Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
lannistunut · 31/08/2021 15:04

@Darker

This conversation is just making me feel incredibly stressed. I'm leaving it for today.
Take care Flowers
Darker · 31/08/2021 15:02

This conversation is just making me feel incredibly stressed. I'm leaving it for today.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 14:57

@Darker

DynamoKev its not really possible to separate out every strand of awareness raising because of course people know a bit about climate change but XR have put phrases such as 'climate emergency' into the public consciousness.
XR have put phrases such as 'climate emergency' into the public consciousness. In your opinion. Or maybe the use of (for example) that phrase by UNEP, 23 National Governments, many local authorities and The European Parliament (there are many more) has placed it into the "public consciousness" without the need for anyone to glue themselves to anything.
Darker · 31/08/2021 14:48

DynamoKev its not really possible to separate out every strand of awareness raising because of course people know a bit about climate change but XR have put phrases such as 'climate emergency' into the public consciousness.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 14:42

@DynamoKev

But the "issue" isn't unknown - how many of those people already knew about climate change as an issue? There is no shortage of coverage in daily news. All XR are raising awareness of is XR and their tactics.
Yes, they are doing precisely that. And doing that brings the issue to the fore again.

They are being visibly extreme, and by being extreme, they are drawing attention to the fact that recycling a few yogurt pots is probably not going to be enough.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 14:37

But the "issue" isn't unknown - how many of those people already knew about climate change as an issue? There is no shortage of coverage in daily news.
All XR are raising awareness of is XR and their tactics.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 14:33

@DynamoKev

They aren't raising awareness of the issue.
Confused

That is just a really odd thing to say - a high percentage of people have heard fo XR and also, crucially, know what they are campaigning about.

Of course they are raising awareness of the issue. They are being reported on the news, in papers, on social media every day.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 14:30

They aren't raising awareness of the issue.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 14:16

@DynamoKev

XR are not making anything worse by raising awareness of this issue.

I do accept that awareness of the issue feels 'worse' in the sense it is upsetting, but as with all problems, overcoming denial/ignornance is the first problem.

You are simply shooting the messenger.

Darker · 31/08/2021 14:13

Using testimony from strangers on the Internet to justify your position? It’s hearsay. Opinion on opinion.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 14:13

@lannistunut

In what way are XR 'not helping', no point in shooting the messenger.

XR are not to blame for the reality we are going to have to deal with.

In this context they are a pointless messenger - in fact only making things worse.
DdraigGoch · 31/08/2021 14:10

@Darker

XR have changed nothing in this respect, though we have seen a few people described by posters upthread who seem to think that going to the odd protest means that they don't have to feel guilty about their three long-haul holidays every year.

You are just pulling out imaginary and extreme examples of hypocrisy and pretending that is evidence that everyone in XR is a hypocrite.

It’s meaningless.

Imaginary? Posters upthread knew them personally.
lannistunut · 31/08/2021 14:02

In what way are XR 'not helping', no point in shooting the messenger.

XR are not to blame for the reality we are going to have to deal with.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 13:43

@lannistunut

So we'll have saved the planet but I'll be homeless.

Is the alternative of 'I'll have a house but the planet will be fucked' actually a better one?

Is there no scenario you can imagine where we restructure how we do things and you are neither homeless nor on a fucked planet?

XR are pointing out the scale of the issue. Governments have the ability to address the issue. They are choosing not to. The electorate is allowing that to continue.

I am not certain who to believe in terms of the action needed.

Neither a fucked planet nor homelessness and destitution appeal to me to be honest.

If the worst of what I read about is true, then the entire western capitalist social democratic system will need to be abandoned in favour of something akin to North Korea where central planning is used.

I don't find either outcome appealing. XR are not helping at all.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:39

So we'll have saved the planet but I'll be homeless.

Is the alternative of 'I'll have a house but the planet will be fucked' actually a better one?

Is there no scenario you can imagine where we restructure how we do things and you are neither homeless nor on a fucked planet?

XR are pointing out the scale of the issue. Governments have the ability to address the issue. They are choosing not to. The electorate is allowing that to continue.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 13:35

@NotDavidTennant

You yourself know what needs to happen, why don't you be honest and come out and say it?

Well yes I know what needs happen. Most flights need to stop, most people need to give up their cars, most consumption of meat and dairy needs to stop, virtually all fossil fuel power generation needs to stop, most people need to reduce their consumption of manufactured goods to the bare minimum.

Even if those things are feasible without completely senidng the economy into the toilet (I suspect they're not), no politican in their right mind is going to campaign on that platform. There would be riots if they tried even half of the things I've just suggested.

Exactly. I will give up my car etc - but then I'll probably lose my job or else the company I work for will have no income (same outcome), so then I can't pay my mortgage. So we'll have saved the planet but I'll be homeless.
DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 13:32

[quote lannistunut]@DynamoKev

I personally have no relationship with XR.

What we know is that 75% of flights are taken by 15% of people.

I would not say an annual holiday is the first issue to tackle.

The question really is - do you think those 15% should continue to take as many flights as they wish? Who are they, why are they flying, what alternatives exist?[/quote]
do you think those 15% should continue to take as many flights as they wish? Who are they, why are they flying, what alternatives exist?
No I wish the fuckers would pack it in, it's noisy and it fucks up the air.

Speaking personally, I would be happy to stop all flying for other than disaster aid - but I am asking @darker if that's what they and/or XR want.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:30

XR are just naming the problem, it is not their job to try to persuade the public on board. If people don't want to get on board (with the fact the environment is in crisis) then that is their choice. But to act as though people 'don't realise' is nonsense. Unless you are either a) thick or b) in denial or c) uncaring, it is pretty obvious. If you are a, b or c then you're not going to get on board anyway.

It is the insanity of the whole of society waiting for someone else to tell them to do what they themselves know needs to be done that, for me, makes XR's approach make sense, in that none of it makes sense Confused.

NotDavidTennant · 31/08/2021 13:29

You yourself know what needs to happen, why don't you be honest and come out and say it?

Well yes I know what needs happen. Most flights need to stop, most people need to give up their cars, most consumption of meat and dairy needs to stop, virtually all fossil fuel power generation needs to stop, most people need to reduce their consumption of manufactured goods to the bare minimum.

Even if those things are feasible without completely senidng the economy into the toilet (I suspect they're not), no politican in their right mind is going to campaign on that platform. There would be riots if they tried even half of the things I've just suggested.

Darker · 31/08/2021 13:26

I'm not XR.

To save the planet we have to change our way of life and expectations. Analogy might be giving up smoking to avoid lung disease. If you stop early (environmental examples being banning CFCs, removing lead from petrol, banning DTD) the benefits might be seen.

I'd probably go for a 'rationing' approach to long haul flights as some travel is probably inevitable for military, medicine etc. I'd hate not to be able to travel but I wouldn't riot for my right to get anywhere by plane if it was non-essential.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:23

@NotDavidTennant

Governments need to act now.

Yes, but act to do what? This is what pisses me off the XR. They want the government to be honest with the people, but XR themselves won't honsetly come out and say what needs happen.

Why is it XR's job to say what the government refuses to say?

You yourself know what needs to happen, why don't you be honest and come out and say it?

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:22

And lest I be called a hypocrite, it is more than fifteen years since I took a flight anyway.

NotDavidTennant · 31/08/2021 13:21

Governments need to act now.

Yes, but act to do what? This is what pisses me off the XR. They want the government to be honest with the people, but XR themselves won't honsetly come out and say what needs happen.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:19

At least I am hoping I have remembered those air stats correctly Grin

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 13:19

@DynamoKev

I personally have no relationship with XR.

What we know is that 75% of flights are taken by 15% of people.

I would not say an annual holiday is the first issue to tackle.

The question really is - do you think those 15% should continue to take as many flights as they wish? Who are they, why are they flying, what alternatives exist?