Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
minionsrule · 30/08/2021 15:44

OP not sure why you bothered to start Thread No 2 other than to feed the bun fight, you've barely contributed to your own 2nd thread.
Are you just passing time till your non marathon Hmm?

lannistunut · 30/08/2021 15:38

I think this is partly why XR just pressure for there to be general truth told about the seriousness of the situation - ordinary policy squabbling of the type above just seems so inappropriate. I personally am not minded to glue myself to anything anytime soon but I understand the frustration.

It has been interesting watching how fast people swung into action re. Covid, and of course how promptly people respond to natural diasters, but the resonse to climate change can't just be the usual turgid policy debate.

We need to throw a lot of effort and a lot of money at it. Some will be wasted - but what is the alternative? A lot more money wasted if we don't tackle it.

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2021 15:29

That took half a decade to set up and get to the stage of recommending anything. Much simpler to start with the next budget in the autumn.

Talking of taxes, did you see that the EU will be implementing a tax on aviation fuel? Most commendable. Except it doesn't apply to "business aviation" or "personal and recreational" flights. So no tax for Harry and Meghan the next time they borrow Elton John's private jet. Nor any tax for hedge fund managers on corporate jollies to ski resorts and the Caribbean. It always astounds me that the other year the powerful and wealthy travelled to Davos to discuss the issue of climate change. In private jets.

How much was spent on lobbying Brussels to exempt private jets from tax?

Darker · 30/08/2021 14:54

That response doesn’t seem very reasoned. Citizens assemblies have been used in several countries to good effect E.g., Ireland to decide on issues around abortion and same sex marriage. It is a foil to populism which seems to me to be a direct threat to the environment (e.g., leading to political outcomes such as the election of Trump and Brexit).

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2021 14:42

I don't really get your objection to citizens assemblies. It sounds like a more useful way to approach issues than many of the existing mechanisms.
Don't you? Who will be in these "Citizens' Assemblies" and what are their terms of reference? How do they fit into the unwritten constitution? Who do they answer to?

Whenever a movement or ideology uses the words "people" or "citizens" in this way, I'm always highly suspicious. Think "People's Republic of China", "Democratic People's Republic of Korea", or "German Democratic Republic". It strikes me that the more someone shouts about how they represent "the people" or that they are "democratic", the more the opposite is true.

I'm willing to bet that the "Citizen's Assembly" proposal is little more than a House of Lords without ermine.

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2021 14:07

[quote Tulipomania]@DdraigGoch I posted 3 examples of change plus an article, does that not answer your question?[/quote]
Onshore wind is fiddling while Rome burns, the best spots are already in use, you'll never get much out of what's left. Wind currently provides 5GW of power, the UK's total consumption peaks daily at 30GW. A few extra onshore turbines will barely touch this. What do you do about the 10GW currently generated using fossil fuels? Nuclear is the only answer, you'd only need four nuclear power stations to completely decarbonise electricity generation. Perhaps XR could campaign for that.

Bringing forward the ban in production of ICE cars? What use is that without investment in rail?

Darker · 30/08/2021 13:09

DdraigGoch all you are saying is recognised by XR.

  • we can't rely on individuals to change their own behaviour. It has to be governments backed by scientific evidence. Public opinion is changing - not fast enough, and not everyone, and not just because of XR, but XR helps keep it in the public eye.
  • its complex. XR have lots of sub-groups campaigning on specific issues and there are lots of other environmental groups campaigning. But XR events/campaigns try to be focused on big, overarching aims (e.g. Tell The Truth) rather than getting embroiled in the myriad of topics which people are already aware of.

I don't really get your objection to citizens assemblies. It sounds like a more useful way to approach issues than many of the existing mechanisms.

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2021 12:21

DdraigGoch They have brought about a change in public attitudes to climate change in just 3 years
What change in public attitudes? All I can see is everyone driving around in their SUVs (not me, I ride a bicycle everywhere local, train anywhere further) and desperate to get back flying to Ibiza (again not me, I take the train to Europe). The general public remain resolutely in the camp of "someone should probably do something about climate change. Just as long as I don't have to change anything about my lifestyle or do anything at all, it's someone else's job to solve it".

Forget thinking that electric cars will solve the world's problems, they are very resource intensive and still emit particulate pollution as their tyres wear down. Any form of car is also a very inefficient use of road space as this photo shows: www.danielbowen.com/2012/09/19/road-space-photo/ so the green future is bicycles and public transport for all but the most remote parts of the country (and no, Stroud is not remote Gail so on your bike)

I see little sign of the government announcing a rolling electrification programme for the railways, not even any hint of them reinstating the bits Chris Grayling scrapped (costing the Treasury more money than it saved). Do we hear a peep from XR about this scandal?

We never even hear XR campaign for improved public transport. Even worse, they actively oppose the big infrastructure project the government has which is intended to give people an excellent, clean alternative to flying and driving. A project which also uses a number of innovative technologies to reduce the CO2 produced by concrete.

Nor is the government moving quickly on nuclear power which (according to a former XR activist no less) is the only way of generating enough carbon-free electricity to sustain the UK's demands. Not that you'll see XR demanding the government gets on and builds Wylfa B... www.bbc.com/news/uk-54103163

Perhaps XR should campaign for practical measures like these rather than wibbling about "People's Assemblies".

Darker · 30/08/2021 09:29

I think most of Doctors for XR (@DoctorsXr) and ScientistsForXR (@ScientistsX) and other XR groups are composed of people who work and experts.

Calling people twats doesn’t contribute to the debate.

lannistunut · 30/08/2021 09:05

They need to get jobs Quite a few already have jobs, and many are also retired. If above pension age, do they still need to get jobs or are they allowed to continue in retirement?

Darker · 30/08/2021 09:00

I’ve noticed there has been quite a lot of coverage of XR in the media this time, even while the competition for media attention couldn’t be much tougher at the moment with Afghanistan and Covid etc.

That keeps climate change in the public eye.

Meanwhile the coverage of Hurricane Ida doesn’t seem to be making much mention of climate change and I’ve seen barely anything about the wildfires in California at all.

HOkieCOkie · 30/08/2021 08:59

You are unreasonable they are horrible ppl. They need to get jobs and stop being utter twats.

lannistunut · 30/08/2021 08:56

[quote Tulipomania]@DdraigGoch I posted 3 examples of change plus an article, does that not answer your question?[/quote]
Quite! What do people expect XR to do?

It is just an easy opt out to blame XR for the fact that the politicians the electorate keep choosing are not in favour of meaningful change.

lannistunut · 30/08/2021 08:52

@DdraigGoch

Protest is protest, that's enough IMO. The world is burning but don't worry, someone is waving a placard while they do yoga. What bloody use is that?

Do people think they are wrong and the climate is not very important?
@lannistunut are you being deliberately obtuse? No one on this thread (or the previous one) has said that climate change is not a serious matter. On the contrary, they are very worried that these people are more likely to turn the public off than get them to change their ways.

I think you post is unnecessarily aggressive, I shan't sink to your level - but maybe do read and (try to) understand the Independent article someone else posted just a few messages back.

XR is not believed to be making anyone think the climate issue is less pressing, even if they are pissing some people off.

XR are not responsible for the fact that the electorate at large cba to hold politicians to account on this issue.

Tulipomania · 30/08/2021 08:50

@DdraigGoch I posted 3 examples of change plus an article, does that not answer your question?

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2021 08:41

Protest is protest, that's enough IMO.
The world is burning but don't worry, someone is waving a placard while they do yoga. What bloody use is that?

Do people think they are wrong and the climate is not very important?
@lannistunut are you being deliberately obtuse? No one on this thread (or the previous one) has said that climate change is not a serious matter. On the contrary, they are very worried that these people are more likely to turn the public off than get them to change their ways.

lannistunut · 30/08/2021 08:28

[quote Tulipomania]www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/opinion/extinction-rebellion-protest-london-boris-johnson-climate-crisis-newspapers-b404981.html[/quote]
This is very interesting - and of course I think it right as it aligns with what I have been trying to express Wink - they don't want you to like them, they want to be unignorable.

This para in particular: By being the outlandish outriders of the climate emergency, they start to make anything just short of blockading roads to tackle emissions look more acceptable. So, consciously or not, they shift the so-called “Overton window” of policies and approaches to tackling the climate crisis that are acceptable to the public. None of that might happen as quickly or as dramatically as Extinction Rebellion might want, but many other campaigns would look at the way climate change, and public desire to take action on it, has shot up the agenda with real envy.

First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. (Gandhi) - with XR I guess they are between laugh and fight? They have skipped quite quickly past ignore.

lannistunut · 30/08/2021 08:21

This is the age group who need to apply political pressure: www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/aug/30/over-50s-want-climate-crisis-addressed-even-if-it-leads-to-high-prices

Tulipomania · 30/08/2021 08:19

DdraigGoch They have brought about a change in public attitudes to climate change in just 3 years which established organisations like Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth have not achieved in several decades.

And from that change in public attitudes comes political pressure.

For example, the government which blocked onshore wind in England 5 years ago is now changing its policy on wind turbines.

They have brought forward the ban on petrol and diesel cars from 2040 to 2030.

And are bringing through an Environment Bill with binding targets on limiting biodiversity loss by 2030.

None of it is nearly enough. But it's a start.

lannistunut · 29/08/2021 19:37

@DdraigGoch Protest is protest, that's enough IMO.

Do people think they are wrong and the climate is not very important? Presumably not for the majority, most people do understand the issue.

What they do is ask the question - if this is a crisis, why the heck are politicians doing so little? I think asking that question is enough, it is up to the wider electorate to do the work of translating it into political pressure.

Darker · 29/08/2021 19:01

www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/apr/25/extinction-rebellion-assessing-the-impact

This might be of interest. From 2019.

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2021 18:58

@Tulipomania

whether or not you like the style of their protests, XR has done a huge amount to raise people's awareness of the climate crisis and the need for us all to the action against it.

And it's helped to raise its profile in parliament too. With help from Greta Thunberg and David Attenborough.

That cn only be a good thing.

What have XR actually achieved?

Something tangible, please.

Darker · 29/08/2021 09:30

@Seagullsstopit

I know a lot of greens, they aren't concerned about environmental issues it seems. Mostly trans idealology and failing to perform when they do get local council seats.
Are you particularly interested in trans ideology yourself?
Tulipomania · 29/08/2021 08:50

whether or not you like the style of their protests, XR has done a huge amount to raise people's awareness of the climate crisis and the need for us all to the action against it.

And it's helped to raise its profile in parliament too. With help from Greta Thunberg and David Attenborough.

That cn only be a good thing.