Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe the statement ‘died surrounded by loved ones’

363 replies

Meredithsbff · 23/08/2021 14:13

I’ve always found comfort with reading the phrase “X died surrounded by their family” when learning of the death of someone. I often thought how lucky they were to have them there at the exact moment of death.

However, my neighbour passed away last year. She was elderly and her adult children weren’t very caring towards her. They were happy to rarely visit as she had 24 hour carers by the end. She died in the middle of the night after her carer realised she’d stopped breathing. Paramedics got her heart beating but when they stopped cpr it would stop again. One of her adult children arrived when it was too late. She had died on the floor with the paramedics and a carer who she had only met that day. However, fast forward to the funeral announcement and it was stated that she was “much loved and died surrounded by her closest family”.

Have I been naive all these years and it’s actually often a lie? I know it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things but I’d be interested to know if this is regular practice.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 23/08/2021 15:49

@PropertyFlipper
"I read something yesterday about somebody dying in the arms of their loved one. I'm not sure how that works frankly. "

I worked in residential and end of life. We'd allow people on to the bed. Often the dying person would lay their head on the other's shoulder etc. My FIL was being hugged when he went. Some ask for a relaxant, which means that they just slip away. In end of life care, we are committed to giving a good death.
My Mum had a relaxant. My DD and Sister held her hand as she died, but we were all there. My DH was clinging on and I think because there was always someone with him. He died with a Nurse present.

ivykaty44 · 23/08/2021 15:48

I can't think of anything worse than having to have those you love most watch you die

its not a spectator event

those around you would hopefully be taking care of you and holding your hand (supporting, helping assisting you) as you leave this world behind

but for many dying they will choose when to die as some people leave the room for a cup of tea or a bathroom trip

HaveringWavering · 23/08/2021 15:48

@Originally

I can't think of anything worse than having to have those you love most watch you die

Couldn't agree more.

That’s an interesting point. I didn’t make it to my Dad’s bedside when he died and, going by how traumatic my Mum and brother found it (Dad was only in his fifties and he was ill but the end came suddenly) I am glad about that if I’m honest.

On the other hand I made it to my Mum’s bedside, but she wasn’t conscious enough to know I was there. I was glad to be there for my brother’s sake but I do still have flashbacks that I find hard to deal with. The other day I looked at my 4 year old and thought- one day that hand may hold mine as I die. Not sure how I feel about that.

GerardWay123 · 23/08/2021 15:47

Myself & my DH were with his Mum as the time was approaching.
DH had to go out for an hour and my MIL passed away. It was so traumatic (even though it was Macmillan). I'm so glad he wasn't there to see the last few minutes. I lied to DH and told him it was peaceful.

Thisnamewasnttaken123 · 23/08/2021 15:47

My father died with his entire family around the bed, we were all saying over and over again we love you, we love you as he was going.
I only managed to get there in time by about 15 minutes before he passed away.
It was absolutely heartbreaking but I hope he could hear us all.
I do think it's rare.

gabsdot · 23/08/2021 15:43

@Ozanj

My gran used to say that in her experience dying people had an instinct (much like animals do) to die away from loved ones. This was back when death was much more common and so she knew many people who had died. She used to always say that preceeding a heart attack or stroke people would leave the house or go into the garden or go into a room alone & then you’d find them there. And that you could tell when a serious sick baby / toddler was about to die when they got slightly better suddenly & tried to move out of their parents arms. Sad
I totally agree with this. I know of several situations where a person was dying in hospital, family with them constantly. They finally died when the person keeping vigil, popped to the loo or for a quick cuppa and they were alone.
Marove · 23/08/2021 15:41

I suppose it reads better than " was greedy nasty manipulating and selfish. Abused everyone she came in contact with including her own children and family but managed to turn on the water works and gain enough sympathy so everyone thought she was the victim and cursed her family for not visiting her so inevitably she died a much deserved lonely death that nobody gave a shit about"

Mybestgirl · 23/08/2021 15:40

I was with both of my parents when they died, I was able to hold their hand, tell them everything is ok, and tell them I loved them. My dad was looking directly at me as he died while I told him I loved him very much…I’m glad I was there, and I believe they were too.

PropertyFlipper · 23/08/2021 15:40

I read something yesterday about somebody dying in the arms of their loved one. I'm not sure how that works frankly. Hmm I'd hate to expire in the arms of my DH. I've no idea how he'd cope.

RavenclawesomeCrone · 23/08/2021 15:39

My mum and dad both died at home, expected deaths, but despite me and my sister and GC (and my mum in the case of my dad who died first) being in the room almost constantly, they both slipped away when they were briefly alone. I don't think that's a coincidence really.

My great uncle died very suddenly in his 90s. He was fit and well (for his age), had walked down to the shop to get milk and a paper, came back and felt a bit funny, so my great aunt (88) told him to go and sit in his chair and she's bring him a brew. He was dead in his chair by the time she brought it through.
That's the way I'd want to go.

Furball · 23/08/2021 15:37

@TheBitterBoy

When my mum was dying, my dad, brother and I spent a week at the hospital with her, all day, late into the evening, but we went home to try to sleep at around 10 each night. It was emotionally and physically exhausting, and we were not there when she died, at around 11pm. I refuse to beat myself up about it, and would never judge someone for saying their family member died surrounded by family. As far as I'm concerned my mum died knowing we had been there for her and with her in her last days, and wouldn't have expected more. Dying is not just the moment of the last breath, especially in cases of long terminal illness.
@TheBitterBoy - Agree

Very similar happened to me, my mum had been really ill (cancer) for about 2 months and had had either my dad/brother/me with her 24/7. On the day she died, we had ended up in the kitchen making a cup of tea only for 5-10 mins when we went back in she had died.

I too can't beat myself up about it, Mum knew we we had been there and I sort of think she waited for that moment alone to die.

TheCuttySharp · 23/08/2021 15:37

My Granny died in her bed with her children and grandchildren sat around her. Her hand was held. We sang her favourite songs. We each had a few minutes alone, to talk to her.
She wasn't conscious but as she took her last breath she she'd a single tear.
I like to think she knew we were there.

Jerseygirl12 · 23/08/2021 15:36

Reading other people’s experiences has been very helpful for me. I’ve spent the last 9 months wondering if I should have stayed longer with my DF, visited more, not visited.
Sorry for all your losses.

PowerhouseOfTheCell · 23/08/2021 15:35

Surely no one is going to write ‘died completely alone because Sheila had nipped to the Co-op’ Confused it’s just one of those things people include in obituaries

waterlego · 23/08/2021 15:35

My brother and I were with our DM when she died in a hospice.

A couple of months earlier, we had been at the same hospice with our DDad, and knew the end was near…but he took quite a long time to eventually actually…stop. We sat up with him all night and when the nurses came in the morning to move and wash him, we stepped outside into the gardens. No sooner had we sat ourselves on a bench out there, one of the nurses appeared at the door and told us he had just that moment gone. I think he knew we were there and waited for us to bugger off, bless him.

Agree with poster upthread that it can be an enormous privilege to be with a parent when they die, and can almost be described as a beautiful experience - as long as the death is expected and the person does not seem to be in pain or distressed. I’m very glad and grateful that I could be with my parents in their final hours.

thegreylady · 23/08/2021 15:34

My best friend’s dh (also a close friend) had pancreatic cancer. My friend was chatting to him and he was responding a little. The telephone rang and she got up to answer it just outside the room. When she returned a couple of minutes later he was dead.
My own mum died shortly after I had left after staying at the hospital most of the day. I had to leave at 10 pm and they rang not long after I was home to say she had died.

QueeniesCroft · 23/08/2021 15:32

Except it’s not always about ‘you’ is it....what if your parent wants you there/ is comforted by your presence....would you stay away because ‘ you couldn’t think of anything worse’ .....some people almost need ‘permission’ To die...before taking their last breath....often from a very close family member....I guess it all depends on how selfish you are

I'm hoping that you just got the wrong end of the stick and jumped in without fully understanding the post. The poster was talking about what she wanted for her own death. Surely this is the one time in a person's life when it really should be about what they want?

My experience tallies with many others in that people seem to want to be alone when they die and will often wait until loved ones have gone, then die shortly afterwards. I don't think that's difficult to understand, or selfish.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 23/08/2021 15:32

When my DM died she had been unconscious for a few days, the hospital rang to let us know that she was not expected to last much longer, we checked that she was still totally unawares then my Dsis and I decided to gather at her home with DF who was housebound and wait together for the call to say she had gone. I have sometimes wondered if it was the right decision but knowing how Mum worried about Dad being left alone I think it was the right thing to do.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 23/08/2021 15:30

@stuffnthings

Interesting to read other people's experiences. When my DW died earlier this year, I had left the room for a 15 mins or so, only for her to pass away whilst I wasn't there. I have some regret about that, but also realise that the nature of terminal illness is it is difficult to predict when the final moment comes.
This happens so often you would not believe it, I was a nurse for 20 years and people would often wait until their relatives or partners nipped to the loo or went for an hours sleep before dying suddenly.
Seriouslymole · 23/08/2021 15:29

My MIL died about 30 minutes after DH and I had left her in the very capable hands of DH's aunt (MIL's sister). I am absolutely convinced she waited until we'd gone because she didn't think we'd cope well with it. DAunt was so experienced with older people, having been an OT all her working life, and was brilliant. But I still would say she died with those she loved around her as all her children and both her siblings were there throughout the day.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 23/08/2021 15:28

@Originally

I can't think of anything worse than having to have those you love most watch you die

Couldn't agree more.

Not for me, I've saved enough money to go to Dignitas when the time comes, and fully intend to go there alone surrounded by my happy memories.
ancientgran · 23/08/2021 15:28

@ConcernedAuntie

Sorry but I can't think of anything worse than having to have those you love most watch you die.

I know some people would find it comforting but having my nearest and dearest watching the light go out of my eyes is not something I could wish for.

We are all different.

Both y parents died suddenly so have never had to make this decision for myself.

I'm so glad it's not just me. I've told mine if I'm near the end they can come and say goodbye but I don't want an audience. My exhusband died, my sons said he was surrounded by his siblings and their partners crying and carrying on and at one point he asked them to leave (not as politely as that.) The idea that someone close to death needs to rouse them to tell people he'd had enough of them seems really sad to me.
YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 23/08/2021 15:28

My father passed away surrounded by love ones. His 3 sisters, my sister and myself were there. I was stroking his hair as he took his last breath.

thepeopleversuswork · 23/08/2021 15:28

I suspect this phrase was much more likely to be true 50-60 years ago than it is today. These days a large number of people will die in care homes/supported living places/hospitals and a minority at home.

I personally would not want to die surrounded by loved ones. I don't see the moment of death as particularly significant from a spiritual point of view, you are unlikely to be sentient and very likely to be barely aware, or uncomfortable or in pain. Having a ton of relatives around you and breathing down your neck is unlikely to alleviate this and would probably make it worse.

I would like to die surrounded by morphine. And possibly one very well chosen relative who I found genuinely comforting. But a whole deathbed scene of hangers-on, no thanks.

TravellingSpoon · 23/08/2021 15:26

When my Grandad passed away, my Nan and my sister (who he was the closest to, purely because she had lived with them growing up) left. We knew his passing was imminent and they both said that they couldn't be around. He passed very quickly after they had gone and I still think he was waiting for them to leave.