Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy the same item as a close friend?

389 replies

lucyli · 23/08/2021 05:53

Firstly I apologise that this is the epitome of a first world problem. I acknowledge I am fortunate to have this problem and that there are many bigger things to worry about.

I have decided to make a high-end purchase from a well-known brand. I've never done this before but am at the stage in my life where I would like to do so.

I spend a long while researching, chose what I wanted and planned to head to the shops in a few days.

Was just chatting to a close friend and it turns out she has the exact same item and is annoyed that I'd buy the same and said she'd rather I didn't. I wasn't aware of this before.

I struggle to understand this mentality as it's not something that would concern me at all the other way around.

Her argument is that she didn't spend all that money, just to have someone close to her have the exact same item.

AIBU to buy it anyway? I was so pleased with the idea of having it and was excited to buy it.

OP posts:
SpeckledyHen · 23/08/2021 07:04

Buy a Hermes OP . Your friend is batshit .

daisychain01 · 23/08/2021 07:01

It's a very nice bag, I'd get it!

GreatEelRun · 23/08/2021 07:01

LV Neverful is everywhere.

If you had come on here and said your friend had spent ages saving up for this, talked about it for ages, and then bought it and you just went out and got one with little thought then I would say YABU, but this is not what you have done so you are NBU.

I do hate it when people copy others though. I have someone who copies me a lot and it is really annoying. It is not like I have great taste or are massively fashionable either. There have been a few times when I have had to put an outfit together and they have then just gone and copied the whole thing. Once this person was staying with me and I came home from work early and they were wearing one of my outfits. I asked why they had gone into my room to try my clothes on and it turned out they had gone out to the shops and bought the exact same clothes I was wearing 2 days earlier and were trying them on. They got very upset with me for accusing them of trying on my stuff and secondly for thinking I was special and only I am allowed those clothes. It was weird though.

daisychain01 · 23/08/2021 06:59

Could = couldn't

daisychain01 · 23/08/2021 06:58

You could always just ditch the friend, or wear the handbag out with pride and enjoy it without fear, and if she finds out and ditches you then you know the friendship has run it's course.

Personally I could be around someone that controlling and none of my friends are, but then again, I'm not you.

Debetswell · 23/08/2021 06:57

I suppose if someone is prepared to pay mega money for a bag then there will be an element of look at me.
Obviously if you have the same bag then your friend won't be looked at quite so much.

whatthejiggeries · 23/08/2021 06:52

I wouldn't buy the same as a friend and it would piss me off particularly if you have both saved and only have one bag you are bound to have it with you every time you go out. That said an LV spoedie for example is such a common bag half of London has one so I can't see how she expected it to be exclusive. I see both sides to be honest. Personally I would by a Gucci Marmont or something instead but if you have your heart set on it then I understand why you want it

Malibukev · 23/08/2021 06:45

I think I see both sides. I could never afford a designer bag and if I ever did have the money it would be better off spent elsewhere so if by some miracle I was in a position to have the spare cash and be able to spend it on myself I would be really pleased and proud that I owned such a wonderful bag. Its like an achievement isn't it. If my friend then went and bought the same knowing we would be together a fair bit using the same bag it would annoy me. Maybe not enough to tell them not to get it but I can understand why she wouldn't want you to have it.

A designer bag would definitely be a bit of a talking point within my group of friends as in oh wow is that an LB bag, it's gorgeous. I suppose if two people were sat there with the same bag it would generate different comments.

SpeakingFranglais · 23/08/2021 06:45

Do you know she actually has this bag & she just doesn’t want you to get one as she’s envious?

I’d get one if you wanted it, but I probably wouldn’t use it when I met up with her.

Wam90 · 23/08/2021 06:38

Also I’d definitely buy the bag and just not mention it again to her. If she sees you with it and she makes a comment about it then say that it was the one you were talking about buying and went ahead with the purchase.

TheFrogsAreDying · 23/08/2021 06:38

I wouldn’t buy the same handbag as a friend if you saw her socially with your handbags a lot, and if she’s already commented on it. It’s too much like wearing the same dress that a friend is wearing to the same places all the time. There are zillions of handbags, find another one. Or if you’re fixated on this one, never take it somewhere that’s she’s going to be at … but then you’d have to buy another one anyway and it’s kind of wasteful to do that.

Goatinthegarden · 23/08/2021 06:37

I sort of get it, if you’ve coveted something special for a while, bought it, and then someone buys the exact same one, it might take the shine off it for you.

I usually wouldn’t buy something to wear that a close friend already had, unless it was a very common item that ‘everyone’ has.

It wouldn’t bother me though if they bought an item I already had.

Everyone is different.

gofg · 23/08/2021 06:36

What would your friend have done if you had bought the bag without telling her beforehand? Honestly, it's a bag, most people aren't going to be looking that closely if you are out together, and even if they do so what, it's a bag Confused

Your friend is being ridiculous. If that is the bag you have set your heart on then buy it.

LakeShoreD · 23/08/2021 06:35

This is batshit. If your friend wanted a bag no one else has she should have gone with something less ubiquitous than the LV. Seriously they’re everywhere. Most women I know own at least a few of the well known classic designer handbags, the suggestion that because one person has one that bag is now off limits is actually insane. I have a Chanel flap bag that my parents bought me for my 21st birthday, one of my close friends wanted to buy one recently and I went to the store with her and then we went to lunch, because we’re normal people. Your friend is coming across as very controlling, I’d buy the bag and give her a wide berth tbh.

Wam90 · 23/08/2021 06:34

Has she definitely already got the bag herself?
I knew someone who always wanted to have the same items that people around her were contemplating buying so would say that she had “x” or was looking at buying it herself so they couldn’t get it too and these items never materialised. It was mainly with more expensive items too.

lucyli · 23/08/2021 06:27

@Oceanbliss

Regardless, if you're really her friend, you won't want her to be upset about this. She has asked you not to buy it so don't.

If she’s really your friend she won’t try to control what you can and can’t buy or have or do.

This is what I'm struggling with. I'm not sure why it upsets her so I'm finding it hard to empathise and therefore understand why I should not buy it. Perhaps I'm thoughtless though. I'm trying to respect that different things are important to different people,
OP posts:
lucyli · 23/08/2021 06:26

@SunShinesBrightly

Was just chatting to a close friend and it turns out she has the exact same item and is annoyed that I'd buy the same and said she'd rather I didn't. I wasn't aware of this before.

How did you not know she had one?
Does she never use it when she is with you?
Has she only just bought it?

Either way, buy the bag and use it when you are not with her.

Yes, she bought it recently and I knew where she'd bought it but I've never seen it. I don't believe she's used it yet.
OP posts:
Oceanbliss · 23/08/2021 06:22

Sorry that first paragraph was a copy ‘n’ paste from a pp. But I don’t agree with it. Friends don’t control their friends like this. She needs to grow up and realise this.

SunShinesBrightly · 23/08/2021 06:21

Was just chatting to a close friend and it turns out she has the exact same item and is annoyed that I'd buy the same and said she'd rather I didn't. I wasn't aware of this before.

How did you not know she had one?
Does she never use it when she is with you?
Has she only just bought it?

Either way, buy the bag and use it when you are not with her.

mobear · 23/08/2021 06:20

Ignore her and buy it anyway if that is what you want to do. I have the same bag as a close friend (I bought mine because I liked hers) and it never even occurred to me it would be a problem (and it hasn’t been).

Oceanbliss · 23/08/2021 06:19

Regardless, if you're really her friend, you won't want her to be upset about this. She has asked you not to buy it so don't.

If she’s really your friend she won’t try to control what you can and can’t buy or have or do.

Mybalconyiscracking · 23/08/2021 06:19

Maybe buy a different handbag at a sensible price and then put the money you save into the handbag?

PurpleFlower1983 · 23/08/2021 06:17

The other option would be to choose one in a different colour, does she have the classic one with the red interior? You could go for a less popular (and less copied by cheap fakes) design.

PurpleFlower1983 · 23/08/2021 06:15

Just ignore her then OP! Lots of people have it and she can’t police what you choose to spend your money on.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 23/08/2021 06:12

I personally wouldn't buy it now. Your friend has made it clear that part of the appeal for her is having something special and unique amongst the friendship group.

I don't understand it myself, but presumably she wants people to be impressed and covetous when they see it and this impact will be lessened if you are standing there with the same item.

Regardless, if you're really her friend, you won't want her to be upset about this. She has asked you not to buy it so don't.

If you buy it, she will like you a little bit less. She will also tell everyone she bought it first and you will look like you copied her, which is a bit sad.

I would buy something equally wonderful, but different, and demonstrate good friend credentials and a bit of originality.