Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe the statement ‘died surrounded by loved ones’

363 replies

Meredithsbff · 23/08/2021 14:13

I’ve always found comfort with reading the phrase “X died surrounded by their family” when learning of the death of someone. I often thought how lucky they were to have them there at the exact moment of death.

However, my neighbour passed away last year. She was elderly and her adult children weren’t very caring towards her. They were happy to rarely visit as she had 24 hour carers by the end. She died in the middle of the night after her carer realised she’d stopped breathing. Paramedics got her heart beating but when they stopped cpr it would stop again. One of her adult children arrived when it was too late. She had died on the floor with the paramedics and a carer who she had only met that day. However, fast forward to the funeral announcement and it was stated that she was “much loved and died surrounded by her closest family”.

Have I been naive all these years and it’s actually often a lie? I know it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things but I’d be interested to know if this is regular practice.

OP posts:
ParkheadParadise · 23/08/2021 23:48

This is a fucking weird thread🤔

My dd was Murdered we didn't have a death notice it had already been mentioned in the local news.
When my mum died all 6 of her children were at her bedside, it was mentioned in the death notice that she died peacefully with her family beside her.

Babyroobs · 23/08/2021 23:44

Gosh I would hate everyone sitting around my bedside particularly if my death had distressing symptoms like death rattle secretions. I've watched hundreds of people die after 35 years as an oncology and palliative care Nurse. Many people let themselves slip away in the few moments that a loved one has popped home for a shower, or popped to the toilet. i would just want my dh there maybe and my dog.

blackheartsgirl · 23/08/2021 23:42

I was there when my dh died in July and so was his sister. Just the three of us and its what he wanted.

I am glad I was, I've done it before with my nan and as I never left dhs side towards the end I'm so glad he wasn't on his own

Yes the death rattle is a thing. I knew dh was going to go that day when I heard that.

My dad waited until we had gone home before he passed away, a macmillan nurse had sat with him holding his hand so he wasn't on his own

OldScrappyAndHungry · 23/08/2021 23:38

I sat and held my best friend’s hand as she took her last breath. She was very scared of dying (only in her 30s) and I’ll be forever grateful that I was there when she died. She was there every time I needed her - to be with her the last time she ever needed me seemed like a small thing to do tbh SadFlowers.

Jasmine11 · 23/08/2021 23:38

Both my parents died (years apart) with my brother and I holding their hand. it is one of the greatest honours of my life being there for them at that time. OP your neighbour's children are clearly saying that to save face or maybe they just (wrongly) think that's the conventional thing to say even if it's not true.

NotMyCat · 23/08/2021 23:31

I sat with my Nan all night and most of the next day, my parents had been with her the night before. She died about 30 mins after I left
When we went to collect her things, the nurse asked "who was Bill?"
It was her husband who had died several years earlier and the nurse heard her say his name just before she died. I like to think she saw him Smile

RumblyMumbly · 23/08/2021 23:21

@BeauxRingarde

we could do with learning about the process of dying and that just like birth it can be fast or slow, painful or uplifting, planned or unexpected

I think we all know that though, don't we? What's to learn exactly?

My full sentence read I think it's good people discuss their experiences, the good and the bad. One of the things I found was that death was a surprise to me (I read up about it afterwards - for example about people's appetites naturally dwindling towards their last days) a bit like ante-natal classes we could do with learning about the process of dying and that just like birth it can be fast or slow, painful or uplifting, planned or unexpected

Well for example I had no idea about the death rattle until I read about it after being shocked when experiencing it when my Dad was dying. Maybe you know all about it? Maybe you know about the sweet smell from dying bodies? I didn't know what happens in peoples final days:
www.hospiceuk.org/what-we-offer/clinical-and-care-support/what-to-expect/what-happens-when-someone-is-dying/changes-in-the-last-days-of-life

I had only seen people die on TV before, I had no idea about the realities of death. What I mean is people should be more open about it, as the opening poster points out, there is a tendency to sugarcoat it.

youdoyoutoday · 23/08/2021 22:57

When my mum was dying I sat with her each night till about 2/3am so my dad could go to sleep as he was beside himself thinking it would happen in the night.
I'd go home and expect 'the call' in the early hours every day but mum passed away at midday when my dad left the room to get her a fresh glass of water.
I don't think we would have put "passed away alone, uncared for" because that simply wasn't true.

Linnet · 23/08/2021 22:42

@JulesCobb

My mum used to work in nursing homes. She often said the residents often died after their families left for the evening. Flowers
This is what happened when my mum died. The family had all been in and out for the whole week, there was always someone sitting with her during the day.

The day she died I’d been in during the afternoon then gone to work, first day back since she’d gone into hospital, my grandparents left to go home for dinner, with a view to going back in the evening I think. But once everyone had gone she passed away. My granny always said that mum waited until she was on her own before she went.

My grandad was the same, we’d all been to see him in the afternoon. My uncle drove up from England and went straight in to see him before coming to the house. He wasn’t expected to pass away, he was scheduled for an operation on the Monday, but on the Sunday night after my uncle had been in to see him my grandad passed away. Almost as if he was waiting for my uncle to arrive then felt he could go.

Riddo · 23/08/2021 22:25

My Mum died with my brother and I holding her hands, one each side of the bed. She wouldn't have wanted to be alone.

Yubaba · 23/08/2021 22:20

I was there when both my stepdad and my FIL died.
Fil had cancer and we knew it was getting close, dh rang me at work to come to the hospice and he died 15 minutes after I got there. It was a very gentle death and he had DH, MIL and Me with him.
My stepdad fell ill and died very unexpectedly, my mum rang me at 10am to say he was being rushed to A&E with suspected pneumonia, I went up fully expecting him to be ok and I arranged to go to work late. By 2pm the Dr told us they couldn’t do anything else and he died at 4:30pm. I was awful and he essentially drowned. It traumatised me and I even couldn’t visit him in the funeral home afterwards. He had his family with him but I wish I hadn’t seen it. Not every death is a good death.

OllyBJolly · 23/08/2021 22:19

@SusanBland

My dad died in a hospice, me and my mum were there most of the time as he was very unwell, we were exhausted and went home for a quick sleep,got a call at 4am to go back but he had already gone by the time we got there. The nurse said that people often wait until their loved ones are gone to pass away, she said it happens alot, even when people just nip out of the room for 5 minutes.
DSis and I had a shift system in place to be with our father when he was dying. He had said he didn’t want us to watch him die. He died in a rare 40 minute window when neither of us were there. We had been told that two weeks before that it was a “matter of hours” Your nurse may well be right. I think he chose to go then. Awkward bugger to the end!

DH’s grandfather died while his children sang “My Way” to him. All three say it was a moving and wonderful experience and they have such lovely memories of his passing.

I was with my DSis when she died. It was a very special time. She had brain tumours, only in her 40s and it had been expected for a while. She had decided it was time to go. I am glad she wasn’t alone. I think it gave her children comfort to know I was with her.

EarringsandLipstick · 23/08/2021 22:08

My a miracle / fluke all 4 of us DC & my DM were with my DF when he died.

We had been doing shifts, and my youngest DB had just flown in from Australia, just about an hour before. We were all there as we were about to swap over. I was leaving the hospital with my own 3 DC when my DSis rang & told me to come back urgently. I will never forget racing back up 3 flights of stairs to get back to him.

We were all there, and it was a comfort. His actual death was peaceful (the lead up decidedly had not been).

I don't tend to read too much into what death notices say, like others it's just giving a sense of the family's feelings, rather than an actual description of how death occurred.

The Irish way of discussing death & grieving, of waking the body & the general (pre Covid) gathering & celebrating life is hugely comforting.

Within an half an hour of my DF dying, the hospital chaplain (priest) came to say prayers etc. He was all over the place, dishevelled, Bible falling apart. He lighted on my brother - returned from Oz - and excitedly quizzed him about his route, stopovers, duration. He went on & on, my poor dad just literally deceased before him. The rest of us started laughing & eventually someone had to go, 'er, Father...' & indicate my dad, to get him to start some prayers before we totally lost the run of ourselves.

WTF475878237NC · 23/08/2021 22:07

When my grandad died we'd all been there all day and slept overnight so as to keep chatting away to him. It was one of the most special moments of my life and an absolute privilege and precious gift to be there to (privately) thank him for what he did for me and then chat and laugh with all the extended family present to him about our various adventures with him. He loved big family time and it was exactly how he would have wanted to go.

RevolvingPivot · 23/08/2021 22:03

So many mistakes!!!

RevolvingPivot · 23/08/2021 22:02

Waited**

RevolvingPivot · 23/08/2021 22:00

According to posts on here some family members passed with family around them and some alone. I've heard people say they "wanted" until they were alone. Maybe it's coincidence. I've had family pass both alone and with loved ones.

I was in hospital recently and an elderly woman was brought in in the middle of the night in pain. Poor woman didn't know where she was or whether she had careers. They neither asking her abs I did wonder why they hadn't called any family to ask. I heard the nurses talking about terrible bedsores. She died and a Nan abs woman came into sit with her so she must have had family. She was laid in her cubicle all day waiting to see if anyone would come and say goodbye. No one else came.

EarringsandLipstick · 23/08/2021 21:57

if you say "they're sitting with them", it means that death is imminent, and family and friends will be keeping vigil around the bedside.

Yes barfofoliv a phrase familiar to me too (also Irish).

DerAlteMann · 23/08/2021 21:55

I was there when both my parents died (only child). I wasn't much of a family but in our case it was true.

BeauxRingarde · 23/08/2021 21:43

we could do with learning about the process of dying and that just like birth it can be fast or slow, painful or uplifting, planned or unexpected

I think we all know that though, don't we? What's to learn exactly?

RuleWithAWoodenFoot · 23/08/2021 21:31

This was back when death was much more common

Whereas now people just keep living.

Eggsley · 23/08/2021 21:31

I was there when my grandma died. She was in a care home, with her three daughters (my mum and her two sisters), me and my dad there. We were holding her hands and stroking her hair when she slipped away. She had deteriorated quickly but we had known for about 5 days that the end was coming. My parents and I spent the whole weekend with her, I called my aunties to come when the nursing home staff said they thought it was getting close. The nursing home staff couldn't have been more caring. I had popped home and was on my way back to the home when my dad rang to say they didn't think she had much longer. She slipped away about 10 minutes after I got there. I hope she knew I wanted to be with her.

It was sad but I was so comforted by the fact that she was surrounded by her family. I dealt with it much better than I did my other grandparents, none of whom I was with. We had spoken to her a lot over that weekend about it being time to let go and we were all ok and she could go and be with my grandpa now. We all miss her so much but she was so surrounded by love, I hope that I am fortunate enough to have similar when it's my time to go.

Mybestgirl · 23/08/2021 21:12

@barfotoliv

Im in Ireland, where the culture around death and dying is very different, but here, if the death is expected, it is very very common to die surrounded by family and even friends. In fact, there is a euphemism we use (in my part of Ireland, at least) - if you say "they're sitting with them", it means that death is imminent, and family and friends will be keeping vigil around the bedside. So in my experience, "died surrounded by loved ones" definitely means just that.
Yes, we say that in my part of Scotland too….
Charley50 · 23/08/2021 20:54

"This was back when death was much more common." Sorry, I know what that PP meant, but that did make me chuckle.

My DM died in her 90s after steadily fading over a few months; her last month was spent in hospital, just fading away really. I worked term-time only, lived in the same area, and it was the summer holidays and I had the time, so I visited her every day in hospital for a few hours. I wasn't with her when she actually died, although my sibling was, but I think you could say she died surrounded by loved ones.

It's really interesting to read that so many people wait until their loved ones leave the room. I suppose it shows we all all need space.

barfotoliv · 23/08/2021 20:45

Im in Ireland, where the culture around death and dying is very different, but here, if the death is expected, it is very very common to die surrounded by family and even friends. In fact, there is a euphemism we use (in my part of Ireland, at least) - if you say "they're sitting with them", it means that death is imminent, and family and friends will be keeping vigil around the bedside. So in my experience, "died surrounded by loved ones" definitely means just that.