Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emergency spiritual help needed!

428 replies

GrrrlPwr · 24/08/2021 11:06

We are moving house. This house has a 'presence'. It is not a happy presence. And we would rather not move house with it!

Have already had a priest round to bless the house which helped.

But it's still not gone. The presence not the priest. He went after a cup of tea and a biscuit.

Removal men commented they could 'feel' the presence too.

So. Any ideas?

Any leaving the house ceremony type thing from another culture we could borrow?

We are white British Christian background. So open to any ideas! Thanks

OP posts:
Dervel · 26/08/2021 13:54

@XDownwiththissortofthingX it’s not only unreasonable to call those with faith ‘whacko’, it’s actually provably and empirically wrong. I’m assuming you are using the term ‘whacko’ as a pejorative synonymous with crazy, but are you aware that having faith makes you statistically less susceptible to mental illness?

Here is study on depression and faith:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3426191/

And here is another on mental health/spirituality:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3705681/

It is interesting to note it doesn’t specifically matter which tradition you find your faith in, simply that it exists. However this a growing body of evidence of the overall psychological benefits of faith across a population. (Fewer suicides, assistance in managing addictions, quicker resolution of severe episodes like depression). Now it is true there are a few faith based manias and such, but much like a good vaccine to the body whilst there will be a few negative side effects there is wider benefits to an overall population’s psychological health.

Now I am curious how you’ll respond to this. I wonder if upon reading this you will roll back your position on those with faith being ‘whacko’ believing so being rational, upon the production of scientific evidence of the contrary (it would show pretty strong commitment to the scientific/rational worldview you espouse. Perhaps you will scurry off and try to produce studies suggesting the obverse, maybe even trying to attack the methodology of the studies I have linked (it’s ok I have more, I just posted a few for the sake of brevity). Perhaps you will endeavour some semantic, linguistic sleight-of-hand to uncouple the term whacko, from actual mental health issues, when it is that precise etymological connotation that lends the word it’s pejorative power. Or perhaps you feel too boxed into a corner to respond at all?

In short I’m not making a truth claim about which religion is “true” or “right”, I am merely claiming faith itself has an empirical, measurable utility to humanity, and it actually strengthens our sanity and mental health, so calling those who have it whacko is actually inaccurate.

MakeMathsFun · 26/08/2021 13:48

I suppose for "EMERGENCY help" in these matters, you need to dial 666 instead of 999?

MakeMathsFun · 26/08/2021 13:46

@GrrrlPwr

Could you please define your experiences that directly led you to believe in a "presence" in the house. What do you see, hear, smell, feel, etc.?

MakeMathsFun · 26/08/2021 13:44

[quote XDownwiththissortofthingX]@MakeMathsFun

Not far off.

All religions are cults, doesn't matter how profligate they are, how long-lived they are, or whether they are regarded as cultural identities or not. Their adherents are cultists whether they regard themselves as belonging to a cult or not, and yes, given what they believe and what religious practice sometimes involves, I think it's entirely reasonable to describe them as 'whacko'.[/quote]
Thank you. On a different thread I made a comment that belief does not prove reality. I think that says it all.

ChargingBuck · 26/08/2021 13:38

[quote Cissyandflora]@ChargingBuck this could actually be true.
@Monestera could be a mental health specialist.[/quote]
Grin Grin Grin

MakeMathsFun · 26/08/2021 13:38

@EmotionalSupportBear

My point was that XDownwiththissortofthingX seems to consider
ALL cults as "whacko". There was no singling out. Therefore not racist to indigenous peoples. Not requiring defense, just clearer understanding before blame.

Ibelieveinghosts · 26/08/2021 13:27

@Lweji

There is no right or wrong here just perspectives.

For some things, there is more than just perspectives. That's an idea that has been passed on by, well, people who don't want their methods and practices and claims scrutinised.

Say, home decoration, yes, it's a matter of perspective.
Health, less so.

Well that’s entirely your own perspective to which you’re entitled 😁
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 26/08/2021 13:26

I wouldn’t take anyone’s word for it on this thread about what the Catholic Church believes

Fair point, though this pearler is far from the only thing that raises a quizzical eyebrow about the Catholic church.

Cissyandflora · 26/08/2021 13:21

@ChargingBuck this could actually be true.
@Monestera could be a mental health specialist.

GraceTheCat · 26/08/2021 13:20

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

I wouldn’t take anyone’s word for it on this thread about what the Catholic Church believes.

Whomever said they will bless your house to calm you down? That’s just not true. No religion is practicing their faith just to make someone else feel ok. House blessing are something that they do for people when asked. It’s not about ghostly activity, just a blessing.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 26/08/2021 13:03

@MakeMathsFun

Not far off.

All religions are cults, doesn't matter how profligate they are, how long-lived they are, or whether they are regarded as cultural identities or not. Their adherents are cultists whether they regard themselves as belonging to a cult or not, and yes, given what they believe and what religious practice sometimes involves, I think it's entirely reasonable to describe them as 'whacko'.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 26/08/2021 13:00

@Foxlover46

So if the church only decide to help after a mental health evaluation then surely if you were suffering from any kind of depression or anxiety they would consider you to have mental health issues ? So therefore would that mean they wouldn't help ?
So let's get this straight -

Catholicism simultaneously expects you to believe in the existence of the divine, the afterlife, transubstantiation, and so on, and all this is regarded as a sign of being perfectly sane and healthy, but if you declare the existence of any sort of 'dark' entity, the first assumption is that you must be mentally ill?

Right...

ChargingBuck · 26/08/2021 12:57

@Monestera

I’m an expert in these kinds of things and unfortunately I don’t have good news. In my professional experience, the presences will follow you everywhere you go.
Wow!

Where did you train, to gain this professional experience, & what are your qualifications?

LoislovesStewie · 26/08/2021 12:48

As an aside;several years ago I watched a TV programme about people who thought they had seen ghosts. One man who was a scientist had experienced something odd while he was alone at night in the lab. Being a scientist he attempted to find a rational explanation and to paraphrase he realized that if the extractor fan near the lab bench was working at a particular level (revs per minute or such like) and his head was in a certain position he 'saw' out of the corner of his eye, something that couldn't be there. In other words his brain was interpreting something in a way that was wrong due to certain physical conditions. Obviously I am shortening the explanation, but I am convinced that lots of these paranormal incidents can be explained by rational phenomena.
Thought I would just say that.

ThePluckOfTheCoward · 26/08/2021 12:48

And here comes the bunfight, so bloody tedious.

Lweji · 26/08/2021 12:26

ESB, I mentioned your spelling, because you've used the same wrong spelling throughout the thread.

Anyway... as much as we should respect anyone's culture, smudging has no demonstrable health effect (although apparently sage extracts might have some benefits), I think we all have the right to call any religion or belief system as "whacko", no matter what culture it comes from. Let's be real, it's not better than burning incense by some cultures or religions. Not better than exorcisms. Or my grandmother's superstitions.
It's all unscientific. Thus whacko.

www.webmd.com/balance/news/20190521/are-there-health-benefits-from-burning-sage

EmotionalSupportBear · 26/08/2021 12:16

Oh, and my apologies if after less than an hours sleep due to ill health that my spelling isn't perfect.

I wasn't aware it needed to be to call out blatant racism.

EmotionalSupportBear · 26/08/2021 12:16

[quote MakeMathsFun]@EmotionalSupportBear re: "Did you seriously just call Indiginous People "whacko cultists"... You are aware how... racist that is, right?"

Please note that XDownwiththissortofthingX did not mention indigenous people at all!

They said "some other bunch of whacko cultists" which "OTHER... whacko cultists" directly implies that there are whacko cultists here too, not just elsewhere. The geography aspect was trying to be all inclusive across the World and very clearly tried to address RESPECT for all cultures, by saying "you might be offending..."

In fact, I believe it was YOU who specifically pointed out earlier that "Native American Tribes... Holy people have requested we stop using it", so clearly you seem to agree about respecting others.

And if you care to read all of XDownwiththissortofthingX's postings you will find that they seem to be skeptical of ALL esoteric beliefs.

So, there was nothing racist about their comment "...you might be offending some other bunch of whacko cultists somewhere, even though they live on the other side of the planet..." because they believe all cultists from all races, countries, cultures, etc. to be misinformed.

@XDownwiththissortofthingX: Am I right?[/quote]
You're just being disingenuous to defend the indefensible.

They were quite clearly referring to the commentary on this thread about Native American People requesting that western practitioners of Magic, and some 'new age' people stop using White Sage, as its considered a closed practise to some, and otherwise related to oppression of their People.

EmotionalSupportBear · 26/08/2021 12:09

[quote Lweji]@EmotionalSupportBear

Ahem, it's spelled indigenous.

If you are going to berate pps might as well write it properly.
And I think all of us, indigenous people, deserve the correct term.

Also, for the record, you need to specify where the indigenous people are from. For example, I'm indigenous to my country (as far as I know Wink).
So, North American Indigenous people. But I suspect not all will use white sage, even.

Interesting article about the use of white sage.

www.beautyindependent.com/native-americans-troubled-appropriation-commoditization-smudging/

One of the main concerns seems to be the overuse and lack of availability of white sage for Native American use, rather than solely cultural appropriation.[/quote]
and my mispelling makes their Racism ok does it?

MakeMathsFun · 26/08/2021 12:08

@EmotionalSupportBear re: "Did you seriously just call Indiginous People "whacko cultists"... You are aware how... racist that is, right?"

Please note that XDownwiththissortofthingX did not mention indigenous people at all!

They said "some other bunch of whacko cultists" which "OTHER... whacko cultists" directly implies that there are whacko cultists here too, not just elsewhere. The geography aspect was trying to be all inclusive across the World and very clearly tried to address RESPECT for all cultures, by saying "you might be offending..."

In fact, I believe it was YOU who specifically pointed out earlier that "Native American Tribes... Holy people have requested we stop using it", so clearly you seem to agree about respecting others.

And if you care to read all of XDownwiththissortofthingX's postings you will find that they seem to be skeptical of ALL esoteric beliefs.

So, there was nothing racist about their comment "...you might be offending some other bunch of whacko cultists somewhere, even though they live on the other side of the planet..." because they believe all cultists from all races, countries, cultures, etc. to be misinformed.

@XDownwiththissortofthingX: Am I right?

Lweji · 26/08/2021 12:07

There is no right or wrong here just perspectives.

For some things, there is more than just perspectives. That's an idea that has been passed on by, well, people who don't want their methods and practices and claims scrutinised.

Say, home decoration, yes, it's a matter of perspective.
Health, less so.

Lweji · 26/08/2021 12:04

@EmotionalSupportBear

Ahem, it's spelled indigenous.

If you are going to berate pps might as well write it properly.
And I think all of us, indigenous people, deserve the correct term.

Also, for the record, you need to specify where the indigenous people are from. For example, I'm indigenous to my country (as far as I know Wink).
So, North American Indigenous people. But I suspect not all will use white sage, even.

Interesting article about the use of white sage.

www.beautyindependent.com/native-americans-troubled-appropriation-commoditization-smudging/

One of the main concerns seems to be the overuse and lack of availability of white sage for Native American use, rather than solely cultural appropriation.

Ibelieveinghosts · 26/08/2021 11:33

@MasterBeth

  1. Says who? How do you know? Why should I believe that? On what basis can I ascertain if you are mistaken? You are still trying to force the situation into a scientific method framework. My belief system is how I know, I just do. It’s not for me to convince you about my personal beliefs/gnosis, I’m happy to explain what they are but you must reach your own conclusions which feel authentic to you And that is your path not mine.

If scientific methodology cannot measure these things people perceive on the physical plane then there are many explanations inc

  1. It’s all made up for a giggle
  2. It’s all made up but people believe because of psychological factors
  3. Things happen due to external factors which are material but read as supernatural
  4. Things happen on a different plane/wave length etc which can be experienced by some people and not others or measured in a scientific way
  5. It’s all in the mind, but then you are left with the question of what is the mind, a load of chemicals and physical connections, a receiver of consciousness a creator of consciousness and is that collective or personal? And then you are left with the question of what is consciousness where there are many theories.

Lots of others will have many different views. There is no right or wrong here just perspectives. Any right or wrong is only absolute within the framework in which it is set.

EmotionalSupportBear · 26/08/2021 11:05

@LoisLane66

ESB. It's per se, not persay
ah, thank you! Habit from hearing it for a long while before seeing it written!
Swipe left for the next trending thread