Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
54321nought · 25/08/2021 00:01

It's Tuesday.
Why weren't they at work?

not everyone works Tuesdays!

Lots of retired doctors, lawyers , teachers, police etc are there

Lots of people on annual leave, or unemployed

OP posts:
PalmarisLongus · 24/08/2021 23:56

It's Tuesday.
Why weren't they at work?

Why were they using up police resources?

How did they all get there?

They do little to inspire support or engagement with environmental issues. They just bring attention on themselves and their higher ups. I would not be surprised if money is flowing from the lowers to the uppers or some kind of patreon / book deal is funding them.

Excelthetube · 24/08/2021 23:56

I can’t believe after 2 threads people don’t really understand the point of them.

Hilarious

Darker · 24/08/2021 23:53

I don’t speak for XR by the way. I’ve popped in to a couple of their events and that’s about it. But I think what they are doing is necessary. Our government will always back big companies because they want the revenue and the jobs.

Darker · 24/08/2021 23:50

XR can’t broker a deal - governments need to do that. XR can keep these issues in the public eye and normalise holding companies and governments to account.

There are other movements advocating for more environmentally sound consumption. XR don’t need to duplicate what they are doing.

DuckDuckGooses · 24/08/2021 23:44

@Darker if that's the view then I think XR aren't going to have much of an impact, their actions all just seem to cause disruption to ordinary working people rather than the "powers that be" that might be able to get the action they want? An economy like China can't just shut down production or shipping overnight, it'd ruin the country. I think their plan of a peak in the next ten or so years then carbon neutral by 2060 (I think?) is already ambitious for such a huge country. If XR want to somehow broker a US-China emissions deal then they might get somewhere!

Darker · 24/08/2021 23:38

DuckDuckGooses I agree it’s annoying but we haven’t got time for everyone to make those sensible choices or for changes on that scale to make a difference. We need drastic action to stop vast amounts of fossil fuels being drilled and mined. It’s like worrying about a dripping tap while ignoring the flood.

DuckDuckGooses · 24/08/2021 23:31

@Darker

"However if you look at the UKs contribution to global emissions we rank so low

So the UKs contribution to climate change is too small to bother about, but a diesel car is worth bothering about?

The car and the flights annoy me as it is hypocritical, but I think that at this stage we need to let it go and look at the bigger picture. We are all hypocrites to some extent. We all compromise in order to function."

The point I was making was it's very much say as we say not as we do - if the world is in the state XR are trying to say it is then they shouldn't be driving diesel or flying around the place - not when they want others to change, they're not leading by example! If we "let it go" about their cars and flights then what on earth are we going to change? They make up the bigger picture - small changes lead to big results, if we all just "let it go" about everything no one will ever make any changes.

54321nought · 24/08/2021 23:29

However if you look at the UKs contribution to global emissions we rank so low on there

This is a myth, we contribute hugely, we import good that have been made in China, where they have caused massive pollution in their production, and we export our waste to countries like Turkey and Malaysia, where it causes massive pollution in its disposal

We are massive global polluters

If they were really clever they would cyber attack large polluting companies or take non-essential consumer websites offline causing disruption or loss of revenue without any extra pollution

What makes you think they are not doing that too?

OP posts:
Darker · 24/08/2021 23:27

Relying on individuals to make changes voluntarily won’t work, though. Most people will not self-limit, especially if they can’t exercise choice due to their circumstances.

TheHateIsNotGood · 24/08/2021 23:25

Was there an XR Event? I had not the slightest idea until I read this post. Did any educational disruption happen, or tried to happen, somewhere?

It's so old news and XR is irrelevant at best and counterproductive at worst. The whole world is takng notice of Climate Change and Environmental concerns, XR has nothing to add and looks a bit silly.

DynamoKev · 24/08/2021 23:21

@54321nought

They are not out to educate, or persuade the public, they are out to disrupt, and get government attention
They will certainly do that - no doubt the current government will point out the damage and disruption caused, then carry on exactly as before.

XR are the most pointless movement ever, not because there isn't an issue, but because they are making it worse.

Theworldisquiethere · 24/08/2021 23:20

I know several people who are heavily involved in XR, they all fly abroad for holidays at least once a year because they feel like they’ve ‘earned it’. Most of them also drive big cars and vans and generally live lifestyles that really don’t match with what XR is supposed to stand for. From conversations I’ve had with some of them they genuinely seem to think their protesting cancels out the pollution they create!

(Obviously that doesn’t apply to everyone who’s involved)

OhWhyNot · 24/08/2021 23:16

Well target MP’s then

That will get their attention

Darker · 24/08/2021 23:16

However if you look at the UKs contribution to global emissions we rank so low

So the UKs contribution to climate change is too small to bother about, but a diesel car is worth bothering about?

The car and the flights annoy me as it is hypocritical, but I think that at this stage we need to let it go and look at the bigger picture. We are all hypocrites to some extent. We all compromise in order to function.

54321nought · 24/08/2021 23:15

They are not out to educate, or persuade the public, they are out to disrupt, and get government attention

OP posts:
OhWhyNot · 24/08/2021 23:13

Flyingantday yes they could

But it doesn’t really have the hippy carnival vibe so a bit boring

Dita73 · 24/08/2021 23:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Flyingantday · 24/08/2021 23:12

But not such a fun day out I guess

Flyingantday · 24/08/2021 23:11

If they were really clever they would cyber attack large polluting companies or take non-essential consumer websites offline causing disruption or loss of revenue without any extra pollution, public littering or stopping people on low incomes getting to work or patients to hospital appointments.

DynamoKev · 24/08/2021 23:11

@Darker

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?
No, we don't, but that doesn't stop us thinking XR are useless twats doing zero to help.
SpittinKitten · 24/08/2021 23:09

@BigGreen

XR isn't a 'they' - it's just ordinary people, like me. Plenty of Mumsnetters go, as past threads have shown. We are just people that have had enough of inaction, especially from the government and we want to be heard (whether it makes change or not, it's about trying something).

We are not crusty, hippy, twats, plonkers, arseholes or fuckers. Personally I just really care about the world I'm leaving to my kids. We are on a knife edge, it's now or never to keep fossil fuels in the ground and avoid the worst effects of climate change. The fires in Greece, Turkey, Siberia and the US, and the floods in Belgium and Germany are just the start.

@BigGreen

I'm sure there's some lovely people involved.
My personal lived experience of the XR founders and a few heavily involved XR organisers/'professional ' activists over the last decade has been that they absolutely were and still are twats, plonkers, arseholes and fuckers. Really exploitative dangerous bastards.

Stay safe out there.

OhWhyNot · 24/08/2021 23:04

XR isn't a 'they' - it's just ordinary people, like me. Plenty of Mumsnetters go

Grin well that explains a lot

Keep banging those drums. I wonder who shall fly in this time

DuckDuckGooses · 24/08/2021 23:04

Climate change is obviously real - how much we contribute is the real stickler for me (and especially when you look at the cycles of extreme heat and cooling the earth has gone through for thousands of years pre industrialisation it's a bit unclear).

However if you look at the UKs contribution to global emissions we rank so low on there that the XR protestors are just turning the public against them - they're not protesting against the countries or industries across the globe causing these emissions - they're sat in london blocking roads and public transport for ordinary working people.

There's no clear message I find from XR on what they want to do internationally - and then when you've got one of the founders on live tv saying she drives a diesel car because she can't afford an electric one (like a lot of the public!) and needs the car as she can't rely on public transport where she is, so you really think it's going to inspire others to make a positive change in their lives? When you've got celebrity faces flying on jets to protests do you think it'll make joe blogs want to join in? When you've got protestors using single use plastic bottles and leaving them in the streets, littering with food wrappers etc do you think the people watching see this as a positive movement? XR come across as a joke to be honest.

iheartredsquirrels · 24/08/2021 23:00

@Darker

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?
Climate change is happening, we all know that it's very real but these idiots are going about it the wrong way. Disruption, to thousands of people criminal damage [the red paint episode], gluing themselves to trains and god knows what. What have they actually achieved? Happy to be educated as long as there is evidence to back a claim up and not a lot of guff from sm and fb.