Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think there is a Rich and Poor Mindset?

185 replies

Brogues · 23/08/2021 17:15

I only came across this theory (Rich dad Poor dad) a couple of weeks ago and I’m not sure or maybe we’ll never be able to not think ‘poor’?

Me and DH were brought up ‘poor’ - comfortable but in council housing, with working parents but worried about unexpected bills. We both went to university are now professionals in our work and are high earners (not top 1% of Mumsnetters by any means Wink admittedly) so ‘rich’ but we still buy stuff like TVs rather than focusing on investments. Can we get out of our ‘poor’ mindset or isn’t there one in the first place?

Nicked from google:

Do you think there is a Rich and Poor Mindset?
OP posts:
Iggly · 23/08/2021 19:53

@blacksax

Poor people spend money and rich people invest money? Ah well, anyone with any real intelligence would see through that to the truth.

And in case any stupid rich people are reading this (and I expect there are a lot of you), then I shall explain in simple terms:

Poor people can't invest money because they don't earn enough.

'Why don't they earn enough?', I hear the stupid rich person ask. It's simple. Rich people are in control of what poor people get paid. The less they pay their employees, the more they can keep for themselves.

Rich people need poor people to stay poor, so they themselves can stay rich. Capitalism, innit?

I could pour scorn on each and every one of the other points in that list, but I'm not going to. It's not hard to work it out for yourself.

All Of This
Wheretoeattweenandteen · 23/08/2021 19:49

Well richer people get told about investing an they have less pressure to spend everything because they have more.

And probably very comfortable from their parents and friends eg if someone's can't afford a meal there is usually someone to plug that gap somewhere

Mumoblue · 23/08/2021 19:47

Nope. That’s the “just world” fallacy.
Sometimes you’re poor just because your circumstances are shitty, and sometimes you’re rich because you had advantages others didn’t, even if you’re blind to them.

I’m pretty broke myself, and it’s not because I’m lazy or irresponsible, and fuck anyone who thinks that.

blacksax · 23/08/2021 19:42

Poor people spend money and rich people invest money? Ah well, anyone with any real intelligence would see through that to the truth.

And in case any stupid rich people are reading this (and I expect there are a lot of you), then I shall explain in simple terms:

Poor people can't invest money because they don't earn enough.

'Why don't they earn enough?', I hear the stupid rich person ask. It's simple. Rich people are in control of what poor people get paid. The less they pay their employees, the more they can keep for themselves.

Rich people need poor people to stay poor, so they themselves can stay rich. Capitalism, innit?

I could pour scorn on each and every one of the other points in that list, but I'm not going to. It's not hard to work it out for yourself.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 23/08/2021 19:32

A zillion..
Do you also invest?

Personally with our small income I'd rather secure our house but for people with more coming there are arguments agaisnt paying it off and investing it instead whilst mortgages are so low..

Planttrees · 23/08/2021 19:31

I think maybe the chart is being taken out of context. Imagine two people starting at the same status. It is saying that the one with the poor mindset will become poor and the one with rich mindset will become rich. I have seen plenty of people from rich backgrounds become poor because they spend their money too fast, don't work hard and study, invest for the future etc. In reverse, plenty of people from poor backgrounds study hard, invest for the future and become doctors, accountants and lawyers, entreprenneurs, etc.

I agree that if you are poor it is much more difficult to get rich and if you are rich it is easy to get richer, but that is not the point that is being made here. If you start somewhere in the middle then it really can come down to mindset, ie positive thinking and hard work in the right direction, with a handful of luck along the way.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 23/08/2021 19:30

Nay day I agree and I also agree that that it's not taught in school.

It's maddening.

Azilliondegrees · 23/08/2021 19:29

I grew up poor. I think there is a mindset but I don’t recognise it in that graphic at all. I would say that my mindset is more about not wasting money on frivolities - big holidays and the like. And being conscious and frugal about things like food shopping. I don’t spend money on clothes or hair or makeup. I still live like I did when I was poor, but because of that am able to make large mortgage overpayments. I’m also very hard working and don’t take anything for granted.

Nayday · 23/08/2021 19:29

Here's an actual quote by the author:

One of the reasons the rich get richer, the poor get poorer, and the middle class struggles in debt is because the subject of money is taught at home, not in school. Most of us learn about money from our parents. So what can a poor parent tell their child about money? They simply say "Stay in school and study hard." The child may graduate with excellent grades but with a poor person's financial programming and mind-set. It was learned while the child was young"

He's trying to break open some of the 'mystery' around money and teach the principles.

I'd recommend a read of the actual book.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 23/08/2021 19:29

Unfashionable,

You have an isa though? Not a stocks and shares isa?

Jack bogle, vanguard... Hated by Wall Street and financials.

Why look for the needle in the hay when you can buy the hay stack.
But index funds with low costs somewhere like vanguard, rough returns are 10% each year over a decade.

Indedx are self cleaning. If a company isn't cutting the mustard, it falls out and is replaced.

  • past returns not a guide to future returns.
miltonj · 23/08/2021 19:29

Gross

aerosocks · 23/08/2021 19:28

'Scuse my language, but that chart is an utter crock of shit.

There. I feel better for saying that.

PickAChew · 23/08/2021 19:25

It's very much based on stereotypes and pretty offensive to the millions of people who do work hard to maintain a pretty basic standard of living, IMO.

FlumpsAreShit · 23/08/2021 19:24

If you're interested in financial literature I recommend The Slow Path to Wealth. Not selling anything (other than his book) and solid advice, and the reddit ukpersonalfinance.

I think there is a rich and poor mindset but it's not what's set out above. The rich are able to take more risks, outsource more, invest not save and focus on earning more rather than scrimping. But saying poor people don't want to learn is Hmm. I've read the book and I don't think how it reads is his intent but laid out like that it looks pretty disgusting. Think his bio dad was the 'poor dad' in his autobiography but he's still from a comfortable background and probably doesn't understand true struggling.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 23/08/2021 19:21

Investing early is a good key to financial stability, unfortunately they don't teach it at school or college.

But steady low cost index investments, invested in small regular pace from early on...

ActonSquirrel · 23/08/2021 19:21

Was this written by the idiot who's own company went bankrupt?

Nayday · 23/08/2021 19:21

@Brogues the American dream is exactly that - a dream. Social mobility is terrible in the US. There are less societal safety nets and more trappings to stay in poorly paid jobs e.g heakth care and, fewer workers rights. American culture tends to be 'sort yourself out' rather than state help. The social problems as a result in affluent cities such as San Francisco speak for themselves e.g homeless tent 'cities', people with mental health issues uncared for and wandering the streets - I found it eye opening in a bad way.
NB Rich Dad Poor Dad isn't a woo manifestation book it's a book on investment and spending principles. That meme is awful but not in the book as far as I'm aware.

SpindleWhorl · 23/08/2021 19:20

@Sparklesocks

It’s the sort of thing I’d expect to find at the start of a presentation from someone trying to get me to join their pyramid scheme
Oh god yes, Sean Tully lives and breathes.
mstroutpout · 23/08/2021 19:18

I'm just pleased the first comment nailed the misuse of apostrophes

SquirryTheSquirrel · 23/08/2021 19:15

@Sparklesocks

It’s the sort of thing I’d expect to find at the start of a presentation from someone trying to get me to join their pyramid scheme
Ha ha, yes!
Brogues · 23/08/2021 19:15

Sorry for my temporary break I had to go and do my own ironing.

OP posts:
Nayday · 23/08/2021 19:14

The list is offensive, the actual book isn't - I've actually read it along with other books on investment. I'd certainly recommend reading it and there's no 'poor blaming' - it sets out principles of what to spend money on.

@Unfashionable, investment does take some learning, but it's not really a problem - it's actually really simple. Warren Buffett - buy stocks in companies you believe in, hold them. That's pretty much it. Ironically it's easier with less money/starting out because there's less risk - I started out on Hargreaves Lansdown sticking £25 a month into a share fund (like a basket of companies to reduce risk) . As I learned more I bought different types of funds and individual shares to diversify. I'm also a fan of crypto.
Trading is a different kettle of fish (for me anyway) - simple principles but I'm too risk adverse and not into the hassle.
I'd highly recommend the book "How to own the World' for a simple way of explaining stock market investments. But please don't think it's just for clever financial people types - with small amounts of money - it really isn't.

Brogues · 23/08/2021 19:13

Oh great posters saying there is a different mindset in other countries.

The list is very American and I did wonder how much the American dream takes away social mobility issues in the UK or if there are the same barriers over there. Do Americans talk about the American dream in the same way we discuss that old chestnut working hard and ignore privilege and luck?

OP posts:
Everydayimhuffling · 23/08/2021 19:13

"Reads and studies" but not enough to learn to use apostrophes correctly...

Total nonsense mixed with cause and effect reverses. Hard to be "net worth driven" or invest money when you have none.

opaleyes2 · 23/08/2021 19:13

@bananamushy

Nope I don’t agree. It’s a nice way to “blame” people for being poor when actually it’s about 99% family wealth/luck which gets people rich.

pretty much.

That really takes away from people who spent years at university studying difficult degrees and amassing ridiculous debt. Or those that pulled themselves up by the boot straps and started their own businesses. I know lots of working class lads who set up their own electric, plumbing and building companies after 15/20 years of hard graft as employees.
Swipe left for the next trending thread