Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion

390 replies

54321nought · 24/08/2021 20:18

carrying on from the first thread

here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4327567-to-support-extinction-rebellion-more-London-action-tomorrow?msgid=110225062#110225062

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
9
FuckingFabulous · 21/09/2021 06:44

Someone I used to live with is all over our local press as a member of extinction rebellion. Either being arrested or interviewed. Giving it the lofty moral high ground bullshit. He is a benefit cheat, he steals from his poor elderly parents, he's regularly banging coke up his nostrils, he causes thousands of pounds worth of damage to cars and buildings and beaten up innocent people in relation to it. And he's truly found his kindred spirits in this "movement."

Sure, support them.

YABU.

DdraigGoch · 20/09/2021 23:39

@Draggondragon

I hate the sanctimonious 'the world we leave our children' crap. You have 3 or 4 children compared to another person who has one or none and think you're a hero but you are the problem!
Indeed, the very cause of climate change is that there are too many humans. All manner of polluting activities wouldn't matter if there were only a fraction of the number of people doing them. So the worst thing you can do to our overcrowded planet is reproduce beyond replenishment level.
Furries · 20/09/2021 03:34

Bunch of blooming tits.

Draggondragon · 20/09/2021 02:45

I hate the sanctimonious 'the world we leave our children' crap. You have 3 or 4 children compared to another person who has one or none and think you're a hero but you are the problem!

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 20/09/2021 00:54

They’re just trying to separate themselves from “Insulate Britain, their ex-founder (Roger Hallam)’s new movement and its bad publicity.

Proof from private XR WhatsApp groups that they ARE supporting Insulate Britain:
thecritic.co.uk/astroturfing-xr/

Statements about Roger Hallam starting Insulate Britain are still up on the Animal Rebellion page:
animalrebellion.org/event/roger-hallam-insulate-britain-strategy-and-recruitment/
I included a pic before they can erase it (first pic) since…

Extinction Rebellion Global had an info event for Insulate Britain just one week ago as you can still see on Google (second pic) but that now leads to a “404 Not Found” on their webpage.

Sigh

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
BelleOfTheProvince · 19/09/2021 20:14

Not xr but some tragic results of poorly thought through protest here.
www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10004241/amp/Son-reveals-mum-left-paralysed-getting-stuck-SIX-HOURS-M25-eco-mob.html

Darker · 08/09/2021 11:26

Whatever people are doing, by whatever means, it isn't enough.

Leaked government emails reveal ministers have bowed to pressure to drop key climate commitments from the UK-Australia trade deal in order to get it over the line.

news.sky.com/story/exclusive-ministers-bowed-to-pressure-to-drop-key-climate-commitments-for-uk-trade-deal-with-australia-12401988

DismantledKing · 03/09/2021 19:30

Not exactly bringing the public with them, are they?

to continue to support Extinction Rebellion
Darker · 01/09/2021 18:23

individuals matters to us because we can identify with them and we can feel the agony of their situation. We can also make a direct causal link between the protest events of the day and the outcome. This is upsetting. Of course it is. It’s heartbreaking.

On the other hand millions of people are losing their lives or being harmed because of climate change, by rising sea levels or famine or flood or wildfires. We can’t make a causal link between their suffering and any particular failure or action. It’s just too big and too abstract. So we feel helpless and try not to dwell on it.

That’s why we need governments and people with power to tackle it and why corporations need to be held to account - it’s too easy for them to offer greenwash solutions and bargain their way out of the kind of changes that are needed.

Crowtooyo · 01/09/2021 17:58

Okay. Just got confused as you said 'what would you suggest' when I clearly said I didn't know what to suggest.
I still don't agree with the extremes they are taking. How would they feel if they missed their loved one dying?

Darker · 01/09/2021 14:43

Yes I read your post.

My sympathy is with XR because they are at least trying to get climate change to the top of the agenda. No-one on this thread has come up with any remotely viable alternatives except what amounts to giving up.

Crowtooyo · 01/09/2021 14:30

@Darker

I agree that something needs to happen about climate change

If you agree that not enough is being done, what would you suggest?

If you read my full post I said I'm not sure what to suggest. But I think blocking emergency vehicles and traffic is not the way to go about it. A) it's dangerous B) paints them in a bad light instead of gaining support.
Darker · 01/09/2021 13:49

I agree that something needs to happen about climate change

If you agree that not enough is being done, what would you suggest?

Darker · 01/09/2021 13:40

XR are advocating deliberative democracy with the citizens assembly.

They are also exercising their democratic right to non-violent protest.

They are not presenting solutions but demanding that the people who do actually have the power take action.

Crowtooyo · 01/09/2021 13:37

I agree that something needs to happen about climate change etc... I'm not sure the best way to go about it. But they came to Bristol once and blocked off the main road in to Bristol. I know of someone who sadly missed saying goodbye to their dying father in the hospital because the road was blocked off. That for me is unforgivable.

DynamoKev · 01/09/2021 13:34

[quote Darker]My issue with Harriet is that her arguments don't take into consideration the people who suffer as a result of other's choices.

What about the 'rights' of an asthmatic child who lives next to a main road, a community in Bangladesh at risk from rising sea levels, the people who will die and lose their livelihoods in disasters? See link below:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-58396975[/quote]
Darker - I accept your points, but I'm having trouble imagining how the power structures in the world will need to change to favour those people currently at risk. I have asked you a few times what you think but you choose not answer (obvs you aren't obliged).
I will confess I don't see XR and the like as a beacon of democracy.

burritofan · 01/09/2021 12:48

Arguably the second person has a more valid point, because climate change will only be a significant problem in the future (as in, extinction of the human race)
Eh, have you missed the part where climate change is already here and already impacting billions of people worldwide? I’d say the people whose houses have burned down, whose children have drowned in front of them, who are starving through drought or displaced by heat, would probably say the problem is already pretty significant Hmm

Darker · 01/09/2021 12:46

My issue with Harriet is that her arguments don't take into consideration the people who suffer as a result of other's choices.

What about the 'rights' of an asthmatic child who lives next to a main road, a community in Bangladesh at risk from rising sea levels, the people who will die and lose their livelihoods in disasters? See link below:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-58396975

Xenia · 01/09/2021 12:29

I agree with Harriet, although I do support the right of anyone including those in favour of hunting foxes and XR and many other groups to demonstrate within the law and peacefully but not criminal damage and they should be forced to pick up all their own litter and not stop people going to work or hospital etc.

Darker · 01/09/2021 12:16

@Andante57

Iannistunut

No such thing as bad publicity as they say!

Not sure the message is getting through. The attendance at Reading festival was mostly young people who are supposed to the ones most environmentally aware but look at the mess they’ve left at the festival site, including masses of throwaway tents.

This is insane. What connects young people behaving atrociously at Reading to XR?

What have I missed?

Darker · 01/09/2021 12:14

XR are directly targeting printing presses and milk factories and the financial areas where people who invest in fossil fuels are based. They have targeted airports.

I don’t agree with. All they do (I didn’t agree with targeting public transport and I seriously worry about drones causing an air accident and death to innocent people) but I think that they are making a lot of noise to people who otherwise shut their eyes and ears to the damage being done to the environment.

Andante57 · 01/09/2021 12:09

Iannistunut

No such thing as bad publicity as they say!

Not sure the message is getting through. The attendance at Reading festival was mostly young people who are supposed to the ones most environmentally aware but look at the mess they’ve left at the festival site, including masses of throwaway tents.

DynamoKev · 01/09/2021 12:04

@Darker

I'd lay money that most people complaining about XR disrupting things have not been inconvenienced at all or only mildly inconvenienced.

Greenham women were hugely derided at the time. It cost public money to police their activity.

I remember them being derided - it was hard going because almost everyone I worked with hated them and I supported them.
The fact remains, they didn't do the protests by putting a pink boat or a table in central London, or gluing themselves to Tube trains. They focused on the source of the issue. The source of the climate emergency is not people going to work or a medical appointment on a Tube train in London.
Return2thebasic · 01/09/2021 11:59

Actually I didn't mean these quoted lines. I mean all of your arguments.

Return2thebasic · 01/09/2021 11:58

@Darker

I'd lay money that most people complaining about XR disrupting things have not been inconvenienced at all or only mildly inconvenienced.

Greenham women were hugely derided at the time. It cost public money to police their activity.

@Darker, you know your own view is "hugely" biased, right?