Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe the statement ‘died surrounded by loved ones’

363 replies

Meredithsbff · 23/08/2021 14:13

I’ve always found comfort with reading the phrase “X died surrounded by their family” when learning of the death of someone. I often thought how lucky they were to have them there at the exact moment of death.

However, my neighbour passed away last year. She was elderly and her adult children weren’t very caring towards her. They were happy to rarely visit as she had 24 hour carers by the end. She died in the middle of the night after her carer realised she’d stopped breathing. Paramedics got her heart beating but when they stopped cpr it would stop again. One of her adult children arrived when it was too late. She had died on the floor with the paramedics and a carer who she had only met that day. However, fast forward to the funeral announcement and it was stated that she was “much loved and died surrounded by her closest family”.

Have I been naive all these years and it’s actually often a lie? I know it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things but I’d be interested to know if this is regular practice.

OP posts:
AfternoonToffee · 23/08/2021 16:37

@JulesCobb

My mum used to work in nursing homes. She often said the residents often died after their families left for the evening. Flowers
Yes my MIL passed away less than 30 minutes after DH and his Aunt (her sister left) We knew it was a waiting game, but she slipped away peacefully in the end.
CaveMum · 23/08/2021 16:35

A few years ago my friend's mother was dying of cancer. She was at home and they had a Macmillan Nurse staying overnight so my friend and her brother could get some rest. In the final days the nurse asked them if they wanted to be woken up during the night if the time was near. My friend didn't know what to do, her mum had slipped into unconsciousness a day or two before and they had already said their goodbyes.

The nurse very gently said that her mum had already "gone" and that the decision to be there or not for her final breaths was for her benefit, not her mums.

She decided not to be woken, though her brother asked for the opposite and in the end both were happy with the decision they had taken.

BrilloPaddy · 23/08/2021 16:27

I take all family death announcements with a pinch of salt tbh.

My Uncle died at 47 from alcoholism. His death announcement read much loved son, brother, father and husband and said that he died unexpectedly in hospital. What a crock. He made my aunt and cousins lives a misery with his addiction - yes we all loved him dearly but we didn't love his actions or behaviour.

Redglitter · 23/08/2021 16:20

When my Dad died, my Mum,Brother & I were with him. We wouldn't have had it any other way

Notmoresugar · 23/08/2021 16:17

@Meredithsbff
It doesn't really surprise me at all.
Lot's of people don't care about their family.
That statement could have been because of their guilt and/or not wanting other people to know that they didn't really care about her.

Blossomtoes · 23/08/2021 16:16

I was with my mum. It felt very fitting that she saw me into the world and I saw her out of it.

Justmuddlingalong · 23/08/2021 16:13

My wording of a relative's obituary had to have the phrase "passed away" instead of saying the person had died. I find that weird, when you don't have a "passing away" certificate, it's a death certificate. We don't need the flowery words and phrases imo.

PhoenixFreesias · 23/08/2021 16:08

I know what you mean I think. My mum died from breast cancer and I moved home to look after her for the least few months when she really wasn’t coping. The last three weeks she was in a hospice.

I basically moved into the hospice with her, slept in the reclining chair at her bedside. During that time I left twice to go home for a shower and to pick up things for my mum like books and photos. While I was away my aunty stayed with her.

In time I was there were very few other visitors for other patients except Sunday afternoons. The nurses told me it was very unusual for a patient to have a visitor everyday and because I was in with my mum all the time, they were able to spend more time with other patients, the ones who got no visitors. Some of those people had no-one left to visit them but some of them did. People have work, children and also I think their own grief/sadness and fears of dying make it too difficult a thing to face, especially when you know there is no chance of someone coming out again.

For my mum’s eulogy there were family members who I mentioned as helping my mum and being there for her in her last days because they would have been offended and felt affronted or shamed if I hadn’t. But they weren’t really there much, if at all.

Flipflopblowout · 23/08/2021 16:07

@Ozanj

My gran used to say that in her experience dying people had an instinct (much like animals do) to die away from loved ones. This was back when death was much more common and so she knew many people who had died. She used to always say that preceeding a heart attack or stroke people would leave the house or go into the garden or go into a room alone & then you’d find them there. And that you could tell when a serious sick baby / toddler was about to die when they got slightly better suddenly & tried to move out of their parents arms. Sad
I always thought that death as with birth was common across the board.
AdditionalCharacter · 23/08/2021 16:06

My FIL died with his children, MIL and me gathered around in a hospital room. Watching someone die is something you never get over.

MIL died in a room by herself, DH missed her by 10 minutes. We had been getting the same "come quickly" phone calls over and over again for 4 months before she died. DH had gone to the wrong hospital, she had been transferred the week before and he forgot. He still feels guilty 8 years on.

The day before both of them died, they requested that their grandchildren came for a visit that day, and they both asked that their hair be brushed before the grandchildren saw them. Probably coincidental, could be that they knew it was their last chance to see them.

FIL had "surrounded by family" in his obituary, MIL did not.

PumpkinPie2016 · 23/08/2021 16:05

I don't think it's necessarily often a lie. Many do have someone with them when they die. Equally, knowing when someone is going to die can be difficult so it may be that someone dies alone or with carers because of circumstances.

I was with my Nan when she died and my Aunt was also with us. However, her death was very much expected and tbh, I essentially spent two days at her house with her, waiting for the inevitable Sad I am glad I was with her during her final days but we were close and I visited a lot. That said, although her death was very peaceful and dignified, I did find it quite traumatic to watch someone I loved dearly dieSad

On the other hand, my Grandad died when I was small. He was one of the 'wait until someone goes'. My mum was pregnant with my sister and sat/slept for 3 days next to his bed in the Christie while he was dying. He died when she went to quickly grab some things. We often wonder if he waited until he knew she wasn't thereSad

isthisareverse · 23/08/2021 16:04

Most posts seem to only imagine an elderly person at the end of their life. In reality, it can be from very young. The stage of your life makes a huge difference.

Jent13c · 23/08/2021 15:58

I would say most of the time in an expected death in hospital family are present, if they have nipped to the loo or we are in doing a turn sometimes it happens then but if the patients breathing had changed then I would probably keep the family very close by while moving them just in case.

Weirdly though I do think there is some element of choice sometimes. I had a patient who was very very unwell who was waiting for his first grandchild, an IVF baby and as soon as he saw her he said me "OK thats me done, funeral is all done, everything is in order, I'll go on Tuesday." The next day he was unresponsive and he died on the exact day he said.

OneTC · 23/08/2021 15:58

I always took it to have a figurative as well as literal interpretation. Though it doesn't sound like either applies to the OPs observation

AlternativePerspective · 23/08/2021 15:57

I can't think of anything worse than having to have those you love most watch you die Me either.

I am in heart failure and I know that will likely be what ultimately kills me.
I have in fact almost died on several occasions, cardiac arrest, heart shock, full organ failure etc etc, and none of my family were there fortunately. And I have told my DP I don’t want anyone there when I die

My DP was with his brother when he died last year and he found it utterly traumatising.

Dixiechickonhols · 23/08/2021 15:57

I found it comforting to watch my grandma die. My Dad her old child was there too. She was comfortable not in pain and looked peaceful. She suddenly gasped said my Grandads name and then died.
I do hear a lot of people going when loved one has nipped out too I do think there’s something in some people wanting peace to die alone.
I think I’d take phrase to mean family had been with them in final few weeks even if they were out of room at moment of passing. I wouldn’t feel guilty if you aren’t there at exact moment it may have been as they wanted.

Crazysheep · 23/08/2021 15:53

My Aunt died last year after falling ill very suddenly. She was placed on life support and literally our whole family were there when it was disconnected. Her husband, children, grandchildren, sisters, nieces and friend. We sang her fave songs and exchanged memories and fun stories. She was surrounded by love. However my mother who is her little sister and they were inseparable left the room along with her daughter and a few others, they were literally gone 5 mins and she chose that moment to pass away. I'm certain she was protecting them until the end. I'm forever grateful I got to hold her hand in that moment and that she chose me to hold on to while she let go.

YanTanTethera123 · 23/08/2021 15:52

My father died with none of us there, his explicit wishes. Just a carer from the nursing home was there.
I couldn’t visit my dying mother, COVID rules in the same nursing home 3 months later. My siblings were there but she pushed them both away from holding her hands, one sibling said it was as if she wanted us to go.

JudgeRindersMinder · 23/08/2021 15:52

We were with both of our parents as they died, and I wouldn’t have had it any other way.
It’s a deeply personal thing though. I firmly believe my late MIL waited for me to leave the hospital to see the children before she died, she had her sisters and her son (dh) with her and although we got on ok we didn’t have a close relationship. I’m absolutely fine with her choice

JudgeJ · 23/08/2021 15:51

@ConcernedAuntie

Sorry but I can't think of anything worse than having to have those you love most watch you die.

I know some people would find it comforting but having my nearest and dearest watching the light go out of my eyes is not something I could wish for.

We are all different.

Both y parents died suddenly so have never had to make this decision for myself.

When my mother died in a Hospice there was no-one at her bedside, we were changing round, someone had been there all day and I was very upset. One of the staff told me that it was very common, sometimes it was simply that a relative had gone to the loo, almost as though the patient wanted to die in private.
RealBecca · 23/08/2021 15:50

Bluntly the family tell the funeral director what to announce in the paper. The family wont say "X died alone and her family never visited".

ivykaty44 · 23/08/2021 15:50

This was back when death was much more common and so she knew many people who had died

do you mean death at home was much more common?

Blanketpolicy · 23/08/2021 15:50

I don't think it literally means the whole family were around the bedside waiting for the finale.

It means in the last years of their life they had their family around them, visiting/doing things together/supporting them if necessary.

When I am actually dying in the last few minutes the only people I am interested in being there are the ones who can give me pain meds if needed!!!

SunbathingDragon · 23/08/2021 15:49

You have to remember that obituaries are written by the family and friends still alive, who may want to appease any guilt they feel for not doing enough and being there when it mattered. On the whole being surrounded by their loved ones is probably general enough to really mean that during the active death phase (ie the last few weeks of life) the person saw many of their loved ones.

Congressdingo · 23/08/2021 15:49

My fil recently died actually surrounded by nearest family, children and wife. He was not left alone for 5 days. They were all there.
My aunt died a few years ago also had everyone there, but waited til they all went out for various reasons (coffee, toilet, smoke) and then died. I think my aunt was waiting to be alone. I think my fil was trying to wait til he was alone but in the end gave up on that idea. My fil wasnt the kind of man who would want people to see him die. If that makes sense.