Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Darker · 26/08/2021 08:07

They don't really care about the environment. They just like a bit of anarchy. When it's pointed out the damage they do, they can say 'but climate crisis' and make themselves morally superior. They don't actually think about the people they are damaging. Until its brought up to them later.

Where do you get this from? ‘They’ are a diverse group of people united only by a call to action to do something about the climate crisis. Their motivations will vary widely.

54321nought · 26/08/2021 08:04

I get that, I mean that's only the same as I think of XR and its supporters. They don't really care about the environment. They just like a bit of anarchy. When it's pointed out the damage they do, they can say 'but climate crisis' and make themselves morally superior. They don't actually think about the people they are damaging. Until its brought up to them later .It like moral superiority on top of their privilege and they can pretend to be heroes.

Of course they care about the environment, that is why they are giving up their resources, time and personal freedom, it isn't fun

Of course they are not privileged. They are a complete cross section of society, rich. poor, all different back grounds and life experiences. Calling someone "privileged" has just become a way of trying to block out their message, without actually having any counter arguments.

Trying to make this about "morals" is also silly, it is about a war with against a lethal enemy, which will destroy our species and our world

Pretend to be heroes? What is your definition of a hero, exactly?

OP posts:
lannistunut · 26/08/2021 08:02

@Hekatestorch

You've claimed to speak for 'poor people' and 'vulnerable people' all the ways through the two threads - you don't speak for them. You have no idea what 'they' think - you are projecting your views onto a group of strangers.

You are doing the same with XR themselves, you have no idea that 'they' think either. You have no idea who 'they' are or what is motivating 'them'.

I am tired of people claiming to care about 'poor people' - and I am sick of the phrase 'poor people' too. When I was a 'poor person' I can tell you I thought exactly the same as I do now I am no longer a 'poor person' and I didn't need someone on the internet partonisingly saying what I wanted or didn't want for the future of the planet vs. getting to my (low paid, insecure) job.

People should speak for themselves and not invoke faux concern for 'poor people' - or indeed any made up group - as a cover.

End of rant.

Lockheart · 26/08/2021 08:02

@DdraigGoch

You want to know what XR could do that I'd actually support? How about actually targeting the polluters directly? Hit them where it hurts. The top 100 polluter list is packed full of oil giants. So blockade the refineries and other oil terminals. Not just one of them, hit the lot in one go. It worked for the lorry drivers in 2000.

The only real achievement XR has to its name so far is supplying the government with popular support for the Policing Bill. They've gone for the wrong targets, hitting ordinary nobodies on public transport. That was never going to get any action from the government.

They do blockade refineries and target the oil giants:

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/terminal-blocked-extinction-rebellion-protest-b1857619.html%3famp - this was only in June this year!

www.google.com/amp/s/www.energyvoice.com/oilandgas/north-sea/272929/extinction-rebellion-manure-bp-aberdeen/amp/

www.euronews.com/2020/08/28/extinction-rebellion-protest-outside-london-hq-of-oil-giant-shell

They have occupied oil rigs: www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-51008524.amp

Whether they could do them all at once effectively, I don't know. I suspect they don't have the numbers, unlike lorry drivers (who of course also had easy access to large numbers of large vehicles).

Hekatestorch · 26/08/2021 07:24

@lannistunut

I personally don't believe many of the posters on here care as much about 'poor people' (patronising, much?) as they are claiming, this is just a way to derail.

The Tory party themselves cite 'poor people' when opposing policies they don't like too, it is a fig leaf imo.

'Poor people' are not a homogenous lump and no one on here can speak for anyone but themselves.

Yes, I have experienced poverty under the government definitions of our country. I can speak only for myself. 'poor people' hold a wide variety of views.

I get that, I mean that's only the same as I think of XR and its supporters.

They don't really care about the environment. They just like a bit of anarchy. When it's pointed out the damage they do, they can say 'but climate crisis' and make themselves morally superior. They don't actually think about the people they are damaging. Until its brought up to them later.

It like moral superiority on top of their privilege and they can pretend to be heroes.

No one said poor people all think the same, though. I have been desperately poor at certain times in my life. I am very aware people all think differently. Not really sure who said they all think the same.

Hekatestorch · 26/08/2021 07:19

@Darker

XR is a movement rather than an institution, and local groups do different things.

I went by Oxford Circus yesterday and there were people who were focused on HS2 and others looking to protect peat, and others focused on getting banks to stop investing in fossil fuel.

No litter that I could see.

No disruption to the tube or pedestrians.

That's great to hear. Its great that they can meet their aims like that. They will get far more support if they do. I would like to see them turn it around.
lannistunut · 26/08/2021 06:56

I personally don't believe many of the posters on here care as much about 'poor people' (patronising, much?) as they are claiming, this is just a way to derail.

The Tory party themselves cite 'poor people' when opposing policies they don't like too, it is a fig leaf imo.

'Poor people' are not a homogenous lump and no one on here can speak for anyone but themselves.

Yes, I have experienced poverty under the government definitions of our country. I can speak only for myself. 'poor people' hold a wide variety of views.

Darker · 26/08/2021 06:24

XR is a movement rather than an institution, and local groups do different things.

I went by Oxford Circus yesterday and there were people who were focused on HS2 and others looking to protect peat, and others focused on getting banks to stop investing in fossil fuel.

No litter that I could see.

No disruption to the tube or pedestrians.

DdraigGoch · 26/08/2021 01:46

You want to know what XR could do that I'd actually support? How about actually targeting the polluters directly? Hit them where it hurts. The top 100 polluter list is packed full of oil giants. So blockade the refineries and other oil terminals. Not just one of them, hit the lot in one go. It worked for the lorry drivers in 2000.

The only real achievement XR has to its name so far is supplying the government with popular support for the Policing Bill. They've gone for the wrong targets, hitting ordinary nobodies on public transport. That was never going to get any action from the government.

VyrnwyGirl · 26/08/2021 00:16

Were you hoping starting a second thread would yield some more support for you @54321nought ? Wink

Epic fail.

The vast majority on here disagree with you. No amount of threads about the hideous Extinction Rebellion is going to change that!

Audit · 26/08/2021 00:06

@sst1234

By the way, they are not protesting, they are just sunbathing and having a good time out in central London because the weather is nice. It’s all ridiculously shallow and obvious.
Yes - the topless lady for example. Born with natural boobs but had them filled with plastic. Just why?

And the group of chained to some plastic block while eating a picnic, drinking from single-use plastic bottles.

Dangerous hypocrites all of them.

Tealightsandd · 25/08/2021 22:56

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?

How does stopping working class people get to work or hospital appointments, and delaying ambulances, tackle climate change?

XR are blocking roads (creating more traffic pollution as a result) during a pandemic. There are several large hospitals in central London. How many ambulances will be delayed by XR?

XR don't care about climate change. They've said nothing about the millions of non essential international journeys to and from the UK over the last 18 months. Of all the times to talk about rationing flights, you'd think a pandemic would be the ideal time. Yet not a peep from XR.

(Not everyone wants rationed flights, I know, but XR say they want 'something done'...

Tealightsandd · 25/08/2021 22:52

@Xenia

XR picked the nicest middle of summer time and near a bank holiday to have some kind of posh people's jolly on Oxford St disrupting small and big businesses alike because it does not care about people's need to feed themselves or get to work.
Yes this.

Cheaper than than a festival ticket, I guess.

knittingaddict · 25/08/2021 14:45

@Darker

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?
I think that question just shows your prejudice and it's obviously a loaded question. Where's the other alternative? None of those is the answer.

I think it's a very serious situation and am trying to do my bit to reduce my impact on the environment. I'm no eco warrior and my lifestyle is hardly radical, but I will up my efforts as and when I can.

I also think XR are a load of idiots and that their way of doing things will achieve nothing good for the environment and climate change. If anything they make people like me turn off from the whole issue. That's not a good thing.

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 14:27

I work in the area, and I'm pretty sure I earn less than most theatre workers

I think you would be surprised.

i had to walk around the block to get to the tube, to get home. Errr, that's it. That's the level of the disruption I faced.

In which case they weren't causing any disruption then.

I haven't heard any of my neighbours in the local area complain. A surprising number were sporting XR stickers by the end of the day, which surprised me.

You live and work close to the west end, you wouldn't need the tube then?

And of course they were. Biodegradable stickers?

Football fans that cause disruption are dickheads.....no one is arguing in favour of them or suggesting XR are the only people who disrupt London.

But it appears this group weren't causing disruption, I thought that was XRs 'thing'.

Its good to hear they weren't.

If it's true, that a large amount of people were wearing their stickers, doesn't that show that by not making peoples lives harder, they get more support? And also that they can make their point without making peoples lives harder?

Win win.

Xenia · 25/08/2021 14:25

XR picked the nicest middle of summer time and near a bank holiday to have some kind of posh people's jolly on Oxford St disrupting small and big businesses alike because it does not care about people's need to feed themselves or get to work.

SpittinKitten · 25/08/2021 14:17

They did knock up an impressively large pink table the other day, mind.

It got dismantled and removed by the police though; what a completely unexpected Hmm waste of resources...

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
sst1234 · 25/08/2021 14:11

By the way, they are not protesting, they are just sunbathing and having a good time out in central London because the weather is nice. It’s all ridiculously shallow and obvious.

sst1234 · 25/08/2021 14:10

Are you just attention seeking OP. Perhaps you should join the protests instead of virtue signalling on here.

ArcheryAnnie · 25/08/2021 14:06

@Hotcuppatea

Once XR came out as anti scientific, said that people could change sex, and that transwomen are women, I couldn't take another thing they said seriously.
Totally agree with this - but XR is a movement, not just an organisation, and I personally know GC women who are part of it. I have no inclination to be a part of it, though I certainly understand their actions - but I also don't confuse the arseholes who run the office with the many people who are part of the movement. (See, for example, all political parties, etc etc.)
ArcheryAnnie · 25/08/2021 14:03

Do you really think blocking a junction in London, doesn't spread traffic to other places? And how much do you think theatre workers earn?

I work in the area, and I'm pretty sure I earn less than most theatre workers.

I had to walk around the block to get to the tube, to get home. Errr, that's it. That's the level of the disruption I faced. I haven't heard any of my neighbours in the local area complain. A surprising number were sporting XR stickers by the end of the day, which surprised me.

The football fans, though, were another breed entirely. We had to shut one office door (that they threw bottles at), I had to call the cops because of the punchups in the street, they left MOUNTAINS of litter behind over half the West End, they pissed over the other half, they trashed a photography exhibition in a church courtyard, and even bloody tescos had to shut because of the danger of drunk people fighting to buy alcohol. Now THAT was an inconvenience to all us poor deprived inner-city workers.

Clavinova · 25/08/2021 14:01

Who is giving China a free ride?

From the XR website:

The greater problem at the moment is that for most Chinese people simple improvements in their quality of life are a far more immediate concern than the climate and ecological emergency.

The whole world needs to reorganise on a scale we haven’t really seen before and as retired detective sergeant of the Metropolitan Police, Paul Stephens, says, you can’t ask another passenger to take their feet off the seats when you’ve still got yours up there.

But you can drive your own kids around in a diesel fuelled car when it suits you.

Hotcuppatea · 25/08/2021 13:53

Once XR came out as anti scientific, said that people could change sex, and that transwomen are women, I couldn't take another thing they said seriously.

Clavinova · 25/08/2021 13:46

Darker
XR in the UK holds the UK to account
The point is that people in the UK can hold the powers that be in the UK to account.

They were protesting outside the Brazilian Embassy in London this morning - 'taking the fight to President Bolsonaro.'

Darker · 25/08/2021 13:26

There is already a political party. What would be the point?

Swipe left for the next trending thread