Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why the NHS is cancelling operations?!

371 replies

CFEC · 24/08/2021 15:19

I'm due to have a (much needed and waited for) op in a few weeks time, I've just rung my consultant's secretary as I haven't had a pre-op appointment letter through yet and queried it, as I wanted to make sure the operation is definitely going ahead as if nothing else, I'll be off work for 2 weeks and my boss would ideally like confirmation.

She said 'Oh, well they're cancelling A LOT of inpatient appointments, but as you'll be a day patient no, I think yours will go ahead.'

I swear I will lose my sh&^ and cry if it gets cancelled again, this will be the third time!!!

Why is the NHS cancelling operations left, right and centre?! Surely it can't be due to Covid still? If it is, what is going to happen to us all, so many people are going to die surely as a result of not getting treatment? A lot more than with Covid! Most people are double vaccinated now, this virus isn't going away, why are operations for in patients being cancelled?

OP posts:
Gumboots29 · 24/08/2021 18:58

@CFEC

For those asking why I won’t pay for healthcare if I have the means, I have tried!! The waiting list currently for private is longer than my scheduled op in a few weeks, much longer in fact. The receptionist at the private hospital said people are going over to private in droves as they’re not getting the care from the NHS and now private are struggling to cope and have 4 month waiting lists.

Also, my op will cost £5,500 private, we have £6k in savings...it would pretty much wipe us out and leave nothing for an emergency fund should one of us lose our jobs, boiler breaks etc. So I’m reluctant to pay to go private unless I absolutely have to. (And yes before people start I do realise I’m lucky that we have 6k in savings blah blah, it’s hardly an astronomical amount though!!) I’ll try one last time on the NHS.

Yes to this. This week I’ve struggled to get an urgent op on NHS. I tried with my private healthcare which I have with work but rarely use and their waiting list was longer. For lots of ops they rent NHS theatres and there is no space.

FWIW I was told the lack of theatre space was a combo of a backlog of delayed ops from covid and staff shortages (due to covid/isolating).

Private health care is not always as straightforward as it seems. I’ve lived in places were I’ve had to pay for it and it’s a nightmare. Lots of limitations unless you have an extremely expensive policy.

BoaCunstrictor · 24/08/2021 18:47

@NotPersephone

I think it’s worse even that *@BoaCunstrictor* - we’re replacing the NHS with a single, for-profit provider. Which means the worst of socialized (no patient choice, same waiting list) with the worst of private (maximizing profit by cheap provision, encouraging low-balling and therefore the barest service).
The British way when it comes to privatisation!
Zilla1 · 24/08/2021 18:38

@NotPersephone I've skimmed global studies like

www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2021/aug/mirror-mirror-2021-reflecting-poorly#rank

which on the face of it has NHS performance against expenditure might appear reasonable (UK is fourth highest out of 11 richer nations for performance with the fourth smallest spend relative to GDP).

worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/best-healthcare-in-the-world

seems to have the UK as ranking 18th of 181.

I've seen individual specialisms and outcomes rated poor such as those relating to certain cancer outcomes and timeliness of treatment but grateful for references to analyses of overall performance that is 'embarrassingly bad'.

NotPersephone · 24/08/2021 18:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BoaCunstrictor · 24/08/2021 18:25

Yes, the problem is that while non-socialised options other than the US model exist, we all know full fucking well which we'd be most likely to end up with.

Zotter · 24/08/2021 18:17

See people say this sort of thing about America all the time on these threads, but it isn't a binary choice between US style healthcare where it's 100% free market privatised and if you don't have insurance you're screwed, or the NHS.

No, it isn’t but Tories are taking us slowly but surely down the path towards the US for profit healthcare model.

DiscoDown21 · 24/08/2021 18:17

I can only speak for the one I work in. But we are rammed. A&e is ridiculous most days. We still have more than one ward open for Covid plus ICU/HDU beds being used. Still regularly admitting Covid patients.

But it’s not Covid inpatients causing major issues: It’s like winter with lots of illnesses that people are catching now they are mixing. Also staff are on leave as it’s school holidays and summer, ( lots of staff are owed leave from not taking it during the worst of the pandemic too) or like my ward: staff are catching Covid and are off sick/isolating. If there aren’t enough staff to staff theatres or the ward safety operations can’t happen.

My trust is doing well at still running electives and catching up. We’ve used private and community facilities throughout lockdowns too. But it only takes a couple of staff off sick or influx of patients to take up remaining beds to stop a theatre list.

Someone mentioned the BBC hospital programme. That documents very well the pressures hospitals have to keep surgery going when running low on beds.

Sugarandtime · 24/08/2021 18:17

The NHS has been on it’s knees at breaking point for as long as I can remember. Regardless of what party has been in power.

Theworldisfullofgs · 24/08/2021 18:12

See people say this sort of thing about America all the time on these threads, but it isn't a binary choice between US style healthcare where it's 100% free market privatised...

Please read my post properly before being outraged. I said not the US, I didn't say it was the only option. Ireland and France both have a hybrid option, both have their flaws as well. Any system does.

The NGS was conceived in a different time. It gets tinkered with but most things are politically driven and short term. I expect, if the NHS, was left to sort itself out, it would develop some kind of hybrid model that was slightly different in each area depending on both the population and the environment.

CFEC · 24/08/2021 18:11

For those asking why I won’t pay for healthcare if I have the means, I have tried!! The waiting list currently for private is longer than my scheduled op in a few weeks, much longer in fact. The receptionist at the private hospital said people are going over to private in droves as they’re not getting the care from the NHS and now private are struggling to cope and have 4 month waiting lists.

Also, my op will cost £5,500 private, we have £6k in savings...it would pretty much wipe us out and leave nothing for an emergency fund should one of us lose our jobs, boiler breaks etc. So I’m reluctant to pay to go private unless I absolutely have to. (And yes before people start I do realise I’m lucky that we have 6k in savings blah blah, it’s hardly an astronomical amount though!!) I’ll try one last time on the NHS.

OP posts:
StrangeToSee · 24/08/2021 18:03

Lack of staff.

Many of those doctors, nurses and clinicians working through the pandemic have left their professions, are sick with long covid, or burnt out and off sick with stress, or taking career breaks to get their mental health back together.

Private is the only option if you don’t want to wait months/years for routine procedures.

RuthW · 24/08/2021 18:00

We at the nhs are on our knees. Staff ill or isolating added to annual leave not taken during the pandemic plus playing catchup. Things are far far from being back to pre pandemic levels.

BoaCunstrictor · 24/08/2021 17:59

TMs proposal started a discussion we as a society need to have. But think about who votes most, and how that differs demographically from who posts on MN most...

NotPersephone · 24/08/2021 17:58

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 24/08/2021 17:57

And of course people on MN always say they'd be very happy to vote for higher taxes/better NHS but the election results for the last 20 years very much speak against that being the reality for the majority of Brits (anyone remember Teresa May's 'dementia tax' which last all of about 10 seconds as a suggestion before being met with disgust/rotten tomatoes/approval ratings plunge?), but maybe Covid will have changed that? I do think most people think it's someone else's problem though, most people think 'the rich' should pay more taxes (conveniently designating the 'rich' as never including themselves) or that 'businesses' should pay more, again forgetting that if businesses need to save money or go outside the UK then job losses will result and no-one wants that either. I don't think there are easy solutions certainly, it's really complex and difficult and certainly not as simple as 'the government should fund it better'...

Absolutely agree with this. I wouldn't pay higher taxes because I don't trust it to be spent on the NHS. But I would be willing to pay a (reasonable) fee for things like GP appointments or blood tests providing the money goes into the NHS. I thought TM's plan was reasonable, if you have the money why wouldn't you you pay for your care? (Speaking as someone whose MIL is self-funding in a £1100 a week care home.)

Newpuppymummy · 24/08/2021 17:56

There still lots of people in hospital with covid. I’m pretty sure as many people as there was last October (we went into lockdown November). Plus there is a massive backlog of previously cancelled operations. There’s just not enough beds/staff

Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 24/08/2021 17:52

It’s tough, I’m waiting for gastroenterologist and orthopaedic surgeons poss for surgery, on my knee, can’t work becuase of it. Nurse so the longer it takes the longer I’m off it’s a vicious cycle of pain and upset and my work are being lovely but I’m an experienced nurse and I won’t To go back to work

chairfoxlight · 24/08/2021 17:50

NHS or private - there are only so many trained staff members in the U.K. in relation to the population.

A private health service in time would entice people to join the ranks for better pay and working conditions (but less AL and pension I expect) creating better service provision but that's years in the making.

For now, a private Heath service instead of the NHS won't open doors quickly, the queue would be just as long with more people trying to jump it 'coz they have to pay now'. And a lot of NHSers disagree with private healthcare so you won't get loads of staff jumping ship to staff these new private super hospitals that take years to build.

None of this helps us with now and coming few years.

Peacrock · 24/08/2021 17:49

Until the government sort out staff retention, this is the future unfortunately.

ladyp87 · 24/08/2021 17:49

@lannistunut

Another one saying the NHS was vastly better 15 years ago, the Tories have done what they always do which is cut cut cut. Always money for crony contracts though. No magic money tree... unless you are Hancock's mate, or Johnson's mate, or a big Tory donor of course.

And operations are being cancelled because of covid, there is too much pressure on the system - and it is AUGUST.

Exactly this! Corrupt government handing out money to their mates and underfunding health care paid for by OUR tax's
bunnybuggs · 24/08/2021 17:48

Vastly increased/increasing population adds to the burden.
The NHS needs reform to do any kind of good service for the people relying on it.
No-one wants to go down the road of American healthcare where people die because they cannot afford treatment but a more European model where insurance is the answer, stopping tourist healthcare, supporting those who cannot afford the premiums and recognise that the current structure (e.g.GPs being independent contractors) does not work.
Local minor injuries/treatment centres that can do the non-urgent cases.

Try to lessen the impact of the numerous PFI contracts that labour Angry under Blair brought in which cost so much that should be going to the front line. They (new labour) have a lot to answer for too.
Oh - and stop the stupid test everyone and ping any contact via the app so the employees are sent home unnecessarily.
Not holding my breath.

maxelly · 24/08/2021 17:46

@Theworldisfullofgs

If we privatised or semi privatised we'd have to make sure we didn't end up like the States where you are only one bad illness away from bankruptc.

Personally, I think its the politicisation of healthcard that is the problem. It costs £££££££ to keep rearranging things with no obvious outcome other than enabling governments to de like they are doing something whilst being able to say 'it's too early to tell yet'.

See people say this sort of thing about America all the time on these threads, but it isn't a binary choice between US style healthcare where it's 100% free market privatised and if you don't have insurance you're screwed, or the NHS. Virtually every other country in the world, including Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Japan, New Zealand, I could go on has some form of an in-between model where insurance is highly regulated and subsidized by the state and hospitals are either state run, privately run (but again, highly regulated) or a mix of both. So saying 'but look at the US!' is not an answer/rebuttal to those that think some degree of privatization is the way to go. I'm not necessarily one of those people BTW but I do think if we want to stick with the current model we are going to have to accept we either need to pay more or have lower quality - the way we are currently doing where we spend less per capita on healthcare than virtually anywhere else in the developed world but still expect first class service seems unsustainable.

And of course people on MN always say they'd be very happy to vote for higher taxes/better NHS but the election results for the last 20 years very much speak against that being the reality for the majority of Brits (anyone remember Teresa May's 'dementia tax' which last all of about 10 seconds as a suggestion before being met with disgust/rotten tomatoes/approval ratings plunge?), but maybe Covid will have changed that? I do think most people think it's someone else's problem though, most people think 'the rich' should pay more taxes (conveniently designating the 'rich' as never including themselves) or that 'businesses' should pay more, again forgetting that if businesses need to save money or go outside the UK then job losses will result and no-one wants that either. I don't think there are easy solutions certainly, it's really complex and difficult and certainly not as simple as 'the government should fund it better'...

igelkott2021 · 24/08/2021 17:45

I appreciate the NHS wasn't in a great state pre-covid, but it just seems madness that a virus that is here to stay, that 87% of the adult population is inoculated against, is still going to grind the NHS to a halt this winter AGAIN

It's not just covid OP. My mum had an operation cancelled three times in a row in 2017 because of the bad flu outbreak. Once she was ready to go into theatre and it was called off at the last minute because they'd turned the orthopedic ward into a flu ward!

Zotter · 24/08/2021 17:45

I've been saying for years that it should be privatised

Please no private for profit model. Govt needs to fund it adequately. Budgets rose by 1.4 per cent each year on average (adjusting for inflation) in the 10 years between 2009/10 to 2018/19, compared to the 3.7 per cent average rises since the NHS was established.

Annual % increased a bit (around 3%) since 2018/19 but not enough to catch up by a long shot. France, Germany, Scandinavia all spend a larger % of GDP on healthcare than U.K. Plus our social care funding is dire and affects NHS budget too.

BoaCunstrictor · 24/08/2021 17:45

I'd pay more tax to ensure an adequate system too. Try and make it only available below a certain income and I'll be paying plenty less.