Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe the statement ‘died surrounded by loved ones’

363 replies

Meredithsbff · 23/08/2021 14:13

I’ve always found comfort with reading the phrase “X died surrounded by their family” when learning of the death of someone. I often thought how lucky they were to have them there at the exact moment of death.

However, my neighbour passed away last year. She was elderly and her adult children weren’t very caring towards her. They were happy to rarely visit as she had 24 hour carers by the end. She died in the middle of the night after her carer realised she’d stopped breathing. Paramedics got her heart beating but when they stopped cpr it would stop again. One of her adult children arrived when it was too late. She had died on the floor with the paramedics and a carer who she had only met that day. However, fast forward to the funeral announcement and it was stated that she was “much loved and died surrounded by her closest family”.

Have I been naive all these years and it’s actually often a lie? I know it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things but I’d be interested to know if this is regular practice.

OP posts:
phishy · 24/08/2021 17:44

@TheBigFatMermaid

Many years of experience as a carer, I tried to be with people if their loved ones couldn't be, but I worked nights on my own and often had to attend to others. If someone passed while I was doing that, I felt a white lie did no harm and possibly helped.

I also have seen families surround the bed, day and night, only to have their loved one pass away in that few minutes nobody was there. I have witnessed this too many times for it to be a coincidence.

That makes sense, I hear that hearing is often the last sense so maybe they do pass when they don’t hear anyone.
BrozTito · 24/08/2021 17:44

I find death an extremely private thing, one of many reasons i dont watch youtube videos of atrocities etc. My grandma died in the middle of the night of no real definite illness but she'd been lost without her husband of 70 odd years when hed died similarly a few months earlier

Jellypudmum · 24/08/2021 17:44

I think that particularly when a relative is in hospital, staff are adept at seeing the signs and often give relatives the heads up that they should inform family members that the time to say goodbye maybe nearing. The was the case of two relatives who passed away quite recently and who were with people who loved them as they did so.

TheBigFatMermaid · 24/08/2021 17:43

Many years of experience as a carer, I tried to be with people if their loved ones couldn't be, but I worked nights on my own and often had to attend to others. If someone passed while I was doing that, I felt a white lie did no harm and possibly helped.

I also have seen families surround the bed, day and night, only to have their loved one pass away in that few minutes nobody was there. I have witnessed this too many times for it to be a coincidence.

lindyloo57 · 24/08/2021 17:42

When the hospice rang my sister to say mum didn't have much time left, I wanted to go straight there to sit with her, but it was discussed to wait until my brother left work and we would all go together, ofcourse she died that afternoon all alone, it took me a long time to get over that, I now wished that i went there straight away, but being the youngest I did as I was told.

Meraas · 24/08/2021 17:39

My dad died at home of cancer surrounded by mum and (mostly adult) children. It was definitely what he wanted, he didn’t want to be in a hospice and it gave us the opportunity to say goodbye to him, so that it was a relief when he died and stopped suffering.

Pinkchocolate · 24/08/2021 17:39

This is really interesting to read, my experiences have been quite far from previous posters. My family members have always died with at least 2 or 3 immediate family members present. We have all found it comforting as well as heartbreaking and I wouldn’t change it. “Dead bodies” don’t seem like dead bodies when they’re your loved ones, they are just your loved ones at that point. When it comes to my time I’d like to be with family too.

Hertsgirl10 · 24/08/2021 17:37

@ConcernedAuntie

Sorry but I can't think of anything worse than having to have those you love most watch you die.

I know some people would find it comforting but having my nearest and dearest watching the light go out of my eyes is not something I could wish for.

We are all different.

Both y parents died suddenly so have never had to make this decision for myself.

Exactly this.
fussyhousewife · 24/08/2021 17:37

The Bitterboy;
Sorry for your loss. My gran died in the same way - we had all been with her and almost as we left the hospital she passed away. My Nan was Irish and my mum made the point that Irish mothers would hate to die in front of their children. Maybe all mothers feel that way which is a comfort if you consider that.

Nofucksleft · 24/08/2021 17:37

Hi I'm a nurse and death announcements can be very political... Its sometimes all about the optics for the neighbours..

ladynyland · 24/08/2021 17:36

My darling Father wouldn’t die with us all there. He left it until my sisters had gone to get a change of clothes from home ( he had been in hospital 3 days and we all stank) it was just myself and my mother. His breathing changed and he passed away. I really think he just wanted some peace and quiet.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 24/08/2021 17:33

My dad died in a hospice at the end of his cancer battle, my cousin also died in the same hospice. Both times we were alerted hours before that it wouldn’t be long and they had us with them, my mum held my dads hand whilst he died and my aunt held her daughters. A mum at DS’ school and a friend of mine both died earlier this year at their homes with husbands and kids at home with them and surrounded by love. I think it’s usually true and I think that it’s unusual for people to lie in the way that your neighbours did.

owlbethere · 24/08/2021 17:33

@AngeloMysterioso

My Dad died in the 5 minutes that no family members were in the room when he was in the hospice at the very end of his life, and I’d actually gone home for the first time in 4 days. I reckon he was waiting for us to leave.
We sat with my mum every minute of every day for weeks. The 5 mins we left she died. I believe she did it on purpose.
Groovee · 24/08/2021 17:33

My half sister would have you believe our dad died surrounded by family when actually my mum and my niece were in the room when he passed.

LawfulSearch · 24/08/2021 17:30

As a child I went to the hospital where my gran had died from a heart attack. My mum asked if she had suffered or been in pain. The doctor said that she wouldn’t have felt anything. Shortly afterwards I overheard a student who had been shadowing the doctor ask if what he had told my mum was true. His answer “of course not, but how’s it going to help her knowing she’d have felt like she was being torn in half”. Never told anyone this before. Never forgot though.

owlbethere · 24/08/2021 17:30

I watched my mum die recently over months and it was horrific.

DanceItOut · 24/08/2021 17:27

I wouldn’t say it’s always a lie though perhaps sometimes it is. Sometimes people prefer to have people there sometimes they don’t. My Nan went surrounded by family and it actually felt nice to know that we were there with her in her last moments holding her hand so she knew she wasn’t alone after all the years she had been there for us. One of my grandads died in hospital when I was a child and he waited until everyone had been to see him one night and died within an hour or two of everyone going home. He said his goodbyes and then went alone but quietly having made peace with it. However lots of people do want to know they aren’t alone in those final moments, whether it’s a loved one or just a kind stranger.

Tal45 · 24/08/2021 16:56

It sounds to me like the kids probably wrote the words, wanting to sound good and like they all bothered with her when they really didn't.

user1471538283 · 24/08/2021 16:42

I was there when my DF died and I like to think he knew. Everyone else got there a little later. We were with one of my DGMs and DGFs until fairly late but he and she died in the night alone. Both were elderly.

It is how much you loved them throughout their lives that is important.

EarringsandLipstick · 24/08/2021 16:16

Sorry you aren't feeling well @SunshineCake

I don't think you were wrong to share your view at all; I meant my post to offer some solace & not to fear what is inevitable for us all but very often has its own beauty (that might sound strange but my nearly-100 year old Grandma had a beautiful death, peaceful & surrounded by love. My dad didn't really, except the very last day when he did die peacefully. But sadly the run up was very very hard & yes, has left trauma for me).

It's just hard to know really x

AngeloMysterioso · 24/08/2021 15:27

My Dad died in the 5 minutes that no family members were in the room when he was in the hospice at the very end of his life, and I’d actually gone home for the first time in 4 days. I reckon he was waiting for us to leave.

RevolvingPivot · 24/08/2021 15:15

Maybe you should ask this to be moved to the unexplained. People will help you more there.

SunshineCake · 24/08/2021 12:53

Thank you @ivykaty44. I've been in bed poorly since last week and really not feeling good at all, physically or emotionally. I posted because I thought there might be others who felt the same but hey, this is MN where someone is always going to be in the wrong. I'm sorry for the loss of your parents Flowers.

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2021 12:10

That's a bit insensitive when the thread is mainly about us watching our loved ones die.

I disagree that this is insensitive as its a thread about dying and started about what was written in the newspaper opposed to what actually happened.

It seems to have developed into a thread sharing experiences and an appropriate place to mention the taboo of dying has made a person scared. Shutting down that part of the conversation isn't helpful and has been the case of death being taboo and that in itself makes life and dying harder than it should be in my opinion.

Sharing experiences of death and information can be really helpful.

SunshineCake, there are usually books on the subject at libraries and water stone. I found this really helpful after my mother died and when my father died, having the information made me caring for him better as I knew a bit more about what was happening and why.

StCharlotte · 24/08/2021 10:12

@Ozanj

My gran used to say that in her experience dying people had an instinct (much like animals do) to die away from loved ones. This was back when death was much more common and so she knew many people who had died. She used to always say that preceeding a heart attack or stroke people would leave the house or go into the garden or go into a room alone & then you’d find them there. And that you could tell when a serious sick baby / toddler was about to die when they got slightly better suddenly & tried to move out of their parents arms. Sad
Yes I've heard this.

(Forgive my levity but "This was back when death was much more common" made me chuckle)