Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Cam2020 · 25/08/2021 07:34

When are you going to China to protest?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 25/08/2021 07:33

[quote Indecisivelurcher]**@anon12345678901* and @Hekatestorch* she says she drives diesel and can't afford electric. So because of that, she can't say anything about climate change? I don't agree with that. The point I'm trying to make is that most XR people are normal people, and therefore not perfect. I don't know this particular woman and what she does or doesn't do, she could still be a dick for all I know. Many people are. But even dicks should be talking about climate change at this point!

Sounds like I'm allowed to talk about it, at I drive an electric car and don't fly... So that's good! I'm not vegan though so maybe not...[/quote]
Talk about it all you want, but stop disrupting the lives of the working classes.

PlanDeRaccordement · 25/08/2021 07:32

Name an issue akin to climate change that's been resolved without public protest and disruption?! There isn't one, not that I can think of! So absolutely XR has a role.

The suffragettes actually delayed votes for women in the U.K. with their violent protest actions. If you read the in depth history on it, it explains eloquently that women’s votes wouldn’t have been limited to only older, married women after WWI if it weren’t for the suffragettes.

When the U.K. students objected to the tuition fees rising to £9,000/yr, they actually had Parliament on their side until they engaged in protests that were violent and caused disruption and vandalism. It was because of the protests that Parliament passed the tuition fee rise.

Indecisivelurcher · 25/08/2021 07:30

@anon12345678901 and @Hekatestorch she says she drives diesel and can't afford electric. So because of that, she can't say anything about climate change? I don't agree with that. The point I'm trying to make is that most XR people are normal people, and therefore not perfect. I don't know this particular woman and what she does or doesn't do, she could still be a dick for all I know. Many people are. But even dicks should be talking about climate change at this point!

Sounds like I'm allowed to talk about it, at I drive an electric car and don't fly... So that's good! I'm not vegan though so maybe not...

PlanDeRaccordement · 25/08/2021 07:24

@Darker

Because most oil isn’t actually burned as fuel but used in medicines, cosmetics and so on

What?

Yes, do some research. Here is an article to start you off. Even if all our cars, trains, planes and ships stopped using oil, we’d still need it for medicine and medical equipment and supplies. For example, the main ingredient in aspirin is made from petroleum oil.

context.capp.ca/articles/2019/feature_petroleum-in-real-life_pills/

anon12345678901 · 25/08/2021 07:17

@Indecisivelurcher

Name an issue akin to climate change that's been resolved without public protest and disruption?! There isn't one, not that I can think of! So absolutely XR has a role.

You don't have to be a perfect eco hero vegan with dreadlocks living off grid in a yurt and only crapping rose petals to think that 'the system' needs to change. In fact you probably can't, because the system needs to change! That's the point of things like the lady who said she drives a diesel car. These are just normal people, who think that governments, countries, businesses, need to fucking get on with things. And if she was an off-grid vegan then no one would listen to her!

Oh please, what a stupid comment. And actually I'm pretty sure Electric cars exist, why doesn't she have one of those? Instead of her diesel? And why does she go on holiday where it involves a flight? That's not necessary. They are hypocrites, do as I say not do as I do. And yes, they do need to change their individual contributions as well, they keep banging on about everyone doing their bit, well there's a few easy things for them. All members to drive electric cars and not go abroad on holiday.
Darker · 25/08/2021 07:15

Because most oil isn’t actually burned as fuel but used in medicines, cosmetics and so on

What?

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 07:13

@Indecisivelurcher

Name an issue akin to climate change that's been resolved without public protest and disruption?! There isn't one, not that I can think of! So absolutely XR has a role.

You don't have to be a perfect eco hero vegan with dreadlocks living off grid in a yurt and only crapping rose petals to think that 'the system' needs to change. In fact you probably can't, because the system needs to change! That's the point of things like the lady who said she drives a diesel car. These are just normal people, who think that governments, countries, businesses, need to fucking get on with things. And if she was an off-grid vegan then no one would listen to her!

Normal people that fly to Costa Rica? For a holiday and then say it was actually because she needed medical treatment not available here?

The same woman who organises protests, that preventing people getting to appointments for their own medical care?

The climate crisis comes in front of other peoples medical care, but not her own?

It wasn't ever about the diesel car alone.

Also the woman that insisted the manager at a bank can and will give consent for their window to be smashed?

What is an ordinary person? What ordinary person can afford to spend days dicking around in London disrupting people? Fly to Costa Rica for medical care?

PlanDeRaccordement · 25/08/2021 07:12

@Darker

So why is this government opening up new oil fields? What about the companies eyeing up the Antarctic when the ice melts?

Yes lots is being done but more needs to be done. Scientists agree on this.

The public are just as likely to object to extra cycle lanes, wind farms and price hikes on energy bills as they are to measures that harm the environment.

Because most oil isn’t actually burned as fuel but used in medicines, cosmetics and so on.

The Antarctic is sitting in huge geothermal energy sources a million times larger than what Iceland, the only carbon neutral country, uses for their energy. Wouldn’t it be wonderful to capture that natural, carbon free energy?

Theluggage15 · 25/08/2021 07:10

They’re a bunch of useless, hypocritical wankers. I’m laughing at the ‘Lots of retired doctors, lawyers , teachers, police etc are there’. Oh how lovely, the middle classes at play! What a jolly time they’re all having, they can chat about it when they’re on their next holiday in Costa Rica.

The government don’t give a shit about them apart from knowing that they annoy the majority of the public. The fact that they’re causing problems for ordinary working people and small businesses that have had such a hard time during the pandemic makes me loathe them even more.

SimonJT · 25/08/2021 07:09

@54321nought

Why do they never protest in sleepy market towns and villages. In the affluent shires - where the CEOs and policy makers live? Where most of them themselves live.

because they never attack individuals

( and no, thats not where most of them live...)

Oh, so the fact that XR members verbally abuse people isn’t attacking individuals? What about the fact that they smash windows of private properties, how is that not attacking windows?

Does this mean I can verbally abuse you, smash up your home and legitimately claim I didn’t attack you?

Darker · 25/08/2021 07:09

So why is this government opening up new oil fields? What about the companies eyeing up the Antarctic when the ice melts?

Yes lots is being done but more needs to be done. Scientists agree on this.

The public are just as likely to object to extra cycle lanes, wind farms and price hikes on energy bills as they are to measures that harm the environment.

SimonJT · 25/08/2021 07:06

@Darker

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?
I’m aware climate change is real, I’m also very concerned about it.

That doesn’t mean I support a group that causes criminal damage, litters, verbally abuses people or stops people and pets accessing vital medical care.

Indecisivelurcher · 25/08/2021 07:05

Name an issue akin to climate change that's been resolved without public protest and disruption?! There isn't one, not that I can think of! So absolutely XR has a role.

You don't have to be a perfect eco hero vegan with dreadlocks living off grid in a yurt and only crapping rose petals to think that 'the system' needs to change. In fact you probably can't, because the system needs to change! That's the point of things like the lady who said she drives a diesel car. These are just normal people, who think that governments, countries, businesses, need to fucking get on with things. And if she was an off-grid vegan then no one would listen to her!

Waxonwaxoff0 · 25/08/2021 07:04

@Darker

People know about XR (even if they misunderstand them).

I had never heard the term ‘climate emergency’ before XR. They are keeping the subject in the public eye.

So do you think it's acceptable to disrupt public transport systems and therefore disrupt the lives of the working classes trying to make a living?
PlanDeRaccordement · 25/08/2021 07:03

YABU
XR are liars and hypocrites. They lie and say there is inaction, that nothing has been done and take credit for “raising awarenesd” about a problem which everyone is already aware of and governments have been addressing since the 1970s. Then, as other posters have pointed out, their protests and methods only increase greenhouse gases and increase pollution. Not only is there no point in making everyone aware of a problem like climate change, it is hypocritcal to protest in a way that only worsens the problem. They should be ashamed to exist.

The world has already done much to tackle the problems of pollution, especially the pollutants that affect climate change. The worldwide ban in 1987 on CFCs for example has been recognised by scientists as resulting in today being 1.5 C cooler than it would have been had the world not acted...back in 1987.

The whole CO Pact has been around since the 1990s and most of the world has reduced per capita CO2 output and is on track to be carbon neutral in the near future.

XR are like anti flood protesters showing up while Noah is finishing the Ark, vandalising the Ark and complaining that nothing is being done to save the animals and pretending that Noah wouldn’t be building the Ark if it wasn’t for them. Even though he started the Ark long before XR even existed.

Darker · 25/08/2021 07:03

People know about XR (even if they misunderstand them).

I had never heard the term ‘climate emergency’ before XR. They are keeping the subject in the public eye.

lannistunut · 25/08/2021 07:01

Most other protests are ignorable and small, so people don't notice them. People would be fine with XR if they were ignorable too.

The fact that people are calling them wankers etc presumably falls under the category of 'publicity'. Most protests get ignored, which is the worst thing. Getting opposed is presumably fine by them.

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 07:01

@lannistunut

They just hate poor people and the vulnerable.

This statement is completely amazing Grin.

I think the way people try to deflect from the climate discussion is interesting, they'll say pretty much anything to not discuss the climate itself.

But we aren't discuss the climate itself. We are discussing XR and why people don't support them. People aren't saying they don't support them 'because fuck the environment'.

The last thread had loads of things XR could do to gain more support from people AND other things they could do.

If you care about the climate crisis, you don't have an obligation to like or support XR.

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 06:57

@Darker

There are dozens of demonstrations in London every year, for all sorts of reasons. Do the objectors also object to them?
Depends. And to be fair, I am not sure everyone is objecting to XR protesting. They are objecting to XR tactics, the hypocrisy and lack or actually doing anything that helps.

If they wanted to just protest, I can't imagine many propel would be bothered.

newnortherner111 · 25/08/2021 06:57

Valid cause, wrong methods/tactics.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 25/08/2021 06:55

@Darker

There are dozens of demonstrations in London every year, for all sorts of reasons. Do the objectors also object to them?
I object to any protest that deliberately gets in the way of normal folk trying to get to work.

Extinction Rebellion are a bunch of hypocritical sanctimonious arseholes.

lannistunut · 25/08/2021 06:55

They just hate poor people and the vulnerable.

This statement is completely amazing Grin.

I think the way people try to deflect from the climate discussion is interesting, they'll say pretty much anything to not discuss the climate itself.

Darker · 25/08/2021 06:48

There are dozens of demonstrations in London every year, for all sorts of reasons. Do the objectors also object to them?

BritinDelco · 25/08/2021 05:34

I'd XR want people to use public transport instead of cars why on earth would they disrupt public transport by using chemicals - glue- to disrupt public transport. And how did they get there in the 1st place? Bunch of sanctimonious b#$@ in my opinion

Swipe left for the next trending thread