Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe the statement ‘died surrounded by loved ones’

363 replies

Meredithsbff · 23/08/2021 14:13

I’ve always found comfort with reading the phrase “X died surrounded by their family” when learning of the death of someone. I often thought how lucky they were to have them there at the exact moment of death.

However, my neighbour passed away last year. She was elderly and her adult children weren’t very caring towards her. They were happy to rarely visit as she had 24 hour carers by the end. She died in the middle of the night after her carer realised she’d stopped breathing. Paramedics got her heart beating but when they stopped cpr it would stop again. One of her adult children arrived when it was too late. She had died on the floor with the paramedics and a carer who she had only met that day. However, fast forward to the funeral announcement and it was stated that she was “much loved and died surrounded by her closest family”.

Have I been naive all these years and it’s actually often a lie? I know it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things but I’d be interested to know if this is regular practice.

OP posts:
Justmuddlingalong · 23/08/2021 17:09

I don't need anything to stand in for 'died', but some people do. And it's only fair to use the wording that those closest to the deceased is/are comfortable with. It's not for us to tell them what words they should use.

And yet that's exactly what happened. I was the close family member trying to get a newspaper obituary printed. Neither I, nor the deceased would use the phrase "passed away." The rules of the newspaper deemed the use of the word "died" as inappropriate.

RumblyMumbly · 23/08/2021 17:08

I've experienced a grandparent and a parents death, neither were like they are depicted on screen. It took much longer than I was expecting from withdrawal of treatment to death (it actually didn't feel very humane how long it dragged out) and I'm sorry to say that one of the deaths I attended wasn't a gentle last breath. I grew up a lot that day. I do try and balance it out that there were 80 odd good years prior to their last unpleasant day.

Kintsugi16 · 23/08/2021 17:07

My DF had us all around him.
We had a connection and I’m not sure it’s what he would have wanted, although he probably wasn’t bothered.

I would prefer to die alone I think

BastardMonkfish · 23/08/2021 17:07

Dying is a process that sometimes takes weeks. Maybe that's what they meant.

Dixiechickonhols · 23/08/2021 17:05

I know everyone dies but I do understand what Ozani meant more exposure to death in everyday life in past eg childhood mortality a lot higher. Lots of people are adult before they experience death in family due to life expectancy now.

Benjispruce5 · 23/08/2021 17:04

DM died with 12 of us around her. It still gives me comfort.

Doomscrolling · 23/08/2021 17:02

I knew DM was frightened of being alone. The high dependency unit staff were wonderful, very supportive. DM died while holding hands with DF and my brother; I was sitting next to her.

The last 45 minutes was pretty rough on us, but we knew she didn’t died afraid, and I was the final act of love we could do for her.

However, most of the time I think the phrase means “had seen their family and said goodbyes”

Bells3032 · 23/08/2021 17:00

When my mother died we had a full room inc her two kids, husband, father, two siblings, siblings in law and several nieces and nephews. it was exactly how she wanted it.

All four of my grandparents had all three of their kids at their side (and if still alive their spouse). so no i don't think it is always a lie.

Cattenberg · 23/08/2021 17:00

I get the impression (no idea if this is right), that most expected deaths happen when the dying person is asleep or heavily sedated.

I know relatives can feel very guilty for not being there right at the end, but maybe the person dying wouldn’t have known if they were there or not.

Floralnomad · 23/08/2021 16:58

@Boatonthehorizon

Its horrific seeing a loved one die, nothing like the movies. But a little bit like a loved one going under anesthetic suddenly pre surgery. Wouldnt wish it on my worst enemy.
I totally disagree , my poor dad died very suddenly at home from a heart attack when he was 51 , my mum and sister found him dead in an armchair when they came in from dealing with our horses . For 30 +yrs I’ve regretted that he died alone with nobody to help him or even just hold his hand and was very glad that we could all be with my mum when she passed . I’m not sure if it’s linked but I’m completely at peace with my mums death which was 2 years ago and have still not really dealt with my dads .
2018SoFarSoGreat · 23/08/2021 16:56

With my DGF, the whole family gathered from far and near (up to 20 at any time!) while he lay dying for a full week. By day 5, we were on our knees, so set up shifts. My cousin and I were on the 10:00 to 2:00 am shift, and he died as his 3 DC were coming in at the end of the long hallway. I'm sure he did not want them to have to watch. I'm honored to have been with him.

With my DF, he died at home, with all of his DC, wife and SIL around him. It was peaceful and beautiful and expected. The medical staff were amazing. They told us it would be that week, then in the next 48 hours, then within 6 hours. They were right, and we could plan accordingly. That really helped.

With my best friend, she was in hospital and we got told it was imminent. Her family, and some of us, her best friends and colleagues, were with her for the last 5 or 6 hours, and we got to say our goodbyes. It was hard up to the last 30 minutes, but then very peaceful.

With my DM, I wasn't there but my siblings caught her last breaths. That one was not expected.

I'm glad I had the opportunity, the good fortune, the privilege to be with those I loved. I do not, however, want anyone around when I go. I've told my DH that there are to be NO friends or colleagues there at the last. That is a step too far for me. Selfish, but how I feel.

saraclara · 23/08/2021 16:55

@Justmuddlingalong

My wording of a relative's obituary had to have the phrase "passed away" instead of saying the person had died. I find that weird, when you don't have a "passing away" certificate, it's a death certificate. We don't need the flowery words and phrases imo.
I don't need anything to stand in for 'died', but some people do. And it's only fair to use the wording that those closest to the deceased is/are comfortable with. It's not for us to tell them what words they should use.

I had to inform a group of people of someone's death just a few days ago, and I knew the spouse would see the message. So though I would normally use the word died, as he'd told me that his wife had passed away, that's the wording I used..

LynseyLoses · 23/08/2021 16:55

@randomlyLostInWales

Is it down to interpetation of the phrase.

We've had family head back from around the world - in some cases literally other side of the globe - and visits weeks/days/hours before to be seen and good byes said but they weren't there at the exact moment - family usually in hospital and homes and with one it was few minutes after a relative left for the night.

Yes, this is my interpretation of it in my own family, as we live all over the place. If everyone gets back to the same town and sees the dying person, I'd say they died surrounded by loved ones.

One relative died in a public place, fairly unexpectedly, (although he was in his nineties), and it just so happened that his immediate family were right beside him when he died. That's the only time I can think of the saying "surrounded by loved ones" to literally be true.

IReallyLikeCrows · 23/08/2021 16:52

@Ozanj

My gran used to say that in her experience dying people had an instinct (much like animals do) to die away from loved ones. This was back when death was much more common and so she knew many people who had died. She used to always say that preceeding a heart attack or stroke people would leave the house or go into the garden or go into a room alone & then you’d find them there. And that you could tell when a serious sick baby / toddler was about to die when they got slightly better suddenly & tried to move out of their parents arms. Sad
I think there may be some truth in this. I sat up with my mum all night before she died. I was stroking her hair, putting lip balm on her lips because they were dry, putting those things you soak in water into her mouth so she wouldn't be thirsty and telling her it was okay for her to go, that we didn't want her to be in pain and we'd all be fine (big fat lie, obviously!). She was in a coma. And then went out for a fag - I used to smoke. A nurse came running out to get me and when I got back she'd died. I felt that she'd wanted me gone before she went. I might just be comforting myself but even if I am I felt that she went in her own time.
Boatonthehorizon · 23/08/2021 16:51

Its horrific seeing a loved one die, nothing like the movies. But a little bit like a loved one going under anesthetic suddenly pre surgery.
Wouldnt wish it on my worst enemy.

Blossomtoes · 23/08/2021 16:49

We were so lucky @waterlego. 💐

saraclara · 23/08/2021 16:49

My DH died with me and our DDs around him, and the cat sitting on the bed. We knew it was happening, so the girls and I were chatting together, perched on the bed, sharing memories and laughing, keeping each other, (and him) company in a warm and loving way.

If it's a peaceful death (and he'd been in a coma for 24 hours, so it was), it's a very comforting thing. It was actively positive, because we'd given him what he wanted - to die peacefully at home. When he breathed his last, the three of us hugged each other happily, not sadly.

But I know we were lucky to have that, and not all deaths are as good.

DeepDown12 · 23/08/2021 16:47

My grandfather asked my mum, with whom he was particularly close with, to leave the room. He died 5 mins after she left the room, with his wife and my father (his son in law) there with him.

waterlego · 23/08/2021 16:45

It felt very fitting that she saw me into the world and I saw her out of it.

I felt exactly the same when my mum died. It felt ‘right’. 💐

Floralnomad · 23/08/2021 16:45

My FIL died with his wife and 2 sons at his bedside , and my mum died at home with 3 daughters , a grandson and SIL around the bed . I was a night staff nurse for about 25 yrs and lots of people had family sitting with them for ages and then died as soon as the family left and only a nurse was present , it was quite strange .

Myothercarisalsoshit · 23/08/2021 16:44

My Mum died from COPD. In her final days at home she had me, my brother, my SIL and my auntie with her. We reminisced, sang her favourite songs, held her hand, brushed her hair and told her how much she was loved. On her last night it was obvious she was going and we all stayed up with her. She waited until everyone was asleep and then slipped away quietly. That's how she was. Never wanted to make a fuss.

Amdone123 · 23/08/2021 16:42

My dad was in hospital for the last 10 days of his life. There are 4 of us and we made sure someone was always there to be with him as he drifted in and out of consciousness. Day 9 was my wedding anniversary and my siblings suggested we go for a meal ( we all needed some respite), and return in the morning. Not only did my dad die when none of us were there but he didn't die on my wedding anniversary.

GinIronic · 23/08/2021 16:42

My employers use a phrase - "Xxxxx death is not only a loss to their family but to all of us at Xxxx".

Utter tripe. One particular person was certainly not mourned. One colleague quipped that this person should be buried at a crossroads at midnight - with a stake through their heart - just to make sure they were dead!

mrsevangelina · 23/08/2021 16:41

My granny and my great granny died surrounded by family, as did all other family members who died in hospital. The only one who didn't was a very sudden heart attack death when it was very unexpected.

Obviously if it's the middle of the night not in hospital it won't be surrounded by loved ones, but I honestly don't know why they would say that in the obituary if it wasn't true! Some people do die suddenly and it's impossible for family to be around in many of those circumstances, which is not a reflection on the family IMO.

MasterBeth · 23/08/2021 16:37

@Ozanj

My gran used to say that in her experience dying people had an instinct (much like animals do) to die away from loved ones. This was back when death was much more common and so she knew many people who had died. She used to always say that preceeding a heart attack or stroke people would leave the house or go into the garden or go into a room alone & then you’d find them there. And that you could tell when a serious sick baby / toddler was about to die when they got slightly better suddenly & tried to move out of their parents arms. Sad
I think you’ll find that death is just about as common now as it’s always been…

My dad died last year. Myself, my Mum and my sister were there as he slipped away. It was comforting for us to be with him, supporting him until the end.