Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
mustlovegin · 26/08/2021 15:03

Are you saying that no-one should be paid?

'Be paid'? What 'job' is it exactly that they do?

Darker · 26/08/2021 13:35

People are treating XR as a single entity, which it isn't. I don't know about their structures other than what I've read and spoken to people about. From what I can see:

There are individuals who will turn up to things without any affiliation at all.

There are self-organised groups, often local or issue based (e.g. HS2).

There are one or more organisations which have a formal structure.

I imagine there are plenty of differences in approach and position between all of these.

Not being an insider in any way at all I can't really comment further.

PalmarisLongus · 26/08/2021 13:14

@Darker

Are you saying that no-one should be paid?
Are you saying they are a proper centralised group with a wage bill spread over different departments? Or "XR is a movement rather than an institution, and local groups do different things."
Darker · 26/08/2021 12:29

Are you saying that no-one should be paid?

PalmarisLongus · 26/08/2021 12:21

@Darker

I'm not sure what your point is, PalmarisLongus.

Organisations of any kind need funding. I can't see them taking money from Shell.

I'm a bit suspicious of the CIFF and their philanthropy model, but then a lot of charitable funding is less than perfect - our own National Lottery feels like a tax on the people + relies on gambling.

My point is simple.

The people on the ground, risking jail etc may mean well and care about environmental issues.

They fund "Extinction Rebellion" by donations, t-shirt sales etc.
The people above them are making a shit ton of cash from this.
To keep their income safe, they must continue public displays, call them protests or and campaign, makes no odds.
They're done, in part, to attract more donations, more t-shirt sales. (Interesting thing about t-shirts as an aside. The XR logo isn't technically supposed to be printed in anything and sold as the designer only gave license to XR. BUUUUT... A quick search of Etsy, redbubble, teespring etc.. you can go buy them.)

People proposition XR as some grass roots movement, full of good folks who are just trying to save the world and it's not accurate.
They're a huge organisation, pushed and publicised by people making huge huge amounts of money.
As with all things of this sort...
Always Follow The Money and you'll see why this is really going on.

www.thesun.co.uk/news/15558082/extinction-rebellion-funding-stunts/

A FIRM funding eco-group Extinction Rebellion was given £3.1million last year — but blew more than £3.5million on stunts.

Compassionate Revolution Ltd, which has XR founder Gail Bradbrook as a director, landed the cash in mystery grants and donations

www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/extinction-rebellion-protests-funding_uk_5da09183e4b02c9da0495bba

Ahead of the action, Andrew Medhurst – Extinction Rebellion’s finance coordinator – said he expected the protests to cost “the best part of a million pounds”.

“I hope there’s a [funding] boost in October, because I’m relying on approximately £15,000 to £20,000 a day to pay for all of this,” he told reporters at an event last week.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-50087022

The press has pointed to the way it is "raking in" money from members to support its operations and Mr Medhurst says the group has raised more than £2.5m this year.

Between the beginning of March and the end of September, gifts from large donors - those giving £5,000 or more - totalled £1.2m. The list of benefactors includes the rock band Radiohead, which gave the organisation £300,000

Darker · 26/08/2021 12:06

I'm not sure what your point is, PalmarisLongus.

Organisations of any kind need funding. I can't see them taking money from Shell.

I'm a bit suspicious of the CIFF and their philanthropy model, but then a lot of charitable funding is less than perfect - our own National Lottery feels like a tax on the people + relies on gambling.

PalmarisLongus · 26/08/2021 11:52

@Darker

That's quite a take, PalmarisLongus
Christopher Hohn gave £50,000 to the group. Additionally, the charity he co-founded, The Children’s Investment Fund Foundation, has donated more than £150,000.

All profits from Michael Stipe’s debut solo single, ‘Your Capricious Soul’, went to the group.

In addition, last year, XR received $350,000 (£273,544.39) from the Climate Emergency Fund.

I take it that cash has been shared between the movement members has it?

mustlovegin · 26/08/2021 11:46

getting banks to stop investing in fossil fuel

This lot are completely insane. They should leave banks alone, do they think they are charities? We will get another banking crisis if this and all the woke madness doesn't stop.

It's time people started crowd funding for legal fees to counteract all these threats to civilisation and way of life in the UK. Fast

RightYesButNo · 26/08/2021 11:32

Also, you have to wonder what kind of change they could really make with £3.1 million (I’ve included “receipts”), so @PalmarisLongus is not that far off on them being a brand. With that kind of money, instead of using it for “disruption” (?!?!?), you could just BUY factories in China and shut them down. There are so many things they could do. And this is just from 2020. It was £1.1 million in 2019. Imagine how much they’ll earn in 2021. They don’t need you and they don’t need your money.
“Compassionate Revolution Limited”, on Companies House, which is the account with Gail Bradbrook as director that holds the money for Extinction Revolution:
s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/document-api-images-live.ch.gov.uk/docs/zpsnniSW9fKA2PzNLHbT2vN_sp4N6kSX4e1zJY-PMA8/application-pdf?

And I’m sure they have other accounts.

@Hekatestorch Thanks for the info. I’m just going to assume OP is a troll then. Because this is ridiculous.

Hekatestorch · 26/08/2021 11:03

@RightYesButNo this OP also had a thread deleted today calling for a world wide ban on more than one child each.

No plan on how they would do this. No answer to the fact, that this usually ends in a population with a lot more men than women. No answer on how to tackle any of the many other things we can do that would reduce popukations etc.

This Op quite frankly, seems like the dosrt of XR supporter who just wants to disrput people, not solve anything. Unfortunately for XR (as I am sure some of them are decent people trying their best), the type of supporters op is, are usually the louder ones and the ones wanting more attention., so doing things like getting their tits out, or gluing themselves to trains.

I have repeatedly said XR could gain my support by making some changes. Which inducing helping the people who are, personally, negatively impacted by XR protests.

But apparently, they can't do that and it just makes me 'faux' concerned.

BigGreen · 26/08/2021 11:00

XR are not supposed to be an organisation, it's a banner under which interested people can take direct action. There are plenty of other orgs producing great policy papers that the government doesn't listen to!

RightYesButNo · 26/08/2021 10:54

I do huge amounts of work in tbe local community. For charity, food banks during covid I delivered to those shielding, those who needed to isolate, those that couldn't get through the week. I helped run breakfast clubs in the school holidays at my sons school so that families could ensure their kids were fed, even though they were financially suffering.

Now THIS is what will change things, @Hekatestorch.

In the last thread, XR supporters invoked the suffragettes disrupting things to get the vote as a sign that disruption would bring them success. But women only got the vote because the suffragettes stopped and changed tactics when WW1 hit. They supported the homefront. They helped their communities. Then they got the vote, disruption free, after the war.

People are going to think, “Ah yes, I should definitely change my whole lifestyle because some middle class person with a graduate degree from Frome glued themselves to something so I couldn’t reach my NHS appointment.” Fuck no. (See stats on XR participants in my last comments Yes, they are middle class with graduate degrees from Frome; I’m not being funny).

But I do think, “Hey, Hekate has helped me/my child/our rec center, she’s done x/y/z, and she’s asking me to sign a petition / sent me a link to write to the MP. It wouldn’t be too hard to do that.” That’s what makes a difference. We do these things because of course we care about the environment but we want a way to help from people we know are genuine, and that if they’re already genuine about one thing, then they’re (hopefully) sending us a genuine way that we can help, too, not wasting our time.

It is truly telling that XR was founded by someone getting their degree in radical campaign “design.” Because XR seems like a lot of design, right down to “here’s the colors we’re using for this protest” (again, see my last comment), and not much else. They have statistics other NGOs have spent time and money to research, if they bother with them. No policy papers. Nothing to present to the government if they actually sat down with XR. So why would the government bother? They’re just going to wait out these protests, and maybe even hope an ambulance or two gets stopped so that the press will be even more against XR, and then they’ll meet with climate change NGOs that are doing work.

I promised myself I was done with the last thread, when OP refused to engage on any facts. She’s started a second thread so she can just do more of the same. XR can’t even get their own shite together. This is a great article, with actual research: www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/aug/04/evolution-of-extinction-rebellion-climate-emergency-protest-coronavirus-pandemic (My favorite part was how one branch of XR occupied another branch of XR in 2019 with crying and cinnamon rolls - yes, government will definitely respect that for climate change demands).
Absolutely we need to save the environment and change the climate (lower greenhouse gases). And you should support groups who actually know how to do that. XR isn’t one of them. Don’t give them a dime. Don’t give them a minute. Support anyone who needs to get to a doctor’s appointment or other important appointment around their protests.

BigGreen · 26/08/2021 10:37

FYI the Extinction Rebellion logo was created and gifted for free.

There is no Extinction Rebellion 'merchandise' - you bring your own t-shirt and print the logos on it yourself.

Yes, I'm sure money changes hands somewhere in preparing large-scale art for protests, but it is a capitalist economy so that is to be expected. It's striking that people can't imagine ways of life beyond consumerism and merchandise.

Darker · 26/08/2021 10:35

That's quite a take, PalmarisLongus

ShinyHappySummers · 26/08/2021 10:35

[quote PalmarisLongus]@RightYesButNo

"Tell us again how XR is all rich and poor and lives where they protest, OP."

It seems obvious to me that these protesters are privileged, all of them, to a degree not everyone knows.
Millions of people have to worry about work, childcare, commutes and getting food on the table, they can't swan hundreds of miles to London to sit about wasting time in a mass and campaign for XR.

That's what it boils down too ultimately.
XR is a Brand, well publicised "Protests" are Ad Campaigns for that brand. The brand relies on people to promote the brand, some people are well meaning and care about the climate obviously.
It's all money though. They say:
"XR isn't an institution, it's a Movement"
But they have a hierarchy, they have or, the have cash flow. Some one is organising the printing of t-shirts, leaflets, stickers. Someone is being paid to print that stuff. Someone commissioned a huge pink table, someone got paid to make it.

A loose collection of like minded people wouldn't have the resources, time and contacts to organise such a huge undertaking. Someone is being paid for the PR, the Press releases, the website upkeep, the blogs, the social media posting etc.

And all that money, that is flowing upwards from the 'boots on the ground', is why they keep need the publicity events, the 'protests' the huge well advertised gatherings, they are basically ad campaigns to keep donations and money flowing into the pockets of the wealthy people at the top of the movement.

Replace XR with Microsoft... Protests with Mass Game event. Not much difference is there?[/quote]
🙄

ShinyHappySummers · 26/08/2021 10:33

@Darker

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?
Right?!
PalmarisLongus · 26/08/2021 10:26

@RightYesButNo

"Tell us again how XR is all rich and poor and lives where they protest, OP."

It seems obvious to me that these protesters are privileged, all of them, to a degree not everyone knows.
Millions of people have to worry about work, childcare, commutes and getting food on the table, they can't swan hundreds of miles to London to sit about wasting time in a mass and campaign for XR.

That's what it boils down too ultimately.
XR is a Brand, well publicised "Protests" are Ad Campaigns for that brand. The brand relies on people to promote the brand, some people are well meaning and care about the climate obviously.
It's all money though. They say:
"XR isn't an institution, it's a Movement"
But they have a hierarchy, they have or, the have cash flow. Some one is organising the printing of t-shirts, leaflets, stickers. Someone is being paid to print that stuff. Someone commissioned a huge pink table, someone got paid to make it.

A loose collection of like minded people wouldn't have the resources, time and contacts to organise such a huge undertaking. Someone is being paid for the PR, the Press releases, the website upkeep, the blogs, the social media posting etc.

And all that money, that is flowing upwards from the 'boots on the ground', is why they keep need the publicity events, the 'protests' the huge well advertised gatherings, they are basically ad campaigns to keep donations and money flowing into the pockets of the wealthy people at the top of the movement.

Replace XR with Microsoft... Protests with Mass Game event. Not much difference is there?

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 26/08/2021 10:26

XR have had no discernible impact on govt policy.
They are well-meaning hippies and also a core of disruptive hypocrites who are alienating the majority of the general public who we need to persuade to change behaviour.
They are not helping the fight against climate change.

Hekatestorch · 26/08/2021 10:19

[quote lannistunut]@Hekatestorch

You've claimed to speak for 'poor people' and 'vulnerable people' all the ways through the two threads - you don't speak for them. You have no idea what 'they' think - you are projecting your views onto a group of strangers.

You are doing the same with XR themselves, you have no idea that 'they' think either. You have no idea who 'they' are or what is motivating 'them'.

I am tired of people claiming to care about 'poor people' - and I am sick of the phrase 'poor people' too. When I was a 'poor person' I can tell you I thought exactly the same as I do now I am no longer a 'poor person' and I didn't need someone on the internet partonisingly saying what I wanted or didn't want for the future of the planet vs. getting to my (low paid, insecure) job.

People should speak for themselves and not invoke faux concern for 'poor people' - or indeed any made up group - as a cover.

End of rant.[/quote]
I haven't claimed to speak for poor at all. I have spoken about people being impacted. I can guess that people with no spare money each month are very much impacted. I can imagine, as the mother of a child with autism and the daughter of a disabled elderly woman, that not getting to appointments is really awful.

I no more speak for all poor people than you speak for all XR supporters.

Up until recently, I was 'poor people'. As in, fled an abusive marriage and slept on a corner couch with my kids for 9 months at my friend's homes. Was a single parent, living wage to wage with absolutely no wiggle room in my finances at all. Trying to balance a disabled child, a older teen and my job.

I grew in a single parent house, with a mother who was one of the ones that went to bed with no food so we could eat. Went to bed when we did, so she could try and keep warm without the heating.

Its not faux concern. It knowing that I have, fairly recently, been in that position. And no one gives a shit. And as long as those groups are being damaged, every one turns a blind eye. Had I not have had the immense of my employer coming across my CV, meeting me and liking Me, I would still be in that position. Doesn't mean I have just forgot what my life was like a couple of years ago.

I do huge amounts of work in tbe local community. For charity, food banks during covid I delivered to those shielding, those who needed to isolate, those that couldn't get through the week. I helped run breakfast clubs in the school holidays at my sons school so that families could ensure their kids were fed, even though they were financially suffering.

Personally, I think the "but it's for their own good' is bollocks. XR just didn't think about the consequences. So wrapped up in their 'aren't we great' and people are just making excuses for them, because they think they are this generations heroes and don't want to face up to the fact, that they are not.

How is me talking about people being negatively impacted any different to you saying its for their own good?

You need to really look at the assumptions, you make about other posters.

Xenia · 26/08/2021 10:04

"No litter that I could see" - well in 2019 an MP says they left 120 tons of litter which cost £50,000 to clear up which is taken from council tax payers locally plenty of whom are in social housing working full time. They swan in from Devon, drink from plastic bottles, dump the rubbish and then leave having got some good photos for their "Insta" near the pink table.

RightYesButNo · 26/08/2021 10:00

Of course they are not privileged. They are a complete cross section of society, rich. poor, all different back grounds and life experiences. Calling someone "privileged" has just become a way of trying to block out their message, without actually having any counter arguments.

When are people going to STOP engaging with this, OP? She says whatever the hell she feels like with nothing to back it up.

Here’s the truth from people who did actual research, maybe that’s a thing XR should try. Wait no, they leave that to NGOs like Greenpeace (who I don’t even support!) but then occupy their offices (XR’s very first action ever - brilliant, attack those who are trying to do the work and demand they use what they’ve developed (their email list) for you; it was disgusting and SHAMEFUL).
www.aston.ac.uk/latest-news/extinction-rebellions-activists-more-likely-be-new-protesting-study-shows
So here are the numbers since OP refuses to engage with that link:
85% had a university degree
1/3rd had a graduate degree
2/3rds identify as middle class
3/4ths of those charged live below the Severn Wash line
1/3rd of those charged who appeared in court were from the West Country hot spots where OP claims they don’t live - Stroud, Totnes, and Frome
Only 6% (of those charged) were from “were from Birmingham, Greater Manchester, Liverpool, Leeds, Bradford, Sheffield, Newcastle, Glasgow, Edinburgh, Swansea and Cardiff combined”

Tell us again how XR is all rich and poor and lives where they protest, OP.

Honestly. The best thing you can do is: make the differences YOU want for climate change, ignore this OP, ignore XR, engage with NGOs that use their money to do actual fucking research that sways governments, not just provide a “campaign messaging packet” to tell everyone what colors to use on their signs, like XR.
And since OP brought Greenpeace up (last thread), let’s compare:
A Greenpeace report on fires that add to climate change: www.greenpeace.org/static/planet4-international-stateless/2020/04/86b5fe06-greenpeace_underfire_artwork_pages.pdf
And…
What Extinction Rebellion makes: drive.google.com/file/d/1kH4bNT1g35KySpUpHSSf4NLQ9C68SgnU/view?1

DerAlteMann · 26/08/2021 09:14

YABU. They are a pack of worthless virtue signallers who have deluded themselves into believing they are achieving something (altho' I'm not sure what, exactly).

BelleOfTheProvince · 26/08/2021 08:57

People should speak for themselves and not invoke faux concern for 'poor people' - or indeed any made up group - as a cover.

They did. A woman told you in the last thread how she had to get a payday loan due to xr.

Presumably not on here because you spent 900 messages telling her she was justified collateral damage.

She wasn't made up. Neither were several posters who had either been held up from visiting London's specialist children's hospital or were worried it was going to.

Not giving anymore fuel to this attention seeking nonsense, but had to point out how you ignored harm done to real people and think people won't notice because anyone negatively effected by xr have probably hidden this thread.

Like I am doing now.

lannistunut · 26/08/2021 08:13

Some XR members are privileged and some XR members are not privileged. Being privileged is no more something someone can control than being one of the 'poor people'.

One thing to note is if they are privileged, they will not be impacted by climate change as much as the average Brit.

I am not privileged. I am going to be badly impacted by the climate crisis here in the UK and so are my children. I am already noticing that in my area, there are lovely houses that those who are cash buyers can pick up cheaply because of the flood risks and impacts on mortgages. This means a significant percentage of homes are not available to me to buy or rent and pushes prices up in the non-flood areas even higher.

Where do you think will get the flood alleviation investment? Hmm, might it be wealthy areas of the South-East, while those who live in shitter housing are left to get wet?

If they are only doing it because they are privileged, I don't get why they are bothering - they can just move and avoid the problem! I can't though.

Seagullsstopit · 26/08/2021 08:09

I personally don't believe many of the posters on here care as much about 'poor people' (patronising, much?) as they are claiming, this is just a way to derail.

I am "poor people" I care very much.