Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think there is a Rich and Poor Mindset?

185 replies

Brogues · 23/08/2021 17:15

I only came across this theory (Rich dad Poor dad) a couple of weeks ago and I’m not sure or maybe we’ll never be able to not think ‘poor’?

Me and DH were brought up ‘poor’ - comfortable but in council housing, with working parents but worried about unexpected bills. We both went to university are now professionals in our work and are high earners (not top 1% of Mumsnetters by any means Wink admittedly) so ‘rich’ but we still buy stuff like TVs rather than focusing on investments. Can we get out of our ‘poor’ mindset or isn’t there one in the first place?

Nicked from google:

Do you think there is a Rich and Poor Mindset?
OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock · 25/08/2021 11:09

Study: it doesn't have to be university. Many of my friends have solid incomes without uni. This is a massive problem on MN I spotted. Uni is not the alpha and omega of study.
Not at all. I saw a study where academics were years behind tradesmen in terms of finances, student loans, internships, tradesmen are making €300 start off and €1000's once qualified after 4 years.
My Dsis husband is a plumber they're very comfortable well he is the controller twat.
My Dbro is a builder a self made millionaire.
Even if a poor woman saved all her coffee/nails money, it would simply give her a backup fund to fall back on if her fridge needs replacing, it won't make her rich.
I am probably what you'd consider a poor woman I don't drink coffee and do my own shellac costing 30euro a year max.
Maybe I shouldn't but nail varnish or even a hair brush may as well look the part.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/08/2021 10:46

Even if a poor woman saved all her coffee/nails money, it would simply give her a backup fund to fall back on if her fridge needs replacing, it won't make her rich.

If it was invested into personal development and moving career or getting a better job, for example, it could absolutely provide in a future. Of course money just sitting somewhere on 0.02% interest (looking at you lloyds😑) will not do much except a small fall back.

Study: it doesn't have to be university. Many of my friends have solid incomes without uni. This is a massive problem on MN I spotted. Uni is not the alpha and omega of study.

Hemingwaycat · 25/08/2021 10:14

Totally disagree with this. I grew up poor so used this as fuel to educate myself and ‘think big’. I’m very driven and I don’t think I’m a special case either, I think a lot of people who grow up poor/working class strive for a better life. It doesn’t necessarily mean going to university but it may mean opening a business for example. I know a couple of women I went to school with now own successful hairdressing businesses for example and credit to them really.

Pollaidh · 25/08/2021 10:12

Investment vs. Expenditure:
Some truth here, but the differences are often an understandable result of income inequality rather than the cause of it. Who doesn't need a little pick-me-up treat to make life feel a bit better, the difference is how much you have left afterwards. Even if you invested all your coffee/nails/car valet spending, it is not going to make wealth to anywhere near the extent of someone with a top 1% salary, or inheritance etc. Social class and mobility comes into play too. Plus if you don't have much money you can't afford the type of financial planning rich people can. Money makes money.

I do perhaps see a mindset whereby some people from poorer backgrounds make money, but then spend it flashily, and that's more to do with the social class system, people trying to prove their worth. Within a generation they'll be investing, putting their own kids in hand-me-downs etc.

Upper classes still spend money, just more discreetly. IME there's some truth in the idea that rich people stay rich because they buy second hand cars and clothes, walk round with holey jumpers etc, but the key word there is stay. They had money to start with, plus their social position is assured and so there's no need to spend to prove worth.

Even if a poor woman saved all her coffee/nails money, it would simply give her a backup fund to fall back on if her fridge needs replacing, it won't make her rich.

Refuses to study:
Admittedly those who have seen first hand what a good education and professional job can (sometimes) net you, may have more respect for study, but I work with really bright, hardworking students, who overcome unbelievable home/social difficulties to win places at elite universities. IME they study harder than many of the MC kids I know.

Thinking Big:
Thinking big requires risk taking. It is MUCH easier to take risks (investments, starting a new business, unpaid internship that could lead to amazing job etc) if you know you have a safety net to fall back on. However, poor people still manage to think big despite the massive risk to them. Necessity is the mother of invention. Studies on this show that many of the world's most successful business owners are from poor, often immigrant backgrounds.

Criticise etc:
Not sure. Not in my experience, but there could be an element that you criticise when you haven't got the power to change things.

Buying time:
Rich people do buy time by buying in cleaners, builders, gardeners, rather than spending time doing themselves. But the opposite of this isn't wasting' time, it's just that if you're poorer you can't afford to buy time.

Income flows:
Many poorer people have multiple jobs = multiple income flows. The difference between poor and rich is in what those income flows bring in, and where they're from.
Poor = income comes from multiple jobs.
Rich = income comes from multiple sources (salary, investments, inheritance, property).

This list is totally lacking in real analysis and nuance.

stepupandbecounted · 25/08/2021 10:07

'Educate yourself' when used in this context is deeply offensive given the huge educational and wealth divide in the country, by highlighting a person's lack of education it is effectively blaming/victim blaming if you like, as if they had the CHOICE of where they were educated and raised when clearly they do not.
They are sum product of a system of underinvestment, poor quality and substandard teaching, sometimes parenting and have been badly let down by society as a whole.
If we had a well resourced school system of quality and equality then you could argue that the child, now adult had the choice to pay more attention/try harder, but without knowing the persons' possible SEN or personal limitations it is a damaging comment made in any context, and one I would immediately call out if I heard it.

Educate yourself - can sometimes mean research the facts, often said in annoyance when an intelligent person appears to not have bothered to check facts properly. We see it on here sometimes.

Educate yourself when said in a more general way or tied up with wealth creation or lack of is very demeaning and dehumanising comment, and should never be used

bananamushy · 25/08/2021 09:37

Omg @opaleyes2 you need to let it go.

You know what poverty looks like" Yet you haven't actually experienced it for yourself.

Again how do you know what poverty Ive experienced?

"I thought it beneficial to link to some actual statistics as I was unsure if you knew the difference between them & your anecdotal data" Yet more condescension.

Again statistical data is far more beneficial to this conversation then anecdotal data but you can disagree.

Just so we are clear, I didn't offer "anecdotal data"

Except you did but again you can disagree.

Realistically, you threw out some stats to deflect from the fact that you had initially agreed with an incorrect statement

But the stats were relevant to the thread, it's not all about you.
I'm glad you've finally acknowledged that it was not my actual statement despite stating it was, that's progress!! 👏🏻

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/08/2021 09:30

"educate yourself" is so aggressive. If someone uses it at me, I simply walk/click away. Though it's very rarely used.
I always imagine peoples face when they type that and it's not a friendly smile.

opaleyes2 · 25/08/2021 09:26

Saying someone "needs to educate" themselves on a topic is the same as saying someone is not educated in that topic, whichever way you try to wrangle it.

"You know what poverty looks like"
Yet you haven't actually experienced it for yourself.

"I thought it beneficial to link to some actual statistics as I was unsure if you knew the difference between them & your anecdotal data" Yet more condescension.

Just so we are clear, I didn't offer "anecdotal data" to dispute social mobility, as I have said previously I don't entirely disagree. Though there are various reasons behind such stats but that would be a whole other essay. I offered my life experiences and observations as an example to refute the comment that you had agreed with.

Which part of telling a grown woman they need to educate themselves is NOT condescending? Realistically, you threw out some stats to deflect from the fact that you had initially agreed with an incorrect statement. You have now said it was for the benefit of the thread even though you had specifically tagged me in your response and assumed I don't know the difference between real statistics and my own stories!!!

Patronisation is clearly a strength of yours!

ChaneySays · 24/08/2021 23:09

All middle class twaddle. Where does a bloke who earns £50k operating a digger on a building site fit into this? Or a trucker earning £60k.

bananamushy · 24/08/2021 22:10

@opaleyes2

pointing out your crass statement and made up statistic

Except it wasn't my statement or statistic was it? I just agreed with the general principle. For the second time what part of that is confusing you?

Just so you know, I actually grew up on a council estate with bailiff visits and all sorts of craziness you wouldn't have been exposed to in your self admitted ivory tower. So don't attempt be a social justice warrior or be a voice for people who have actually experienced poverty first hand.

😆 I said my background helped because it did. Don't confuse that with an ivory tower though as my parents are immigrants who came to this country with nothing & my mum left her family behind at 17 for a better life. Her family are still there so I'm fully aware what poverty looks like.

Furthermore, Sociology and Psychology where my chosen subjects, so you can imagine calling me uneducated has really hit a nerve

Clearly! although I didn't call you uneducated, I said educate yourself. I thought it beneficial to link to some actual statistics as I was unsure if you knew the difference between them & your anecdotal data of I know lots of working class lads who set up their own electric, plumbing and building companies after 15/20 years of hard graft as employees.

I certainly didn't say anything to warrant your condescending rant.

The statistics I posted were also a benefit to the general thread. I'm not sure why you found them condescending?

I merely pointed out that saying 99% of rich people got their by luck or family is wrong. I'm living proof!

Again I didn't say that did I? But by your logic the above doesn't even mean what you think it does because I'm sure you understand that 99% is not the same as 100%? So your living proof of what exactly?

Comprehension is clearly not a strength of yours!

bananamushy · 24/08/2021 21:50

That's a great example @ssd

EmeraldShamrock · 24/08/2021 18:32

@ssd Great link. The arrogance is stomach churning on these threads.

Maverickess · 24/08/2021 18:26

I think there are certain mindsets that contribute towards 'success' but the main issue is that success for so many people is based purely on financial status and contribution to society and nothing else.
I contribute very little financially to society because I don't earn very much, in fact I'm supported by taxes that are paid by society. From that POV (which is very popular) I'm completely unsuccessful.
I work in care, however, my contributionto society is practical rather than financial, without my contribution (and those like me) many people would be much worse off and not just the people I look after but their families too, because they'd need to do that caring.
But my contribution isn't valued at all by most people because it's not financially successful.

I find that list closed minded and could be offensive really, without people in society that are 'poor' from low paid jobs a lot of people wouldn't be doing their better paid jobs at all.

ssd · 24/08/2021 18:24

Has anyone posted that cartoon explaining rich and poor mindsets?

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 24/08/2021 18:21
  • tons the poster who mentioned buying the Nike trainers for a baby and huge TV.

The huge TV I have can understand, a good TV is a joy and used so much often it will increase quality of life.

However the £25 quit or whatever baby Nike trainers cost, put into a low cost stock and shares junior isa index fund will have about 16 glorious years to grow into something, esp with a few tops ups here and there.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 24/08/2021 18:18

I knew/ met loads of successful people's from the wc background in successful roles who went to grammar schools.

Unfortunately not now so much because Labour kicked that ladder away from the academy children by the removing school help.

In the old days the system was much fairer to help dc get in without parents involvement or help needed.

Now not only does that system soley rely on parents being invested but also it means many bright dc from the wc families who don't value education or can't support their dc, :can't access a grammar school.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 24/08/2021 18:14

vivain

I have tel dc, same parents, family both diametrically opposed.

One dc is happy to wait for more cookies than have the one right there on the table

The other had to have the one in the table

The rest of ones personality follows through this... Spends wisely, spaces things out, the other is now how now

Both young and I'm trying to educate no 2 but nature is a vast part of this.
Even wetting this thinking about opening a sipp for no 2 because I think she will struggle to manage money!!

EmeraldShamrock · 24/08/2021 18:04

Omfg. Poverty is a reality not a mindset.

opaleyes2 · 24/08/2021 17:57

were*

opaleyes2 · 24/08/2021 17:22

bananamushy

Your essay was unnecessary. For you to assume I am uneducated on these matters purely for pointing out your crass statement and made up statistic is pretty gross tbh. Just so you know, I actually grew up on a council estate with bailiff visits and all sorts of craziness you wouldn't have been exposed to in your self admitted ivory tower. So don't attempt be a social justice warrior or be a voice for people who have actually experienced poverty first hand.

Furthermore, Sociology and Psychology where my chosen subjects, so you can imagine calling me uneducated has really hit a nerve!

I am now in a fortunate position where money is not an issue, so I have real lived experience in both social classes and absolutely know the behaviours and choices of many working class people are self destructive for example binge drinking and smoking. (Which I still do myself) I also didn't disagree with you about social mobility, I certainly didn't say anything to warrant your condescending rant. I merely pointed out that saying 99% of rich people got their by luck or family is wrong. I'm living proof!

Petardos · 24/08/2021 10:19

Blame others is evident in this threat. 🤣

Icecreamsoda99 · 24/08/2021 10:09

Rich one sounds like a totally narcissist Confused

DynamoKev · 24/08/2021 09:34

I read rich dad poor dad ages ago it is fucking rubbish and it's entirely devoted to the USA taxation and legal system so most of the advice wouldn't even work in the UK. My advice to anyone is don't read it, it's shit and a prefect illustration of why most self-help books are a waste of money.

Brogues · 24/08/2021 09:26

@MasterGland

Yes, there is, but not as detailed in that chart. Generally, those with a poor mindset engage in lots of conspicuous consumption and chase instant gratification. These people are not necessarily poor though; your lower middle class brand lovers and range rover evoque drivers, fall into this group. They spend too much to increase their net worth. My parents are working class and absolutely hated their jobs. They would save like mad all year in order to go abroad for a fortnight. Every year they wished away the days so they could have a holiday. Then blow it all. Thousands. Every year.
Some of the charts have poor/middle class but obviously that’s the US-centric version so I don’t know how directly it would compare to UK class signifiers but I think the Range Rover evoque clique are still on the ‘poor’ mindset side, as I feel am I.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread