Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nirvana baby to sue…

281 replies

Toffu · 25/08/2021 08:38

I’ve just read an article about the man who’s photo as a baby was used on the cover of Nevermind.

He is planning to sue the band for violating pornography laws and claims that his parents never signed a release allowing Nirvana to use the photo.

He alleges Nirvana "used child pornography depicting Spencer as an essential element of a record promotion scheme commonly utilized in the music industry to get attention, wherein album covers posed children in a sexually provocative manner to gain notoriety, drive sales, and garner media attention, and critical reviews." He says he’s suffered and will co it is to suffer lifelong damages.

While a lot of people (judging by online comments) seem to think it’s a money grab, I’m inclined to agree with him. Imagine if Michael Jackson or Take That had done this? Is it considered ok because it’s rock music, an arty shot and he’s a boy? Am I being unreasonable to think actually it’s really not ok?

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 25/08/2021 10:59

It’s a representation of greed being such a part of human nature that we are born with it.

Interesting. I always saw it as, rather than being born with it, we are manipulated into it from babyhood. It's the fish hook that made me think that. Had it just been a randomly floating banknote, I might have had your interpretation.

Although you could also see it as childhood innocence, since the baby obviously doesn't know what he's looking at.

Whatever the interpretation, I didn't think you needed the penis to make the point. Perhaps to get the provocation.

ConstanceGracy · 25/08/2021 10:59
  1. there’s no such thing as child “porn” They’re child abuse images and 2) he was happy to pose as a grown up in the same way so it couldn’t have been that distressing for him! It IS a money grab.
JudgeJ · 25/08/2021 10:58

@MurielSpriggs

It's not pornographic (or "grim")!
But it's worth money to him, hence his actions. Kerching!
Tommika · 25/08/2021 10:58

HarrietsChariot

Your Nicola Sturgeon nudes example has different issues, not just the need of consent

If we ignore the right to privacy etc for nudes you don’t need any consent/permission to photograph someone in a public place
(Topless beach photos become a different issue which would be moral rather than legal - there are plenty paparazzi style celebrity nudes that get published, though they may or may not have been prearranged for publicity in some cases)

So if the Nicola Sturgeon photos had been legally taken with no need for consent, then it becomes the issue on what basis they are published.
You require consent / model release for ‘commercial use’ which does not cover all forms of publication. Advertise Scottish holidays with a picture of Nicola Sturgeon and it becomes commercial use
Put a picture of Nicola Sturgeon in the paper and though the paper is commercially sold the photos publication is not commercial use
Put Nicola Sturgeon on an album cover and though the cover is art there is the commercial use that the cover is ‘advertising’ the content

Many publishers will ask for model release whether it’s legally required or not, they just cover their back

If she is spotted on the beach topless and a paparazzi or anyone sends in a photo to the newspaper then it will get used with no legal need for her consent
If she’s topless in her garden and you fly a drone camera overhead then that’s an invasion of her privacy

gogohm · 25/08/2021 10:56

Cannot understand the fuss, it's a picture of a baby, the parents and photographer agreed a fee and it was known to be for the album cover. The person this guy should be going after is his own father for not getting a better deal (make no mistake this is about money). It's art not pornography - possibly wouldn't be done now but the shot is 30+ years old

Jengnr · 25/08/2021 10:55

He was a child model for an obscure band. His parents were paid at that rate. His picture was used on an album cover.

The fact the album went multi platinum is neither here nor there.

He’s a perfect example of life imitating art.

People need to stop sexualising babies. That’s what’s actually grim here.

Frodogo · 25/08/2021 10:53

Seems like an obvious money grab, especially given that he's recreated the photo as an adult. If he is bothered by it, why draw more attention to the fact that it's him in the photo?

It's not pornographic, but they should have done something to obscure his genitals. I do look askance at people who sell nude photos of their baby. It's his father he should be angry with, imo.

Ohpulltheotherone · 25/08/2021 10:47

Ffs no.

Whilst I agree NOW it would be weird and just not appropriate that is because of the shift in society and cultural norms / expectations. Not because it’s a particularly explicit photo.

In the late 80s and early 90s it was a different time. We did not view everything as sexualised.

I’m not suggesting child pornography wasn’t an issue because clearly is was.
But this photo is not sexualised in the slightest.

The parent made the choice on behalf of the baby. If they gave consent for him to be photographed and then used on the album then he should be suing them and not the band.

We make choices on behalf of our children every day, we have to. They can’t do it themselves. They gave consent, end of.

TheRebelle · 25/08/2021 10:44

I feel for him, he couldn’t consent at the time and when he was a young adult recreating the photos the full implications of having your nude baby photo reproduced in the hundreds of thousands may not have been apparent to him. Regardless of whether we middle aged women think it is pornographic or not there will have been someone, somewhere who does and who has used it as such. I certainly would not be comfortable with a naked picture of me being out in the world without me having any control of it, whether people knew it was me or not.

I don’t have any nude pictures of my children at all, it’s not necessary, my mantra is in all photos of my kids they must be clothed and happy and it must be a photo I’d be happy to have of myself. We have a responsibility to our children and his parents failed in theirs.

ChaneySays · 25/08/2021 10:38

It’s a representation of greed being such a part of human nature that we are born with it.

Consolidated by the baby still apparently chasing the money in adulthood! 😂

ChaneySays · 25/08/2021 10:36

To be honest I'd be more angry with the parents who had him circumcised (unless it was for medical reasons of course)

Seriously? FO

I don't understand why you're offended by the comment above. IMO nobody should have parts of their genitals chopped off against their will.

Hemingwaycat · 25/08/2021 10:34

Paedophiles will always find content to fulfil their fantasies. Some of them will do this from completely innocent places, maybe they sit watching CBeebies for example? Who knows.

The point is this guy isn’t actually mentally scarred in any way by this, quite the opposite. He’s broke and he wants some money. He also clearly wants attention and perhaps infamy.

He’s quite a good looking guy so it’s a shame he’s such a desperate attention seeker, perhaps he could have pursued a career in modelling then he might not be so salty about an image of him his parents sold in 1990 for $200.

Samcro7 · 25/08/2021 10:34

He's done multiple interviews where he's said he thought it was great and he's slept with loads of women due to the fame. He also has Nevermind tattooed across his chest.... Sounds like he's really suffering from the effects of his picture being used....Hmm

OchNoAgain · 25/08/2021 10:33

If you sold me the nude photos of Nicola Sturgeon

Hold the bus! There are nude photos of Nicola Sturgeon floating about? Shock

Garriet · 25/08/2021 10:32

@User135644

What was the point of that album cover? Why would you want to put that on?
It’s a representation of greed being such a part of human nature that we are born with it.
BlankTimes · 25/08/2021 10:32

Sorry, not RTFT, but here's the photographer's account of how the album cover was shot.

flashbak.com/how-i-shot-the-cover-to-nirvanas-nevermind-419252/

category12 · 25/08/2021 10:31

sue

category12 · 25/08/2021 10:30

@Auntienumber8

I did not work in that field but have friends who are psychologists and one specialises in rehabilitating sex offenders.

Any picture of a child can have a sexual element for child sex offenders I remember reading how a raid found as well as high category pictures of child abuse many Mothercare catalogues.

There is nothing remotely sexual in that picture for the posters on this thread but I guarantee that paedophiles will have used that image.

Does that mean the babies and children in Mothercare catalogues should be able to sure Mothercare?
Auntienumber8 · 25/08/2021 10:29

I did not work in that field but have friends who are psychologists and one specialises in rehabilitating sex offenders.

Any picture of a child can have a sexual element for child sex offenders I remember reading how a raid found as well as high category pictures of child abuse many Mothercare catalogues.

There is nothing remotely sexual in that picture for the posters on this thread but I guarantee that paedophiles will have used that image.

DrSbaitso · 25/08/2021 10:29

Why shouldn't he seek money when his image was used to bring a lot of it in for other people?

GeorgiaMcGraw · 25/08/2021 10:29

I do find it funny that when he "recreated" the cover at 25 years old (not very well imo, arms in the wrong place and he can't help but look directly into the camera) he wanted to do it naked (it was in an NYPost article). The photographer told him to keep his trunks on. Less sweet and innocent on a 25 year old than a baby.

RoseRedRoseBlue · 25/08/2021 10:27

This reeks of money grabbing. I have seen an interview with this guy where he spoke of how pleased he was to have been part of such an iconic album/time.

category12 · 25/08/2021 10:26

I doubt many people would recognise this one for example.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Utero

Because it wasn't their breakthrough album and it doesn't have their best-known songs on it.

Howshouldibehave · 25/08/2021 10:25

I don’t see what nirvana did wrong. The parents agreed. If he’s not happy, he can take it up with them.

SunShinesBrightly · 25/08/2021 10:24

So what? It's his body and his image.

He has used the band and album cover to promote himself.
Maybe they will counter sue.

Swipe left for the next trending thread