Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My 13 ds is genuinely aggrieved that he is not allowed to swear

162 replies

Veuvelily · 22/08/2021 09:28

He says he has heard all his friends swear in front of their parents and reckons he should be able to swear in his own home
Does your 13 yr old swear at home ?

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 22/08/2021 12:39

My mum and dad are pretty sweary. Esp my mum. When she's cooking it's oh shit I've dropped the sodding potatoes. Ow bugger I've burnt myself. I wish she'd let us help more!

Dad only tends to swear when he hurts himself working in the garage but the language was interesting when I was a kid.

I'm v sweary myself. Unsurprisingly prob.

DH seems unable to. His family don't. I once tried to get him to say fuck and he was squirming and couldn't do more than mumble.

So kids have one of each. They don't swear at all in front of us. Well DD said fuck once she's 14 and then said oops.

I'd be a hypocrite to say no but they don't so don't know how would feel in practice.

Swearing AT is a no no. I don't do it ever. I would stamp down hard on that. None of us call each other names at all. Even silly or innocuous things.

I would have zero problem with anyone swearing if they stub their toe or hit their head or trip over etc.

If the kids are older for the non swearers. What happens with telly with swearing is that ok?

LeSquigh · 22/08/2021 12:39

Swearing is part of language. I don't really see the big deal. I swear, my kids are fairly young still and they don't copy me but when they do as long as it is in context I won't have an issue with it.

Mumoblue · 22/08/2021 12:39

I swear semi regularly. I didn’t swear in front of my family until quite recently, but just because it felt awkward to start.
13 might be a bit young, but the teens is generally when I’ll be fine with my son swearing. No c-word though, I just don’t like it, and don’t use it myself.

Lysianthus · 22/08/2021 12:35

@TheSockMonster

I had a very prim and quite old English Lit A Level teacher who managed to stun our whole class to silence by saying ‘fuck’. She found our shock amusing and said that profanities have their place in every language and her only objection was when they were used inappropriately or excessively.

I have followed the same edict with my own DC. Inappropriate swearing is banned. Occasional and appropriate use is fine.

We might have had the same teacher. She talked about Anglo-Saxon dialect (or possibly diatribe). I love a good sweary diatribe as it releases stress but would never swear at anyone. DD says shit but nothing else, in front of me at least.
zingally · 22/08/2021 12:35

I didn't even know swear words existed until I was 9 or 10 years old!

It was absolutely NOT ALLOWED in our house growing up. I never did swear in front of my parents, but I think I'd probably have got a slap if I did.

Even now, at the age of 36, I would NEVER swear in front of my mum. My dad (who died 4 years ago), I think I did a couple of times - we had the exact same personality/sense of humour.

I even think twice about swearing on my fb, because my mum is on my friends list. She'd say that it shows a complete lack of intelligence.

Hadalifeonce · 22/08/2021 12:33

I come from a generation which had no qualms washing out a mouth with soap (literally), do I do not often swear, although my DC do swear they never use the f word at home, if it slips out I remind the they are at home. Even DH curbs his language at home.
I have even told off DD's friends for the f word.
I find it really offensive and will not accept it in my own home.
My DC are both adults as are their friends.

zukiecat · 22/08/2021 12:31

I never allowed swearing when my DDs lived at home, I don't swear myself because I hate it, and I especially hate st and c*p. Awful words.

My younger DD still lives with me, and she never swears in front of me.

My parents don't swear and I've never heard any of my aunts or uncles swear either.

Northernsoullover · 22/08/2021 12:30

I'm quite relaxed about swearing. We only tend to as a release like if we have forgotten something or stubbed a toe. My rule has always been never to use it as punctuation.

RubyFowler · 22/08/2021 12:29

Yes, mine is allowed to swear, but distinction made between swearing and swearing at someone, which is not allowed.
Never swear stronger than bloody in front of the grandparents or someone else's parents though! And not around small children.

itsgettingwierd · 22/08/2021 12:27

@hocusspocuss

I allow swearing so long as it isn't directed at people, but we have made a special exception for Boris Johnson Grin
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

My ds isn't allowed to swear at people or about people in an unkind way.

But I've always let it go when he's referred to Boris or Trump as "fucking knobheads".

ThreeWitches · 22/08/2021 12:27

I'm an English lecturer and quite honestly believe that swearing can have an impact that some other words can't - especially in writing

This.

FolkyFoxFace · 22/08/2021 12:25

Not at the age yet, but I'll allow mine to swear. I can't get worked up about it. I was allowed to swear growing up, as long as it wasn't loudly in public or around people we didn't know, etc. My parents were the same though; happily swear at home and around family and friends, but didn't think it was respectable in other situations.

I've never had an issue with it. Never really "slipped up" by swearing in appropriately or anything. I don't really swear at work, maybe a mild "bloody hell" or "oh that's a bit shit", depending on who I'm talking to. Not when I first started though, I don't want to be seen as the potty mouth in a none swearing environment. Just read the room really.

I love a good swear! It's just language. Yes, there absolutely are other words you can use, but "fuck" and "fucking" especially have a totally different feeling to them, and sometimes I think it's just appropriate. I also love the word cunt. I'm an English lecturer and quite honestly believe that swearing can have an impact that some other words can't - especially in writing.

Some people don't, and that's fine - it's why I won't speak like that around people who don't swear. If my kids want to swear, they can do, as long as they know when is and isn't appropriate.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/08/2021 12:25

[quote secular39]@NeverDropYourMooncup

I'm entitled to my opinion. Swearing like a trooper does not look good at all. If this applies to you, maybe this is something that you can work on?[/quote]
You are, indeed. As am I.

I don't need to work on anything, thank you very much.

grey12 · 22/08/2021 12:18

Depends on the circumstance. If they stub a toe and let out a swear word, fine. If it is part of their normal sentences, no!!!!

secular39 · 22/08/2021 12:14

@NeverDropYourMooncup

I'm entitled to my opinion. Swearing like a trooper does not look good at all. If this applies to you, maybe this is something that you can work on?

Branleuse · 22/08/2021 12:11

yes mine swear. Particularly my 14 year old aspie who loves all that horrid gamer culture where they insult each other as "banter". I dont pull him up on all of it, but I do when it gets bad and ive resorted to "time and place". if he gets done at school for swearing I have no sympathy for him. If he swears at me, then that is different to swearing around me.
I pick my battles tbh

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/08/2021 12:11

[quote secular39]@ThreeWitches

There isn't any correlation between swearing and intelligence. I completely agree and many of my friends work in a professional capacity and swear like no tomorrow. However, swearing (likes its apart of your vocabulary) makes you look unintelligent. Swearing here and there, putting an odd swear words in conversations if fine but speaking like this "Frankly, I'm fucking disgusted, the management was just full of shit, I went to see her and there she was, sitting in her fucking crown of glory..".... where every sentence has to have a swear word, just makes the conversation intolerable, believe me, it does not sound or look good at all. Unfortunately, it's a habit and a difficult one to remedy.[/quote]
You are, of course, perfectly entitled to hold your views - but I'd be more judgemental of somebody typing 'swear like no tomorrow' or 'likes its apart of your vocabulary'.

However, due to my applying the same leniency and assuming that you are either a very distracted typist or you're using a phone with an overenthusiastic autocorrect that also deletes conjunctions and substitutes incorrect punctuation for the appropriate ones, I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt.

pointythings · 22/08/2021 12:10

secular39 I agree that the kind of swearing you describe, where every clause in a sentence has a profanity in it, does make the speaker look limited. It's also unprofessional. However, there's a big difference between that and saying no-one is ever allowed to say 'fuck' at home when they drop a pan on their foot. Like nearly everything in life, moderation is the key.

wheresmyhairytoe · 22/08/2021 12:06

Mine, 12 and 14, are allowed to swear, I do so it would be hypocritical to tell them off.

However, we don't allow swearing at people or done aggressively and they know when it isn't appropriate ie in front of grandparents or using Jesus etc in front of our Catholic friends.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/08/2021 12:03

@Idontbelieveit14

Mine are allowed the odd one here and there. They are 13 and 14. They know when it’s appropriate and when it isn’t. They would never swear in front of teachers or their 4 year old brother, for example.
You might be surprised if you could eavesdrop upon them in school (especially when they aren't being directly supervised).

My usual approach is that there's a whole world of difference between swearing in front of a staff member (which can be a. entirely understandable in the circumstances, upset, in pain, etc or b. forgetting/not seeing that they're present, where a gentle 'could you try and think of alternative words, please?' usually gets you a variation upon the theme of 'Oh! Shit! Sorry Miss' Grin) and swearing at a member of staff.

I do, however, remind them that whilst I can tell the difference in meaning, that doesn't mean other members of staff would feel the same way and alternative words would be a better choice for an easy life.

It's an important part of language and vocabulary development - just as they have to learn to use academic writing styles and adapt voices appropriate for creative or persuasive writing, they need to develop the appropriate language around friends, threats/creepy men/etc, people in authority ('Now, how far do you think you'd get if you spoke to a Police Officer/the Head Teacher like that?') and as an everyday thing 'Yes dear, I did hear you say 'Fuck, the fucking fucker's fucking fucked', but whilst I can tell you aren't particularly happy from your tone and facial expression, it's not actually clear what is wrong, so I'm going to need to know a little more detail'.

There's also the thing that some words are only deemed vulgar now whereas they were purely descriptive historically and some that were deeply offensive but now aren't. Applying modern sensibilities to those can mean that a lot of meaning is lost; but again, addressing those means another way of learning how to adapt appropriate voices for the particular circumstances in life.

JacquelineCarlyle · 22/08/2021 11:59

@teaandcrumpets35

I never swear in front of my mum. But I swear like a trooper at home. My ds 10 knows what swear words are, but he also knows at his age he's not allowed to say them. I've told him when he's older his choice of language is his own responsibility. However when he's feeling particularly aggrieved about something he has been known to ask for permission to swear which I usually allow Grin
This is me too with my DCs!
secular39 · 22/08/2021 11:55

@ThreeWitches

There isn't any correlation between swearing and intelligence. I completely agree and many of my friends work in a professional capacity and swear like no tomorrow. However, swearing (likes its apart of your vocabulary) makes you look unintelligent. Swearing here and there, putting an odd swear words in conversations if fine but speaking like this "Frankly, I'm fucking disgusted, the management was just full of shit, I went to see her and there she was, sitting in her fucking crown of glory..".... where every sentence has to have a swear word, just makes the conversation intolerable, believe me, it does not sound or look good at all. Unfortunately, it's a habit and a difficult one to remedy.

SirenSays · 22/08/2021 11:46

My mother rarely swears and finds it disrespectful so I won't swear around her. Growing we weren't even allowed to say things like crap, bloody, damn.. Now I usually swear like a sailor on leave and will use fuck like people use erm when in my own home 😂

ThreeWitches · 22/08/2021 11:45

@secular39

I don't know. I know of many many many adults who swear like it's apart of their vocabulary. It just does not look good and makes them look very unintelligent. There is no need for it. I suspect that this became a habit, starting from when they were young and possibly their parents were laxed or it could have stemmed from their friendship group.
Literally no correlation between swearing and intelligence.

My university professors swore sometimes; they were great.

secular39 · 22/08/2021 11:40

I don't know. I know of many many many adults who swear like it's apart of their vocabulary. It just does not look good and makes them look very unintelligent. There is no need for it. I suspect that this became a habit, starting from when they were young and possibly their parents were laxed or it could have stemmed from their friendship group.