Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
HarrietsChariot · 25/08/2021 09:42

"XR" are hypocritical at best and downright criminal at worst. Their activities cause so much pollution, both through the extra traffic congestion they cause and through their own travel to get to London. I read that their Welsh group was causing the disruption in London the other day - why on earth were they not causing trouble in Cardiff or Swansea or Newport instead? No need to go to London for every protest.

If people were serious about tackling climate change they need to act on an individual level in meaningful ways. That means doing things like not having children, never flying or owning a car, never eating meat, never using public transport for non-essential travel, and importantly, never buying anything from China (at least until they clean up their act). Are those things easy? No, but it all reminds me of the bible story, "take the log of your own eye before criticizing the speck in mine."

Darker · 25/08/2021 09:41

I haven’t made any such assumptions. Can you pick out an example of anyone stating that? It’s a complex issue and I did ask whether people believed in it but that was a question.

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 09:38

@Darker

There are plenty of groups advocating for a reduction in meat consumption, Belle.

Which is great.

You have no way of knowing what choices other posters are making to reduce their carbon footprint.

No you don't have a way of knowing.

But people who dont support XR have had loads of assumptions about their own lifeastyles. Assumptions the not supporting XR means you don't have a shit about the climate crisis. That we just go about not giving a shit, living our life because we assum ot won't impact us.

Etc. Why is it fine when aimed at people who will not support XR, but not the other way round?

Darker · 25/08/2021 09:34

There are plenty of groups advocating for a reduction in meat consumption, Belle.

Which is great.

You have no way of knowing what choices other posters are making to reduce their carbon footprint.

BelleOfTheProvince · 25/08/2021 09:19

The biggest single thing an individual can do for the environment is reduce their meat intake.
Have an of you xr enthusiasts done that or considered it since it was brought up on the last thread?
No. Instead of some positive change, you've started another thread where you minimise and waive away the damage and distress xr cause to ordinary people.

And that 'personal individual changes is not enough' line is handy, isn't it? It means you can continue doing whatever the fuck you want to harm the planet as 'individual efforts don't matter'.

I'm vegan, so I feel perfectly comfortable calling you hypocrites with a clear conscience if you support harming others through xr and make no personal sacrifices yourself.
Not further responding to this thread because there are 900 posts of you ignoring the fact that xr actions hurt the most vulnerable and you don't care.

So hypocritical and uncaring.

Why don't you start a thread on all the positive actions xr can take that wouldn't disrupt the working people in London or people trying to get to the most specialist hospitals in the country?

I know why.

burritofan · 25/08/2021 08:49

But are you saying oil is not used in that list? Biased or not, it's not incorrect...
I’m saying it’s disingenuous and misleading to argue, “Oh, we need fossil fuels, here’s an article” and link to a biased source that of course is going to confirm we need fossil fuels.

We don’t. The IEA, the IPCC, and many more scientific research bodies with far more intelligence and clout than me or any other random on MN has made clear that there are future pathways with no new oil, gas or coal production needed. If we can make renewable energy, free from fossil fuels, of course we can make medicines, cosmetics, etc, without fossil fuels. Anything that can’t be made without them will have an alternative, either already or in research and development; or be banned and we catch up and find the technology to do something different: the way we did with CFCs. Plenty of research companies working on replacements and alternatives to fossil fuel-derived products.

The only people arguing for their continued production are the fossil fuel companies. Who also produced that article. Which was shared as though it were a legitimate source. And I think it’s important to point that out, especially on a chat forum where people spout all kinds of shite to support their agenda – particularly that poster, who’s on every climate thread denying that the climate emergency is manmade – and on the internet, where you can find a spurious link to support literally anything. The internet contains detailed instructions on how to make love to a dolphin, for goodness’ sake. It contains everything. Of course it’s going to contain “oil and gas are grrrrrrreat!” articles.

Parky04 · 25/08/2021 08:21

@Excelthetube

Sorry work from home zooming counting paper clips
Where can I find this role - it would be my ideal job!
Darker · 25/08/2021 08:20

Which one of you is Sarah Vine?

anon12345678901 · 25/08/2021 08:17

@burritofan

And the totally non-biased source of that “we still need to drill for fossil fuels” article is… drumroll… the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers.
But are you saying oil is not used in that list? Biased or not, it's not incorrect...
Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 08:08

@Seagullsstopit

What is an ordinary person? What ordinary person can afford to spend days dicking around in London disrupting people? Fly to Costa Rica for medical care?

It wasn't even medical care, it was a retreat where you get off your tits on psychedelics.
She's a joke.

Absolutely it was. She just though pretending it was for medical care was a better line. But that doesn't makebit any better either
Seagullsstopit · 25/08/2021 08:07

What is an ordinary person? What ordinary person can afford to spend days dicking around in London disrupting people? Fly to Costa Rica for medical care?

It wasn't even medical care, it was a retreat where you get off your tits on psychedelics.
She's a joke.

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 08:02

@ActonSquirrel

What I meant was they don't care about climate change because they are losing it over their holidays and plenty of threads are cropping up with people wanting a long haul holiday with a minimum 10 hour flight.

Sorry you didn't get that. Where did I say XR had anything to do with pcr tests?! Confused

Most people don't care about climate change the way they are going on about their holidays. Was that clear enough for you this time.

Because of the quote you responded to which said

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?

So I presumed your response was in regards to those objecting to XR. Why wouldn't I? I didn't realise it was just a random comment regarding people in general not those objecting to XR and not relevant to the bit you quoted.

Or are there loads of threads where people are objecting to XR because of their own 10 hour flight and PCR test?

GoodGrief100 · 25/08/2021 08:02

Next thing you know, OP will do something silly like supporting the boycott of the upside down dairylea adverts...oh wait.

AtticusHoysAnus · 25/08/2021 07:57

When are you going to China to protest?

Hahaha exactly.

Probably at the same time womens rights activists go to Afghanistan.

Darker · 25/08/2021 07:57

I’ve been shocked at how the media has taken up the idea of a ‘staycation’ being something we need to endure until we can get on a plane and go abroad again. In my day a staycation was a few days when you went on day trips to places within reach of home, with dinner most likely at home in front of the telly.

Seagullsstopit · 25/08/2021 07:55

@54321nought

They are not out to educate, or persuade the public, they are out to disrupt, and get government attention
They should disrupt parliament then and leave the ordinary working class people that are trying to get to work/hospital appointments/to visit dying relatives the fuck alone.

Without public support, you are nothing.

ActonSquirrel · 25/08/2021 07:51

What I meant was they don't care about climate change because they are losing it over their holidays and plenty of threads are cropping up with people wanting a long haul holiday with a minimum 10 hour flight.

Sorry you didn't get that. Where did I say XR had anything to do with pcr tests?! Confused

Most people don't care about climate change the way they are going on about their holidays. Was that clear enough for you this time.

Darker · 25/08/2021 07:51

Most of them have taken no steps to reduce their own carbon footprint

You cannot possibly substantiate this.

I’m not interested in picking out individual people to prove otherwise, I’m interested in this huge generalisation you are making about XR people and their life choices.

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 07:49

Judging the way people on here are losing their shit over holidays and PCR tests I'd wager they know but don't care

Yes because most people on this thread are complaining about xr blocking their pcr test, for their holiday.

Oh nope, that's not correct is it.

ActonSquirrel · 25/08/2021 07:46

I object to XR as it is just wanton destruction. Most of them have taken no steps to reduce their own carbon footprint.

Also the human race will go extinct. It will. The question is when not if. There were species here millennia before we existed and there will species after us. If the human race goes extinct so be it.

Hekatestorch · 25/08/2021 07:44

[quote Indecisivelurcher]**@anon12345678901* and @Hekatestorch* she says she drives diesel and can't afford electric. So because of that, she can't say anything about climate change? I don't agree with that. The point I'm trying to make is that most XR people are normal people, and therefore not perfect. I don't know this particular woman and what she does or doesn't do, she could still be a dick for all I know. Many people are. But even dicks should be talking about climate change at this point!

Sounds like I'm allowed to talk about it, at I drive an electric car and don't fly... So that's good! I'm not vegan though so maybe not...[/quote]
But she has, in tbe time had enough money to fly to Costa Rica? She went from skint, to having that sort of money?

She also said she bought the diesel cat when emissions faked to be lower. What has she done to speak about this and the emission scandal.

Something that has impacted her personally, has duped people into thinking they were making a green choice and is damaging the environment? You know, the climate change activist.

Oh thats right. She did nothing until it was brought up to her and THEN she bought it during the emissions scandal and now she can't afford it.

Again, as I said before. If she went to Costa Rica for a holiday its bad. If she went for medical treatment, it's bad. Because she is happy for other people to not get access to medical care, to put this fight first.

But her own health came before the climate crisis.

She doesn't have to be perfect. But she isn't even doing the basics.

ActonSquirrel · 25/08/2021 07:42

@Darker

Do those of you who object to XR think the threat from climate change is not real? Or that it’s not very serious or urgent?
Judging the way people on here are losing their shit over holidays and PCR tests I'd wager they know but don't care
burritofan · 25/08/2021 07:38

And the totally non-biased source of that “we still need to drill for fossil fuels” article is… drumroll… the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers.

Cam2020 · 25/08/2021 07:35

Talk about it all you want, but stop disrupting the lives of the working classes.

Who also can't afford to drive electric cars or to miss work, most likely.

Darker · 25/08/2021 07:34

Even if all our cars, trains, planes and ships stopped using oil, we’d still need it for medicine and medical equipment and supplies

That’s very, very different from saying most oil is used for those things. And of course we need transportation. But we need to vastly reduce our reliance on oil and gas.

This will involve a change in our way of life, probably as radical as the changes we’ve made as a result of using these resources and learning how to make plastic etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread