Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - to say rip currents can get you in shallow water and body boards are actually quite dangerous

108 replies

Tillylovestomatoes · 24/08/2021 07:17

So whenever I’ve heard about people getting into trouble at the beach I’ve always assumed it was either unsupervised kids or people swimming / surfing in deep water. I never thought anything like that could happen to me and my family because we always stayed in shallow water close to shore. I thought body boarding in the shallows was safe, especially when the tide was coming in, so me and the kids would paddle out to about thigh height, get on our boards and let the waves bring us back to shore. Unfortunately we were doing just that when we got pulled into a rip current and carried out to sea.

Rip currents can travel up to 2m per second and can pull you out the length of a football pitch in the space of 1 minute. You don’t even realise it’s happening until you suddenly see the beach looking very far away.

By the time I realised something was wrong and leapt off my board to test the water depth - I was up to my neck in water. I grabbed the kids and tried to wade back holding them above the water but the current was too strong and just kept pushing us back even further until the water started coming over my head. I had to scream for the kids to swim. Luckily, they are both good swimmers because we’d lost our boards in the panic. The boards should have been attached to our arms but the Velcro straps were rubbish and always came undone.

I swam to get the boards back and managed to grab two of them but by that time my kids had drifted further away. They were swimming on their backs by this point but I found it hard to catch them up and get back to them. The sight of them in the deep open water will haunt me for the rest of my life. Even though it was only a few metres they have never seemed to far away and out of reach. I really didn’t think we were going to make it.

We were incredibly fortunate that day because we had positioned ourselves near a local surf school which had trained life guards working for them and they came to rescue us. If we’d been on a more isolated beach then I dread to think what could have happened. We didn’t see any flags or signs to indicate any danger and we hadn’t managed to spot anything untoward from the shore. The beach we were on only had a voluntary life guard presence at weekends so lots of scope for accidents to happen for people like me not fully understanding the risks.

Prior to this, I’d heard of rip currents but didn’t know how common they were. I also didn’t know that they could pull you out from shallow water or really understand how quickly they could pull you in. (Apparently a rip current on the same beach had previously pulled in a horse and rider cantering along the shoreline). I had also thought body boarding in shallow water with me present was relatively safe. I was very wrong and would hate any other families to make the same mistake. I for one will never get on a body board again but I see so many people using them on social media. So AIBU to highlight that rip currents very much can get you in the shallow water and that body boarding might not be as safe as you think it is?

Please take care x

Have name changed as I haven’t been able to talk about this to anyone in RL yet. Am still too upset but wanted to highlight dangers for others before the bank holiday.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Popcornriver · 24/08/2021 09:06

I'm glad you and the little ones are OK, can't imagine how scary it was for you Flowers

You're right though, they're not always easy to spot. We live by the beach and regularly see the coastguards out looking for people. I don't actually go in the sea and don't allow the children to. We go to swimming pools. Some might say I'm OTT but I don't care quite frankly. I've heard of too many accidents.

MilkWasABadChoice · 24/08/2021 09:05

Terrifying. I have nightmares about this kind of thing. My son isn’t a strong swimmer and wouldn’t have been able to be calm enough to float on his back. He will have more lessons next year in Y4.

Thanks also to the previous poster who linked to the RNLI - I just made a donation as they were at the beach where we bodyboarded last week.

egglette · 24/08/2021 09:02

So sorry, OP - it must have been absolutely terrifying Flowers the same happened to my sister and me on holiday in Europe as children. She managed to get out but I just kept getting taken further and further out. Luckily some locals outside the rip spotted me and encouraged me to swim over to them as they couldn't get to me. I'll never forget the sight of my dad standing in the shallows in his trousers frantically looking for me, and he often says he won't either.

You have mentioned not going in the sea again, which is fair enough, but see how your children feel. Now I mostly lurk in yh shallows but it's enough for having a dip on holiday.

MoreRainThanAnyYet · 24/08/2021 08:58

You and your children did a lot that was right. They can swim, you were supervising them, and they stayed calm enough to float on their backs. Well done.

ssd · 24/08/2021 08:51

Thanks for sharing. We kayak in the sea and hadn't realised this.

ElsieMc · 24/08/2021 08:50

So scary op. I took the kids to a more remote lake in the western lakes a few weeks back. They had boards, straps etc stayed shallow, had a wonderful day.

But on our walk back I came across an elderly man and his grand daughters. They had been rescued. He had let them go in where a stream entered the lake. It was clearly marked as No Swimming. I don't get how he missed that. He told me it was like a horror film watching the girls go under water, like they were trapped under ice. Fortunately they were rescued.

I felt guilty for even letting the boys go out after that. So many have lost their lives over summer this year - in Scotland and the NW.

Thank you op for highlighting the dangers - it must have been an awful shock for you.

I live near where the cockling disaster occurred. Throughout that season, there were so many near misses with inaction by the authorities. I live by the sea and know it is treacherous no matter how well you think you know an area. Sinking sand as well, you will see bubbles and here you cannot outrun the tide. You will have a warning, like you have op, and you need to heed it.

finova · 24/08/2021 08:46

How did the lifeguard rescue you all? Were there 3 of them?

icedcoffees · 24/08/2021 08:44

Oh I totally appreciate that @Tillylovestomatoes.

My DH is a keen surfer, fisher and kayaker and often goes out alone to sea. He's there now, in fact!

It does freak me out a fair bit - it's certainly not something I would risk! I think sea swimming and other sea activities need a lot of knowledge of things like geography, weather and tides to be done safely - lots of people just see the sea as a big pool with a wave machine!

Tillylovestomatoes · 24/08/2021 08:38

WhathaveIdone I suppose it depends on how competent he is and when he surfs. If he’s surfing when the lifeguards are there or with the surf school who have trained lifeguards working for them then he had people to help if he gets into trouble but I have to admit we won’t be going in the water there again. It’s a beautiful beach but we’ll stick to walking there instead x

OP posts:
LynseyLoses · 24/08/2021 08:33

Really scary op. Thanks for sharing. So glad you're alright.

We don't have anything which floats with us in the sea, but reading these responses makes me realise you could still get swept in just standing in the shallows, which is a bit scary. We lived by the coast where I grew up and we were always in the sea. Never considered any of this! Looking back we were pretty lucky none of us ever got hurt.

Window1 · 24/08/2021 08:29

Thank you for sharing your experience with us. It sounds terrifying. I'm glad you all managed to get yourself to safety.

I feel I could easily put myself in the same situation as you have described.

WhathaveIdoneagain · 24/08/2021 08:29

Tilly I am so glad you are all OK. Flowers

DS sometimes surfs on that beach, now I think maybe he shouldn't.

Tillylovestomatoes · 24/08/2021 08:29

ILookAtTheFloor absolutely right though if I’m honest, after what’s happened to us, I don’t think we’ll ever go back in the sea - even with lifeguards

OP posts:
DaftVader42 · 24/08/2021 08:25

Good time to mention that the RNLI has a junior section. For £14, you get a welcome pack and 4 magazines a year full of facts and stories about the sea. There’s obviously water safety information - but they make it really fun.

Please do consider joining - my kids loved it, and they now know to do things like chat to lifeguards if at a new beach. Lifeguards will tell you about where the rips are in the beach , rocks to watch out for under the water etc

Becoming a member helps the RNLI with funds and increases your child’s awareness Can only be a good thing ! More funds then more beaches can get lifeguards.

rnli.org/support-us/become-a-member/become-a-storm-force-member

Lalliella · 24/08/2021 08:24

Gosh that sounds terrifying.

Thank you for sharing. By doing so, you may well save lives Flowers

ILookAtTheFloor · 24/08/2021 08:21

This sounds terrifying. Like others have said, I only let my children bodyboard on lifeguarded beaches between the flags.

TwooThirty · 24/08/2021 08:20

They look incredibly difficult to spot.

AIBU - to say rip currents can get you in shallow water and body boards are actually quite dangerous
AIBU - to say rip currents can get you in shallow water and body boards are actually quite dangerous
AIBU - to say rip currents can get you in shallow water and body boards are actually quite dangerous
Tillylovestomatoes · 24/08/2021 08:13

StrangetoSee - yes we were trying to cut across sideways in the direction of the surf school but it was quite disorientating because the rip had pulled us out 200m so we couldn’t even see the shoreline anymore. Plus we were trying to swim on our backs which was less tiring but harder to see where we were going if that makes sense x

OP posts:
Tillylovestomatoes · 24/08/2021 08:09

Icedcoffees We had no intention of swimming in the sea either that day! We only ever swim in pools and I’m the kind of person that always swims by the side just in case. The body boarding we were doing was just from leg height. Just deep enough to float back to shore. I thought that was safe until we were swept away. I really don’t want others to make that mistake x

OP posts:
StrangeToSee · 24/08/2021 08:04

That’s sounds terrifying!

Did you try getting everyone to swim sideways? Because most rips are only a couple of metres in diameter, if you paddle sideways you’ll escape the pull and be able to swim back to shore.

My friend got caught in a rip near our local beach (we did warn him but it was a hazy day and not easy to spot the rips, normally you can see them as dark calm streaks in the water). He’s a strong swimmer so we assumed he’d be ok.

We noticed he’d swum out a long way in a short time and was now swimming parallel rather than back to us. Luckily he got out of the rip but got caught in another, so by the time he emerged from the water he was another beach away and couldn’t find us. I had to run to him with a towel as his boxers had been pulled off in the current and he was standing on the beach looking for us, surrounded by lots of shocked families who didn’t expect a naked man to emerge in front of them!

megletthesecond · 24/08/2021 07:59

Gad you are OK.

This is why I only swim on lifeguarded beaches. If there are no flags then there isn't anyone keeping an eye on the sea.

icedcoffees · 24/08/2021 07:59

That's horrible - I'm so glad you're all okay Thanks

Unfortunately the vast vast majority of British beaches aren't lifeguarded. None of our local ones have any kind of regular lifeguard presence at all. I also think the British coastline is pretty dangerous in comparison to the Mediterranean which is what many people are used to swimming in.

Personally I'd never swim in the sea in the UK unless I was accompanied by professionals or there was a lifeguard, and even then I'd be incredibly hesitant Blush

Tillylovestomatoes · 24/08/2021 07:58

Silverglitterbaubles I know what you mean - I thought it was safer with me being in the water with the kids too but in reality it was just more people to rescue. I hope our experience shows how careful you have to be. I really thought it was safe if you were only shallow. I had no idea it could happen from shallow water too.

OP posts:
smittenkittten · 24/08/2021 07:57

Can’t believe the timing of this thread. This video came up on my newsfeed on FB last night. Very informative, not just the video but the comments too.

Veryverycalmnow · 24/08/2021 07:56

That's terrifying! Poor you. Hope you're all recovering well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread