Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think giving up sugar is really hard? If you’ve done it, what do you eat?

111 replies

Hallomother · 22/08/2021 19:10

I really want to do this as I get bad migraines and think sugar is a trigger. I never used to eat much aside from natural sugar but during lockdown went a bit mad and now feel so
Lethargic and sluggish.. but I seem to crave it!!

What kind of thing do you eat if you don’t eat sugar? I want to put a bit of a plan together

OP posts:
wetpants · 24/08/2021 22:07

As I said earlier, modern fruit, especially tropical fruit, is now cultivated to be very sweet as that is what makes people to buy them.

The sugar in fruit is fructose and once consumed, it turns into glucose which will make your blood sugar to sky rocket and in turn your body to pump a tonne of insulin. If you are overweight/obese or otherwise insulin resistant, this is detrimental on your health. The benefit of fibre and vitamins that come from a fruit is neglible compared to the damage the fructose will do.
You can have vitamins and fibre from many other sources than just fruits.

To OP and PP, maybe cut fruit and other sources of sugar for a couple of weeks and see if it makes a difference. Don’t focus on the thought that these can’t be consumed for ever.

Bryonyshcmyony · 24/08/2021 22:05

Another bootcamper here. I haven't eaten sugar for months. If I feel really like I want something I have plain full fat Greek yogurt and strawberries
Or a spoonful of peanut butter

Bookaholic73 · 24/08/2021 22:02

@phishy

For me all or nothing works. I can’t self-regulate, if there are biscuits, or a share bag of Maltesers etc in the house I will eat the whole pack in one sitting.

However if I know I’m not allowed ANY then it’s easier to put it out of my head.

I’m exactly the same. If it’s in the house, I cannot think about anything else. It’s easier for me mentally, to go cold turkey, even if it does make me feel horrific for the first week.
Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 24/08/2021 21:47

Full fat Greek yoghurt, just a small amount as it's really filling, with about 6 raspberries and 6 cashew nuts. Good amount of protein and keeps you full for longer.

Monestera · 24/08/2021 21:45

Not sure science agrees with you - fruit sugar has exactly the same effect on your body as any other sugar. Especially if you aren’t eating it on an empty stomach.

But fruit comes with additional benefits that chocolate doesn’t, and it doesn’t come with the additional disadvantages of an UPF.

phishy · 24/08/2021 17:12

For me all or nothing works. I can’t self-regulate, if there are biscuits, or a share bag of Maltesers etc in the house I will eat the whole pack in one sitting.

However if I know I’m not allowed ANY then it’s easier to put it out of my head.

yahyahs22 · 24/08/2021 16:43

I feel hugely better for it regardless. Heaps more energy and weight has fallen off me

Hallomother · 24/08/2021 16:38

Okay well I’ve managed day two thus far. And it’s not been too tricky actually. I haven’t eliminated entirely but I have drastically cut down.

Things will go a bit wobbly for the next three days as we have guests and are doing afternoon tea etc but I’m going to see if I can still reduce what I have compared to what I would normally. I shall report back

OP posts:
NavigatingAdolescence · 24/08/2021 15:28

@Comtesse

Yes but fruit does at least have fibre and vitamins etc so it’s hardly the same as eating a bag of Haribo!
Not as much as veg does.
Comtesse · 24/08/2021 14:32

Yes but fruit does at least have fibre and vitamins etc so it’s hardly the same as eating a bag of Haribo!

JammyDozen · 23/08/2021 23:24

I’d like to cut down on refined sugar rather than give it up. No migraines here and I genuinely enjoy it, not just crave it, but I’m worried that if I go on the way I am (lots of chocolate every day is the main problem) the choice will be taken out of my hands in the form of diabetes.

Anyone here had any success in cutting down rather than eliminating it entirely?

VyrnwyGirl · 23/08/2021 23:23

I don't know @Hallomother as I have never tried giving up sugar. Hats off to those who have, because I couldn't do it. Wouldn't even try actually.

NavigatingAdolescence · 23/08/2021 23:12

@yahyahs22

Its insanely addictive, that's why. I replaced it for the real stuff, fruit. Best thing you can do for your body
Not sure science agrees with you - fruit sugar has exactly the same effect on your body as any other sugar. Especially if you aren’t eating it on an empty stomach.
yahyahs22 · 23/08/2021 22:26

Its insanely addictive, that's why. I replaced it for the real stuff, fruit. Best thing you can do for your body

NavigatingAdolescence · 23/08/2021 21:24

@wetpants

Well done *@Hallomother*! Make sure to meal plan for the week ahead. If you are just going to wing it, it’s not going to work out.

It took me months to be ready to ditch my afternoon coffee. I finally did it few weeks ago and in the end wasn’t that big deal. I cut it out as the older I get, caffeine is really starting to affect my sleep. I saw a Dr Chatterjee clip which said caffeine circulates 12 hours in your body, so if you have a cup at 1pm, caffeine is still in your body when you go to bed. It gave me the push to do it.

I love cacao nibs too but bear in mind they are a stimulant and can impact your sleep if you eat them late in the day (and if you are senitive to stimulants that is).

Chocolate for breakfast or not at all. :)
NavigatingAdolescence · 23/08/2021 21:23

[quote wetpants]@NavigatingAdolescence FWIW I eat a very similar way except for I have one coffee with cream in the morning. It is very enjoyable way to eat once you have got over the sugar withdrewal phase. I’m 10 months in and find it very sustainable. A block of quality cheddar is a treat now, not a crappy Penguin bar.[/quote]
I never thought I could give up coffee or dairy (would have 2 double shot coffees with double cream previously and something cheesy for lunch) but it’s been easier than expected and I feel so well I don’t want to have those things very often anymore.

TheSockMonster · 23/08/2021 21:10

I’m not overweight (BMI of 19 point something and smallish waist) but I am very prone to migraines and I suspect insulin resistance might be playing a part in it.

wetpants · 23/08/2021 21:00

@TheSockMonster Are you very overweight? And/or do you have a lot of abdominal fat?
If yes, eliminate tropical fruits, at least for a while.

Or have maybe a quarter of the said mango but freeze the rest.

TheSockMonster · 23/08/2021 20:54

I finding this thread fascinating, so won’t derail with a new one quite yet.

For dinner I had salmon which I cooked in tinfoil with some onions and tomatoes, with mashed potatoes (plenty of butter), broccoli and carrots (more butter and some garlic on those).

I have some mango in the fridge that I was going to eat tomorrow, but I am now wondering if I should after reading everything above. I don’t get sugar cravings after eating it (like I would if I ate sweets). Google results are contradictory!

wetpants · 23/08/2021 20:37

Good luck 👏🏻👏🏻

Hallomother · 23/08/2021 20:32

Thank you! I’ve planned as far as Wednesday then we have guests which is going to be tricky but I’m hoping I can exercise a little more will power than usual!

I’ve made a plan for the following week as well. I’ve made it easy for myself this week - cooked chicken from tesco etc, so I couldn’t tel myself I didn’t have time to cook and grab a pastry instead.

Good point about the cacao nibs! I’m switching to decaf coffee slowly and going from there

OP posts:
wetpants · 23/08/2021 20:30

Well done @Hallomother! Make sure to meal plan for the week ahead. If you are just going to wing it, it’s not going to work out.

It took me months to be ready to ditch my afternoon coffee. I finally did it few weeks ago and in the end wasn’t that big deal. I cut it out as the older I get, caffeine is really starting to affect my sleep. I saw a Dr Chatterjee clip which said caffeine circulates 12 hours in your body, so if you have a cup at 1pm, caffeine is still in your body when you go to bed. It gave me the push to do it.

I love cacao nibs too but bear in mind they are a stimulant and can impact your sleep if you eat them late in the day (and if you are senitive to stimulants that is).

Hallomother · 23/08/2021 20:12

I’m still going to have fruit and dairy etc I’m not going to cut down on everything as I know it won’t be sustainable for me.

I’m making small steps. So today I’ve had:

Roast chicken salad with rice, olives and cubes of cheese

Lamb with bulgar wheat and courgette ribbons in a tomato sauce with garlic and dill

Had the craving for something sweet about an hour ago so had full fat Greek yogurt, berries and some crushed walnuts and cacao nibs which seemed to satiate the craving

It’s only been one day and I’ve still had two coffees (no sugar though) but had loads of water and I have to say I do feel slightly less brain foggy

OP posts:
wetpants · 23/08/2021 19:50

@NavigatingAdolescence FWIW I eat a very similar way except for I have one coffee with cream in the morning. It is very enjoyable way to eat once you have got over the sugar withdrewal phase. I’m 10 months in and find it very sustainable. A block of quality cheddar is a treat now, not a crappy Penguin bar.

wetpants · 23/08/2021 19:47

@Firstwelive

No fruit or root vegetables - because they are high in carbs which your body turns into glucose once consumed. This causes insulin spike which eventually turns into a fat around your liver. If you are metabolicly healthy, then these don’t tend to be a problem but if you are insulin resistant or have T2 diabetes, you are best to eliminate these.

Many people can’t have these in moderation at all. Apples, pears and berries are better but tropical fruits are very high in sugar and have been cultivated to be extremely sweet in order to sell more.

Swipe left for the next trending thread