Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy the same item as a close friend?

389 replies

lucyli · 23/08/2021 05:53

Firstly I apologise that this is the epitome of a first world problem. I acknowledge I am fortunate to have this problem and that there are many bigger things to worry about.

I have decided to make a high-end purchase from a well-known brand. I've never done this before but am at the stage in my life where I would like to do so.

I spend a long while researching, chose what I wanted and planned to head to the shops in a few days.

Was just chatting to a close friend and it turns out she has the exact same item and is annoyed that I'd buy the same and said she'd rather I didn't. I wasn't aware of this before.

I struggle to understand this mentality as it's not something that would concern me at all the other way around.

Her argument is that she didn't spend all that money, just to have someone close to her have the exact same item.

AIBU to buy it anyway? I was so pleased with the idea of having it and was excited to buy it.

OP posts:
Ragwort · 23/08/2021 08:07

LV must be delighted at all the people now looking at their website to see what this bag is, I've never seen one, but I don't move in the sort of circles where people have designer handbags Grin.

ifonly4 · 23/08/2021 08:05

Will you have other bags, or it for use everyday? If you've got other bags, could you use one of those when you're seeing her?

countrytown · 23/08/2021 08:04

Look at Goyard. Same idea of a canvas tote from a heritage brand but less ubiquitous. I prefer the pattern too.

I had one of these but then they were everywhere & lots of fakes were about too

BanningTheWordNaice · 23/08/2021 08:01

The problem might be solved for you - LV have made the canvas items really difficult to get hold of. Your friends an idiot though to be honest, I’d have more sympathy with her if she’d chosen a less popular LV bag but the neverfull is literally everywhere.

WithLoveFromMyselfToYourself · 23/08/2021 07:59

I think the St Louis is closest to the Neverfull but I prefer the Artois which is a little more structured. It has an internal pocket and a zip fastening on the bag. There are size options.

countrytown · 23/08/2021 07:59

V Neverfull - I had to Google it but I too have seen them everywhere. It will probably turn out like Burberry plaid in the 90s and soon be common as muck.

This happened years ago

Jemand · 23/08/2021 07:59

The problem is going to be that, if you want to keep this friendship, you can't ever take that bag when you go anywhere this friend might be. Doesn't that rather reduce its usefulness?

Jasmine11 · 23/08/2021 07:59

I can kind of see her point if she is a close friend and you spend a lot of time together. You will both look a bit ridiculous rocking up places with the same distinctive LV bag. Could you at least get one of the other patterns than the one she has? Ultimately it's up to you what you buy and they are still fairly popular bags, but from your friends point of view it will look like you are copying her.

RampantIvy · 23/08/2021 07:57

TBH, I don’t understand the mentality of someone who behaves like your friend. It isn’t as if they own the copyright of the bag. If anyone bought something that was the same as mine, I would feel flattered and compliment them on their taste.

Also, a bag is far less noticeable than a dress for example. Not being a “bag person” (I had to google said bag Blush). I doubt that I would notice if two people owned the same bag, and I imagine that this goes for most of the population. I think your friend is making a mountain out of a molehill. People really don’t care, and your friend needs to grow up.

TheVolturi · 23/08/2021 07:57

What are the chances of you both selecting the exact same item at the exact same time!

WithLoveFromMyselfToYourself · 23/08/2021 07:56

Look at Goyard. Same idea of a canvas tote from a heritage brand but less ubiquitous. I prefer the pattern too.

lucyli · 23/08/2021 07:56

Thanks all. I agree. Even if I wanted it, it feels a bit tainted now. I'm going to opt for a Longchamp I think. Granted she has one of those too but I can't make allowances for everything!

OP posts:
Monestera · 23/08/2021 07:56

This is what I'm struggling with. I'm not sure why it upsets her so I'm finding it hard to empathise and therefore understand why I should not buy it.

It is literally the whole point and psychology of consumerism though! Something has a high price not because it costs a lot of money to make, but because people want exclusivity. Your friend paid that amount of money to have something few others did. It's not something that appeals to me, it is superficial, but I understand where she's coming from.

UnicornMadeOfPinkGlitter · 23/08/2021 07:56

Is it the closeness of time that she’s most upset about? She’s just brought it hasn’t had time to show it off yet and you’re buying one? Whereas if she’s had it a couple of years and you then got one she might not be so upset.

I have to say I don’t like mine as much as I thought. The straps dig in if you have a lot in it and the small clasp fastening means it’s not very secure. I’ve had mine fit years and didn’t pay anything like the price they sell for now.

If I was to buy again I would buy the ballerina pink interior or the black leather one.

countrytown · 23/08/2021 07:55

ha just read the update

countrytown · 23/08/2021 07:55

If it's something like a LV tote bag though then fair enough as not exclusive at all.

Crockof · 23/08/2021 07:55

Another one that thought they had never seem one but after a Google realise they are on the arm of every school kid here. A bit like the MK bags a few years ago, I'd just assume it was fake.

But you are NBU if you want to buy it, maybe hers is fake?

DancesWithTortoises · 23/08/2021 07:54

I struggle to understand why anyone would pay that amount of money for an ordinary looking bag.

I don't really get designer anything. SiL says it's because I can afford them so I have a choice whereas for others it's an aspiration and an achievement when they buy them.

I don't think it's that simple. I just don't like throwing money away when there are reasonably priced alternatives.

CeceJoyce · 23/08/2021 07:54

I’m one of those people that hates having the same things as other people BUT I tend to buy pieces that aren’t too popular. I’d say mine is more a copying issue too as In if I have something new and then a friend buys it after seeing mine I feel annoyed, I guess I feel that there are so many items out there to choose from why buy exactly the same as me. However if it’s a very popular bag that lots of people have then your friend can’t really be surprised that someone else she knows wants it. I’d prob want it less if a friend had it though. Is there a very similar one you could get? Like slightly different size, shape, colour?

countrytown · 23/08/2021 07:53

It's a bag. And we can't ensure we don't use it for the same event, but I struggle to understand why it would matter it we did.

It's annoying as you weren't copying but I do think it matters. If a close friend had a bag I wanted though I would probably go off it as if paying a lot for something you want a bit of exclusivity.

junebirthdaygirl · 23/08/2021 07:52

Don't buy it. You will never feel right about it now. The good is gone out of it. Either wait until the novelty has worn off for her and she won't care or buy an equally nice or even nicer one. I understand why she wouldn't like you to have the same one and think it's strange you don't get that.

SavoyCabbage · 23/08/2021 07:52

Just buy it. You want to buy it and so you should. It's only a handbag.

fellrunner85 · 23/08/2021 07:52

Just get something else, OP. Yes, these bags are ubiquitous, which means your friends is daft to be being so precious about it, but by the same token you're also being daft to buy one.
As pps have said, these bags are so common now that anyone carrying one looks like they've got it for 20 quid off Bury Market (a la Burberry in the 90s). If you have that money for a bag, buy something genuinely elegant, classy, and a bit different?

JustJustWhy · 23/08/2021 07:51

Another one here who just doesn't get the appeal of handbags like this. I don't like the colour, I think the design is ugly and I don't like logos on anything (since my teenage years of having "BENETTON" emblazoned across my chest). I like pretty, high street bags in different colours that can be durable but even when not, can be replaced at a fraction of the price.

milcal · 23/08/2021 07:47

Buy it. Your friend should be pleased you both have the same taste. I regularly end up buying the same as my friend even though we never discuss beforehand what we are buying. We just laugh about it afterwards. 😂