Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 13:15

@Darker

It's too late for 'incremental'.

Governments need to act now. 'Now' now. Not next year now or 2050 now.

The day your house is flooded or burning and there is no food on the shelves is not the day to cancel your trip to long-haul flight to Bali and order a home composting kit.

So are you (and or XR) saying all foreign holidays involving air travel should stop immediately? (I don't have any axe to grind since I hate air travel)
Darker · 31/08/2021 13:12

It's too late for 'incremental'.

Governments need to act now. 'Now' now. Not next year now or 2050 now.

The day your house is flooded or burning and there is no food on the shelves is not the day to cancel your trip to long-haul flight to Bali and order a home composting kit.

Return2thebasic · 31/08/2021 13:12

@lannistunut

However, it's not only a shame but also such a waste of energy/resources that by alienating the public, they gave a bad name to environmentalist and people who do care about the planet.

XR are not alienating the public to their cause, they are only alienating people to their own organisation, and their organisation does not need public support.

"lone soldiers"? Quite brave. But shame, would all be forgotten in 10 years time. right now, it's a nuisance only.

The cause is absolutely right. But the means/goals are completely out of mind.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:08

Probably because my work is on the project management side. My philosophy is you give pressure by giving very specific achievable and incremental goals. Only that leads to a positive advancement to your goal.

This clearly does not work with the environment, this is fairytale talk. Why is the government stll in favour of burning fossil fuels - including finding new oil fields - when better alternatives exist? Money money money money money money money money money money.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:06

However, it's not only a shame but also such a waste of energy/resources that by alienating the public, they gave a bad name to environmentalist and people who do care about the planet.

XR are not alienating the public to their cause, they are only alienating people to their own organisation, and their organisation does not need public support.

Return2thebasic · 31/08/2021 13:01

@lannistunut

If most of the people think it's unreasonable to support XR, don't you consider something is not right with XR

This is only correct if the aim of XR is to win popular support for themselves. It is not. The aim of XR is to raise awareness.

XR are succeeding in making more people aware of the existence of XR and their key message - 'there is a climate emergency'.

The fact people don't like them matters not. They will not be standing for election, and XR accept the legal framework within which they are operating.

If that's really their goal (by making people hear "their voice" and see the destruction they created for not only the government but also the ordinary people trying to make a living/support their families), then they have already succeeded.

However, it's not only a shame but also such a waste of energy/resources that by alienating the public, they gave a bad name to environmentalist and people who do care about the planet.

Protest as such, without achievable goals set to government alongside those more ambitious/challenging ones, the impact would be very limited. It's not none, but just very limited in comparison to the amount of efforts/resources put in.

Probably because my work is on the project management side. My philosophy is you give pressure by giving very specific achievable and incremental goals. Only that leads to a positive advancement to your goal.

Again, this also leads me to think, do XR really care about making a difference to help the planet in its maximum capacity, or it's more about satisfying their own pride. (No offense. Just some reflection.)

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:00

@DynamoKev There is time to limit and mitigate, but yes, what is the point of anything is a pertinent question Sad

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 12:57

@lannistunut

I think plenty of people are just pissed off with XR because they are not playing the game of pretending it'll all be OK. They are saying - loudly and right in people's faces - that the planet is fucked. They are scary, but they're not wrong in their analysis of the seriousness of the climate situation IMO.
If the planet is fucked what is the point of anything?
RightYesButNo · 31/08/2021 12:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Darker · 31/08/2021 12:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ for repeating a deleted message. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 12:26

I think plenty of people are just pissed off with XR because they are not playing the game of pretending it'll all be OK. They are saying - loudly and right in people's faces - that the planet is fucked. They are scary, but they're not wrong in their analysis of the seriousness of the climate situation IMO.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 12:22

If most of the people think it's unreasonable to support XR, don't you consider something is not right with XR

This is only correct if the aim of XR is to win popular support for themselves. It is not. The aim of XR is to raise awareness.

XR are succeeding in making more people aware of the existence of XR and their key message - 'there is a climate emergency'.

The fact people don't like them matters not. They will not be standing for election, and XR accept the legal framework within which they are operating.

Return2thebasic · 31/08/2021 12:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Darker · 31/08/2021 11:11

Where is the mob rule?

You might be interested in the deliberative democracy model advocated by XR.

SusanBAnthony999 · 31/08/2021 11:08

Mob rule has no place in a democracy.

Darker · 31/08/2021 11:06

And once again for those struggling at the back, the point is that we won’t get the societal changes we need by waiting for individuals to make those choices voluntarily. For every concerned citizen there will be someone else only too happy to jump on the cheap flight or unable to afford the ethical brands in the supermarket. But together we can press governments to make changes.

Darker · 31/08/2021 11:03

XR have changed nothing in this respect, though we have seen a few people described by posters upthread who seem to think that going to the odd protest means that they don't have to feel guilty about their three long-haul holidays every year.

You are just pulling out imaginary and extreme examples of hypocrisy and pretending that is evidence that everyone in XR is a hypocrite.

It’s meaningless.

DdraigGoch · 31/08/2021 10:29

They have brought about a change in public attitudes to climate change in just 3 years
I saw a couple of threads this morning which made me want to bring this back up.

The first thread was about helicopter parents who give their kids lifts for journeys they could have walked in 15 minutes (in one batshit case a poster was going to walk her child to a sleepover a few streets away, and the hosting parent insisted on driving them). Do you remember the scene in Toy Story 2 where Al moans about driving "all the way to work" which turns out to be just the other side of the road? My parents used to joke about lazy Americans but evidently there are plenty of car addicts on this side of the pond too.

The second concerned Reading festival and the waste left behind, much of it going to landfill. So much for the "most environmentally conscious generation", it's all talk and no action.

Again shows that most of the public are only concerned about the environment, just as far as it's someone else's responsibility to fix. As soon as they are challenged to take action themselves, suddenly it's "oh I couldn't possibly do without my car..." or "how dare the government put up taxes on petrol!"

XR have changed nothing in this respect, though we have seen a few people described by posters upthread who seem to think that going to the odd protest means that they don't have to feel guilty about their three long-haul holidays every year.

Darker · 30/08/2021 21:37

Perhaps if we had proportional representation and not FPTP we would have more Greens in government.

Return2thebasic · 30/08/2021 21:36

@DdraigGoch

Well, the power of the rich = Tory. Just sad and irritating. Hmm because no other party is ever subject to lobbying via vested interests. But no, let's blame a party which isn't even in Brussels any more.
I realised I didn't read it carefully! Sorry! Blush
Return2thebasic · 30/08/2021 21:35

Well said! All the practical issues can be ignored just so easily by XR. That's why I can hardly take them seriously, even without the violence and extreme protest tactics.

It's always easier to shout than to provide viable solutions.

Shame, they had most of the public on their side to begin with.

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2021 21:32

Well, the power of the rich = Tory. Just sad and irritating.
Hmm because no other party is ever subject to lobbying via vested interests. But no, let's blame a party which isn't even in Brussels any more.

Return2thebasic · 30/08/2021 21:29

@DdraigGoch

That took half a decade to set up and get to the stage of recommending anything. Much simpler to start with the next budget in the autumn.

Talking of taxes, did you see that the EU will be implementing a tax on aviation fuel? Most commendable. Except it doesn't apply to "business aviation" or "personal and recreational" flights. So no tax for Harry and Meghan the next time they borrow Elton John's private jet. Nor any tax for hedge fund managers on corporate jollies to ski resorts and the Caribbean. It always astounds me that the other year the powerful and wealthy travelled to Davos to discuss the issue of climate change. In private jets.

How much was spent on lobbying Brussels to exempt private jets from tax?

Well, the power of the rich = Tory. Just sad and irritating.
Return2thebasic · 30/08/2021 21:24

Was in the Science Museum yesterday. Surprised on the way out in mid afternoon to see the crowd and the logos of XR. I felt outright rage at the first sight. Seriously? With all the young children about inside and around the area. Most of them are too young to understand what these people are aiming at. (I had to really calm down to explain to my 8 yo what was going on.) We didn't want them see trouble. Luckily we left in time before what was in the news later on broke out, i.e. glued / headlocked themselves to the chain at the entrance in the museum. Just very inconsiderate. Most of the visitors are families. Young children would be horrified at the scene.

Climate change is real and very saddening and is urgent too. But XR behave like a group of people just wanting attention and shouting without providing solutions to practical problems. Ban fossil exploitation. Sure, I wish too. But it's a very complex issue with little other comparable options available. (I'm hoping for fusion power breakthrough one day in mid-term future!)

I would take them a bit more serious if have clearer "achievable" step-by-step agenda to press the government on policies in short-term, mid-term and long-term. Certainly not by shouting"the planet needs our protection" and then fill up their car with diesel and go on holiday in aeroplane.

Darker · 30/08/2021 15:51

@minionsrule

OP not sure why you bothered to start Thread No 2 other than to feed the bun fight, you've barely contributed to your own 2nd thread. Are you just passing time till your non marathon Hmm?
Why does this matter to you and why the personal attacks? It’s horrible for other people to read.

It’s an important topic and anyone can start a thread. You can hide it if you don’t like it.