Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Darker · 01/09/2021 11:53

I'd lay money that most people complaining about XR disrupting things have not been inconvenienced at all or only mildly inconvenienced.

Greenham women were hugely derided at the time. It cost public money to police their activity.

DynamoKev · 01/09/2021 11:47

@Darker

I think your post is morally bankrupt.

We don’t have a functioning global democracy. If we did we would have made the necessary changes decades ago. Countries which suffered the most have had the least say.

I agree we have a democratic deficit - at the very least we need PR in the UK.

Do you think PR would help or what other changes would be needed to make our democracy "functioning"?

DynamoKev · 01/09/2021 11:45

@Darker

Interesting discussion on Women's Hour this morning about Greenham Common - reflecting on the way they were perceived at the time and their legacy.
I have massive respect for the Greenham Women - they were peaceful and they targeted the actual installations. I was around at the time (even went on a days NVDA myself at RAF Molesworth). Non of them (or us) stopped ordinary people going to work or medical appointments or did stunts to attract publicity (or in modern parlance "raise awareness"). They are not remotely comparable with XR.
Darker · 01/09/2021 11:41

I think your post is morally bankrupt.

We don’t have a functioning global democracy. If we did we would have made the necessary changes decades ago. Countries which suffered the most have had the least say.

HarrietsChariot · 01/09/2021 11:36

People have a right not to care about the planet. One person's demand that another should change their behaviour to help the environment or prevent a climate catastrophe is no more valid than another person's demand to carry on flying, eating meat and driving a Range Rover.

Both believe that the other is wrong and that the other should change their behaviour because of their own actions or beliefs. Arguably the second person has a more valid point, because climate change will only be a significant problem in the future (as in, extinction of the human race) whereas the first person demands sweeping lifestyle changes immediately.

Anyway, we live in a democracy. If enough people want climate issues to be put front and centre, they can vote for politicians that espouse these views. If those politicians don't exist, people can stand knowing they've already got huge numbers of supporters on tap. Democracies don't elect leaders based on who shouts the loudest or has the largest mob of thugs behind them, they elect leaders through argument and debate. Peacefully.

Darker · 01/09/2021 10:59

Interesting discussion on Women's Hour this morning about Greenham Common - reflecting on the way they were perceived at the time and their legacy.

Darker · 01/09/2021 09:11

Thank you lannistunut for the flowers.

Darker · 01/09/2021 09:04

You don’t know the point sst1234 because you don’t want to see the point. But don’t worry, you’ve got lots of company.

sst1234 · 01/09/2021 08:56

And still we don’t know, what exactly is the point of these nonsense protests. These ‘activists’ having a nice day out in central London in the middle of summer changes nothing. While China and US make up 43% of global carbon emissions. Why are so many people taken in by such blatant virtue signalling.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 16:27

The wink was supposed to make it lighthearted @DynamoKev, I was just trying to wrap it up in a jokey way.
OK, thanks for clarifying.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 16:23

@DynamoKev

You are perfectly entitled to be wrong As are you.
The wink was supposed to make it lighthearted @DynamoKev, I was just trying to wrap it up in a jokey way.
DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 16:17

You are perfectly entitled to be wrong
As are you.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 16:12

@DynamoKev

But it seems unlikely… To you, because that’s your opinion. I don’t agree.
Well, yes, I can see that, that is why I said I can't argue all day Grin

You are perfectly entitled to be wrong Wink

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 16:10

No such thing as bad publicity as they say!
Well then “they” haven’t thought about it very much or they would realise that it’s entirely possible to have bad publicity.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 16:07

But it seems unlikely…
To you, because that’s your opinion.
I don’t agree.

NotDavidTennant · 31/08/2021 16:06

I may be overly cycnical, but I suspect a big part of the function of XR is to give activists feeling that they are doing something, when the reality is that doing anything about climate change is difficult and most likely involves changes that have to be phased in over years and decades and which don't produce any dramatic changes in the short term.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 16:02

It is circular though @DynamoKev, I agree they get coverage of their stunts, and what evidence there is (public awareness research) is that people are aware of XR and what they want.

There is no evidence that disapproving of the stunts is making people want to damage the planet more.

Lots of people don't like them, my point is this does not matter to them in terms of what they are aiming to do.

People don't like protestors. This is not a new phenomenon.

But it seems unlikely that anything more than a small niche of people would have heard and remembered the use of (for example) that phrase by UNEP, 23 National Governments, many local authorities and The European Parliament.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 15:56

That's fine. I can;t argue with you all day, but IMo you're deluded if you think that a council passing a motion got the same level of coverage as what has gone on this week in London.
That's not what I said, and it's dishonest to represent it as such. I think you are deluded if you think XR are "raising awareness" of anything other than XR stunts.

I don't expect XR or any other protest group to seek "my approval" - what a weird expression. It would be nice if the leadership weren't such self-serving hypocrites - but they are far from alone in that, and it would be good if they didn't do environmental damage in their protests, or didn't prevent people getting medical attention or getting to work, but I don't expect them to get approval from me.
At the same time they can't expect any respect without earning it.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 15:49

@DynamoKev

Here's the actual kind of coverage they get - all about stunts and court cases
No such thing as bad publicity as they say!
DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 15:47

Here's the actual kind of coverage they get - all about stunts and court cases

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
lannistunut · 31/08/2021 15:41

@DynamoKev

As I said, I disagree. XR are not mentioned in the clip you linked to at all. It is a BBC report about the forthcoming Glasgow summit.
That's fine. I can;t argue with you all day, but IMo you're deluded if you think that a council passing a motion got the same level of coverage as what has gone on this week in London.

Anyway, XR won't listen to you so you can think whatever you like Grin. They are doing what they are doing and one of the reasons people dislike them is they don't seek my approval or your approval.

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 15:37

As I said, I disagree. XR are not mentioned in the clip you linked to at all. It is a BBC report about the forthcoming Glasgow summit.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 15:24

I don't agree - in my estimation, those various declarations have received news coverage. They did not get 14 days' coverage plus a lot of discussion on social media. They just didn't! At best they got worthy pieces.

Look at this clip from BBC News - only a minute but about the issues, not the stunts at all - as with many other clips I have seen this week, proper reporting secured because of the stunts: twitter.com/ExtinctionR/status/1432489941016223744

DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 15:13

@lannistunut

Or maybe the use of (for example) that phrase by UNEP, 23 National Governments, many local authorities and The European Parliament (there are many more) has placed it into the "public consciousness" without the need for anyone to glue themselves to anything. Hmm yeah sure, cos I remember all the media coverage they got.

Like it or not, XR get more news coverage than any other voices.

I don't agree - in my estimation, those various declarations have received news coverage.

XR get coverage, but it relates to their stunts, not the actual issues.

lannistunut · 31/08/2021 15:06

Or maybe the use of (for example) that phrase by UNEP, 23 National Governments, many local authorities and The European Parliament (there are many more) has placed it into the "public consciousness" without the need for anyone to glue themselves to anything. Hmm yeah sure, cos I remember all the media coverage they got.

Like it or not, XR get more news coverage than any other voices.