Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Formula

114 replies

Newmumma25 · 23/08/2021 23:47

Hi everyone I’m a first time (very confused mum) I recently stopped breastfeeding my 12 week old baby as I wasn’t producing enough due to having mastitis for the 3rd time and had to use bottles to get through which she ultimately got too used too so had to begin bottle feeding. My question is how do you actually make formula up? What does everyone do? I’ve been following the instructions letting it cool and making it fresh but it’s a mega faff! My HV said she personally boils water makes the bottle up adds the formula when needed and heat it a little. When asking everyone they tell me they made it up with fresh boiled water and put it in the fridge! Im so confused on how to make it. The way I’m doing it just now is a real hassle!

OP posts:
youdoyoutoday · 24/08/2021 15:01

With my first, I made up 6 bottles,cooled them, kept them in the fridge and heated them as needed.
Second, I got a prefect prep and it's just so quick and easy, get one. The only annoying thing about it is how loud the beeps are on it.

HotPinkTeaSet · 24/08/2021 15:00

Perfect prep machine. The NCT and others are quite sniffy about them but we cleaned ours regularly and no problems whatsoever.

Somethingsnappy · 24/08/2021 14:57

@BastardMonkfish

The reports of mould in the tubes of the PP - this isn't mould, it's deposits of carbon residue cause by using knock offs filters instead of the proper TT ones. If people are going to use these and not clean and sterilise the machine then even if the machine did get mould that's on them!

The PP is a brilliant invention OP and I think it's safer than the NHS method because when you have a baby screaming with hunger it would be easy to give them the bottle too early before it's properly cooked and scald them.

Very good point actually!
Arsebucket · 24/08/2021 14:27

@BabyLeaf I’m so sorry.

I had a similar experience with my ds, he was already in SCBU from birth and I produced next to no milk. Midwives and neonatal nurses kept telling me to try harder, that it was the most natural thing in the world, that he would get better faster on my milk.

They reduced me to a sobbing wreck on more than on occasion. One time I was sat by his incubator sobbing when the consultant was doing his rounds and saw me, asked me what was wrong.

He was wonderful. Immediately told them to
stop pressuring me and to give formula. He spoke to me in private and told me not to worry, my baby needed milk and it didn’t really matter to his health where it came from, as long as he had it to grow. I’ll never forget him and his kindness.

Sceptre86 · 24/08/2021 14:23

@BabyLeaf I had a similar experience with my dd. I will forever look on that time bitterly as it led to so many feelings of guilt and being a failure because I couldn't do what so many other women can, feed their baby.

Sceptre86 · 24/08/2021 14:19

Previously I would boil water and put it in a flask and then use that to make the bottle up and cool under the tap. This time I intend to use a perfect prep at least during the night.

BastardMonkfish · 24/08/2021 14:12

The reports of mould in the tubes of the PP - this isn't mould, it's deposits of carbon residue cause by using knock offs filters instead of the proper TT ones. If people are going to use these and not clean and sterilise the machine then even if the machine did get mould that's on them!

The PP is a brilliant invention OP and I think it's safer than the NHS method because when you have a baby screaming with hunger it would be easy to give them the bottle too early before it's properly cooked and scald them.

whatswithtodaytoday · 24/08/2021 14:11

Oh @BabyLeaf. I'm so sorry you went through that.

BabyLeaf · 24/08/2021 13:38

@Needapoodle

Nobody connected with the NHS will do or say anything that might even slightly be seen as recommending formula. Even when i was losing my mind over breastfeeding in the nicu, when i eventually switched to formula not one bastard nurse would help me work out what bottles or formula to buy for a premature baby. They told me to Google it. They had to be persuaded to show me how to make up a feed. They "weren't allowed" apparently.
This is so accurate, seriously. I too developed PTSD related to breastfeeding. My tiny baby was literally starving at my breast while I told everyone around I wasn't producing enough milk, they just patronised me, told me I was anxious and that my body was designed to meet his needs.

Until he had lost 13%, could no longer nurse due to sheer exhaustion, needed a nasogastric tube, almost ended up with brain damage needing a full blood transfusion.

Absolutely appalling state of affairs. Even with a mother saying loudly she isn't making any milk midwives were absolutely determined that I would continue EBF, despite it slowly killing him. I trusted them and will regret it forever.

Anecdotally I've found that the vast majority of doctors are very pro fed is best, they have a solid understanding of the evidence around infant feeding and don't buy into the breast is best nonsense. Midwives were another breed, man. They would honestly be like a cartoon dog salivating over a pork chop at the idea of 'mummy's lovely milk' and 'that lovely liquid gold'. It's completely barbaric that that is the state of maternity care women are subjected to in this country. Treated like idiot children basically.

We ended up in the neonatal unit for ten days trying to recover from complications from starvation and not once did a single person tell me it wasn't my fault, that some women just don't produce enough milk, and that I should consider moving to exclusive formula feeding. I was just encouraged heavily to 'give him the best', and triple feed round the clock. I drove myself insane believing that if milk works on supply and demand and I'm not producing enough I'm clearly not working hard to demand enough and so I just need to pump more. Ended up triple feeding for nine months on strong prescription drugs to force a supply and only stopped when my body finally stopped making any. Never made enough to EBF despite all of the above work. I've never known anyone work harder to be able to breastfeed and to fail so spectacularly.

Fed is best. 'Breast is best' does SO much damage to women and babies.

AtticusHoysAnus · 24/08/2021 13:22

Oh great a BF bashing post, was wondering when there would be another one 🙄

You win weirdest comment of the day.

Looks like you're the one trying to engineer an argument.

Erictheavocado · 24/08/2021 10:53

When my dcs were babies, I made bottles up in advance using boiled water, cooled quickly under cold running water and then stored in fridge. It was acceptable at the time and both dcs were fine. When dgs was born, their formula was made in a perfect prep machine. So much easier to make when needed and, as long as you follow the cleaning instructions and have the correct filter , I don't see an issue with them.

In a perfect world, every mother would want and be able to breastfeed and no baby would need to be formula fed. But we don't live in a perfect world and the vast majority of parents, usually mothers, do the very best they can for their babies, within whatever constraints they have on them.
OP, I do agree that of all methods available, your HV seems to have suggested one that is actually unsafe. A PP machine is helpful and convenient. Also, ready made formula is available in different sizes should you prefer that - definitely worth considering for when you are out and about.

StarfishDish · 24/08/2021 10:32

@Needapoodle

Nobody connected with the NHS will do or say anything that might even slightly be seen as recommending formula. Even when i was losing my mind over breastfeeding in the nicu, when i eventually switched to formula not one bastard nurse would help me work out what bottles or formula to buy for a premature baby. They told me to Google it. They had to be persuaded to show me how to make up a feed. They "weren't allowed" apparently.
@Needapoodle My midwife refused to discharge me initially until she'd seen me breastfeed 3 times. When I said ill discharge myself, she told me if I did, my baby would lose a lot of weight, would get ill and would need to come back to hospital where there is a much higher risk of them getting covid.

Luckily, my husband was there and told her that she can watch me feed our daughter do two feeds - either breast or formula - and then he'd be coming straight back to collect us.

Luckily, she backed down on that and let me use formula. I'm just so glad my husband was there and put his foot down!

Needapoodle · 24/08/2021 10:29

It really is. The pressure to breastfeed and the way i was treated was a very strong contributor towards me developing ptsd. So when some arse comes onto a thread of a new mum struggling with formula after struggling to breastfeed, and says it's a bf bashing thread ... They can fuck off.

Breastfeeding isn't actually important in the grand scheme of things. Having a mum who is happy, healthy and sane and who feels supported is far more important.

whatswithtodaytoday · 24/08/2021 10:23

Same, @Needapoodle. I had a baby who wasn't feeding properly and had lost a lot of weight, and severe post-natal anxiety, was trying to breastfeed but needed to get a certain amount of formula into him as well so they knew how much he'd had. They wouldn't tell me what type they recommended or how to make it up, and I ended up doing something wrong and potentially dangerous with the bottles they gave us because they didn't explain how to use them. It's fucking ridiculous.

Needapoodle · 24/08/2021 10:19

Nobody connected with the NHS will do or say anything that might even slightly be seen as recommending formula. Even when i was losing my mind over breastfeeding in the nicu, when i eventually switched to formula not one bastard nurse would help me work out what bottles or formula to buy for a premature baby. They told me to Google it. They had to be persuaded to show me how to make up a feed. They "weren't allowed" apparently.

Cam2020 · 24/08/2021 10:13

Everyone is covering their own arses at the end of the day - no-one wants to be liable for endorsing something that's not 100% safe in the rare event that a child becomes seriously ill or worse. It all comes down to your own risk assessment.

twinningatlife · 24/08/2021 10:07

I used pre made with DD but too expensive with twins but when we are out and about use pre made except one twin absolutely hates the stuff and refuses to drink it and gets really upset she would seemingly rather go hungry than have it so have to plan days out quite carefully

MrsG30 · 24/08/2021 10:02

Sat here breastfeeding baby and I literally do not see how this is a bf bashing post?

Incidentally OP, I do agree with you and often said that when I had my first (that they make formula so difficult to force bfing, we swapped to formula at 6 weeks due to mastitis also which killed my supply)

With my first we got a prep machine. I always bought the official filters and religiously did the clean cycle. I periodically removed the back also and checked for mould in the tubes (probably didn’t need to be done but I was an extremely anxious ftm)

We couldn’t use ready made with DS1 as he had CMPA so was on prescription formula, I did the flask method when out and about.

Also - well done for 12 weeks breastfeeding!

freshFortunes · 24/08/2021 09:53

Am I reading this correctly? "My HV said she personally boils water makes the bottle up adds the formula when needed and heat it a little" So she boils 8oz of water, puts it in the bottle and leaves it. Then adds the formula when needed and then heats it up a bit? If so that is shockingly bad advice. The formula needs to touch boiling water to sterilise it.

I use a perfect prep and cartons when out and about. If not using a prep then 3oz boiling water, add formula and mix, then top up with 5oz of pre boiled water from the fridge.

Arsebucket · 24/08/2021 09:45

As an aside, I’d love to see how many parents use a thermometer to check the temp of the water in the kettle they have let cool to 70 degrees!

Use it properly, PP machine is fine. When you hear horror stories of then being “full of mould”, it’s usually from people who haven’t bothered to clean them and then complain.

Hankunamatata · 24/08/2021 09:34

I used to keep pre boiled water in fridge. Add hot boiled water to formula then top up with pre boiled fridge water.

RookieRoo · 24/08/2021 09:31

Your HV is doing the least safe way. The reason to use boiling water is to kill bacteria in the powder. By boiling and cooling water, there is nothing to kill the bacteria 🤦‍♀️ which is why it's safest to make with boiling water and cool as PP mentioned, if you can't make fresh.

I found having a supply of ready made easiest when we started although that was with a newborn, at 3 months you may find you know baby well enough to make the formula.

Perfect prep machine not advised however I wouldn't have survived without it!!! Just buy a food thermometer and make sure you check the hot shot from time to time to make sure. And only use the tommee tippee filters. One of my HV actually said "whatever you find works best for you" when I told her I use the prep machine!

Liverbird77 · 24/08/2021 09:27

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

DingleyDel · 24/08/2021 09:14

@AndTheReasonIsYou

Another vote for the perfect prep here. HVs don’t like them but never did I meet one who could give me a decent explanation as to why that was…
It’s because when they’ve been tested independently the ‘hot shot’ of water was not sufficient to heat all the powder to kill the bacteria in formula. Open tins of formula are a pretty perfect breeding ground for pathogens. Making up formula ‘correctly’ is a faff so I do understand why people might want to take the risk, especially with older babies.
CarlottaValdez · 24/08/2021 09:07

I just used pre made, much easier. You can buy big bottles for the fridge and little ones for taking out.