Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say my sister is the biggest f****** hypocrite

87 replies

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 00:06

Through covid I have followed the rules as best I can, stayed at home unless going to work/food shopping, isolated if I'd come into contact with someone who tested positive etc... I've always had a funny relationship with my sister and we seem to clash quite often. I've always felt that she thinks she's better than everyone else, entitled to do whatever she wants - 1 rule for her and 1 for everyone else...

Anyway, a couple of months ago she went to a party with a few friends and the party was hosted by an old friend of hers. They were there for a couple of hours I think, had food and drinks then went out to the pub down the road. Next morning old friend messaged everyone to say that she had tested positive for covid and would be forwarding everyone's details to track and trace. Everyone asked her not to, as some people couldn't afford to take the time off work to isolate (I'm not saying it's right btw but I do understand). The friend did as everyone asked. A day or so later my sister messaged me to say that she was on the beach with two of her friends who had also been to the party (when it was really busy as all the holiday makers were visiting at the time) and asked if I wanted to join them. I had plans so didn't go. At the time I did think it was quite selfish of them as unlike work reasons, a beach visit wasn't necessary but I kept my thoughts to myself. I'm not the covid police after all and it would only cause arguments if I voiced my opinion.

Fast forward to last Friday when I visited my friend. I didn't tell her I was going as I was just passing through and decided to knock on and see if she was home. She explained that she hadn't been feeling very well the last few days and it was probably best that I didn't come in, although she was confident that it was just a stomach bug. I was desperate for the loo (thank you McDonald's tea) so asked if I could just pop in quickly to use the loo. We didn't touch, hug, anything and I left after using the toilet. I was in there 5 mins max. Told her I would pop in when she was feeling better. Anyway, friend messaged me on Saturday morning to say she had tested positive. I've decided not to take a test or isolate (unless I start to feel ill of course) as I think it would be quite extreme given that I was only in there for 5 minutes and we didn't actually come into close contact.

I told my sister earlier about my friend being unwell. She decided to give me a huge lecture about how I should be taking a test and isolating for the next 10 days. It is really irresponsible for me not to do so Confused I honestly think she's forgotten about what she did two months ago. As the peace maker I try to hold my tongue as much as I can, more so because I just cba with the argument or hassle. I think she thrives on the drama between us sometimes. But please tell me I'm not wrong here and the two situations above are completely different??

OP posts:
ThumbWitchesAbroad · 23/08/2021 03:39

If I were you, I'd get tested anyway for peace of mind. I would also stay at home until I got the result.

Your sister is a hypocritical arse, yes - but if you don't get tested, then you lose any moral highground yourself, despite the disparity in circumstances and the fact that you are vaccinated.

The vaccine doesn't give you absolute protection and it doesn't stop you spreading covid if you have picked it up.

Wideawake2345 · 23/08/2021 02:24

@chickenandbacon I think you’ll feel much better if you test tomorrow and again in 7 days time - you are doubled jabbed, and are willing to self isolate, so you obviously care about Covid and are not a crazy anti vaxxer or something like that! So you’ll be able to sleep at night and take the moral high ground that you have done the right thing (easier said than done sometimes when you have a d*ickheaf of a sibling/SIL getting on their soapbox about something - speaking from personal experience here! Smile

You’re just pssed off with your sister Grin so go on, tell us some juicy knbbish things she’s done to keep us entertained at this god forsaken hour haha

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 02:18

Anyway, off to bed! I'm bloody shattered and up early in the morning. I will see if I can order a test tomorrow (when I'm half awake). Thanks for all the messages, goodnight 💤

OP posts:
Wideawake2345 · 23/08/2021 02:18

@OswaldOwl completely agree with your second paragraph, but not necessarily the third - in her defence, OP has said she is going to self isolate anyway, so is already inconveniencing herself up to a point, but I complete agree I have no idea why she won’t take a test! Other than her sister (who she doesn’t get along with) told her to, so is using this as a small act of defiance when really she should be telling us why her sister can be an idiot on all things non-Covid related so we can sympathise and give her the vindication that she clearly needs, but is looking for in the wrong place/on the wrong topic

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 02:17

@Wideawake2345 I hear you and I didn't think you were being sarcastic (Smile). I can take a test tomorrow but in all fairness, positive results don't always show straight away either. I've known people take tests every single day for 7 days after contact and not test positive until the last day...

@OswaldOwl I've already said I would be isolating anyway even if I didn't take a test. I work from home so it's not difficult for me!

OP posts:
OswaldOwl · 23/08/2021 02:11

The unreasonable part is your unwillingness to take a test.

If you’re so confident you’ll be okay, where’s the harm in getting a test to confirm that?
You will surely be putting you mind at rest that you are definitely not an asymptomatic spreader?

Could it possibly be that you don’t want to test because you don’t want to risk being told you’re positive, and therefore have to isolate? You’d much rather continue in ignorance, assume you don’t have it, potentially putting others at risk because you don’t want to inconvenience yourself?

Just a hypothesis.

HopefulRose · 23/08/2021 02:08

@chickenandbacon your sister sounds pretty selfish, maybe she gets off on winding you up as that’s clearly what she’s done here!

In future, my advice would be keep your business to yourself and don’t tell her anything you aren’t prepared to have her opinion on. Not everyone is as diplomatic as you are in keeping their thoughts to themselves.

Wideawake2345 · 23/08/2021 02:03

@chickenandbacon I just don’t understand your logic lol

Surely if you’re so convinced you’re not going to have contracted it, there’s no need to isolate and/or test, but you’re doing some strange halfway house by isolating, but not taking a test to be sure? Like I said, plenty of people can catch and spread Covid without being symptomatic.

The real issue is that you don’t get on with your sister and you’re just annoyed that she lectured you - you are absolutely entitled to feel this way if your relationship is strained at times, perhaps you would feel better if the the thread focused on this aspect so that you could feel vindicated in some way?

I think you’re probably fighting a losing battle going down the AIBU about Covid route. Pick something else to tell us about that your sister has been a kn*b about and then everyone can have a good moan with you, and you’ll feel better I’m sure Smile (not being sarcastic here in case it doesn’t translate over written message!)

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:53

@Kintsugi16 to be fair, I didn't either. They've changed so much it's hard to keep up sometimes.

OP posts:
chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:51

@RoseRedRoseBlue I didn't know at the time but posters have now clarified...

OP posts:
Kintsugi16 · 23/08/2021 01:51

I’m amazed how many don’t know the current rules tbh

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:50

@Wideawake2345 I've already said a few times that I will be isolating anyway, just not taking a test. If I'm isolating what does it matter if I don't take one?

Btw - I did not see my sister today. We spoke on the phone... I should have made that clear in my op. Sorry

OP posts:
RoseRedRoseBlue · 23/08/2021 01:50

[quote chickenandbacon]@RoseRedRoseBlue again, as others have explained, the rules have now changed. I don't need to test or isolate unless I start to feel unwell, so no, I'm obviously not being unreasonable. [/quote]
Then WHY are you posting in AIBU?

Kintsugi16 · 23/08/2021 01:49

You don’t need to SI as double vaccinated but should take a LFT if leaving the house

Your sister broke the rules as they only changed a week ago but there’s no point in falling out with her about this now. Just explain the current rules to her

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:47

@RoseRedRoseBlue again, as others have explained, the rules have now changed. I don't need to test or isolate unless I start to feel unwell, so no, I'm obviously not being unreasonable.

OP posts:
chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:46

@mathanxiety you have clearly not read my post properly at all. I had 1 cup of tea. not 10. You do realise that it's really unhealthy to hold in urine, don't you? Anyway, I know my own body, better than someone on mumsnet I'm sure, and I know that I wouldn't have been able to hold it in for another 15 minutes.

OP posts:
Wideawake2345 · 23/08/2021 01:45

Is everyone just going to ignore the fact that some people can have/spread Covid without having any symptoms…the adverts on the radio make it quite clear that there are a good number of people to whom this applies. Could be both you and your sister - yes she might be being a hypocrite, but in the grand scheme of things both of you could be unwittingly transmitting Covid.

If you’re going to work from home anyway, I can’t see what the big deal is about doing a test? Yes the rules might have been different at the time your sister was potentially exposed, but the government have to set these arbitrary rules, so surely even if the rules are different now, you use a bit of common sense even if not strictly legally necessary to isolate and take a test.

Seems to me it’s mainly because your sister gave you a lecture about it which IMO isn’t really a good enough reason…

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:42

In what way did I press her @mathanxiety? I didn't barge my way in and force her to drink tea with me. I desperately needed the loo and asked first if I could use it quickly which she said yes to. I was 15 minutes away from home and any supermarkets or somewhere that I could use a toilet. I'm not sure what else I could have done? I left straight after using the toilet.

Yes, I do believe that I will be ok, as we had no close contact and I feel fine, but I'm also not choosing to go to a beach and socialise with other people. We're not cut from the same cloth at all IMO.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 23/08/2021 01:39

What should I have done, wee'd on the car floor?

You're not a recently potty trained three year old.
Don't drink so much when you're out.
Hold in your pee.

RoseRedRoseBlue · 23/08/2021 01:38

@chickenandbacon

I'm not irritated *@RoseRedRoseBlue*. You didn't explain why I was unreasonable though did you? just made a silly comment about me using her loo. I asked you, what would you have suggested I do?
OP, it’s quite clear you are being unreasonable, as pointed out over and over on this thread. I don’t need to explain why.
mathanxiety · 23/08/2021 01:37

1 - You should take a test, and

2 - the two situations are different.
Your sister socialised while unaware that someone may have had covid, whereas you knew your friend was not feeling well but pressed her to let you in anyway.

3 - I'm pretty confident I will be ok though.
You and your sister are cut from the same cloth. This is the reasoning that led your sister to hit the beach.

chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:37

I thought so too @EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall

OP posts:
chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:28

I honestly don't think we do though @Saoirse82 . I'm staying at home and the rules have now changed anyway. I don't need to take a test or isolate unless I start to feel ill but I will be staying in (work from home) anyway just incase. My sister willingly went to a beach after her friend had tested positive and at the time the rules were different. She should have isolated.

OP posts:
chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:25

I'm not irritated @RoseRedRoseBlue. You didn't explain why I was unreasonable though did you? just made a silly comment about me using her loo. I asked you, what would you have suggested I do?

OP posts:
chickenandbacon · 23/08/2021 01:23

Thank you @Winter2020 . I will be staying in as unfortunately I have to work. I feel fine at the moment but understand that could change. I'm pretty confident I will be ok though. I'm sure you're right that it's probably best not to talk about these sorts of things (especially Covid!) with other people. Everyone has an opinion...

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread