Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Lostmarbles2021 · 28/08/2021 17:23

they just don't have enough of the public behind them.

You are wrong. I think most of those that have been educated and are aware of the science want to see action. You’d be daft not to ... (do I ... a. Want to keep things as they are which will lead to our children experiencing hardship we can’t begin to imagine and human extinction, Or b. Make sacrifices to our very greedy and comfortable lives now to help our children have more safety and security and avoid human extinction?). Most people would chose b surely. Otherwise it’s like turkeys voting for Christmas! NB: people across the world are already dying and it’s only going to get worse.

Onetraumaatatimeplease · 28/08/2021 16:51

@Darker

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?
I think climate change is real, I also think that it's serious and real. I cannot, however, support XR. Their tactics are terrible, they are hypocrites (see Emma and the plane and the leader and the diesel, see the plastic waste they leave behind) and now they've got a woman running round in the nud claiming she's drawing attention to XR when really she's drawing attention to herself. They have completely turned me against them, I shall continue making my own difference in my own way. The government will never cave to these people, they just don't have enough of the public behind them.

lannistunut · 28/08/2021 16:45

@Darker

XR discussed on Radio 4 Any Questions? this week plus Any Answers? this afternoon. Very interesting.
Yes I listened to it earlier and was very interested there were two Quakers on the panel which presumably influenced their views on protest and lawbreaking.

It was a very pro-XR audience by the sounds of it, I was surprised at that.

Darker · 28/08/2021 16:37

XR discussed on Radio 4 Any Questions? this week plus Any Answers? this afternoon. Very interesting.

lannistunut · 27/08/2021 05:38

Bring = being

lannistunut · 27/08/2021 05:37

@Hekatestorch

When you say 'you don't get to decide people's motives or intentions', I think you are bring hugely hypocritical.

Repeatedly you've done precisely that.

Baluchistan95 · 26/08/2021 23:07

@lannistunut

Yes, bit bemused by people who think the climate crisis is not the end of the world!
We're all going to die, lol. Seriously, get a grip.
Xenia · 26/08/2021 22:51

The climate crisis is not the end of the world. Humans are on the planet for only a tiny blink of an eye and never expected to be here for long. As is common on the planet things change from various reasons including in this case actions of men. Once man kind has gone that is definitely not the end of the planet and all kinds of other things can thrive.

ShinyHappySummers · 26/08/2021 22:28

@lannistunut

Yes, bit bemused by people who think the climate crisis is not the end of the world!
Justifies their cause really imo 🤷🏻‍♀️
Hekatestorch · 26/08/2021 21:41

[quote lannistunut]**@Hekatestorch* Please stop making up rubbish. This XR feel it's for their own good. The view that you are supporting.* is not a view I espouse at all.

I said right back at the very outset that I agree with XR's aims but think their tactics need a bit of a review.

I do believe in the right to protest and would always defend a person's right to protest, even where I fully disagree with what they are protesting about.

There's no good talking at length as your answers don't relate to what I even post, so I will leave it there. Other than to say again I really dislike the repeated use of the term 'poor people' as though discussing a separate category of being.[/quote]
Oh yes, it's me making up rubbish.

You have decided anyone objecting to XR because if the damage they cause to actual people, to be faux concerned and patronising. Based on nothing.

Or maybe it's based on you just like people who disagree with you.

You are essentially trying to shut down anyone who has concerns about the people being impacted.

Most things on these threads has been repeated. New people join, people miss things etc. Are you trying to allocate how many times people can mention certain points?

You have said you don't like it over and over again. Is that not allowed?

You don't get to decide people's motives or intentions.

lannistunut · 26/08/2021 21:29

Yes, bit bemused by people who think the climate crisis is not the end of the world!

ShinyHappySummers · 26/08/2021 21:28

Lol. "End of the world"!! A tad dramatic, don't you think?

@Baluchistan95 erm no. That's literally what ER are concerned about. Hmm

lannistunut · 26/08/2021 21:17

@Hekatestorch Please stop making up rubbish. This XR feel it's for their own good. The view that you are supporting. is not a view I espouse at all.

I said right back at the very outset that I agree with XR's aims but think their tactics need a bit of a review.

I do believe in the right to protest and would always defend a person's right to protest, even where I fully disagree with what they are protesting about.

There's no good talking at length as your answers don't relate to what I even post, so I will leave it there. Other than to say again I really dislike the repeated use of the term 'poor people' as though discussing a separate category of being.

Baluchistan95 · 26/08/2021 19:50

Can we please be honest here? We are talking about middle-class, privileged people here with little concept of the real world. This group is divided into SAHMs and retired Doctors, Lawyers, Teachers, etc. I'm not knocking them for being bored and wanting a hobby to occupy their time and to provide discussion at the next dinner party. However, when it impacts on the rest of us, then that is just not on.

PalmarisLongus · 26/08/2021 19:49

@Darker

As far as I’m aware there were a few occasions when activists disrupted public transport, but XR didn’t like it. During the big bridge takeovers the stations remained open. At least, that’s what I recall.
XR planned to disrupt the tube and only admitted that was a mistake after their members got dragged to floor and violently attacked by members of the public.

www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/20/extinction-rebellion-tube-protest-was-a-mistake

Sarah Lunnon, a member of XR’s political circle, said: “There is absolutely no shrinking away from the fact that we have got to learn from what happened around the Tube, most especially within our own internal decision making.

“Obviously we did not get that right. People have given up their jobs to join XR, for them to be so upset and so dismayed by the action is an absolute pointer to us that we have to look again at how we make those decisions.”

So to say XR didn't like it, when they planned it, is a bit misleading.

Hekatestorch · 26/08/2021 19:44

[quote lannistunut]@Hekatestorch

You have written a lot of misrepresentations about me in your post. In particular this is not related to anything I have posted AFAIR: How is me talking about people being negatively impacted any different to you saying its for their own good?

Where have I said anything was 'for their own good*? (by 'their' I assume you are again referring to 'poor people')

I really do object to people patronisingly talking about 'poor people' as a homogenous group, having been in that category myself for a long enough time.[/quote]
XR feel it's for their own good. The view that you are supporting.

Again, I am not talking talking about them as a group. I am talking about people who have been damaged by them. XR haven't damaged ALL poor people. And actually, I haven't talked about how they ALL feel.

I have stated I don't agree with XR stopping people working, especially when it's hitting people already on the breadline. I don't like when XR stop people getting medical attention or getting to medical appointments.

I have talked about MY feelings on it. I have talked about how much harder life is, when you lose pay (for whatever reason), the impact on physical and mental health. I have talked about how people's medical appointments are needed and not attending them, makes people's lives worse. Sometimes this means missing more paid work, to get another.

At no point have I said 'poor people all think/feel'

You decided anyone who cares about these groups of people were only pretending to care to dismiss XR. Which is wholly ridiculous. If XR wasn't doing the stupid shit they were doing, I would support them. Not make up reasons to not support them.

The fact that you find my sharing my opinion, patronising is about you. Not me.

Baluchistan95 · 26/08/2021 19:44

@emilylily

YANBU- it's quite literally the end of the world at stake here.

People are more bothered about being inconvenienced than about the future of the world.

Lol. "End of the world"!! A tad dramatic, don't you think?
lannistunut · 26/08/2021 19:20

@Hekatestorch

You have written a lot of misrepresentations about me in your post. In particular this is not related to anything I have posted AFAIR: How is me talking about people being negatively impacted any different to you saying its for their own good?

Where have I said anything was 'for their own good*? (by 'their' I assume you are again referring to 'poor people')

I really do object to people patronisingly talking about 'poor people' as a homogenous group, having been in that category myself for a long enough time.

Merrymumoftwo · 26/08/2021 19:18

I would probably respect XR more if they tidy after they left. Yes they are not an homogeneous group but they are trying to spread one message.
During the Euros Scotland fans took over Leicester Square. They left it a tip but early next morning a group of Scotland fans pitched up and helped tidy up.
Things like this don’t help
www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/animal-rebellion-buckingham-palace-victoria-memoria-b1909284.html%3famp
Another poster put it better. XR would get further getting positive stories in the media than with all this negative.
Government are not listening as previously stated they are in recess until 6th September. The financial district is not in Westminster it’s split between City of London and Canary Wharf. Many civil servants are working from home so their offices are not really occupied. So who are they targeting, the shops that are borderline going bust?
The people trying to travel on public transport that is diverted so probably no longer going near the location they need?
What is the aim of this two weeks? If it’s to get institutions and government to listen then they are in the wrong place /here at the wrong time. If it’s to highlight the climate emergency and they don’t care if anyone listens then own that.

lannistunut · 26/08/2021 19:09

@BelleOfTheProvince

People should speak for themselves and not invoke faux concern for 'poor people' - or indeed any made up group - as a cover.

They did. A woman told you in the last thread how she had to get a payday loan due to xr.

Presumably not on here because you spent 900 messages telling her she was justified collateral damage.

She wasn't made up. Neither were several posters who had either been held up from visiting London's specialist children's hospital or were worried it was going to.

Not giving anymore fuel to this attention seeking nonsense, but had to point out how you ignored harm done to real people and think people won't notice because anyone negatively effected by xr have probably hidden this thread.

Like I am doing now.

Although they may have posted it on the thread I don't remember reading it and I do not recall replying to a person who had a payday loan? Possibly you have me confused with someone else?

Unless I have totally left my sense behind, which could have happened Confused

Buttons294749 · 26/08/2021 18:57

@Darker

As far as I’m aware there were a few occasions when activists disrupted public transport, but XR didn’t like it. During the big bridge takeovers the stations remained open. At least, that’s what I recall.
When they took over Wloo bridge I was heavily pregnant and had to push DS in his puschair the 1 mile to work as the buses couldn't run any of the route i need (again no other possoble option) Had I collapsed or lost the baby due to over exertion I doubt any of them would care Grin as it happens the physical damage was only to me.
Buttons294749 · 26/08/2021 18:54

I got so scared today as I was on the bus and saw some blockades near Waterloo bridge which panicked me as I thought I would not be able to catch my train. If I don't catch my train my DD cannot be picked up from nursery. I have no clue what happens if I turn up majorly late.

Do XR offer to collect children of disrupted parents and take them home? (And can they bathe them too 😂😂). Just so all XR members understand.

I'm all for lobbying big business, but targeting working mothers is not the way.

Darker · 26/08/2021 18:29

As far as I’m aware there were a few occasions when activists disrupted public transport, but XR didn’t like it. During the big bridge takeovers the stations remained open. At least, that’s what I recall.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/08/2021 18:23

@Darker

By your response you would think XR had hijacked the ambulances and struck up camps to block access to hospitals and factories.

The events this week are widely publicised in advance, which give people a chance to find other routes to work or to their appointments.

Guy's Hospital is just across the road from London Bridge Station.

Just how do you get to it by train without, you know - using London Bridge Station?

Is there a secret 'not London Bridge Station; in London Bridge? Can't use the Tube when the tube doesn't go where you live (and it's all connected anyhow). It's not remotely reasonable to expect somebody to catch the last night bus to x destination, then catch 4 other buses and go through 3 separate diversions for planned water main works, a one way system that has been permanently gridlocked in the morning since around 1987. Especially when the train journey takes about 24 minutes.

Maybe the suggestion would be 'go to Victoria and catch a bus from there'? Ummm, apart from the bus having to go through the bits that were kitted out like a giant's tea party with humans splatted on the roads like dropped biscuits? How about 'get on a bike and cycle it'? Yeah, the needing it to be a hospital appointment generally implies that getting on a bike and cycling to a specialist hospital rather than the nearest one kind of suggests that there's probably some sort of physical issue preventing that.

Of course, where you have ambulances, XR blithely state 'they should be rerouted, not our problem'. IF there is an alternative route, that's got delivery vehicles, public transport, other emergency vehicles and everybody else who would have been going down the original route all squeezed into another especially since so many two way roads have been bollarded off into empty cycle lanes so there isn't anywhere for them to go anyhow

It's inappropriate to drive or get a cab to GSTT when there's a fantastic public transport link literally just across the road. It's entirely inappropriate to suggest to somebody that they leave for a hospital appointment that would take under half an hour to get to by train a good six and a half hours beforehand.

The only explanation for such totally tonedeaf nonsense is that when somebody thinks nothing of fucking off on a plane to be handheld in a totally culturally appropriative ceremony that the indigenous people who use Ayahuasca as part of their religious belief and practice are getting pretty pissed off about whilst getting off their tits on a hallucinogenic preparation of a plant that is well on the way to becoming extinct in the wild due to rich western cunts wanting bragging rights over the common or garden coke and skunk users at home, when that money would have gone a bloody long way to leasing an electric vehicle, never mind buying one, is that either they've fried their brain with all the vaguely plant based psychotropics they've dropped since University or that their conceit is that it's a noble thing they are doing to put people at risk.

cleowasmycat · 26/08/2021 17:20

This annoys me

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
Swipe left for the next trending thread