Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Non binary in school [title edited by MNHQ]

110 replies

malificent7 · 24/08/2021 11:35

Done to death i know but i dont know how to feel.
Dd (13) says loads of her peers are non binary and she finds it confusing. Lots of confusion about pronouns etc.
In dsd school appatently they have had lessons on it ( in what context im not sure).
Everyone is bi which there is no real big deal as at least everyone is learning about the horrors of homophobia.
Its good that ultra feminine/ masculine traits are being questioned...isn't it?
Dd is very sure of her femininity and declares herself as straight/ girly which is not without problems as she likes the faux nails/big bum/ preened eyebrows look.

OP posts:
trancepants · 24/08/2021 12:19

@isthisareverse

I am looking forward to the day we'll be buying "gender neutral" puppies or kitten Hmm

because if we can dismiss the sex we were born with, the same applies to everybody else surely.

Well technically....., my dog has XY chromosomes but no bollocks so I guess that makes him non-binary?
nearlyhellokitty · 24/08/2021 12:19

all these people saying there's only male and female people do know that biologically 1-2 people in a 100 are intersex?? life is a lot more complicated.

non-binary is about how you feel in your head. if you listen to people who actually identify as that - often in later life, it's the only thing that's makes sense to them as to how they feel. it's all very well if you don't feel that but don't be so rude as to reject someone else's experience adn call it 'bollocks'. That's in fact incredibly rude.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 24/08/2021 12:17

Its good that ultra feminine/ masculine traits are being questioned...isn't it?

There's the rub. They are not being questioned, they are being reinforced.

Gender ideology does what it says on the tin. It subscribes, wholesale, to all this feminine = pink, glitter, unicorns and long hair; masculine = blue, machismo, superheroes, no effeminacy allowed kind of nonsense. Men are from Mars, women are from Venus. Men are the breadmakers, women are homemakers. Public sphere = masculine, domestic hearth and home = feminine.

These are precisely the kind of reductive gender stereotypes feminists in particular have been challenging for at least the last century. There's no demonstrable connection between these imagined gender traits and [immutable] human biology that designates whether we are male or female.

This whole recent gender anxiety stems from the reinforcement of those stereotypes, not a challenge to them. 'I like pink and glitter so I must be a girl' is clearly (to me, anyway) bunkum. In these terms, non-binary becomes meaningless because we are all fall somewhere in that category.

Parcelling yourself up in another identity 'box' and shoving a neat little label on yourself merely reinforces those ideologies. It doesn't challenge them in any way whatsoever. 'Gender' is such a nebulous concept that I've seen anyone able to establish in any way what 'feeling like a woman', or a man, or for that matter, neither, actually entails.

Unsure what the YABU/YANBU refers to. If it's a scratching of your head over the whole messed-up shebang, YANBU. If it's a belief that any of this reductive, dictatorial ideology is in any way subversive, YABU!

Mazblue86 · 24/08/2021 12:17

@Itsanewdah

its great. there are millions of ways of being human, no need to fit into 2 random categories.
'Two random categories...' Come on...
PlanDeRaccordement · 24/08/2021 12:17

Well, gender hypothesis has gender being a spectrum rather than binary of two choices. So the way to explain it is to draw a line and at one end put stereotypical boy/man and on the other end stereotypical girl/woman. Then ask your child, how many people do you think meet all the gender stereotypes that exist for their sex? The answer will be very few. The vast majority of people do not meet all gender stereotypes. So then show her that means in gender hypothesis language that only a few people are actually “binary.” The rest of us, don’t meet all the stereotypes, and therefore are non-binary. Non-binary really means average or the norm, a person who isn’t a living example of all stereotypes for their sex and we fall all along the gender spectrum which is literally defined by gender stereotypes.

Then you can go over the problems of defining gender through stereotypes. How it is restrictive and how it changes over time and by culture.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 24/08/2021 12:17

What's confusing about saying 'they' or 'them' Confused

Its not a big deal.

BeauxRingarde · 24/08/2021 12:16

@Itsanewdah

its great. there are millions of ways of being human, no need to fit into 2 random categories.
There always were, and there weren't two random categories.

It's NOW that children are being forced into boxes. If you're not ultra feminine then you're non-binary or trans, even though all you actual are is a perfectly average girl.

It's reductive offensive bollocks.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 24/08/2021 12:13

@Hopdathelf

No it’s not good because it’s very reductive. There used to be myriad ways of being a woman, all as valid as one another. Now you’re either a woman or you’re non binary. Too many non-girly girls or tomboys are being told they’re non-binary. It medicalises what is basic personal choice to adapt from day to day without labelling it.
That's a very good point. I wonder what would my label be if I was growing up now as a tomboy who occasionally liked pretty girly stuff
CatsArePeople · 24/08/2021 12:13

everybody is essentially non-binary and every generation pushed gender norms to a certain extent.
Its important that kids are occupied with something worthwhile and don't have too much time for internet.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/08/2021 12:12

IMO it’s a fashion. Or a fad, if you prefer. And at that age they’re so often painfully conscious of fashion, whether clothes or the words they use, or anything else.

DontBeAHaterDear · 24/08/2021 12:09

Lots of if not all, my daughter’s school friends are non binary or trans or gay/bisexual/Pansexual. Some are a combination. My daughter is a lesbian. Neither of us are arsed about it, her friends are her friends, they’re all very young and finding stuff out about themselves and those around them and dealing with all the same stuff we all did as teenagers only now they can be open about it. That’s brilliant imo. I remember being sure I was a lesbian when a teenager (whether I was or wasn’t, I’m not now) and feeling like I couldn’t talk about it openly. I’m in my 30s- not like I was born in a totally different time or anything.

I really don’t see the harm in exploring this stuff as long as no one is being hurt or exploited, and that can and does happen to straight, cis young people plenty so my attitude is the same either way.

SmokeyDevil · 24/08/2021 12:08

I have decided, after a long think about it with many debates, tantrums and discussions with my peers, and writing lists to decide what I am and how I am to be perceived, in the long and short of it that I am human. Grin

Who actually, worthwhile talking to at least, gives a fuck what's between your legs and what your corresponding likes and dislikes are? Anyone that gives a shit about that is a complete moron and isn't worth talking to.

You are born either male or female. Liking cars doesn't make you any less female, and liking fashion doesn't make you any less male. Who gives a toss? No one worth while!

Beowulfa · 24/08/2021 12:03

What do these teenagers understand by "non binary"?

If they mean, people who don't want to conform to tedious masculine/feminine gender stereotypes, then great. You can have lots of fun looking up videos of 80s pop stars with them. And reiterating that of course women can be chemical engineers and men can be social workers.

If they mean they are no longer either male or female then you need to be clear that nobody gets to opt out of biological reality.

Velvetap · 24/08/2021 12:00

One of the many good reasons to home educate.

AdditionalCharacter · 24/08/2021 11:57

DS3 (13) refers to everyone as they/them, and says that most of his school use those pronouns. I've suggested to him that he should use he/she/him/her unless told otherwise, but he's not having it.

AFS1 · 24/08/2021 11:56

My daughter is facing this within her friendship group. It’s a social contagion amongst predominantly pre-teen and teenage girls. She tries very hard to use the new names and pronouns by her friends, but it’s not easy when she’s known some of them by different names and pronouns since they were 5.

My personal view is that for the vast majority of these children it’s a fad that they’ll grow out of if they’re allowed to. My concern is they’re being taken down a path led by professionals where it will not be possible for them to change their minds back again.

And I agree with the first PP. It’s an erosion of accepting women and men in whatever way they present. We’re heading back 50 years where if you’re not stereotypical for your gender, you’re not that gender anymore.

Spottybluepyjamas · 24/08/2021 11:54

It's great to challenge gender norms. But saying that people are anything other than male or female is like saying the world is flat. You can't change your sex chromosomes.

Apart from not being possible to switch sex (apart from in extreme cases such as where people are mis-sexed at birth) it's regressive. For example, defining a woman with anything other than biology suggests there are other traits that should hold women together as a class. Which is what? Behaviour/dressing a certain way/wearing makeup/getting back in the kitchen?

I think that the only thing that makes me a woman is my DNA/chromosomes - anything other than that is defined by a misogynistic society designed to reinforce gender stereotypes.

Men can wear dresses, wear makeup. Whatever. They are not a woman, nor are they neither sex - they are still men.

I really hope society finds a way to help trans people, and those who feel that they do not typically fit into a male/female category, feel safe and free to be who they are, but erasing the biological reality of sex is not the way to do it.

countrygirl99 · 24/08/2021 11:54

@Itsanewdah

its great. there are millions of ways of being human, no need to fit into 2 random categories.
They aren't random categories, they are basic biology and it can make a real difference for medical treatment. Much better to break down gender stereotypes.
DuckDuckGooses · 24/08/2021 11:54

It's just a bit trendy right now to be non binary! I think it's quite harmful how it is being pushed about - teenagers and young adults are in that stage of life trying to figure out who they are, what they like etc and now they're being bombarded by new categories that the internet is telling them they belong in because they prefer blue to pink or something equally silly. I have no doubt that some teenagers may feel like this, but the majority are being taught that if they like or do anything outside of regular "girly" or "boy" things to question their identity. Tomboys have all but disappeared because everyone is suddenly non binary etc!

IAmNotAClownfish · 24/08/2021 11:53

It is all rubbish, no one is 100% masculine or feminine, but you will always be the sex you were born. It's all personality, but declaring yourself non-binary makes you extra special.

I imagine this thread will be sent off to the naughty corner soon when the usual suspects report it. See you there!

isthisareverse · 24/08/2021 11:52

I am looking forward to the day we'll be buying "gender neutral" puppies or kitten Hmm

because if we can dismiss the sex we were born with, the same applies to everybody else surely.

Faceicle · 24/08/2021 11:52

I'm sorry that your daughter and her peers are being pressured into accepting and asserting the new binary way of thinking, that they must either be hyper masculine or feminine in their presentation and expression or alternatively must be non binary. It's not progressive. I've heard some peer reports that nonbinary identities can act as a soft landing away from adopting a trans identity and thus may be the reversible pause button that puberty blockers were erroneously once feted as.

FFSFFSFFS · 24/08/2021 11:52

Well - I can guarantee you that all the non-binary human females are still sexually harassed by all the non-binary male females.

You can't opt of the sexism.

You can however reinforce gender stereotypes which perpetuate sexism though.

Non-binary. I mean seriously.

Comedycook · 24/08/2021 11:49

@Itsanewdah

its great. there are millions of ways of being human, no need to fit into 2 random categories.
What two random categories do you mean? Biological sex? Hobbies, interests and dress sense are entirely separate to our sex.
NailsNeedDoing · 24/08/2021 11:49

It’s ridiculous. They can teach about homophobia in the same context as racism and discrimination. But when kids regularly leave school with no idea how to cook, budget, pay bills or any idea what an interest rate it, I really can’t see why we need to be teaching them this shite.

Swipe left for the next trending thread