Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy the same item as a close friend?

389 replies

lucyli · 23/08/2021 05:53

Firstly I apologise that this is the epitome of a first world problem. I acknowledge I am fortunate to have this problem and that there are many bigger things to worry about.

I have decided to make a high-end purchase from a well-known brand. I've never done this before but am at the stage in my life where I would like to do so.

I spend a long while researching, chose what I wanted and planned to head to the shops in a few days.

Was just chatting to a close friend and it turns out she has the exact same item and is annoyed that I'd buy the same and said she'd rather I didn't. I wasn't aware of this before.

I struggle to understand this mentality as it's not something that would concern me at all the other way around.

Her argument is that she didn't spend all that money, just to have someone close to her have the exact same item.

AIBU to buy it anyway? I was so pleased with the idea of having it and was excited to buy it.

OP posts:
rhowton · 23/08/2021 10:12

I saw my close friends Mulberry and i loved it! It was small enough for a night out but big enough to fit my purse and phone. I then went home, spoke to DH about buying one and then text her to ask her the exact type of her bag. She replied and said "go for it", like a normal person. Now we have the same bag and when we meet up, and have the same bag on, we cheers our matching bags.

AlternativePerspective · 23/08/2021 10:10

Regardless, if you're really her friend, you won't want her to be upset about this. She has asked you not to buy it so don't. FGS, it’s a bag. How petty do you have to be to get upset about someone owning the same bag as you. It’s not unique, the shops are full of them.

I would struggle to stay friends with someone who is quite that petty that she would tell someone she would prefer they didn’t buy a certain item because she has one.

Not as in I would end the friendship, but it would be so irritating that I would probably distance myself from it, because if she’s this petty about a bag, then she’s probably like that over other things as well and I just couldn’t be doing with it.

Friend needs to grow up and get a bloody grip.

Meanwhile I think you should go and buy the bag in every colour. Wink

isthisareverse · 23/08/2021 10:04

There are so many bags to choose from, it is unreasonable to pretend it must the same one as a friend.

Jelly4444 · 23/08/2021 10:03

I have one of those bags OP so you better not copy me 🤣 Seriously though- get it if you want it OP. It's a popular bag.

isthisareverse · 23/08/2021 10:03

I hope you find something else you like.

I sympathise with your friend. You haven't bought the bag yet, so it's not difficult not to get it and go for something else.

There's nothing you can do, but it IS annoying when someone is copying you. A tshirt or a kettle don't matter, but an expensive handbag that you intend to use a lot? It's a bit childish to copy.

Dogoodfeelgood · 23/08/2021 09:55

Some people are funny about this, especially something special like a designer handbag. Can you choose a different colour? I think if she’s asked you not to, whilst it is annoying and I don’t think you’re unreasonable, is it really worth falling out with her over? Just get a different colour/style or brand. If it’s that common why don’t you spend your money on something less common like Celine instead of LV, for instance.

Blufandango · 23/08/2021 09:54

I wouldn't get it. I don't think you friend is reasonable to ask you not to but it sounds like she has already spoiled the experience for you. Instead of feeling pleased with your purchase you'll end up feeling defensive and maybe a bit disappointed, No doubt she'll also feel sad when she thinks about it too, which might bother you, or it might not

WombatChocolate · 23/08/2021 09:51

Just seen this is a popular very branded bag. It is known to be expensive.

In certain circles who are interested in these things, your friend would hope the bag would be spotted and fawned over, with people understanding she has spent a lot of money on it and her feeling this reflects well on her and gives her a certain image. That image is reduced and not so impressive if others in the same circle have it too.

Personally, I think heavily branded stuff is tacky and screams ‘look at me’ and is often bought by those who need to boost their self esteem by something like this, or a new car bought on lease, or designer trainers, or the latest phone, when in the other areas that might show genuine affluence, those people are lacking.

If you’re in a circle if people who are interested in designer gear or expensive branded flashy items, you probably understand feeling annoyed when your push-the-boat-out purchase is replicated by someone else and the thunder is halved or reduced even more.

Someone with an expensive bag that was more subtle and not so bling, and who had it just because they loved it and kept it for 30 years, might not be so bothered, because it’s not then about making a statement….or at least not about an obvious showy one.

WeAreTheWeirdosMister · 23/08/2021 09:48

@CheeseyMcCheeseface

It does have a mark of teenage BBFs if you go to a lot of places together.
This totally, I wouldn't want to look like we had decided on a 'uniform'
WombatChocolate · 23/08/2021 09:42

People often choose an expensive bag or designer item so that others can see it, and they can be a bit unique. The uniqueness is lost if other people have it too.

Of course, most items are owned by lots of people but when there is a limited number, it’s unlikely to be a close friend.

Your friend wants to have an expensive bag that no-one around her has. She wants people to see it and say ‘oh I love your bag, where is it from’ or to recognise it as a designer bag from seeing it in magazines etc. If instead they say ‘like your bag, X has the same one doesn’t she’ then it becomes less special.

Personally I’m not bothered by this stuff or designer bags, but people are and they like to be unique. It’s also seen in the issue of choosing.p names for babies and how some people are very upset if someone else names their child the same name as they chose for theirs.

So Op, given you hadn’t bought the bag and friend expressed this view, I’d avoid buying the same one. If you’d already bought it, would be different, but you hadn’t.

readingismycardio · 23/08/2021 09:42

That's a really common bag to have. Practical and beautiful. This is batshit. If she wants to be SOOOOO unique, she can have custom made bags and that's that. Unless you have form for copying her fashion choices, I wouldn't bat an eyelid

Dacquoise · 23/08/2021 09:39

At least she knows about it before you bought it. I went travelling with someone many years ago who had gone out and bought exactly the same clothes that I had shown her when I bought them. Ended up having to check what she was wearing before l got dressed in the morning otherwise we'd have looked like clones. Creepy and weird!

mafted · 23/08/2021 09:37

@peanutbear

I have one. Very practical still going strong after 10 years of daily use. I bought mine purely because it fits everything I need in one bag and I'm not a handbag fan. I don't think a friend can dictate your choice in bag. have you chosen the same design and colour? If not just buy it.
Come on, you must be a bit of a handbag fan to spend that amount of money on one. Otherwise an Ikea bag would fit your brief, I've got one that's twenty years old and as good as new!
BakeOffRewatch · 23/08/2021 09:34

[quote SavoyCabbage]I have a bag made from old firehoses, I have not had it long so I can't speak for how durable it will be, but it's survived being dragged about as firehose for many years before being turned into a bag so I'm guessing it will be good. It's a fraction of the cost of your bag, looks great, has a bit of individuality about it, and is big enough to fit everything I want and need to carry (and more). I definitely recommend it so far. I opted for one that still has printing on it as I felt it added a bit of character, and I love it. It's from a company called Elvis and Kresse and they donate 50% of their profit back into charities for firefighters. They have a great range so well worth a look.

These are lovely @SnoopyLights and not at all what I expected when I looked.

Here is a link

www.elvisandkresse.com/collections/womens-bags[/quote]
Wow these are nice! Thank you for the link, I also would not have looked it up based on the description. Reasonable prices too.

OP not designer, but from a practicality point of view, I’ve got Reiss large leather totes to carry everything.

blueberrywaffle · 23/08/2021 09:29

Op I had one of these (until my DD accidentally ruined it)
Was a brilliant bag, went with most outfits and fitted absolutely everything in, my oh always joked I could fit a body in their ! 🤣
Go get it. Their a common bag to have!
Il be getting a new one for Christmas, so don't copy me 🙄

LittleMysSister · 23/08/2021 09:25

[quote NalPolishRemover]@MrsHedgehog it's ok the first couple of times but it does wear v v thin I find.
The person I know has bought so many things the same as me - including bags from a small hard to find maker, perfume that's difficult to source where we live (so not tripping over in boots for instance) to entire colour schemes in their house inc a 3 piece suite. Buying art from the same artist (despite not knowing their work before coming across it through me!)
Then if anyone compliments/ notices she acts like she's discovered it all.
I've actually distanced myself a fair bit as it was getting pretty irritating tbh[/quote]
I agree, had a friend like this at college and she would buy the exact same items as me so we'd often end up showing up for the day in the same clothes, which made us both look like idiots.

Naturally people like things that others buy and might go out and get them from time-to-time, but when it's almost every new thing your purchase it can be very frustrating.

Not saying this is OP btw!

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 23/08/2021 09:23

@WiggIyWoo

Most women I know own at least a few of the well known classic designer handbags

Absolutely fascinated by this! I'm mid 30s with lots of doctor, accountant, engineer type friends and I don't believe I know a single person with a designer bag, let alone multiple. What kind of age are you and are you in London, if you don't mind me asking?

Same here - designer handbags aren't really a thing amongst my friends (most of whom are 30s/40s, child-free and earn well).

I do like the look of the Elvis and Kresse bags though - glad to hear they seem hard-wearing in the flesh, as I've contemplated getting one.

NalPolishRemover · 23/08/2021 09:20

@MrsHedgehog it's ok the first couple of times but it does wear v v thin I find.
The person I know has bought so many things the same as me - including bags from a small hard to find maker, perfume that's difficult to source where we live (so not tripping over in boots for instance) to entire colour schemes in their house inc a 3 piece suite. Buying art from the same artist (despite not knowing their work before coming across it through me!)
Then if anyone compliments/ notices she acts like she's discovered it all.
I've actually distanced myself a fair bit as it was getting pretty irritating tbh

LittleMysSister · 23/08/2021 09:20

I think you're friend is being a little harsh BUT also I'd rather buy a bag I can use all the time without having to think about whether she'll be there too. So this would have ruined it for me anyway and I'd choose another.

impostersong · 23/08/2021 09:18

If I were spending that much on a bag (and I wouldn't) I would absolutely want it to be unique. Having the same as someone else is not special and I can totally see why she'd be annoyed. Much prefer that Gucci bag - go for that one, problem solved!!

RealBecca · 23/08/2021 09:17

The reason she is upset is she has spent £2k on a LOOK AT ME item and hopes people will make a bit of a fuss over her. You having the exact same, poss at same events, takes away from that.

SunshineCake · 23/08/2021 09:15

Does she want to be special for being able to afford one and now she isn't as you have one too? Are you not as good as her in her mind Shock?

MsHedgehog · 23/08/2021 09:13

@NalPolishRemover

I'm on your friends side I think. I've a friend who buys the same things as me & then feigns innocence that she never knew I had it first & pretends to everyone that she 'discovered' it. This applies to everything from bags to house decor. It wears v v thin after a while

Those bags are really not my thing at all, I hate overtly branded stuff.

I think you should keep researching OP & get something more individual that still suits your requirements.

With you on this. I have a close friend who does the same thing too. Not so much on house decor as she doesn’t have her own home yet, but she does it on bags, jewellery and even clothes, even though she used to have a very different sense of style to me. I love her to bits so I put it aside, but every now and then I do make a comment along the lines of “oh just like mine”, because it really bugs me!
copernicium · 23/08/2021 09:09

I had a close friend who was absolutely raging with me when I brought a new car. Apparently, that's the car she always wanted and was going to buy when she passed her test and I ruined it Hmm

Rannva · 23/08/2021 09:08

It's a tacky bag. Your tacky friend wants to show off with it. Let her by buying something more tasteful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread