Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it too soon to have this conversation?

92 replies

minkymilk · 22/08/2021 15:46

I met my boyfriend in March, officially 'together' since April, so the relationship is still very new. We have seen each other a lot, in fact it is most days since we met, so around 5 days a week unless we have other plans, we also keep in regular contact throughout the day. It's all been a bit of a whirlwind if I'm honest, I'm used to seeing new boyfriends 1-2 times a week. We've also been on a holiday for a week together and several nights away. We've not argued, fallen out, got bored of each other and I've not had any red flags with him.

The thing is, we've yet to have 'the kids' chat properly. He's got 2 DC from a previous relationship and I've got 1 DC. We've sort of skirted around the issue and he's been quite vague. Whilst I appreciate we'd have 3 DC between us, I've always wanted another biological child. I want my DC to have a biological sibling, and I want to experience pregnancy, birth, raising a child, being a mum in a solid relationship with someone I love, which I haven't experienced with DC1.

Things are starting to get more serious and we are being invited to events as a couple, we've met one another's family and friends. He's planning things for us to do months in advance... the thing is, I'm not sure whether this relationship has a future or not because I definitely want another DC. I've thought about whether I could be happy with just one DC, but I am only 27 and want the opportunity of more kids.

When we were at a family event recently, his mum commented that she wanted more grandchildren, but 'not from him as he already had enough.' He didn't really say anything back but I took note of what she had said. I'm not sure if it's too soon to bring up the conversation, but at the same time I can feel myself holding back from committing to him properly. Is it too soon?

OP posts:
burnoutbabe · 22/08/2021 20:25

I always made it clear early days how I felt about this as i DO NOT want kids and wanted men to know this.
No point dating if they really wanted kids and I didn't.

Though lots of them have had kids and stayed friends with me.

Met current partner via online dating and there you do say up front what you want as I would rule out anyone who wanted kids or had kids.

tedsletterofthelaw · 22/08/2021 20:23

I agree with the PPs saying it's not too early.

What's the point in wasting time with someone you see no future with if you want different things?

Lilymossflower · 22/08/2021 20:19

I would personally ask this on one of the first few dates aha. Because I know I definitely don't want any more kids. I feel like it's an easier first date question in some ways , like where are you from? Where do you wanna go with your career ? Etc etc.
So I would say yabu for not having that chat yet

MakeAWhish · 22/08/2021 20:19

Why are people so wary about talking about these things 'early on' in a relationship?! If it scares him away, then he wasn't ever the one!! You're both adults and you need to be honest about how you see the future for you - you're not asking him to impregnate you immediately and you don't even have to ask him necessarily what he wants, just make it clear you see more children in your future. Then it's up to him. This is more a 'getting to know you' piece of information surely? Be confident in who you are and what you want! It's not too much to ask and the right partner will support you!

Whatinthelord · 22/08/2021 20:16

I personally do think it’s too soon.
Maybe in 6 months time if things are still going good you could mention that in the long term you want another child.

Lady1576 · 22/08/2021 20:12

My now husband and I talked about this early on. I think it’s a good idea to talk about it early on. Why would he run, if you both want the same thing. If he doesn’t it’s best to know early on.

TheNinny · 22/08/2021 20:03

If this is a dealbreaker it’s fine to ask at 4 months. At this point, I’d say you know if you want to continue dating someone so it’s only natural to bring up things that are dealbreakers. Why waste your time and someone else’s on a relationship that you won’t stay in otherwise. If It’s a hypothetical ‘would you see yourself having another child’ sort of thing I can’t see how anyone would run a mile. Anyone serious about a relationship would of likely had these thoughts anyway. And plenty of relationships are serious at 4 months. I’m weirder than most but I let my boyfriend know early on I wanted marriage then kids with whoever my long term partner ends up being, so if he didn’t see himself doing this then to move on. I was 27 as well and had neither been married or had kids though. I just didn’t want to waste anyone’s time.

BasicDad · 22/08/2021 20:02

Those saying they'd run a mile if this was brought up after nearly 5 months of dating? 🤔

If it's important to you, you should absolutely have the conversation as soon as possible. It doesn't need to be serious and committing, but understanding what each other wants is really important.

turbonerd · 22/08/2021 19:56

My DH had this conversation with me on our second date. It went as follows: I WILL NOT HAVE ANY MORE CHILDREN!
I appreciated his honesty. We have 3 each.

As it happened I did fall pregnant but miscarried before 2 months, and it turns out I cant have any more children anyway.

In short: have the conversation. It is important to know where you both stand on this issue.

PheasantsNest · 22/08/2021 19:54

We discussed having kids on the first date. Still together 25 years later.

PlanDeRaccordement · 22/08/2021 19:50

I don’t think it’s too early to talk about what each of you wants in the future to include more kids or not. By now there should be talks about what you want to do with your lives? Do see yourself living in a big city? Or countryside? What career plans to you have? Do you like to travel a lot? How in to your hobbies are you? And yes, do you think you’d like more children?

Have that general future where do you see yourself what are your plans talk. It’s not too early. Just don’t open it with “hey I want another DC and I want you to be the dad and I want them in next three years”. It’s too soon for that kind of specific conversation. Stay general and see if any point going further.

CoalCraft · 22/08/2021 19:46

DH and I had "the chat" on the second day of being formally in a relationship, but it was a bit different as we knew each other for a year as friends before getting together, and it had already casually come up. DH said to me "you want kids one day, right?" And I said "yeah, one or two. You cool with that?" And he was.

I think it's sensible to have the conversation early to make sure you're even remotely compatible before getting too attached.

underneaththeash · 22/08/2021 19:45

I asked blokes when dating - poonutkess going out with someone when you want kids and they don’t!

TootTootTootToot · 22/08/2021 19:43

Also, his Mum sounds awful!!

MalagaNights · 22/08/2021 19:42

I think if you're 27 already have one child and know you want a long term partner and another child it should be a first date discussion.

If you don't want the same things in life there's no point in all the 'how much do we like each other?' stuff.

If you want diffrent things you'll end up splitting up eventually.

It's diffrent if you're 18 not looking to settle down and just want to go with the flow.

But you know what you want and you only have so much time.

TootTootTootToot · 22/08/2021 19:42

I don't think it's too early. Like a PP said if you are having sex with him then how is it too early to discus what happens if you get pregnant and do you want kids conversation.

It sounds like it's a very full on relationship though - I'd slow things down and see how it goes.

You still have plenty of time to have another kid.

billy1966 · 22/08/2021 19:40

It's not necessarily the child together but if he is open to having more children in a relationship.

Most people have an idea.
He is dating, so it can't be that big a surprise.
His mother is openly discussing it, even in front of you.
Her statement sounds like it may have come up before.

What ages is he and his children?

The further away from the baby stage you are, the less likely you want to return to it I think for a lot of people.

scarpa · 22/08/2021 19:34

DH and I discussed this on our first date: I asked if he wanted kids, he said he would in future but that it wasn't a dealbreaker for him, I said I did and that it was important to me. It was fairly lighthearted in a general getting-to-know chat (politics, life plans, cats or dogs - the crucial stuff haha) but there was no point getting a year down the line and then one of us going "Oh btw this is a dealbreaker for me" and having wasted our time/being gutted the relationship is over.

(As it happens, 6 years later we both definitely don't want children! So people can also change their minds. But at the time, I didn't see the point in continuing to date someone who didn't share fundamental life goals with me - I wasn't dating for the sake of it, I was looking for a relationship with a view to it going long term, so I knew that conversation was important)

Briarshollow · 22/08/2021 19:29

@PeasPeasPeasAreGoodForYou

I'd run if someone asked me this 4 months in
Yep. Me too. Especially if they already had a child. Calm down. You’re 27.
Seafog · 22/08/2021 19:29

You are the thing is, if you are having sex, you should have the " if a pregnancy happens" conversation.

Travielkapelka · 22/08/2021 19:25

We had this conversation early on, maybe within weeks. It wasn’t “would you want a child with me” it was, “would you want more children one day”. Big difference. I was certain I would never want another child and if he could see more children in his future then there wasn’t any point in moving the relationship forward. Lucky he doesn’t want anymore either so that’s fine but it was an important to have the conversation

billy1966 · 22/08/2021 19:23

@Dixiechickonhols

His Mum has done you a favour. Could you just say I’ve been thinking about what your mum said at bbq last week. I’m only 27 and know I definitely do want another baby at some point, I’m definitely not over that stage and would like DC to have a half sibling. Then see what he says. If it’s a hard no as he already has 2 then you all know where you stand.
I think it is certainly something that can be discussed.

He has two children and could well feel he's done.
Which is perfectly reasonable.

But if he is it means he just is not the one for you.
There is absolutely no point becoming more invested, introducing you children if you are not on the same page.

I agree with very vague answers.
They are very often a cover for No but I really like what we have and don't want it to end.

You have one child, taking on another 2 and having another yourself adds up to a hefty 4 children.

I have 4 and it is not to be sneezed at work and expense wise.

We both love them very much but it is full on, and the older they get you realise just how huge a commitment it is.

Look carefully at how much he does for and with his children.

Is he fully hands on?

Don't get sucked into a step mother scenario which can be relentless and utterly thankless as so many threads on MN attest to.
Flowers

MyOtherProfile · 22/08/2021 19:22

@EssexLioness

Looks like I am in the minority here. We had the conversation (initiated by him) on our very first date as part of the whole getting to know you thing. I was happy with this and thought it was good to know where we stood.
Same here with several men. One of those getting to know you questions. I met a guy, had a lovely date but half way through the evening he said he had 3 kids already and definitely didn't want any more. That was the end of the road for me because I did want kids

This doesn't mean I wanted him just for his sperm. It means I knew what I wanted. It's not the only deal breaker for me but it was an important one.

Blossomtoes · 22/08/2021 19:21

@thepeopleversuswork

TBH I would also run for the hills if someone asked me this after four months.

You're still in the honeymoon period. I assume your kids haven't met yet. There's still a ways to go before you know if you're even compatible as a couple yet, let alone whether you can blend families etc.

And you're only 27. I'd wait at least a year and until your kids have met one another before bringing this up.

There’s no point in the kids meeting if there’s no future in the relationship. If you have red lines - and this is a big one - it’s better to sort them out sooner, rather than later.
twinningatlife · 22/08/2021 19:19

You're 27 not 37 - you've got time. You've been together all of 5 mins

Swipe left for the next trending thread