Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy the same item as a close friend?

389 replies

lucyli · 23/08/2021 05:53

Firstly I apologise that this is the epitome of a first world problem. I acknowledge I am fortunate to have this problem and that there are many bigger things to worry about.

I have decided to make a high-end purchase from a well-known brand. I've never done this before but am at the stage in my life where I would like to do so.

I spend a long while researching, chose what I wanted and planned to head to the shops in a few days.

Was just chatting to a close friend and it turns out she has the exact same item and is annoyed that I'd buy the same and said she'd rather I didn't. I wasn't aware of this before.

I struggle to understand this mentality as it's not something that would concern me at all the other way around.

Her argument is that she didn't spend all that money, just to have someone close to her have the exact same item.

AIBU to buy it anyway? I was so pleased with the idea of having it and was excited to buy it.

OP posts:
tenredthings · 23/08/2021 10:59

Buy a very cheap copy just to troll her and spend the money on something else !

BeauxRingarde · 23/08/2021 10:59

Her argument is that she didn't spend all that money, just to have someone close to her have the exact same item

But what batshit thinking leads her to believe she has any control over that

Lweji · 23/08/2021 10:58

As others have said, it's such a boring popular design and copied so much that it will hardly register to anyone that you have similar bags.

It's not even something you're likely to take to an event where "unique" clothing is expected. I'd say it's a functional bag that you can take everywhere.

Having said that, and looking at the LV website, you can choose from different patterns.
But, I don't particularly like the bag. It's too big not to have compartments and it will be a big mess inside.
And it's too much an on your face brand bag.

You can probably find a nicer, more understated leather bag elsewhere, if you want style and quality over brand.

luckylavender · 23/08/2021 10:57

I wouldn't buy it now. Too weird.

Dumpling89 · 23/08/2021 10:55

YANBU

If you like the item no one should dictate whether you buy it or not. You have the same taste, so what?
Bags (alongside everything you see in the shops) are in mass reproduction for the very reason that many people will want to buy the product.

TheRealMrsMorningstar · 23/08/2021 10:53

@fourminutestosavetheworld

I personally wouldn't buy it now. Your friend has made it clear that part of the appeal for her is having something special and unique amongst the friendship group.

I don't understand it myself, but presumably she wants people to be impressed and covetous when they see it and this impact will be lessened if you are standing there with the same item.

Regardless, if you're really her friend, you won't want her to be upset about this. She has asked you not to buy it so don't.

If you buy it, she will like you a little bit less. She will also tell everyone she bought it first and you will look like you copied her, which is a bit sad.

I would buy something equally wonderful, but different, and demonstrate good friend credentials and a bit of originality.

And if the "friend" was a real friend then she would be pleased that the OP was about to treat herself to something that gave her joy!

Personally I would buy the bag and ditch the friend!

Dogoodfeelgood · 23/08/2021 10:51

@LivingLaVidaBabyShower darn! Good to know though.

nameisnotimportant · 23/08/2021 10:51

I wouldn't buy it. The bag is tainted now and you will feel nervous about using it around her and you won't enjoy it. I would just pick a better bag to be honest

Dogoodfeelgood · 23/08/2021 10:51

The celine medium cabas in triomphe is exactly like the never full and so sturdy, but I can’t find it anywhere online? How odd. Not even on vestaire.

MintyGreenDream · 23/08/2021 10:49

You said it first so you get to buy it.Wink

isthisareverse · 23/08/2021 10:48

@Eclairesarethebest

Your friend isn't really a friend. She's being petty. "You can't have what I have" is such a child's mentality.
only a child would buy the same item as a friend frankly.

Again, a white tshirt or a bag to add to your collection and would use once in a blue moon wouldn't matter, but an expensive bag that you intend to use everyday? Petty and silly.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 23/08/2021 10:46

@Dogoodfeelgood

The Saint Laurent shopping bags are gorgeous and I think more chic than the neverfull!
Agree but the straps are flimsy and its crap vs NF.

I was chastised by an angry frenchman when i returned mine for "putting many things" in my bag. "It is not designed for this" apparently 🙄
Fantastique....

VQ1970 · 23/08/2021 10:35

www.mulberry.com/gg/shop/bayswater/bayswater-tote-mulberry-green-small-classic-grain

The Mulberry Bayswater Tote is much, much nicer in my opinion - would this work for you?

AramintaLee · 23/08/2021 10:34

Same sort of thing happened to me. I wanted a specific car in a specific colour. I was saving up for it and made the mistake of telling my friend who then went out and got the exact car I wanted, right down to the colour. She was like "you can still get it" but it totally ruined it for me.

I ended up getting a different car and loved it so would advise you to look for something else.

Eclairesarethebest · 23/08/2021 10:33

Your friend isn't really a friend. She's being petty. "You can't have what I have" is such a child's mentality.

sloutside · 23/08/2021 10:31

Ridiculous.
If you want the bag just buy it. Or buy something else.
Whatever.
Your friend buying a particular bag does not give her ownership of that particular bag.

Dogoodfeelgood · 23/08/2021 10:29

The Saint Laurent shopping bags are gorgeous and I think more chic than the neverfull!

AlternativePerspective · 23/08/2021 10:27

My issue with a friend having the same one as me, particularly an in your face brand bag, is that people seeing you together with them would assume they were fake and that you bought them from the same Facebook seller. The rip off fakes spoil the genuine brands.* do most people even care? I mean how many people actually notice which bag someone has.

Most people who actually notice either do so because they think the kinds of people who spend that kind of money on a bag are just pretentious poseurs, and the rest notice because they spend equal amounts of money on worthless stuff and it’s a case of oneupmanship.

But your average member of the public really couldn’t give a shit. Seriously. And the ones who are the posers probably think that the bag is fake whether one or two people own one because they probably all have fakes which they pass off as the genuine article as well…

isthisareverse · 23/08/2021 10:26

@Notonthestairs

The Op has already researched and chosen the bag. She's not copying. She and her friend happen to like the same bag. It's not a unique item.

That said the Elvis & Kresse bags linked to are lovely and, in my opinion, much nicer.

She hasn't bought it, her friend has. It IS now copying. Now she is free to decide if she cares or not about copying, but there are hundreds of designer bags around. Thousands of non-designer bags...

If there is so much agg and drama about a bag, you are spending way too much in it! It's a handbag Hmm

Wexone · 23/08/2021 10:25

If you like the bag go buy it ignore her, as everyone says they are fairly common so its not just her that will have one. Plus there are different colours and sizes and you can your initials on them too. Personally ( i do love my bags and shoes) i wouldn't get one as they are quiet common plus they are very popular for the fake market ( a women in work gets fakes and three have the neverful fake bag ) i would get the graceful, similar sizes but more secure and not as common. But that's me. Have a look at Emma Hill and Emma Anders on Instagram and your tube. They are very good at talking about bags and the pros and cons of them. Plus Emma Hill good for sustainability and sourcing second hand. Buy the bag if you want

Sillysop92 · 23/08/2021 10:24

Just buy it, it’s only a bag, albeit an expensive one.

LittleMysSister · 23/08/2021 10:20

@ANameChangeAgain

My issue with a friend having the same one as me, particularly an in your face brand bag, is that people seeing you together with them would assume they were fake and that you bought them from the same Facebook seller. The rip off fakes spoil the genuine brands.
Tbh I always assume this about LV bags anyway because the fakes are so prolific!
Tal45 · 23/08/2021 10:20

I think you are both BVU to spend £1000 on a bag. It's literally just a bag. The only reason to buy it over a 'normal' bag is to impress other people as demonstrated by your friend who knows that her impressiveness will be watered down by you having the same bag.

Notonthestairs · 23/08/2021 10:15

The Op has already researched and chosen the bag. She's not copying. She and her friend happen to like the same bag. It's not a unique item.

That said the Elvis & Kresse bags linked to are lovely and, in my opinion, much nicer.

ANameChangeAgain · 23/08/2021 10:13

My issue with a friend having the same one as me, particularly an in your face brand bag, is that people seeing you together with them would assume they were fake and that you bought them from the same Facebook seller. The rip off fakes spoil the genuine brands.