating the shots

D) It's not sexually suggestive and anyone who thinks it is perhaps needs to have a good look at themselves.

3ormorecharactersss · 25/08/2021 10:06

Hasn’t been got a huge never mind tattoo? And he’s down lots of interviews saying how much he loved being that baby and he said it had been lucrative for him?

It’s a tough one because I’d love to be that baby! I’d be so damned proud. And I’ve never seen it as pornographic, same as I’ve never seen any art that contains nudity as pornographic. However, it’s his image so I guess it’s his feeling on the subject matter.

I highly doubt he will win though. Money was exchanged and signatures provided.

BeauxRingarde · 25/08/2021 10:05

I think some of these comments begin to prove his claims though....

category12 · 25/08/2021 10:04

I completely agree. It's one of the most iconic album covers and undoubtedly brought Nirvana a lot of money.

It's an iconic cover only because the band were iconic. The album cover didn't make them successful. If they'd disappeared without trace so would the album cover.

MurielSpriggs · 25/08/2021 10:01

I do largely agree, but if a naked girl was on the front and then years later said her view was that it was pornographic, would you dismiss that too?

I don't understand why you think it would be different?

category12 · 25/08/2021 10:01

I do largely agree, but if a naked girl was on the front and then years later said her view was that it was pornographic, would you dismiss that too?

Yes, you wouldn't even be able to see any genitals if it was a girl.

It is not pornographic.

AntiSocialDistancer · 25/08/2021 10:01

@RoxytheRexy

I think I agree with him. And even if it is a money grab then I’m ok with that too. I’m sure the record company can afford it
I completely agree. It's one of the most iconic album covers and undoubtedly brought Nirvana a lot of money.

I don't mind if he wants a slice of that, and yes I agree that it's unpleasant to have your penis photo plastered globally and there is no legitimate way he could have consented.

jay55 · 25/08/2021 10:01

I feel for him, that image was used on millions of pieces of merchandise and he had no control over it.
And now it probably is an image shared amongst pedos.

I remember watching a TV show about the model in the Athena man and baby poster (the man not the baby) trying to sue for more money as the image had been used far more widely than in his original release. I don't think he got anywhere.

DrSbaitso · 25/08/2021 10:01

It's not pornographic but it was intended to be provocative and it is; it would still raise eyebrows today. It could have been shot or edited differently. Of course, then you would have lost some degree of the provocation. I suppose it depends on whether you think Nirvana and whatever they were trying to say needed that extra level of provocation by having the baby's penis clearly visible.

I'm not advocating for censorship, but it's surprising how often people try to be provocative and then get all surprised when they don't actually get universal approval.

Peacrock · 25/08/2021 09:58

@Balonzette

It's not pornographic! What an absolute disgusting and bizarre thing to say! Agree he just wants money out of it. How can he have suffered in ANY way, no way did anyone recognise him from that photo 😂 Ridiculous.
I do largely agree, but if a naked girl was on the front and then years later said her view was that it was pornographic, would you dismiss that too?
Confusedandshaken · 25/08/2021 09:58

We are going back to Victorian times if any depiction of human genitalia is considered pornographic.

DrSbaitso · 25/08/2021 09:58

I have always thought there were better ways to shoot a photo like that and wondered how the baby would feel when he grew up.

Branleuse · 25/08/2021 09:57

Thats not porn fgs

TheKeatingFive · 25/08/2021 09:55

Sounds like he should be taking it up with his parents

Balonzette · 25/08/2021 09:53

It's not pornographic! What an absolute disgusting and bizarre thing to say! Agree he just wants money out of it. How can he have suffered in ANY way, no way did anyone recognise him from that photo 😂 Ridiculous.

Nopetryagain · 25/08/2021 09:52

I am sure I saw one of those ‘Best Album’ countdown shows years ago and he was on it bragging about getting “laid” a lot as a result of being the ‘Nirvana baby’. Seemed pretty pleased with himself at the time.

TonTonMacoute · 25/08/2021 09:52

If he didn't go around telling everyone that he was the Nirvana baby then he wouldn't suffer, would he?

At the time the album came out taking your little baby swimming was quite a new thing. The fact that you could just put them in water and they floated and swam naturally, amazed everyone, and the images of these little babies swimming were everywhere.

He should get a proper job if he wants money.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 25/08/2021 09:51

ew.com/article/2016/09/22/nirvana-nevermind-album-cover-behind-scenes/

From a few years ago... For his skinny-dipping adventure, Spencer was paid $250 (standard hourly rate for a no-name model) and was later presented with a triple-platinum album by Ed Rosenblatt, president of Geffen Records.

category12 · 25/08/2021 09:51

I feel like his parents owe him $200.

Herecomesthesun70 · 25/08/2021 09:49

He's an attention seeker.
He has never mind tattooed on him and moans he's never met the band. Ffs

chatw0o0 · 25/08/2021 09:48

I can see there's more to this than meets the eye, but before I go off to Google some more, if he's claiming that his parents never signed a release allowing Nirvana to use the photo, they (his parents) have had since 1991 to do something about it!

Peacrock · 25/08/2021 09:46

I supposed the wider issue of children having images of themselves put into the public arena forever before they can consent themselves is interesting. I always wonder if in future this will be the case for the mummy bloggers who post every aspect of their children's lives online.

In this case be probably is after some easy money, why not really, I'd be tempted to do the same hah.

FleetwoodRaincoat · 25/08/2021 09:45

I wish people would stop confusing nudity with pornography. There is nothing remotely sexual or pornographic about this picture.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 25/08/2021 09:44

If there was a quiz question asking if baby's penis is visible I would've said no. 100%. that's how unremarkable it is - the actual underwater image is far more powerful than a body part that happens to be there.

He's a money grabbing twat.
Also wouldn't getting paid for a naked baby photo be considered child pornography?
It feels quite ironic that he claims it's pornography because he was never paid.
ah, well, Nevermind

Kanaloa · 25/08/2021 09:44

@Heckythump1

I've never seen the album before, but from a quick google, it's quite clearly his foot not his genitals. Nothing wrong with that photo at all!
No, it’s his penis. I don’t necessarily think that makes it wrong or gives him a solid case but it’s definitely his penis.