Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy the same item as a close friend?

389 replies

lucyli · 23/08/2021 05:53

Firstly I apologise that this is the epitome of a first world problem. I acknowledge I am fortunate to have this problem and that there are many bigger things to worry about.

I have decided to make a high-end purchase from a well-known brand. I've never done this before but am at the stage in my life where I would like to do so.

I spend a long while researching, chose what I wanted and planned to head to the shops in a few days.

Was just chatting to a close friend and it turns out she has the exact same item and is annoyed that I'd buy the same and said she'd rather I didn't. I wasn't aware of this before.

I struggle to understand this mentality as it's not something that would concern me at all the other way around.

Her argument is that she didn't spend all that money, just to have someone close to her have the exact same item.

AIBU to buy it anyway? I was so pleased with the idea of having it and was excited to buy it.

OP posts:
Darlingx · 24/08/2021 20:19

Mybalconyiscracking
So true!!
I am as fashion as the David Bowie track and take it from me what you covert this year will lose it’s shine. The heels I had to must have sitting in a box a cardboard box . I had a Chanel bag got it for £2 from a Charity shop the real thing . I sold it for £40 back in the day when it was out of fashion now it would be worth £2000 or more but I didn’t like a brown Chanel bag with gold chain. Ah now that was a mistake. My sister has my mother’s black one smart cookie. I love love love design and beautiful things but I would let it go for the sake of the friendship. I would value a friend and upsetting her even though slightly irrational it would take the shine off how about finding an even better bag? Handbag wars

Xkerching08x · 24/08/2021 20:19

I’ve got a £1500 LV propriano bag and honestly it would pee me off if a close friend had it. There’s a few different LV bags so I’d choose a different one or a better one. p.s the neverfuls feel flimsy x

Whycantibeapuppy · 24/08/2021 20:12

I find this really strange from a close friend. My close friend often buys something I have or vice Versa, and several times I’ve commented on something of hers and then she gifts me one the same! What a strange thing for her to be annoyed about. Surely it’s a compliment on her taste?

LimeRedBanana · 24/08/2021 20:01

The Gucci one is no nicer than the LV one.

There are so many better alternatives out there, if you’ve got that much to spend.

Gwenhwyfar · 24/08/2021 19:59

[quote Pbbananabagel]Upgrade to Gucci?

www.farfetch.com/uk/shopping/women/gucci-ophidia-gg-tote-item-13433955.aspx?storeid=10524&rtype=inspire_portal_pdp_generic_a&rpos=2&rid=c92a7493-14d4-4b51-b4ce-60b8fba0ee48[/quote]
OMG 1200 for an ugly bag that doesn't even zip up.

Dontwatchfootball · 24/08/2021 19:57

This is ridiculous! I have a friend who has very similar taste and we often find we have bought the same thing. And at some point I guess we will show up somewhere matching. But since we are grown ups we dont care. I thought the PP who asked if you could get a different colour was on to something.

LouH1981 · 24/08/2021 19:55

You need to buy the bag. Life is too short. Chances are you’ll probably use it many times without her. Unless of course this has just zapped all the joy out of it. I think your friend is being a bit unkind tbh.

EspressoDoubleShot · 24/08/2021 19:51

The LV bag you were considering it’s a PTA classic they all hoik it about

ERFFER · 24/08/2021 19:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Eatdrinkbemerry · 24/08/2021 19:40

I would buy it. It’s ridiculous that you can’t buy a well known designer bag just because your friend had one. Your friend is actually quite pathetic. My friend and I have so many similar items and at times we meet up with the same shoes, bag or even jacket on. Neither of us really cared because we know we are not copying one another. We just have such similar tastes.

Tell you friend to grow up!

EspressoDoubleShot · 24/08/2021 19:37

For all those who’d hate someone having same bag, knowing you felt entitled to be annoyed that’d just encourage me to buy the same bag
And I’d get a frisson of mirth at your annoyance

MyNameIsElizaDay · 24/08/2021 19:29

@Lougle

I clearly have no taste because, having googled it, that looks like something you could get at the local market for £20. I'd save your £1000 and buy something else Grin
I agree! How about a lovely kippling bag instead? Better looking and a lot less money😇
Alcemeg · 24/08/2021 19:24

@runthatbymeagain

Can I introduce you to Sarah Haran bags? sarahharan.com/ They are amazing and the Michelle tote is a similar size and shape to the Lab Neverfull. The difference is you can change the accessories on the SH bags -tassels, mini add on bags etc. They are gorgeous leather and beautifully made. I’ll never use another bag again. If you become a VIP (which I’m not) you can reserve a free bag each quarter if you meet the spend. There is a whole Facebook Group Bags of Joy dedicated to them.
I'm a bit gobsmacked by this thread as most of the bags mentioned are in roughly the price range of what I'd pay for a car 😊 and I can't really see why! But these do actually look gorgeous.
Howshouldibehave · 24/08/2021 19:23

Hers was real, mine was a genuine fake

Grin
EspressoDoubleShot · 24/08/2021 19:21

No one has dibs on a handbag, if you like it buy it and yiu don’t need her permission
Majority of the PTA have same ghastly bag and they all turn up at same events

Positivelyrandom · 24/08/2021 19:17

@dreamkitchenhelp

Loving that Cartier one!
Me too, it’s gorgeous.
runthatbymeagain · 24/08/2021 19:05

Can I introduce you to Sarah Haran bags? sarahharan.com/ They are amazing and the Michelle tote is a similar size and shape to the Lab Neverfull. The difference is you can change the accessories on the SH bags -tassels, mini add on bags etc. They are gorgeous leather and beautifully made. I’ll never use another bag again. If you become a VIP (which I’m not) you can reserve a free bag each quarter if you meet the spend. There is a whole Facebook Group Bags of Joy dedicated to them.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 24/08/2021 19:05

YANBU to buy the same bag as a friend. Especially one that is very popular.

But I agree with others that you might find you like other tote bags even more if you look around. Aspinal of London do some lovely ones - much cheaper (and nicer IMO) than LV.

HermioneKipper · 24/08/2021 19:04

This would leave a very nasty taste in my mouth re the friend. What pathetic behaviour from her.

Sounds like a toddler squabbling over a toy!

Buy the bag and enjoy it. You deserve it.

Bin the friend

Honeymare · 24/08/2021 19:03

I think your friend is right. Some people are very caught up in style, it represents more than how they dress but communicates how they want the world to see them. Don't buy the bag and ruin it for her.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 24/08/2021 19:00

@fourminutestosavetheworld

I personally wouldn't buy it now. Your friend has made it clear that part of the appeal for her is having something special and unique amongst the friendship group.

I don't understand it myself, but presumably she wants people to be impressed and covetous when they see it and this impact will be lessened if you are standing there with the same item.

Regardless, if you're really her friend, you won't want her to be upset about this. She has asked you not to buy it so don't.

If you buy it, she will like you a little bit less. She will also tell everyone she bought it first and you will look like you copied her, which is a bit sad.

I would buy something equally wonderful, but different, and demonstrate good friend credentials and a bit of originality.

^This, well said.
Derbee · 24/08/2021 18:56

She sounds a bit precious trying to ban you from buying a relatively common bag. But how about the Mulberry Bayswater tote? I love mine.

Clammyclam · 24/08/2021 18:53

Buy the bag.
I hate this kind of thing, I know a few people like this and one in particular who returned her child's coat because I had bought my child the same one (without knowing her child had one) and she had saved for hers whereas she felt it was something I could buy without worrying and therefore she felt it made her version of the coat worthless.
Absolutely ridiculous!!

These objects aren't limited edition runs- people will have similar or the same.

I've been to work before and been in the exact same outfit as another lady there- it's funny and makes other people look twice and giggle (kindly)
What's to worry about.
BUY THE BAG.

Howshouldibehave · 24/08/2021 18:50

I wouldn’t let anyone tell me what I could and couldn’t buy, but, I have to say, most of DD’s sixth form girls have copies of that bag (I’m presuming they aren’t real, anyway?!) which would put me right off!!