Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nirvana baby to sue…

281 replies

Toffu · 25/08/2021 08:38

I’ve just read an article about the man who’s photo as a baby was used on the cover of Nevermind.

He is planning to sue the band for violating pornography laws and claims that his parents never signed a release allowing Nirvana to use the photo.

He alleges Nirvana "used child pornography depicting Spencer as an essential element of a record promotion scheme commonly utilized in the music industry to get attention, wherein album covers posed children in a sexually provocative manner to gain notoriety, drive sales, and garner media attention, and critical reviews." He says he’s suffered and will co it is to suffer lifelong damages.

While a lot of people (judging by online comments) seem to think it’s a money grab, I’m inclined to agree with him. Imagine if Michael Jackson or Take That had done this? Is it considered ok because it’s rock music, an arty shot and he’s a boy? Am I being unreasonable to think actually it’s really not ok?

OP posts:
SnottyLottie · 26/08/2021 19:55

I love the irony that he’s chasing money for a photo of him as a baby chasing money (and has chased money by recreating the photo of him chasing money).

Nevermind inception?

DottyHarmer · 26/08/2021 19:48

That’s absolutely irrelevant, @onanoff . You sign a contract. That’s it. Some people sign a contract which involves a share of profits, but most musicians/artists etc do a piece of work for a set price. You can’t claim decades later that you want a bigger price because something may have become iconic.

Plunger · 26/08/2021 19:46

He has recreated the album cover several times as a teenager and as an adult all be it wearing swimming trunks: 10th, 20th and 25th anniversaries of the release of Nevermind album. So much for finding the original caused him lifelong damage. Definitely a money Grab!

onanoff · 26/08/2021 19:44

I read that he was paid (or his parents were) $250 for the image

Given how much money the album made and how iconic that image is, i hope he gets a decent pay out now. Grohl and co can afford it

Mollymoostoo · 26/08/2021 19:34

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2015/jan/16/thats-me-picture-spencer-elden-nirvana-nevermind

He wasn't so bothered a few years ago...money grab.
If he wants paying, just own it and yes I guess he should be paid, but the law suit is a mockery to the real victims of abuse.

DrSbaitso · 26/08/2021 19:26

He's made comments in recent years about his mixed feelings over it and the photographer has confirmed he's had conversations along those lines.

If you can't change your mind about a naked baby picture, what can you change your mind about?

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 26/08/2021 19:22

He did at 25 too.

They picked the right baby for the money chasing for sure.

mamabear715 · 26/08/2021 19:17

Get over it, FFS!!

DrSbaitso · 26/08/2021 19:15

[quote Emmelina]www.dolly.com.au/lifestyle/im-the-nirvana-baby-9746[/quote]
He was 17 at the time of that interview.

DrJohnZoidberg · 26/08/2021 19:06

[quote Emmelina]www.dolly.com.au/lifestyle/im-the-nirvana-baby-9746[/quote]
Such a cringey interview because he’s been dining off it for life but is trying to make out it’s not a big deal.

ThanksForAllTheFish · 26/08/2021 18:11

For years I thought that it was an umbilical cord (edited it). The photo looked (to me) to represent humans are chasing money from the moment they are born - hence the baby swimming after cash right after it’s born.

Also if we are going down this route then there are a lot of paintings hanging in galleries around the world that will also be deemed as inappropriate and pornographic when really they are just art.

kurtney · 26/08/2021 18:01

Did somebody really link to In Utero and say not many people would recognise that album cover?!

🤣🤣🤣

Margerine78 · 26/08/2021 17:51

The guy is an absolute money-grabbing, attention-seeking twat. Like other folks have said above, he's been dining out on that image his entire life, and only recently decided to sue as he wanted Nirvana to collaborate on something with him and the manager didn't say yes straight away - something like that (it's online). So he had a sulk.

It's crap as well for kids that have genuinely been violated. It's up there with women who cry rape for attention, people won't take real victims seriously.

Spodge · 26/08/2021 17:50

Shouldn't he be suing his parents?

Pliudev · 26/08/2021 17:46

I always thought it was rather a lovely cover. My guess is it's a way for him to realise some easy money ie: not having to work for it. Is nakedness pornographic now?

FreddieMercurysCat · 26/08/2021 17:44

Personally, I think he’s full of shit. His parents allowed the image to be used whether they signed a waiver or not. They got paid, albeit not much. He’s recreated it as an adult. And now he just wants money. I don’t hold much with people like that.

DottyHarmer · 26/08/2021 16:30

I just spoke to a lawyer who works in this sort of area. He said that the old argument had absolutely no legs as the man’s claim would have had to have been against his own parents. So he has eventually found a lawyer who has come up with the “pornography” angle. His recreation of the cover and the fact that he hasn’t complained before will not help his case, though.

samyeagar · 25/08/2021 20:29

Nah. He's still the same money grabbing baby that he was 30 years ago.

MondayYogurt · 25/08/2021 15:49

At least it will get people thinking more about child's right to privacy. Just because you can exploit your child's image for profit doesn't mean it's morally right.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 25/08/2021 15:41

Agreed category12

You don’t buy an album to look at the cover. You buy it for the music.

As iconic as the cover is, the music is the reason people bought it.

category12 · 25/08/2021 15:36

And many, many people will indeed recognise that album cover

Yes indeed. I did instantly. Smile

The argument that It's one of the most iconic album covers and undoubtedly brought Nirvana a lot of money. is just flawed - well, yes it is iconic, but only because that album is iconic. Nobody saw the album cover and ran out to buy it on that basis alone - they heard the music, saw the band, then they bought the album.

torchh · 25/08/2021 15:27

@category12

I doubt many people would recognise this one for example. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Utero

Because it wasn't their breakthrough album and it doesn't have their best-known songs on it.

And many, many people will indeed recognise that album cover
SheldonesqueTheBstard · 25/08/2021 14:46

If he's been recreating the image, perhaps DGC Records should sue him for copyright infringement.

That really.

He has dined out on it long enough. Used it as a pulling line.

Going after more is the behaviour of an arse.

OhRene · 25/08/2021 14:35

All the years I've owned this album I never really looked well enough to see that it wasn't a foot. Hmm. I guess every day is a school day.

As for the story? I disagree it's a pornographic shot. It's an interesting, artistic photograph (though it's a shame it shows the penis). The dad was already paid by his photographer friend. Just because the kid thinks he should have got more than $200 is irrelevant. His parents made the decision when they had the legal rights to. Payment was made and the deal was done. No backsies, fella! Sorry.

Swipe left for the next trending thread