Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe the statement ‘died surrounded by loved ones’

363 replies

Meredithsbff · 23/08/2021 14:13

I’ve always found comfort with reading the phrase “X died surrounded by their family” when learning of the death of someone. I often thought how lucky they were to have them there at the exact moment of death.

However, my neighbour passed away last year. She was elderly and her adult children weren’t very caring towards her. They were happy to rarely visit as she had 24 hour carers by the end. She died in the middle of the night after her carer realised she’d stopped breathing. Paramedics got her heart beating but when they stopped cpr it would stop again. One of her adult children arrived when it was too late. She had died on the floor with the paramedics and a carer who she had only met that day. However, fast forward to the funeral announcement and it was stated that she was “much loved and died surrounded by her closest family”.

Have I been naive all these years and it’s actually often a lie? I know it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things but I’d be interested to know if this is regular practice.

OP posts:
FooFightersFan · 23/08/2021 17:54

Blossomtoes

“I was with my mum. It felt very fitting that she saw me into the world and I saw her out of it.”

When my father died recently I had a similar thought. My mum gave birth to me at home and my dad was there when I was born. My dad died at home and I was there with him when he died. It seemed poetic almost.

Before his death I had never seen anyone die. I was shocked. It was slow. And I know he was in pain, right up until we managed to get him on a morphine drip the day before he died.

Then I knew he was pain free and, I hope peaceful.

Fortunately my mum, brother and me were all with him for his last days and I’m sure he felt loved and cared for.

I miss him terribly.

MaMelon · 23/08/2021 17:53

@mogratpineapple

I wonder if it's a case of the dying person simply relaxes when they're on their own, lets go. A bit like when you get into bed after a hard day and everything just slips way
I think that’s a lovely way of looking at it.
AdventuresDownRabbitholes · 23/08/2021 17:53

@BSideBaby

Many of the people I cared for were horribly lonely in their last few years/ months because family very rarely visited (if at all), but it was amazing how many relatives appeared when they were told death was imminent.

So yes many people die 'surrounded by loved ones', but it often isn't for the right reasons. In my experience people just want to be around to make sure they get their fair share of their relative's possessions. Working as a carer can make you very cynical.

I hope my DGM's care home didn't think that of me Sad

She was only in there 2 months, I was there to help move her in, visited after a month and came when they said she was dying - I ended up taking a week off work and spent weeks after that trying to catch up. I'm in another city, her move in coincided with work peak season (90+ hour weeks), and visiting at that time of year was always difficult.

I screwed myself work-wise to be with her when she was dying, because I cared about her. I would hate to think the care home staff thought I was only there to get my hands on her possessions Sad

saraclara · 23/08/2021 17:53

@Justmuddlingalong

I don't need anything to stand in for 'died', but some people do. And it's only fair to use the wording that those closest to the deceased is/are comfortable with. It's not for us to tell them what words they should use.

And yet that's exactly what happened. I was the close family member trying to get a newspaper obituary printed. Neither I, nor the deceased would use the phrase "passed away." The rules of the newspaper deemed the use of the word "died" as inappropriate.

Wow. That's appalling. What gives a newspaper the right to dictate that? I'm really shocked, and obviously it didn't occur to me as a possibility when I read your post. I'm sorry you were forced into that. I'd have been angry about it too.
mogratpineapple · 23/08/2021 17:50

I wonder if it's a case of the dying person simply relaxes when they're on their own, lets go. A bit like when you get into bed after a hard day and everything just slips way

iloveeverykindofcat · 23/08/2021 17:48

I don't know if people have an instinct to be alone - I imagine I would, but its just a guess - but my friend who is a nurse is quite convinced that people usually know when their death is imminent, especially if they are old. She told me that if someone tells her 'I will die tomorrow' they usually do.

DingDongThongs · 23/08/2021 17:48

@Meredithsbff

I’ve always found comfort with reading the phrase “X died surrounded by their family” when learning of the death of someone. I often thought how lucky they were to have them there at the exact moment of death.

However, my neighbour passed away last year. She was elderly and her adult children weren’t very caring towards her. They were happy to rarely visit as she had 24 hour carers by the end. She died in the middle of the night after her carer realised she’d stopped breathing. Paramedics got her heart beating but when they stopped cpr it would stop again. One of her adult children arrived when it was too late. She had died on the floor with the paramedics and a carer who she had only met that day. However, fast forward to the funeral announcement and it was stated that she was “much loved and died surrounded by her closest family”.

Have I been naive all these years and it’s actually often a lie? I know it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things but I’d be interested to know if this is regular practice.

it's to make death seem less upsetting.
MrsToothyBitch · 23/08/2021 17:47

My uncle died with his wife and my dad- his brother, there. My aunt told him that it was alright for him to go and he did, about 10 minutes later. Similarly, my grandad woke up with a touch of angina and had sent my grandma to make a cup of tea. He died just as she left the room. She heard it and she was with him but he nipped out when she wasn't looking, as it were. I'm sure they both chose it.

I would be with my parents if they chose it. My dad, I think, would just want mum. They have a big age gap & she'll likely outlive him- if I was able and she wanted it, I'd be there. Personally, I'd go alone or only with my partner with me, if I can. I have always assumed the "surrounded by family" means people in the house/around/visited. I've certainly always hoped that's what it means. I couldn't bear being watched by everyone in one big crowd as I went.

2andahalfpints · 23/08/2021 17:45

My nan died last
Year, during lockdown but we were allowed to the hospital with her and to stay while she passed.

As soon as we arrived (she was taken in by ambulance) we were warned it was time and sat with her. Medical staff can normally tell so I don't think it is that uncommon.

The officiant at the funeral did make 3 mistakes during the speech though, it was written with us over the phone and then emailed to me on the day of the funeral. I had emailed back immediately to point out the mistakes but they were left in. The worst was missing one of my brother's names out when listing children and grandchildren.

AdventuresDownRabbitholes · 23/08/2021 17:45

These messages always have their own set of platitudes - died [at home / in a care home / in hospital] after a [long/short] illness etc. etc.

We were with DGM when she went; it was an expected death and by that point she was dosed up on morphine and sedatives, and the death rattle went on for the best part of 24 hours. Frankly at that point I would have opted for euthanasia as there is no benefit to be gained from lingering in thath way.

DGF went quite suddenly in the night at a good age, in his own home - it was so unexpected there had to be a post mortem, which showed it was a heart attack. I suspect he had a couple of minutes of pain and a bit of an "oh shit" moment, but at least it was quick. No one was with him - someone was in the next room, and he was simply found the next morning.

Given the choice, I know which way I'd rather go.

MaMelon · 23/08/2021 17:44

@CakeandGo

Yeah it’s a lie. As is the ‘died peacefully’ statement. I’ve witnessed a few deaths and there was nothing ‘peaceful’ about any of them. It’s a lie to make the death “easier” to come to terms with for everyone else. That’s my experience anyway.
My mum died very peacefully. Her breathing got slower, shallower and more spaced out, and then she just didn’t take another one. It might be your experience but that doesn’t make it a lie as such.
CakeandGo · 23/08/2021 17:39

Yeah it’s a lie. As is the ‘died peacefully’ statement. I’ve witnessed a few deaths and there was nothing ‘peaceful’ about any of them. It’s a lie to make the death “easier” to come to terms with for everyone else.
That’s my experience anyway.

ddl1 · 23/08/2021 17:39

Not everyone wants loved ones around them at the point of death. Both from personal experience, and from what I hear from doctors and nurses, many people, who are very close to family members during their illness, will seem to 'pull away' and withdraw when they are close to death, and indeed sometimes seem to wait to leave when their loved ones are out of the room.

I know I would prefer not to have a deathbed vigil around me when it is my time to go.

Xenia · 23/08/2021 17:29

People differ. I think I would prefer to be alone whereas my mother's granny died with loads of her 10 children around and when she was dying called out that she could see a beautiful lady in the top corner of the room (the Blessed Virgin Mary apparently). My mother was present. My mother died in the night at home, alone as my father was asleep upstairs but I think for her letting go and dying was something to be done alone and I suspect I will feel the same a bit like at times I felt I wanted to give birth alone in the silent dark and peace.

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 23/08/2021 17:27

It's like when the person who has died is described as a lovely person, so caring and bubbly natter what they were actually like when they were alive.

HappyBirthdayMrPresident · 23/08/2021 17:27

It breaks my fucking heart knowing I wasn't there at the end for my lovely wee mum the guilt I feel is horrific

TerraNovaTwo · 23/08/2021 17:23

Both my DGPs died surrounded by loved ones, in their own home and at a good age.

R0SEMARY · 23/08/2021 17:22

@TheCuttySharp

My Granny died in her bed with her children and grandchildren sat around her. Her hand was held. We sang her favourite songs. We each had a few minutes alone, to talk to her. She wasn't conscious but as she took her last breath she she'd a single tear. I like to think she knew we were there.
It’s quite possible that she did know you were - hearing is one of the last senses to go and music / songs are stored deep in our memories.

Patients who recover often recall things that were said when they were supposedly unconscious.

Whirlywooo · 23/08/2021 17:19

We were all with my mum when she died. I was holding her hand. To be perfectly honest, I don't think she really knew we were there, she was so heavily sedated which was a good thing.

SayItBackwards · 23/08/2021 17:16

Interesting.
Not quite the same thing but when my DF died from an unexpected heart attack, he'd just stepped out of the car after driving my DM and DA home from holiday. I like to think he'd somehow (perhaps a sixth sense - and I'm absolutely not 'woo') hung on until he'd got them to safety.

Ludoole · 23/08/2021 17:16

My husband died with me at his side in the early hours. It was an expected death so the hospital let me be with him. It was peaceful and I was there because he didn't want to be alone. It gives me comfort to know i could do that for him.

BSideBaby · 23/08/2021 17:15

Many of the people I cared for were horribly lonely in their last few years/ months because family very rarely visited (if at all), but it was amazing how many relatives appeared when they were told death was imminent.

So yes many people die 'surrounded by loved ones', but it often isn't for the right reasons. In my experience people just want to be around to make sure they get their fair share of their relative's possessions. Working as a carer can make you very cynical.

Crazysheep · 23/08/2021 17:14

Also for the people saying they wouldn't want to watch their loved ones die, well I didn't really I would much rather I was watching them dance or enjoy themselves but apparently it was their time to go so I watched that instead. Yes it was traumatic and something that will stick with me for a long long time, would I do it again for a loved one? In a heartbeat.

HereticFanjo · 23/08/2021 17:13

We kept a vigil for a relative. She waited for all the family to leave the room for 2 minutes when nursing staff arrived and died literally a minute after we walked out the door. Any nurse or carer will tell you this is common.

I know in Buddhist thinking, the presence of the family can be seen as a distraction in the important dying process because it anchors the soul to the body at a time when there's an opportunity to leave this life behind and gain enlightenment. It's interesting that so many people from all faiths and none seem to quietly wait for a chance to slip away.

lightand · 23/08/2021 17:12

@3scape

I'm in care a lot of people have died alone. A lot have died with company. Announcements are always a sop to the living though.
Yes Those that read "died peacefully" omit that the person was in 5 years of pain leading up to that.