Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think there is a Rich and Poor Mindset?

185 replies

Brogues · 23/08/2021 17:15

I only came across this theory (Rich dad Poor dad) a couple of weeks ago and I’m not sure or maybe we’ll never be able to not think ‘poor’?

Me and DH were brought up ‘poor’ - comfortable but in council housing, with working parents but worried about unexpected bills. We both went to university are now professionals in our work and are high earners (not top 1% of Mumsnetters by any means Wink admittedly) so ‘rich’ but we still buy stuff like TVs rather than focusing on investments. Can we get out of our ‘poor’ mindset or isn’t there one in the first place?

Nicked from google:

Do you think there is a Rich and Poor Mindset?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LadyofMisrule · 26/08/2021 17:12

RDPD is a poorly-written and poorly-evidenced book, but it does pose some interesting questions about how people with different mentalities view money.

For example:
The willingness to take on debt and make money work for you vs the fear of debt.
Paying someone to work for you so that you can (potentially) make more money elsewhere
Developing passive income streams.

Whilst not following its advice to the letter, it did make me reflect on my attitudes.

BiddyPop · 26/08/2021 10:07

Also, if you have money to start with, you can buy higher quality items that last longer. But if you don't, you are stuck buying items that are cheaper because they are poorer quality so won't last as long and will need to be replaced, and are less practical to repair before replacement.

I know that's a serious generalisation- you can get very high quality items in charity shops sometimes, some rich people spend all their money on loads of "stuff" just to have it....you can turn it on its head all sorts of ways.

BiddyPop · 26/08/2021 10:04

Part of it is a mindset towards "stuff" - rich people DO still buy cars, TVs, handbags etc - but buy a good one once and use it for years (mostly - I am generalising), quite possibly buy 2nd hand or else buy new to get specific things but keep a long time, but also tend to buy quality - so might buy a decent leather handbag that works well for their lifestyle, which might be high end or more mid-range, but just one daily and 1 evening purse that will last years, not a whole range of bags to match different outfits or new one each season etc.

That what they buy is a good version of what they need, but they will use a lot before replacing. And only replace when it's necessary, not constantly updating. (And they may well repair their original item before replacing it, depending on what it is and how practical that is to do).

nanbread · 26/08/2021 09:35

@aerosocks

'Scuse my language, but that chart is an utter crock of shit.

There. I feel better for saying that.

Star
Iggly · 26/08/2021 09:29

Most people will have a bit of both traits, but likely to have more in one or the other column. The more traits from the second column, the more likely to reach a level of financial wealth. I can't see how this is debatable

Again, our society gives us the illusion that hard work pays off when it really doesn’t for a lot of people.

That’s why most people on housing benefit are actually in paid work. That’s why people who want to work, but can’t because they cannot afford childcare. That’s why you have nurses visiting foodbanks.

We can all find examples to fit the idea what you just need to work hard and you’ll be fine - but the reality is that that does not apply to most people.

Put simply, there’s a finite pool of money/land/assets in the world. I think we can all agree on that.

So, by logical extension, that if too much of that sits with too small a group of people, then there’s less for everyone else?

Some people will have just about enough. They’ll keep fighting for what little there is left for them.

Those with the most will smile and say “just work harder and you can be like us” - but how, if they’re not giving any up?

Seriously, I wish people would actually do some research and try and understand why people struggle with this “rich mindset” nonsense.

Iggly · 26/08/2021 09:23

There are differences between rich and poor but not as described in the OP. For example, it’s not true that poor people don’t study. They just make the mistake of studying subjects that aren’t profitable, such as nursing or art or vague media studies courses. They haven’t thought about long term profitability. While the rich think very specifically from day 1 about how their studies will ultimately lead to a well paying job and they don’t waste time studying something they merely enjoy. Unless they’re SO rich that they don’t need to work in a well paid job

Straight up bullshit.

As for “vague” courses - again plenty of rich people study what you may define as nonsense which don’t lead to an obvious career. But because of connections, stereotypes etc, they still manage to get decent jobs.

And what’s wrong with nursing? We need nurses, we just don’t pay nurses enough.

There is an inherent assumption that having more money makes you a “better” person - that’s what sits uncomfortably with me. That people are “stupid” in studying “poor” subjects.

The problem with our society is that working in certain careers doesn’t give you enough money to survive. And those at the top continue to perpetuate the myth that it is those at the bottom who are at fault.

When the reality is, that the rich are hoarding too much wealth for themselves.

vivainsomnia · 26/08/2021 08:33

I have elements from both sides of that chart. That's incredibly insulting to both sides
You are missing the point as the majority of posters seem to be. It's not about being one or the other, it's about traits that makes you who you are.

Like feminine vs masculine traits. I have more stereotypical masculine traits than feminine, but I'm still very much a women.

Most people will have a bit of both traits, but likely to have more in one or the other column. The more traits from the second column, the more likely to reach a level of financial wealth. I can't see how this is debatable.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 26/08/2021 08:24

Coming back to this thread to give one example that I think demonstrates this difference in mindset, interested in what others think.

I run a food bank for people who need ongoing food support. Every week 10* people queue up before opening time to be there as the place opens. One took me aside on his second visit to ask if he could help at all, volunteer, do anything for us. We bit his hand off and he now helps with shelf-stacking, inventory and similar.

That's the difference for me - 10 people with time on their hands who are happy to stand there and wait for a handout, v one who thinks about how he can learn and grow. In a few months' time this chap will have current work experience on his CV and a decent reference to apply for a job, the others will still be queuing up waiting for our doors to open.

Someone's going to come along in a sec and ask how I know who is fit for work, what issues they have etc - for obvious reasons I won't share details on here but there are plenty of people there who could make the decision to do the same, once you factor out ill health, caring duties etc.

MasterBeth · 26/08/2021 08:09

This list was written by a cunt.

Blueleah · 26/08/2021 08:08

There are differences between rich and poor but not as described in the OP. For example, it’s not true that poor people don’t study. They just make the mistake of studying subjects that aren’t profitable, such as nursing or art or vague media studies courses. They haven’t thought about long term profitability. While the rich think very specifically from day 1 about how their studies will ultimately lead to a well paying job and they don’t waste time studying something they merely enjoy. Unless they’re SO rich that they don’t need to work in a well paid job.

I agree with what PP have said about how it’s much easier to embrace change and take chances when you have money to invest and to fall back on if you fail. When you’re living from one payday to the next you’re unlikely to have enough money to invest. You can’t take responsibility and develop multiple income streams if you’re barely surviving.

There is a “poor” mindset in the sense that you don’t like to spend money or get into debt because you’re used to being poor. Splashing the cash never feels safe or right no matter how much you have. Whereas wealthy people (and even middle class people) feel more comfortable about spending.

And the main thing I’ve noticed - rich people seem to think you can do anything you want. They’re the people spouting “do what you love”, “follow your dreams”... because doors are open for them and they’re not tied to earning enough money to stay afloat. Poor people understand that life and money restricts you, and ultimately you can only do what the wealthy gate keepers allow you to do.

Iggly · 26/08/2021 07:33

I swear some people think there's a difference between them and the "wealthy" or whatever they call them

There is - a big pile of money and other assets for a start. Plus inherent advantages that come from having a wealthy background. Let’s not pretend we all start from the same place.

As human beings, yes we are all similar and would do well to remember that. But when it comes to opportunities, we are very much not.

EmeraldShamrock · 25/08/2021 18:45

I swear some people think there's a difference between them and the "wealthy" or whatever they call them.
Maybe because there is. Britain is renowned for its class system sticking people in boxes and treating them accordingly.
You won't convince me otherwise I've read too many class threads on here.
It is like saying we're all human and equal, yes we should be but we're not.

Maverickess · 25/08/2021 13:18

@isthisareverse

The answer isn't moving everyone into management roles because who would they be managing?

well, no ,but not everyone define themselves based on their role either. It was just an example.

I swear some people think there's a difference between them and the "wealthy" or whatever they call them.

There is a difference though, or all we'd all be the same. Everyone isn't starting from the same point with the same attributes or circumstances, and some people are on a faster path because they were able to go a different way. It also works the other way too, some 'wealthy' people seem to think the difference between 'them' and the 'poor' lack of aspirations and hard work, but it seems far more acceptable to think that than attributing some success to luck and having opportunities because of the advantages some people have. Double standards.
isthisareverse · 25/08/2021 12:28

The answer isn't moving everyone into management roles because who would they be managing?

well, no ,but not everyone define themselves based on their role either. It was just an example.

I swear some people think there's a difference between them and the "wealthy" or whatever they call them.

Maverickess · 25/08/2021 12:20

@isthisareverse

Yes, there's room to climb the ladder, the opportunity is open to anyone, but can't be open to everyone.

but there's a difference between the people who don't want to
(see the miffed posts about refusing to work 30 seconds after your finish time, or god forbid being sent an email at the weekend - that no one is expecting them to reply to out of business hours)

and the people who seem to think there's different species and "them" "management" "the professionals" (that's a new one) the rest of the world.

Someone even mentioned it on a thread about Madeleine McCann, commenting that her parents had special treatment and were "protected" because of their status. Confused One is a GP, the other a professor - very commendable, but hardly the so called elite.

Yes, some people don't want to, but that does not justify paying people wages that mean they're in poverty, and not wanting to is not the only reason by a long shot. The answer isn't moving everyone into management roles because who would they be managing? It just shifts the problem onto the next lot of people who are getting the jobs that were vacated and then the whole cycle starts again, just with different people. Everyone where I work gives 15 mins of their own time, every shift for handovers. All of us. There simply aren't enough senior roles to accommodate us all, even ones like me who want to.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/08/2021 12:19

Some people think they don't "belong" in some places and won't even try.

There is lots of this kind of self fulfilling prophecy in the uk, I found

maddy68 · 25/08/2021 12:05

I have elements from both sides of that chart. That's incredibly insulting to both sides

isthisareverse · 25/08/2021 11:49

Yes, there's room to climb the ladder, the opportunity is open to anyone, but can't be open to everyone.

but there's a difference between the people who don't want to
(see the miffed posts about refusing to work 30 seconds after your finish time, or god forbid being sent an email at the weekend - that no one is expecting them to reply to out of business hours)

and the people who seem to think there's different species and "them" "management" "the professionals" (that's a new one) the rest of the world.

Someone even mentioned it on a thread about Madeleine McCann, commenting that her parents had special treatment and were "protected" because of their status. Confused One is a GP, the other a professor - very commendable, but hardly the so called elite.

Maverickess · 25/08/2021 11:40

@isthisareverse

It won't be popular, but the biggest difference I notice is about expectations.

Born wealthy, know they belong in a wealthy group, stays wealthy. It's not a question of "if", it's a question of "how". Wouldn't even consider a low paid no future job.

While others settle too much, refuse to move.

Think about it: in a business, some employees are very much in the mindset of "them" vs "us". "management" vs "us". Others don't see that, and will climb the so-called ladder. You see it even on MN when some posters refer as "management" as if it's a different species from another planet. Not just someone doing a job they could just apply for and do themselves.

It doesn't mean some people born poor haven't done amazingly well.

But if you're not born into the 'born wealthy, stay wealthy' set then you're not likely to have the education, connections and advantages of that to enable you to be someone who can apply for that role and do it themselves. Refusing to entertain a low paid and dead end job isn't going to help any because the wealthy person can support themselves still while holding out for something better, the poor person can't. Not everyone can go into a management position, and not just because of lack of education or connections etc but because who would they manage if everyone does that? There wouldn't be enough management roles to do that. We need the lower rungs to support the upper tiers or the whole lot comes down. Yes, there's room to climb the ladder, the opportunity is open to anyone, but can't be open to everyone. So while yes, some people 'settle' we need those people to settle, and some absolutely don't, but there isn't room for them, or it takes that long to acquire the necessary that it can be like an endless fight with very little at the end of it anyway.
EmeraldShamrock · 25/08/2021 11:33

Some people think they don't "belong" in some places and won't even try. You just need to read the thread about luxury hotels or restaurants and people being intimated or feeling out of place in them.
Yes because a lot of them they're genuinely out of place it seems like an inferiority complex to you however years of conditioning and judgement from the professionals and those with more grind on a person.
Okay luckily some have the confidence to feel they deserve a place.
If they feel not good enough it is because they were made to feel less in many situations.
"Show me who you are and I'll treat you accordingly mentality" usually displayed by those who think they're better.

vivainsomnia · 25/08/2021 11:28

@Wheretoeattweenandteen,
I never believed how much genes impacted personality until m kids were born. Genes don't mean you are like your parents, genes are recessive and so can jump generation. Just like you can have two brown eyes parents giving birth to a blue eyed baby, two extroverts can give birth to an introvert, and although nurture can mould the person and make them lean less extremely one way, I do believe now that the state we resort to and feel confident with is inheritant. I agree that some kids will be born more naturally comfortable with the conceptof delaying gratification.

This is why poverty is so hard to get out of and why generations after generations struggle to move away from it. Both nature and nurture are involved. Breaking the cycle is almost impossible and the reason why it still exists.

It takes a lot to gain even half of the attributes listen in the 'rich' mindset when it's not in your genes, and you don't have role models to show you differently.

isthisareverse · 25/08/2021 11:28

@EmeraldShamrock

While others settle too much, refuse to move. Oh yes that is some wc don't succeed they settle and refuse to move. Hmm
why do you think that's not true?

Some people will relocate, for their jobs, their career, their children school. Others will point blank refuse. Great, but when there are no job where you are, don't complain 🤷

Some people think they don't "belong" in some places and won't even try. You just need to read the thread about luxury hotels or restaurants and people being intimated or feeling out of place in them.

emilylily · 25/08/2021 11:23

Wow, this is so awful and absolutely not!

It's a great way to blame people for their misfortune though.

Wealth creates wealth and the vast majority of truly wealthy people in the UK were born into wealth- they were sent to private school, helped financially as young people and then provided with large inheritances from their grandparents and/or parents. Their parents will have contacts to help them get jobs in the right places too!

Levels of social mobility have decreased over the past fifty years- meaning it's getting harder and harder to escape the traps of poverty even if you read, study, embrace change, invest 'money' (wait how do you do that without money?!!), problem-solve and 'think big'.

EmeraldShamrock · 25/08/2021 11:19

While others settle too much, refuse to move. Oh yes that is some wc don't succeed they settle and refuse to move. Hmm

isthisareverse · 25/08/2021 11:17

It won't be popular, but the biggest difference I notice is about expectations.

Born wealthy, know they belong in a wealthy group, stays wealthy. It's not a question of "if", it's a question of "how". Wouldn't even consider a low paid no future job.

While others settle too much, refuse to move.

Think about it: in a business, some employees are very much in the mindset of "them" vs "us". "management" vs "us". Others don't see that, and will climb the so-called ladder. You see it even on MN when some posters refer as "management" as if it's a different species from another planet. Not just someone doing a job they could just apply for and do themselves.

It doesn't mean some people born poor haven't done amazingly well.