Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what to do about this gift

379 replies

summersending · 22/08/2021 10:43

Last week a relative rang me in great excitement to tell me he’d found the perfect present for me. It was gift vouchers for a health type place. I did gently try to dissuade him but he was so sure he’d found the perfect present it seemed a bit mean to, so I thought it would be about £30, £40 tops, and I could just have a massage or something.

So the gift vouchers arrived and they are for £300 Shock

I really don’t know what to do.

On the one hand, I know if I reject them, he will be beyond hurt. He has ASD, high functioning but still - he’s desperate to have got something right. I feel like I should pretend to enjoy them.

But on the other it feels horrendously like taking advantage of someone’s vulnerability, although of course I haven’t. The problem is it’s one of those alternative health places and I don’t really have any interest in any of the things they offer.

So it’s a WWYD, really Sad

OP posts:
HareHare · 23/08/2021 18:49

Do what Polmuggle suggested. Don’t feel badly about it you have certainly demonstrated you care about his feelings

Rockhopper81 · 23/08/2021 18:48

I've skimmed the thread, but admit to not having read it thoroughly. Here is how I see it:

-relative with ASD believes they've found the perfect gift for OP (considering her slipped disc) and spends an awful lot of money on it.

-OP is not interested in alternative therapies (fair enough - sounds like my idea of hell too), but is now looking for advice on how to deal with the situation.

-a lot of people seem to think OP should do something against her wishes, which she shouldn't, because it's a thoughtful.

From my perspective - as an adult with ASD who can agonise over gift choices - I think the vouchers were given with the best intention. To him, finding something that might potentially help someone with a problem then have - even more so if it's something they would enjoy - is a win in terms of gift giving. He probably hasn't considered beyond 'this would be good as it will help her back' - he hasn't thought it would 'cure' OP, but that it might help, hence why it's the "perfect" gift. He probably hasn't thought about her personal thoughts on alternative therapies, just that this must be a perfect gift as it could help with pain.

Ultimately, OP doesn't have to do anything she doesn't want/like, regardless of whether she was given vouchers for free or otherwise - I cannot stand being touched by anybody I don't trust, so it would be a nightmare for me.

You say relative - how close of a relative? I appreciate straightforward and to the point communication, even if it seems hurtful - if I'd given vouchers for, say, a craft activity (something I would very much enjoy), and the person I'd given them to hated the very thought of it, I'd prefer them to say and give them back so I could enjoy them! Would I obsess over my thought process for a long time afterwards? Yes, because I have a lot of anxiety over 'getting things wrong', but if it meant a £300 voucher would actually get used, I'd want to know!

Also, please don't call the spa/treatment centre and 'stress that he isn't NT', or that he has ASD and isn't capable of rational thought (unless you actually think this) - disabled people don't need co-opting to make problems for NT people easier, we're people in our own right (not aimed at the OP, just the PP who suggested it).

wishingchair1 · 23/08/2021 18:46

Just sell them on ebay or re gift them.

Perhaps if you were able to name the venue, someone here might make an offer if local.

MarvellousMonsters · 23/08/2021 18:41

@summersending

Problem with FB marketplace is he has FB so runs the risk of him seeing it.

I have a slipped disc and he’s constantly trying to ‘cure’ it.

I have had disc issues in the past, and my osteopath has used acupuncture to ease muscle spasms. Acupuncture isn't Woo like homeopathy, it's a fairly well established treatment. If you have back problems that cause you pain why not use the vouchers? You literally have nothing to lose.
AnnieSnap · 23/08/2021 18:40

@BeauxRingarde

I have a slipped disc and he’s constantly trying to ‘cure’ it

Honestly OP, you should just go for the acupuncture. I'm a scientist, the worlds biggest sceptic, hates pretty much all alternative medcine and loathes woo bollocks with a fiery passion.....but I can tell you that acupuncture gave me pain relief after a slipped disc like nothing else did (other than very hard drugs!).

Just use the voucher.

Have you looked at the literature on this?
AnnieSnap · 23/08/2021 18:39

There is certainly no good evidence for pain being helped by acupuncture. I can’t say if it works for anything else except placebo (which is very useful, but of course you have to believe). If they have Reflexology, it is essentially, as mentioned by a previous poster, just a foot massage. I love all kinds of massages, if you do too, just have a serious if those. They will ask you which areas of your life/body you have problems with. Just say that’s not your thing, you are just having it as a foot massage.

BeauxRingarde · 23/08/2021 18:35

I have a slipped disc and he’s constantly trying to ‘cure’ it

Honestly OP, you should just go for the acupuncture. I'm a scientist, the worlds biggest sceptic, hates pretty much all alternative medcine and loathes woo bollocks with a fiery passion.....but I can tell you that acupuncture gave me pain relief after a slipped disc like nothing else did (other than very hard drugs!).

Just use the voucher.

Polmuggle · 23/08/2021 18:33

Oh, and you don't sound bonkers at all.

Polmuggle · 23/08/2021 18:32

OP how about this:

  1. find out if they offer refunds
  2. If they do, ring said relative and say how kind it is but unfortunately you've been advised against getting acupuncture for your slipped disc, so wont be able to use it.
  3. Repeat how kind and thoughtful but would be wasted, suggest he get refund and you think of something to do together, how about a nice meal (sub activity suitable)
Backwaterjunction · 23/08/2021 18:31

Wow hard work, go or don’t go, you sound bonkers

Purplealienpuke · 23/08/2021 18:30

I had acupuncture on the NHS for nerve damage resulting from a slipped disc.
It was amazing.
I went on to have further acupuncture. I often fall asleep whilst on the table.
I would say its worth a try if you can see past the 'woo' factor.
Other than that there are other places than FB market place you can sell. Are you a member of your local Nextdoor page?
What a lovely thoughtful family member you have

Hoppinggreen · 23/08/2021 18:21

@Hivis

Good Lord. How many times does OP, an intelligent capable woman have to state that she doesn’t want any of these treatments on offer!!
Yeah, but she should probably just give it a go anyway
summersending · 23/08/2021 18:14

@Hivis

Good Lord. How many times does OP, an intelligent capable woman have to state that she doesn’t want any of these treatments on offer!!
Grin

It has turned into a bit of a parody.

OP posts:
Tessabelle74 · 23/08/2021 18:08

It sounds like a lovely thoughtful gift, maybe he thought you'd appreciate the pampering after being in a baby bubble for a while. Just go and use them, you might surprise yourself and enjoy it if you give yourself a chance

bellocchild · 23/08/2021 18:06

Possibly your physio/osteopath/GP/other specialist has advised you not to have pilates or acupuncture or anything else on offer? It wouldn't help your slipped disc and might make things worse...

inappropriateraspberry · 23/08/2021 18:05

Just thank him and donate the vouchers to a school or charity raffle. Then tell him you had a lovely time, thanks.
If he lives far away he'll never know.

godmum56 · 23/08/2021 17:51

@Hivis

Good Lord. How many times does OP, an intelligent capable woman have to state that she doesn’t want any of these treatments on offer!!
obvs more than she has already Grin
Hivis · 23/08/2021 17:45

Good Lord. How many times does OP, an intelligent capable woman have to state that she doesn’t want any of these treatments on offer!!

Yourcatisnotsorry · 23/08/2021 17:44

I would go once before you go back to work to try it (reflexology is v relaxing if they offer that) if you hate it give the rest to a charity you like to raffle off. Good deed done, relative happy cos you’ve tried it. Not much time ‘wasted’

thenovice · 23/08/2021 17:36

I had hyperemesis and tried EVERYTHING to get rid of the sickness. Acupuncture was recommended but it was the biggest con of the lot.

Amaksy · 23/08/2021 17:34

But maybe he got on Groupon/ offer so not that big a deal re taking advantage.

Moonwatcher1234 · 23/08/2021 14:59

@texinthecity

If he is vulnerable are you sure that the spa place haven't taken advantage of this? Perhaps phone them up and explain the situation and say you want his money refunded.
This is an excellent point…these places thrive on upselling and could have encouraged adding more to the experience. It wouldn’t be the first time and it’s quite hard to say no.
billy1966 · 23/08/2021 09:30

Completely understand.
Gifts like this are pressure, particularly when time is short.

I don't have any suggestions other than could you use the lot of it in one go by bringing a few friends with you?

Flowers
texinthecity · 23/08/2021 07:26

If he is vulnerable are you sure that the spa place haven't taken advantage of this? Perhaps phone them up and explain the situation and say you want his money refunded.

justmaybenot · 23/08/2021 07:15

My sympathies to you, OP. I really find a lot of alternative therapies to be woo and would also dislike a gift like this - unless the place offered massages maybe.

I live with someone with ASD and I imagine the thought process of your relative could be that they themselves are interested in this and want you to participate as well. For example, my family member is really into playing bridge (not really, but something like that) and almost evangelical about it and bought me a very fancy bridge game for my birthday in the hope I'd get into it.

You say he will be 'beyond hurt' and is 'desperate to have got something right.'

It also sounds like they might be a little bit gullible and maybe vulnerable.

What I'd do is maybe explain the situation to the health place and tell them that your relative lacks decision making capacity and has inadvertently overspent. See if you can arrange a refund, explain to your relative that you were uncomfortable with that much money being spent on you and suggest that the two of you go for lunch or the cinema or something like that instead and that he can pay and that's a gift you'd really enjoy - time with him, a nice meal, a film with him etc (whatever it is). It would make him feel valued and maybe teach him something about what would be an appropriate level to spend on someone as well as enhancing his social skills/life. People with ASD often lack social outlets and this way you're offering him one and hopefully not hurting his feelings but rather making him feel better.

If you can't get any refund, then I'd go once, tell the relative it didn't really work for you and then donate the voucher.

Swipe left for the next trending thread