Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

9st 12lb at 5’4” and size 4-6?

321 replies

OrganicAvocado · 23/08/2021 09:12

Do they mean US size 6? The lady is in Wales.
I’m only 2 inches shorter and weigh 9st 6lb and wear size 10-12.
Well done to her for losing the weight though. Just confused by her clothing size.
uk.yahoo.com/news/22-stone-size-26-mum-060002422.html

OP posts:
Etulosba · 23/08/2021 14:31

If she bought the dress in M&S or Next, it could easily be a size six.

5128gap · 23/08/2021 14:30

The thing is OP, your own clothes size tells you very little about the size you are as they vary so much, never mind using some other woman's size as a yardstick. You know the size you are from your measurements and the mirror, and it really matters nothing if clothing manufacturers call you a size 6, 10 or 22. If I go into a shop and fit into a size 6 lycra thing with lots of stretch it doesn't make me any smaller than if I order something made in Asia and need an XL. I'm the size I am regardless of the label, and the woman in the article is the size she is whatever they call it. And neither effect the size you are.

Ozanj · 23/08/2021 14:29

She looks quite muscular so maybe. I was a small size 12 (H&M) at 86kg because I used to have a core of steel due to climbing / weight training.

phishy · 23/08/2021 14:28

@Sunnygold well said

Sunnygold · 23/08/2021 14:25

She looks great and is a healthy weight so why on earth does it matter what her dress size is?
It matters because it’s suggesting that an average height healthy woman is a size 4. It’s presenting size 4 as an achievable target and a reasonable goal, when in fact most women would be borderline anorexic at that size. Women who aren’t a size 4 will read that and think size 4 is normal and healthy - which for the majority of adult women it isn’t. It’s triggering for normal BMI women - who may be only a size 8-10 - to think they’re too fat. When the actual fact is that a woman of that weight and height will be more like a size 10-12.

Logmein · 23/08/2021 14:20

I think she is a 6-8.
I'm the same height/weight and a size 8. Work out 3 x a week and this changes your body composition so well believe she is the size she says.

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 23/08/2021 14:12

I think you're confused about clothing sizes. I have clothes that are an UK size 8. Yet I'm smaller and heavier than posters who are saying they are size 10s. Shape, fat and muscle play a big part.

5128gap · 23/08/2021 14:10

Stats not stars!

5128gap · 23/08/2021 14:09

@Gwenhwyfar

"The 50s starlet 'ideal' was 36, 24, 36 but in my day, kate Moss era, everyone actually just aimed to be very very slim."

Just before Kate Moss was the supermodel era and they weren't as skinny. Also, the models that appeared in magazines and catalogues were closer to average young women. Some of the magazines used to give their stats and they were around the 36-24-36 or 34-24-34. This would have been early 90s, not the 50s.

I was referring to the Marilyn Monroe silhouette when I mentioned the 50s. Yes, the likes of Cindy Crawford were bigger than Kate Moss certainly, but their height made them look very slim with those stars, more so than the shorter 50s women.
notacooldad · 23/08/2021 14:07

I once had a date with someone I met online who said they were 5’10” on their profile. Turned out he was only 5’3”. It mattered because it wasn’t true. Apart from that he was lovely. If he hadn’t put 5’10” on his profile I wouldn’t have had any issue with his height...
I’m not at all saying the lady in the article is lying about her size, but that the article is incorrect and probably US sizes. It matters to a lot of people who are trying to lose weight. A size 4-6 U.K. is not a healthy goal

You are not saying she is lying but you are trying to imply it.
What ever her size is does not matter to people who are trying to lose weight ( Me included) We all have our own goals.
You should know that journalist will put words in people's mouths and twist things.
I think this is a unfair thread you have started.
I also think, well done to her and it would not occur to me to start nit picking about her dress size.

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 23/08/2021 14:05

I was a size 6 when I was that weight and I'm a similar height. I was working out a lot and I naturally have a tiny waist. I looked so thin, I looked ill even though it's within a healthy BMI.
There's something very mean-spirited about taking someone's achievement and then trying to pick it away at it.

Coogee · 23/08/2021 14:04

And given I’m pretty skeletal at a size 8 I reckon 4-6 should very def be the preserve of the odd slender teenage girl ….. definitely NOT something to be aspired too!!

Don’t be daft. I’m two inches taller than you and a size 6. I’m not remotely skeletal.

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 23/08/2021 14:03

It's hard to know but when I weighed 9st 8lb at 5'9" I was still only ever a size 8-10.

But petite people have smaller frames; I think part of my size was genuinely due to my skeleton's dimensions.

Lovelouise6778 · 23/08/2021 14:02

I'm 5ft 4 with 8stone 1lbs and I am a uk size 10!

countrytown · 23/08/2021 14:02

Just before Kate Moss was the supermodel era and they weren't as skinny. Also, the models that appeared in magazines and catalogues were closer to average young women. Some of the magazines used to give their stats and they were around the 36-24-36 or 34-24-34. This would have been early 90s, not the 50s.

Since when have models been average heights?

Blinkingbatshit · 23/08/2021 13:59

And given I’m pretty skeletal at a size 8 I reckon 4-6 should very def be the preserve of the odd slender teenage girl ….. definitely NOT something to be aspired too!!

Gwenhwyfar · 23/08/2021 13:59

"The 50s starlet 'ideal' was 36, 24, 36 but in my day, kate Moss era, everyone actually just aimed to be very very slim."

Just before Kate Moss was the supermodel era and they weren't as skinny. Also, the models that appeared in magazines and catalogues were closer to average young women. Some of the magazines used to give their stats and they were around the 36-24-36 or 34-24-34. This would have been early 90s, not the 50s.

Blinkingbatshit · 23/08/2021 13:57

5’4” and 7.5 stone (not a stealth brag - I’ve lost due to being unwell and am desperate to gain) and I’m a size 8 now. Size 4-6?!🤣

elp30 · 23/08/2021 13:55

I'm in the US and I'm 5'4" and weigh 10 stone.
I wear a US 10 but a 12 is more comfortable.
I haven't worn a size 4-6 since I was 25 (26 years ago) and weighed 8.8 stone.

But if the woman says she wears a 4-6, who am I to argue with her.
Well done to her!

OrganicAvocado · 23/08/2021 13:54

glastogal

Newsflash: you can't tell someone's weight by looking at them. I'm 5'6" and wear size 10-12 at 11.5 stone! I have a heavy build so it seems reasonable to me that some people have a light build.

I don’t think anyone is disputing her weight.

OP posts:
BeefSupreme · 23/08/2021 13:54

Well that's a load of bollocks, a 4-6 looks underweight

🙄

Not always

glastogal · 23/08/2021 13:52

Newsflash: you can't tell someone's weight by looking at them. I'm 5'6" and wear size 10-12 at 11.5 stone! I have a heavy build so it seems reasonable to me that some people have a light build.

OrganicAvocado · 23/08/2021 13:39

There's your answer then OP. You have a rectangular body shape and your waist is making you a size 10. She is an hourglass with slimmer mid section. She may carry weight on her legs you can't see in the photo.

But even when I truly was a size 8 and had a 26 inch waist, I was smaller all over, not just my waist, and a stone and a half lighter.
I am size 10 in jeans now (to accommodate my hips) but 12 in tops. If my waist was currently 26” then I’d still not fit into general “size 8” clothing unless super stretch material to cover my bum or big boxy tops to accommodate my boobs. There’s a difference between having a small waist and wearing size 4-6 clothes. My super skinny but muscular (sporty) 5’ tall 12-year-old wears some size 6 women’s clothing. She’s still wearing age 10-11 kids clothes. Size 4-6 on a 41-year-old 4 inches taller than her?

OP posts:
haba · 23/08/2021 13:37

The thing is that everyone is differently built. DD and I are within a few lbs of one another- she's 8stone0, 5'4', and a size 8.
I'm 7st12, 5'0" and a size 8/10, but mostly 10. I have slightly more muscle, and rather more norkage, I've had three pregnancies, am an hourglass whereas she's oblong/athletic build.

This woman has obviously worked very hard to get down to an healthy weight- well done to her Star
Think of the difference that has made to her health and long-term fitness.

PickAChew · 23/08/2021 13:36

She's muscular with a small waist so it's feasible. I'm similar height and weight and a pretty soft 12-14!