Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Seagullsstopit · 29/08/2021 08:44

I know a lot of greens, they aren't concerned about environmental issues it seems. Mostly trans idealology and failing to perform when they do get local council seats.

Effybriest · 29/08/2021 08:02

Student marxists ? I really can't imagine that the green party are 'marxist'..
Guess that's the insult that strikes most fear into people. Hated Corbyn but same accusations were thrown at him too. As if being a student and having vaguely left wing ideas means you are wildly idealistic, that actually doing something about climate change is unrealistic and beyond us. And that is the get out clause. Only have to read that article by Andrew Neil, same old knee jerk dog whistle headlines reassuring folk that they don't have to do anything, just a load of old lefty hand wringing eco warriors...

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2021 07:40

@Darker

This is the response when Greens get a tiny bit of political influence.
You don't agree that people might be more willing to vote for the Scottish Green Party if they didn't sound like a bunch of student Marxists?
Darker · 29/08/2021 07:28

This is the response when Greens get a tiny bit of political influence.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
Darker · 28/08/2021 23:08

The customers of top polluters are not individuals but other big companies and governments.

Individuals trying to reduce their reliance on fossil fuels will struggle to do so because the world economy is built around these industries. E.g. we can fly cheaply while trains are expensive. Imported food is often cheaper than home grown. Farmers can’t sell their wool at any price because the cost is undercut by other materials. Individuals can’t resolve this unless they are relatively well off and able to make ethical choices.

DdraigGoch · 28/08/2021 22:54

@Darker

I don’t represent XR. I’m not a member. I share some of the concerns expressed here. I was very unhappy about the public transport disruption two years ago, for example.

But I do think non-violent disruption is justified by the nature of the crisis. And I like a lot of their messaging, e.g., around not blaming individuals.

What is society if not a collection of individuals?

Most of the top 100 polluters are oil giants. They wouldn't pollute if they had no customers. Those customers are individuals, are they not?

Darker · 28/08/2021 22:13

I don’t represent XR. I’m not a member. I share some of the concerns expressed here. I was very unhappy about the public transport disruption two years ago, for example.

But I do think non-violent disruption is justified by the nature of the crisis. And I like a lot of their messaging, e.g., around not blaming individuals.

RightYesButNo · 28/08/2021 21:59

@Darker

That poll was done in 2019 in the month of the protest.

I'd be interested to see if public opinion has shifted in the ensuing two years and the developing consensus that climate change is man made and that action is needed now.

Well yes, that second link that shows their popularity at only 19%, as I stated, as stable for last two quarters of 2020 and first two quarters of 2021… but as usual, no one on the XR side of this thread pays any bloody attention to the truth. I’ll just include the screenshot since a link was STILL too much, and then I think I’m done with this thread and doing your work for you. You don’t have public support, XR is not using the right tactics, and you need to hitch your wagon to another star (and I’d recommend not a star at all, but real people) if you want to make a climate change difference.

And statistics about climate change by itself have nothing to do with this discussion and XR. As stated, MANY people in this thread who disagree with XR care deeply about climate change. I’m one of them.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
Darker · 28/08/2021 21:26

@Xenia

Effy I think most of us will be wiped out (or rather our great grandchildren) around the same time or in not too different a timescale.

I put others above humans. I put dogs and worms and rocks above us. Is that so very wrong? Does ER think protection of humans is better than that of say pandas?

Climate change will cause suffering for most species - hunger, extreme temperatures, loss of shelter and safety. A battle for resources.

Doing nothing increases suffering.

Xenia · 28/08/2021 20:48

Effy I think most of us will be wiped out (or rather our great grandchildren) around the same time or in not too different a timescale.

I put others above humans. I put dogs and worms and rocks above us. Is that so very wrong? Does ER think protection of humans is better than that of say pandas?

Darker · 28/08/2021 19:47

For anything to change we need awareness that climate change is happening plus a plan of action based on the evidence.

For all I know il could be too late but I’m all for trying.

lannistunut · 28/08/2021 19:39

Certainly any high profile protest does get an issue into people's minds.

I think the recent fires + floods across the globe have had a big impact on public consciousness.

Crowsaregreat · 28/08/2021 19:34

You don't have to agree with XR. They're dragging the overton window so climate change is more prominent. Environment is now no2 in voter priorities. I don't care if they're annoying, anything that makes people think is good.

Darker · 28/08/2021 19:25

@Seagullsstopit

And people find the term "Need to be educated" very patronising, yet another turn off
Lots of people here have said the the way to tackle climate change is through individual actions such as changing diet, reducing waste, reducing travel.

If that is to happen at the level needed to achieve change then people will need to believe that climate change is man made and that the need for action is urgent. Scientists have come to a consensus on this.

Or, if people believe governments need to act they need to make an informed choice about who to vote for.

Education is key.

Effybriest · 28/08/2021 18:45

But @Xenia you are an extremely wealthy lawyer earning thousands a year. You really aren't going to be wiped out first are you ? What about your children ? What you are basically saying is 'I'm not bothered if we as a race are extinguished, just let me carry on as I am.'

Xenia · 28/08/2021 18:39

I don't put humans above stones or dogs so if we die off and they don't so what? If you look at any time line of this planet the human phase is tiny and whether we bring our end sooner or later does not matter too much in my view.

The person who asked " Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?" It is happening (climate change) but I would rather just let it happen and not bother to stop it.

Effybriest · 28/08/2021 18:39

The only time that people in the UK will feel that action has to be taken is when there is a natural disaster close at hand that affects 1000s of brits. When things are directly affected and the reality kicks in, whether that be parts of spain are too hot to holiday in or water supplies are rationed, when huge areas of the UK are flooded, harvests reduced due to weather extremes. Saying that, people are remarkably happy to write off the effects of brexit so who knows ?
Thing is it's the poor and vulnerable who will be affected the worst by climate change. Already are in fact. So the handwringing about the poor and vullnerable is a bit disingenuous...
A lot of the posts on here banging on about how XR is just a middle class concern, full of lawyers, teachers and whatever are turning it into something reminiscent of the leave campaign - Leave campaign anti elitist, pro the ordinary w/c man yeah right, and remainers m/c metropolitan liberal hand wringers. The tories know that most people are inherently selfish, they've won so many elections they can read us like a book. They do the minimum necessary, lots of talk, no action, green policies brought in by previous administrations overturned, it's clear they are not really bothered. Read the conservative home website, they are up in arms about green policies, reckon it's woke virtue signalling. And this thread sounds like most of them are on here.
Fair enough that people don't agree with their methods, but how on earth do we force the government to do anything ? No one seems too eager to stop voting for them even if soooo concerned about climate change not.

DdraigGoch · 28/08/2021 18:08

@Lostmarbles2021

they just don't have enough of the public behind them.

You are wrong. I think most of those that have been educated and are aware of the science want to see action. You’d be daft not to ... (do I ... a. Want to keep things as they are which will lead to our children experiencing hardship we can’t begin to imagine and human extinction, Or b. Make sacrifices to our very greedy and comfortable lives now to help our children have more safety and security and avoid human extinction?). Most people would chose b surely. Otherwise it’s like turkeys voting for Christmas! NB: people across the world are already dying and it’s only going to get worse.

The public are not behind XR. The public are generally supportive of dealing with environmental issues (so long as they are not remotely inconvenienced) but they do not support XR.
LaurieFairyCake · 28/08/2021 18:05

It's just a shame if public opinion has shifted

It's not like we don't know how fucked we are Hmm

Seagullsstopit · 28/08/2021 18:03

And people find the term "Need to be educated" very patronising, yet another turn off

Seagullsstopit · 28/08/2021 18:03

@Darker

That poll was done in 2019 in the month of the protest.

I'd be interested to see if public opinion has shifted in the ensuing two years and the developing consensus that climate change is man made and that action is needed now.

I think support has probably lessened in light of recent events and revelations. I'd love to see an up to date one.
Darker · 28/08/2021 18:00

I noticed that a different, June 2021 poll on the same site found that only 38% believed climate change was mainly due to human activity, which shows that there is work to be done in educating people.

www.statista.com/statistics/426733/united-kingdom-uk-concern-about-climate-change/

Darker · 28/08/2021 17:56

That poll was done in 2019 in the month of the protest.

I'd be interested to see if public opinion has shifted in the ensuing two years and the developing consensus that climate change is man made and that action is needed now.

RightYesButNo · 28/08/2021 17:47

@Lostmarbles2021

they just don't have enough of the public behind them.

You are wrong. I think most of those that have been educated and are aware of the science want to see action. You’d be daft not to ... (do I ... a. Want to keep things as they are which will lead to our children experiencing hardship we can’t begin to imagine and human extinction, Or b. Make sacrifices to our very greedy and comfortable lives now to help our children have more safety and security and avoid human extinction?). Most people would chose b surely. Otherwise it’s like turkeys voting for Christmas! NB: people across the world are already dying and it’s only going to get worse.

With that “making a statement that’s utter bollocks with no proof,” I’d almost think you were the OP. @Onetraumaatatimeplease is absolutely right. A majority of the public, when polled, are against XR and their tactics (lest you say it’s just their tactics). 54% are against their tactics of shutting down London and in fact, 34% strongly oppose it as opposed to 13% strongly supporting it www.statista.com/chart/19613/opinion-on-extinction-rebellion-protests-uk/ And then the organization itself: Only 19% positive support. And 35% negative. The non-profits on either side of them in this list, #126 and #128, have only 2% and 4% negative ratings. yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/explore/not-for-profit/Extinction_Rebellion?content=all

But as that link shows, they ARE famous. They’ve been heard of by 73% of people. And that’s all they seem to want. So, do continue.

Lostmarbles2021 · 28/08/2021 17:30

Xenia

The climate crisis is not the end of the world. Humans are on the planet for only a tiny blink of an eye and never expected to be here for long. As is common on the planet things change from various reasons including in this case actions of men. Once man kind has gone that is definitely not the end of the planet and all kinds of other things can thrive.

Agree. The planet will be much better off if we become extinct. It’s just a question of whether we are happy to die off - bearing in mind the suffering we and our children will experience in the process. I’d rather fight for survival personally.

Of course we are not the only species that will die out so we should hold some responsibility for other animals and their fate too IMO...