Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what to do about this gift

379 replies

summersending · 22/08/2021 10:43

Last week a relative rang me in great excitement to tell me he’d found the perfect present for me. It was gift vouchers for a health type place. I did gently try to dissuade him but he was so sure he’d found the perfect present it seemed a bit mean to, so I thought it would be about £30, £40 tops, and I could just have a massage or something.

So the gift vouchers arrived and they are for £300 Shock

I really don’t know what to do.

On the one hand, I know if I reject them, he will be beyond hurt. He has ASD, high functioning but still - he’s desperate to have got something right. I feel like I should pretend to enjoy them.

But on the other it feels horrendously like taking advantage of someone’s vulnerability, although of course I haven’t. The problem is it’s one of those alternative health places and I don’t really have any interest in any of the things they offer.

So it’s a WWYD, really Sad

OP posts:
Acryforhelp · 23/08/2021 21:30

I used to fall asleep in acupuncture (and reflexology) I would love those vouchers!

However, if someone had bought me expensive vouchers for a full makeover and boudoir photo shoot I would probably feel like you do about those vouchers op.

OrlaPeely · 23/08/2021 21:22

Can you contact the centre yourself and find out if they would refund in this instance? If they will then you can ask relative to get a refund (giving some sort of excuse/reason so as not to hurt their feelings if you like). If they don't do refunds then donate them to a charity raffle or eBay them (have sold tickets that way) and buy yourself the nice things you would like.

Tam20779 · 23/08/2021 21:21

You know what? All these people saying your ungrateful etc can do one. If I was given an unwanted gift, I would either try to return for a refund (they might not accept if you don’t have the receipt for the vouchers) or sell on for as close the face value as possible. If you live far enough away, could you join any marketplace FB groups that are local to you and unlikely to appear on his feed?

BeauxRingarde · 23/08/2021 21:16

Okay then. I’ll stick with the evidence and my own reluctant experience. I saw an NHS Physiotherapist got back pain. She suggested Acupuncture (cheap, since they stick the needles in then go off to deal with another patient). I asked if there was any evidence of efficacy. She admitted there wasn’t, so we agreed to do actual physiotherapy instead!

She obviously wasn't familiar with the research, which she should have told you. I saw an acupuncturist who was also a trained physiotherapist.

ittakes2 · 23/08/2021 20:47

NHS advises the NICE guidelines acknowledge acupuncture maybe helpful for tension headaches
www.nhs.uk/conditions/tension-headaches/
Guidelines from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) state that a course of up to 10 sessions of acupuncture over a 5- to 8-week period may be beneficial in preventing chronic tension-type headaches.

AnnieSnap · 23/08/2021 20:47

@ittakes2

Chiropractors are trained to use acupuncture and and research has proven that using acupuncture on the day embroy/s are put back in the womb can increase the success rate of IVF. Its also widely used to help with hormones during pregnancy maybe that's why he bought it for you.
Chiropractors are not approved by the NHS since there is a lack of evidence for efficacy. The nearest effective treatment is osteopathy.
AnnieSnap · 23/08/2021 20:45

@BeauxRingarde

Yes, there are interesting theories, but if you are a scientist you will know that a theory is tested to see if it’s valid. Testing of theories that acupuncture helps pain, particularly back pain, found no significant evidence that it works!

Of course I know that, I also know there are many studies that show some efficacy of use, even though it is incredibly difficult to study as randomised trial (it's not like a drug study when you can easily give sugar pills).

NICE and the NHS agree that there is "reasonably good evidence" of efficacy for it's use in some circumstances, and a recent large scale meta-analysis showed an efficacy in pain reduction of around 20% over placebo.

As a scientist I also understand that we don't have to know why something works exactly to know it does. That's pretty common in fact.

Okay then. I’ll stick with the evidence and my own reluctant experience. I saw an NHS Physiotherapist got back pain. She suggested Acupuncture (cheap, since they stick the needles in then go off to deal with another patient). I asked if there was any evidence of efficacy. She admitted there wasn’t, so we agreed to do actual physiotherapy instead!
ittakes2 · 23/08/2021 20:45

Chiropractors are trained to use acupuncture and and research has proven that using acupuncture on the day embroy/s are put back in the womb can increase the success rate of IVF. Its also widely used to help with hormones during pregnancy maybe that's why he bought it for you.

Mackymacmacface · 23/08/2021 20:45

Sorry that you're in this dilemma: a well-intended gift has now turned into a problem for you. Maybe to the person who gifted say: come up for the weekend (you've said in pp that they live some distance away) and we'll use the vouchers together and make a real treat of it?? (In the new year, when you've found your rhythm with work/ family juggle) Or else maybe you could gift them onto someone here?! (I'd happily take them off your hands) Flowers

helpIhateclothesshopping · 23/08/2021 20:40

Is it possible he won the tickets in a raffle and thought they'd be great for you? I was very sceptical about some of these alternative treatments but I agree some can be amazing, especially reflexology. Maybe check out what they have to offer, explain to him that you feel uncomfortable accepting such a lavish gift and are not sure you'll be able to use them fully with the baby and going back to work.

BeauxRingarde · 23/08/2021 20:37

Yes, there are interesting theories, but if you are a scientist you will know that a theory is tested to see if it’s valid. Testing of theories that acupuncture helps pain, particularly back pain, found no significant evidence that it works!

Of course I know that, I also know there are many studies that show some efficacy of use, even though it is incredibly difficult to study as randomised trial (it's not like a drug study when you can easily give sugar pills).

NICE and the NHS agree that there is "reasonably good evidence" of efficacy for it's use in some circumstances, and a recent large scale meta-analysis showed an efficacy in pain reduction of around 20% over placebo.

As a scientist I also understand that we don't have to know why something works exactly to know it does. That's pretty common in fact.

Snortlepig · 23/08/2021 20:28

Honestly. Can you not just suck this up for the sake of kindness? Speaking as a parent of a younger ASD child. The value of the gift is irrelevant. It was given to you in more than good faith, in excitement. Feign enjoyment if you have to.

AnnieSnap · 23/08/2021 20:24

@BeauxRingarde

Have you looked at the literature on this?

Actually yes, and there are some interesting theories on acupuncture and neurotransmitters.

Yes, there are interesting theories, but if you are a scientist you will know that a theory is tested to see if it’s valid. Testing of theories that acupuncture helps pain, particularly back pain, found no significant evidence that it works! 🤷‍♀️
busymomtoone · 23/08/2021 20:16

Selling the vouchers would be awful - deceitful, hurtful if discovered, a waste of money. Additionally you are bound to be asked about the experience- and if you lie this could be your gift ongoing every Christmas and birthday!! At £300 surely the gift giver had something specific in mind( you’ve complained about bad back/ sore feet etc) and wanted to help resolve?? I think you need to either suspend scepticism and at least give ONE of the treatments a try ( you might actually enjoy/ benefit from it??) or take the bull by the horns and say whilst you really really appreciate the thought and intention, you absolutely do not have the time, energy or wish to try any alternative therapies and you can’t accept such an expensive gift. Even ( especially?) for sensitive , neuro diverse people honesty is still rated far more highly than lies/ lack of clarity or wasting a gift. Good luck!

LoisLane66 · 23/08/2021 20:12

I would explain your circumstances to the manager of the 'alternative' health centre. Tell him/her/they that you are just back to work after mat leave and relative has a condition which means he gets fixated on solutions. You would like a refund as you have neither the time nor the inclination to use the vouchers but cannot tell the relative as they would not understand your reasons due to ASD. Offer to take a lesser amount, perhaps £250.
Say why you can't put them for sale on FB.
Just do it otherwise it will irritate you.

LoisLane66 · 23/08/2021 20:04

I'm entirely with the OP on this. I even dislike getting flowers unless they're the colour and kind I like.
I can think of better ways to spend £300 and I would have to smile through gritted teeth if I smiled at all.
The OP has a young child. Why would she want to have acupuncture (I had it to curb my sweet tooth but it didn't work, only will power works)
Why lie and say you're thrilled if you're not? As others have said, he may be delighted to have found something that pleases you and you'll be snowed under at Christmas and birthdays for the foreseeable unless you carefully explain how you feel.
Does he usually splash out that sort of money on your present. Was it a birthday? Does he have a good job which supports that kind of spending?
Personally, I think he's been talked into it by whoever recommended a health spa but he's accidentally contacted an 'alternative' health centre instead. They've encouraged that level of spend by bigging it up.

angielou791417 · 23/08/2021 20:00

My daughter is Autistic and so I guess I'm seeing it more through her eyes, I'd suck it up and go, maybe you can spread the things out over a few months taking different people? I know my daughter wouldn't understand any reason given why her idea wasn't completely correct! But another poster had a good point , try find a way of saying you loved it but a nice way of saying you would like to try something different now as you have already tried that!

TheRebelle · 23/08/2021 19:59

I meant to add, I get a lot of expensive but crap gifts from my in-laws, they go in a cupboard for six months then either sold or given to charity, the waste of money makes me want to cry but try as I might they won’t take the hint so now I just let them waste their money and try not to think about it.

TheRebelle · 23/08/2021 19:56

I haven’t rtft just the ops posts, I’m with you OP, I would not want to waste my time on something I’ve no interest in and it’s a massively expensive gift which would make me feel uncomfortable.

I’d either sell them on of you can or ring him and explain you simply don’t have the time to commit to a course of treatment and you don’t really fancy anything on offer anyway, would he like the vouchers back or to try and get a refund? It might upset him but at least you won’t get another £300 worth at Christmas!

MalagaNights · 23/08/2021 19:43

How close are you to the relative?

If you are close I'd talk to them directly: 'Dad I love that you want to help my slipped disc but I really didn't expect you to spend this much and I dont think I'll have the time to use them, and don't want them to go to waste, do you think there is any way we could get a refund?'

If they are more distant offence is more easily taken.
So go for 1 or 2 'treatments', if you hate it as much as you think you will don't go again and bin them. At least you'll be able to say 'yes Uncle Peter I went for acupunture. They were very nice there and it is was interesting but I don't think it helped.'
No need to tell him you only went once.

It's a minor inconvience in resposne to a kind gesture.

Hivis · 23/08/2021 19:26

@MumInBrussels Grin

The thing is, the OP already has strategies that work for her and rightly wants to spend her spare time benefitting from them physically and socially.

maybloss2 · 23/08/2021 19:23

Hi op, Reflexology and reiki are both really relaxing, if that’s on offer. If there’s nothing maybe you know someone who would benefit from acupuncture- it is good for pain, but not something I’d find relaxing, why does he think it would be beneficial? Oesteopaths and chiropractors also do good if you have a friend who has probs?
Or, you can just be truthful and say when you looked at the website there wasn’t anything that appealed, so would he like to give it to someone else in the family?

MumInBrussels · 23/08/2021 19:18

@Hivis

Good Lord. How many times does OP, an intelligent capable woman have to state that she doesn’t want any of these treatments on offer!!
Know what, @summersending? I've changed my mind. I did think you should try and get the vouchers refunded, since you're clearly an intelligent woman who knows her own mind, interests and constraints. But this thread has convinced me, you should give it a go anyway. All of it. Even the potentially dangerous treatments, the entirely impractical ones and the totally-bollocks-complete-waste-of-time ones. Especially those. Do have fun!
Tigger1895 · 23/08/2021 19:17

If you haven’t tried what they have to offer it’s v dismissive to say it’s not for you. Don’t knock it till you’ve tried it.

BeauxRingarde · 23/08/2021 18:50

Have you looked at the literature on this?

Actually yes, and there are some interesting theories on acupuncture and neurotransmitters.

Swipe left for the next trending thread