Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think giving up sugar is really hard? If you’ve done it, what do you eat?

111 replies

Hallomother · 22/08/2021 19:10

I really want to do this as I get bad migraines and think sugar is a trigger. I never used to eat much aside from natural sugar but during lockdown went a bit mad and now feel so
Lethargic and sluggish.. but I seem to crave it!!

What kind of thing do you eat if you don’t eat sugar? I want to put a bit of a plan together

OP posts:
EssexLioness · 23/08/2021 09:31

Used to be a complete sugar addict but cut out sugary food, refined carbs and all processed foods a while ago due to the triggering my IBS. I would get agonising stomach pains.
I am vegan also so base meals round whole grains, vegetables and proteins such as tofu. I eat very little fruit and for snacks I have plain soya yoghurt. It is amazing how much better you feel soon after quitting, I never got any cravings and now plain yoghurt is sweet to me whereas I wouldn’t even consider it a sweet treat before. I also feel less hungry and don’t really get cravings for anything any more

thelegohooverer · 23/08/2021 09:17

If you can stop for a moment before reaching for the sugary treat and just sort of check in with yourself, sometimes it’s about responding to a need that you can meet in another way. You can indulge yourself with a lovely cup of tea, a snuggly throw and a good book. Feeding the other senses so to speak.

beastlyslumber · 23/08/2021 09:17

You might find a sugar substitute you like - ethryritol (spelling?) and stevia are both really popular sugar-free sweeteners. Personally I find them all a bit unpleasant, but many people love them because they give a sweet taste so are perfect for baking or sweetening drinks without breaking your sugar-free plans.

Neron · 23/08/2021 09:03

I change little things at a time. Example, I moved to 85% dark chocolate. I still felt like I was eating something naughty - but it's so bitter and low in sugar that I definitely don't want to eat more than a square. Also, if it's all I have, then I'm now happy to leave it.

I also cut down gradually. So tried going every other day without sugar, or from 2 sugars to 1.5 then 1 then none etc. If I wanted to sustain it, then I needed to be sensible about it.

dangermouseisace · 23/08/2021 08:52

I’ve kind of stopped having sugar by accident! I was cutting down, but now find it too sweet. I replaced sweet stuff with natural unsweetened yoghurt (soya for me) and fruit. When I have porridge it is sweetened with grated apple and cinnamon. Things like sweet potato are really sweet too.

I have the occasional bit of cake etc if it’s my kids birthday to be sociable, but that’s about it. And a bar of 70% to be gradually.

DaisyDozyDee · 23/08/2021 07:14

I’ve got past my sugar cravings by accepting that ultimately it makes me feel rubbish, so it no longer feels like a treat.
The question you’re asking yourself needs to change from ‘Do I deserve a sweet treat today?’ to ‘Do I deserve a migraine today?’.
No one deserves a migraine, so look for other ways to treat yourself (either food or non-food) that actually make you feel better.

Bluntness100 · 23/08/2021 07:00

@Bobholll

Life’s too short to give up chocolate quite frankly. 😂 Self control, moderation & exercise is key. I eat chocolate daily but it’s a small bar after tea. A penguin, a gold bar, a small wispa from a 4x pack. I don’t need anything more than that but it’s a nice treat. I also eat yoghurt, fruit, toast & jam & I love a Diet Coke.

I exercise 4x a week. & drink a shed loada water. I rarely drink & home cook 90% of my meals. That absolutely stops me feeling sluggish in anyway. Sugar can be a perfectly OK part of a diet so long as you don’t go mad everyday!

That’s nice, but this thread is about triggers for migraines.
Bobholll · 22/08/2021 22:24

Life’s too short to give up chocolate quite frankly. 😂 Self control, moderation & exercise is key. I eat chocolate daily but it’s a small bar after tea. A penguin, a gold bar, a small wispa from a 4x pack. I don’t need anything more than that but it’s a nice treat. I also eat yoghurt, fruit, toast & jam & I love a Diet Coke.

I exercise 4x a week. & drink a shed loada water. I rarely drink & home cook 90% of my meals. That absolutely stops me feeling sluggish in anyway. Sugar can be a perfectly OK part of a diet so long as you don’t go mad everyday!

thelegohooverer · 22/08/2021 22:15

I never got completely sugar free (I got scuppered by Christmas) but I started by giving up chocolate, then obviously sugary things, and as my tastebuds readjusted I just started disliking savoury food with sugar in it, and eating more veg, nuts, cheese and cold meats.

I was still eating fruit, and sweet veg, so not as extreme as some, but I couldn’t get over how sweet berries were! Now that I’m stuck in a sugar rut again, they barely register.

I’d really like to try again but I find it so difficult at Christmas when people are being generous and hospitable and it feels anti social to refuse treats.

Hallomother · 22/08/2021 21:44

Ooh I didn’t think about sourdough

OP posts:
Gardenfish · 22/08/2021 21:36

Best mayonnaise is Hellmanns
Bread has a load of added sugar, try sourdough, makes the best toast.
Cereals- oats, oatbix, shredded wheat, wheatbix

FlorallyBankrupt · 22/08/2021 21:33

I'm so glad you posted this, thank you. I am also mainlining chocolate and sugar, I've gotten fatter and fatter but I've tried and failed to lose so many times I've all but given up.

So, if I was going to give up refined sugar and keep an eye on carbs, are porridge oats with a bit of peanut butter acceptable?

nancybotwinbloom · 22/08/2021 21:33

I'm on Atkins or heavanly chocolate if I want a treat. Both nice.

beastlyslumber · 22/08/2021 21:30

I don't eat any sugar or carbs. I have fruit but very rarely, as a treat. I eat fish, meat, avocadoes, kimchi, courgettes, onions and garlic and occasional other veg (no root veg). At the moment I have dairy also, but I feel better when I don't have it and plan to cut that out again soon. It's basically a 'ketovore' diet. It's hard at first but after a while it just becomes normal.

For a treat I will make something like 'fat bombs' with coconut butter, almond butter and 100% dark chocolate. Or I will have some berries or melon. But fruit contains a lot of sugar and I find if I start eating too fruit much I'll get sugar cravings, so I tend to avoid it.

It's quite extreme as diets go but I'm never hungry, have lost loads of weight (6 stone) have loads of energy and have helped improve a serious health condition, so well worth it for me.

BadgeronaMoped · 22/08/2021 21:28

When I first started, I took it back to basics and thought of a plain post-war sort of diet. Not rations, just thinking of the type of food people would eat. Protein, complex carbohydrates, vegetables and fats. That really helped me.

BadgeronaMoped · 22/08/2021 21:27

I like Lizi's granola with full fat Greek yoghurt. I just switched to full fat everything, I love the supermarket baked in store seed/multigrain loaves/sourdough, two doorstop slices with butter for breakfast. It's been a revelation, I'm not hungry all the time and my excess weight gradually disappeared without me having to do any exercise (I'm quite lazy). I don't really eat much fruit, I have the odd kiwi or apple.
DH says I live on carbs. I do love toast...

foxy86 · 22/08/2021 21:27

Someone I work with have up meat because of migraines and is now vegetarian. She said it has rapidly reduced her migraines.
Regarding sugar it’s only as I am getting older that I am finding it harder to keep it out of my diet. I can go a couple of week without it and then BAM just eaten a full big sharer bar of chocolate. I have decided I need to go completely cold turkey on the stuff. It’s at work I find hard to not eat. Deciding to add extra cheese to my salad to fill me up more in hopes I don’t crave anything sweet.

Gardenfish · 22/08/2021 21:26

My husband actually can't eat any sugar, both sucrose and fructose. He’s ok with glucose. He just doesn’t have the ensigns to process any sugar.

Because of this, I base meals around: meat, dairy, most greens, white vegetables (not parsnips) and complex carbs. Chicken with creamed spinach and wholemeal basmati rice.

The hardest thing I find/notice is how much sugar is put into things, that normally you would not add sugar to - mayonnaise, pre-made carbonara, pulled pork, even veggies. So it makes ready-meals out of the question. Food out is generally steak and french fries.

If you want to stop sugar, cook from scratch.

Low fat and low salt general means added sugar. Fats ok (everything in moderation)

Happy to give more meal ideas.

Saying that my daughter and I both love lasagna, ragu and pudding.

OnTheBrink1 · 22/08/2021 21:18

It’s really hard. But once you are in the swing and been doing it for a couple of weeks, the cravings do reduce a lot.
Almond butter with oat cakes, cashew nuts, plain Greek youghurt with berries, very good quality dark chocolate (must have a very high cocoa content for it to be low sugar)
An apple. The occasional small banana with no sugar almond or peanut butter on, handful of almond. The occasional date if I really feel a craving but they are high in natural sugars so only occasionally

Hallomother · 22/08/2021 21:17

This is all really useful thank you. Yes I mean refined sugars and carbs.
My eating habits are terrible at the moment, lots of takeaways and convenience foods and I’m really feeling it.

OP posts:
myhumps123 · 22/08/2021 21:11

I could do with some tips too. Eating chocolate makes me happy but now that I am approaching 40 and I can see my waist line is getting bigger I really need to boot this habit to the curb.

TheSockMonster · 22/08/2021 21:09

Do you mean refined sugars and processed foods? I have a very low consumption of those foods for the same reason as you - migraines.

I generally only eat fruit, veg, meat, pulses, oats, rice and seafood. I don’t eat any bread, pasty or bakery type foods aside from the very rare treat. Mentally I find it just easier to limit myself to no processed foods and concentrate on getting variety within those categories.

I snack on raspberries, strawberries, carrots and apples. I shop every few days to make sure I always have some in the fridge.

Porridge oats and unsweetened almond milk for breakfast (or regular milk would work, I just don’t like the taste of milk!), or an apple if I’m in a rush.

Cold new potatoes are great for lunch and salads. Tinned tuna, frozen prawns (I buy the cheap ones and defrost in warm water, not sure if you’re supposed to do this), avocados, and those frozen baked potatoes you cook for 4 minutes in the microwave are all quick lunch ideas.

If I cook chicken or salmon for dinner I make extra to have for lunch the next day.

The cravings go within a week. I still get migraines around my period, but I only get about 1 in the second half of my cycle now.

FrangipanFlower · 22/08/2021 21:00

I have gestational diabetes and have to follow a strict no sugar/low carb diet. Breakfast is usually Greek yoghurt with berries and nuts/seeds, or eggs with a small piece of low carb whole meal bread, lunch is usually a salad with protein, dinner fish and veg or some sort of curry/stir fry with a small amount of rice or new potatoes. Lots of nuts, cheese, olives, hummus, sugar free jelly as snacks. It’s a very healthy way to eat, I’m 29 weeks pregnant and have only put on just under 3kgs so far. But it is boring, eating out is difficult, no take aways etc

Hallomother · 22/08/2021 20:55

@Morningstar66 I think carbs might be. I used to low carb before DS and had hardly any migraines but I find it SO hard to low carb with a toddler because I’m always grabbing a quick slice of toast or some cereal etc

OP posts:
Strokethefurrywall · 22/08/2021 20:45

When I quit sugar, I don’t crave it at all so I never feel like I missing out.

So many people said to me “but don’t you miss x?” and my point was always “why would I miss something I don’t crave? I never feel like I’m deny myself so once you’ve killed your sugar demon you won’t have the cravings and it’s much easier.

Swipe left for the next trending thread