Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My 13 ds is genuinely aggrieved that he is not allowed to swear

162 replies

Veuvelily · 22/08/2021 09:28

He says he has heard all his friends swear in front of their parents and reckons he should be able to swear in his own home
Does your 13 yr old swear at home ?

OP posts:
grapewine · 24/08/2021 01:52

Plus, Brits have some very imaginative, entertaining swear words. It would be a shame not to use them.

grapewine · 24/08/2021 01:47

@ThreeWitches

I'm an English lecturer and quite honestly believe that swearing can have an impact that some other words can't - especially in writing

This.

Absolutely.

Also, as per PP, in dealing with pain.

NiceGerbil · 24/08/2021 01:32

Different areas and what words are strong is really interesting for sure.

USA family stuff I've seen English characters say wanker. And bugger. I can only assume they don't know what they mean or think the USA audience won't? Afaik USA is not very sweary compared to us.

Then you have aus where words are used in parliament that would not be ok here.

Then there's stuff like. Why are bugger and sod (in my area) seen as mild when fuck is v strong? Logically they should be equally bad at least. It doesn't make any sense but that's language norms for you!

SlipSlop · 23/08/2021 23:45

@NiceGerbil

Slip what do you say if you stub your toe?

Or I dunno. A fight spills out of a pub and it's a load of blokes really going for it with blood etc. Or you switch the news on and see some new awful news with loads of people dead. Or you see someone get hit by a car?

Genuinely interested. I'm very sweary indeed. Got it from my family. DH can't bring himself to swear. His family don't.

I enjoy it. We have some words that are so satisfying. You can really spit them out. I work with some Scottish blokes and their language is littered with really inventive invective. My work is very sweary though as well. My industry probably.

I'm just trying to think what DH says when something sudden etc happens. I can't actually think what he says. That's weird. Maybe he's just less verbal or something.

Funnily enough I stubbed my toe a few months ago. So badly the nail went black due to blood underneath. What did I say then? If I remember correctly, it was "Oh for goodness sake or for heavens sake!!!!", very crossly and loudly". I use those a lot. I'm not really religious by the way.

Other times I might say "flaming hell", which was changed to "flaming ale" when my son when little asked me what I had just said. Grin

It's interesting what is thought of as a swear word. For me crap means something is rubbish. I never ever associate it as being an alternative to the 's' word. The first word I can say very occasionally and write as here. The second one gives me the rage when anyone says it especially in the workplace when they wouldn't use the 'f' world. Strange huh. Smile.

GCAutist · 23/08/2021 05:17

I allow my Children to swear in contextually appropriate situations but I don’t allow them to swear at people except tory politicians.

1forAll74 · 23/08/2021 04:47

My two never swore at home, not sure when they both went off to UNI,and out into the world though.

PinniGig · 23/08/2021 04:17

@aLilNonnyMouse

Our rule is that you can swear as much as you want as long as it's never directed at someone in particular. Call someone a cunt and you are in serious trouble. Saying something like "the fucking computer is acting up and being slow" is fine.

It lets everyone get out their aggression while not letting people be nasty towards each other.

That word is banned here too. I nearly said it the other day in reference to the people in Afghanistan being abandoned and left to their fate "That's an absolute cunt's trick" but just stopped short and my daughter (23) drew a sharp intake of breath and did this Shock "OMG you nearly said it.. I'm telling you're gonna get well done"

Same with language and the difference between a throwaway casual and personal disrespect.

aLilNonnyMouse · 23/08/2021 03:47

Our rule is that you can swear as much as you want as long as it's never directed at someone in particular. Call someone a cunt and you are in serious trouble. Saying something like "the fucking computer is acting up and being slow" is fine.

It lets everyone get out their aggression while not letting people be nasty towards each other.

PinniGig · 23/08/2021 02:15

This is a very personal one and something that I understand whatever side of the fence someone may sit when it comes to language.

For me personally it's never been an issue. We had very few rules or restrictions when the kids were growing up in terms of age appropriate content and my language is a disgrace generally speaking. The main, major rules we did have was never to take the piss, push their luck too much and always assume that others don't like and won't want to hear, see or talk about the same stuff we do freely at home. Husband is the epitome of an old fashioned gent and seldom uses language and the very few times he has chirped up and put the fear of God into anyone it's been to groups of young lads really giving it the full effing and jeffing and being vile about girls.

Here nothing is off limits and we live and thrive on a household filled with language, insults thrown back and forth and oddly enough neither of our kids ever really swore until their late teens. They understood that swearing is not something they can or will ever do outside the confines of our four walls and even now in their early 20's, they don't even use words like “bloody” or “crap” out and about in public because they hate hearing other people swearing and being crass out in public, grew up mindful of others and have always been respectful even when using the worst language at home.

They are the most respectful, kind, honest kids with a moral compass that puts me and most others to shame which is ironic given the lack of rules and restrictions we had. I remember when they were very little sat in the back seat of my car singing along innocently to “Rage Against the Machine” I had playing and when I turned it off and went “Kids... you're not in trouble and haven't done anything wrong but that word – you can't sing or say that word it's really upsetting to most people OK?”

My daughter asked by they're called “Curse” words one day almost thinking aloud and my son who has always been a mad historian chirped up that it dates back ages to Medieval beliefs that using those words cursed people and caused ill health, the plaque and other unpleasantries and my daughter was “Really? Cool so where did this come from then?” Pair of them – both in primary school so very young and they were sitting there discussing the origins of swear and curse words like literary professors 😂

The main difference for me is not being sworn at Neither has ever uttered even a mild swear word in anger or temper but I will not tolerate being spoken to with attitude that's disrespectful, being muttered and mumbled about and I will not tolerate anyone swearing at me.

Kids are so mindful of language / grew up to have such respect they don't even use mild swear words when we're at the house of their Grandma who died earlier this year. They have accidentally said the odd swear but immediately “Sorry Grandma sorry sorry sorry!” cos it feels wrong to speak like that in her house.

It's not something everyone will get or agree with and each to their own but the swearing and listening to dodgy music or movies / video games doesn't create the problems it's the understanding and respect they have around its use.

Funniest thing for me anyway is the very rare time my daughter pops a button over something at work or Uni and from the second she gets in the car or through the front door she unleashes this intense torrent of the foul mouthed, raging torrent of abuse that would make Gordon Ramsay blush.

It's not offensive though it's more just brilliantly effective because she reserves it for special occasions 😂

BlackForestCake · 23/08/2021 01:46

My mum's 80 and I'm still shocked when she (very occasionally) swears, and I'd never swear in front of her.

bellabentley · 23/08/2021 01:42

If you told them off in your own home, thats perfectly fine as it is your house and they must respect your rules - but if you 'told them off' outside the parameters of your home then that really isn't your place to be doing that.

bellabentley · 23/08/2021 01:41

@Hadalifeonce

I come from a generation which had no qualms washing out a mouth with soap (literally), do I do not often swear, although my DC do swear they never use the f word at home, if it slips out I remind the they are at home. Even DH curbs his language at home. I have even told off DD's friends for the f word. I find it really offensive and will not accept it in my own home. My DC are both adults as are their friends.
If it's your home, your rules, fair play - but if your DC are both adults, and you 'tell their friends off' I'd be worried, in your own home, fine

If someone tried telling me off as a 29 year old for swearing I'd tell them to keep their nose out my choice of language!

Pendhxa · 23/08/2021 01:24

My 13yo and 15yo are allowed to swear, yes. They are both well behaved and good students. It’s never abusive eg “you are an evil cunt”, it’s more expressive. Burn some cooking “grrr fucking hell”

NiceGerbil · 23/08/2021 01:11

I don't know what the s word is!

Will never know.

Swearing for me adds power and emotion. When my friend told me her DH was having an affair I said fucking hell what a wanker. Saying oh dear that's terrible he's really not a good person (?) just doesn't have the same feel for me.

NiceGerbil · 23/08/2021 01:09

Slip what do you say if you stub your toe?

Or I dunno. A fight spills out of a pub and it's a load of blokes really going for it with blood etc. Or you switch the news on and see some new awful news with loads of people dead. Or you see someone get hit by a car?

Genuinely interested. I'm very sweary indeed. Got it from my family. DH can't bring himself to swear. His family don't.

I enjoy it. We have some words that are so satisfying. You can really spit them out. I work with some Scottish blokes and their language is littered with really inventive invective. My work is very sweary though as well. My industry probably.

I'm just trying to think what DH says when something sudden etc happens. I can't actually think what he says. That's weird. Maybe he's just less verbal or something.

SlipSlop · 22/08/2021 23:19

I don't swear. I can't bring myself to let swear words pass my lips. I sometimes think the very occasional "f" word though, but never the "s" or "c" word in my thoughts.

I hated it when after starting school my child sometimes used swear words. That was nipped in the bud, but as an adult they do what they want.

But generally, I can never understand why some people can't say a sentence without every other word being a swear word.

Worst of all is women using the "c" word especially on mumsnet. I see it as an extremely derogatory word men use against women. So to see it used here always enrages me. As a black woman the use of the "n" word by some black rappers etc equally enrages me.

Mistressofnone · 22/08/2021 22:41

@JEdgarHoover

This is an interesting question. I never sweat as my parents came down hard as a child

@Mistressofnone are you Prince Andrew? 😉

😂 why does autocorrect always attack the worst word! Fiddlesticks.
icedcoffees · 22/08/2021 13:46

I swore in front of my parents - not all the time, but if I was in pain or frustrated and said "oh shit" or "oh for FUCKS sake" they never corrected me or told me off.

They're just words. Nothing to get offended by imo.

AlexaShutUp · 22/08/2021 13:41

I honestly don't care in the slightest if dd swears at home, as long as she isn't swearing at people. They're just words, and I'm happy for her to express herself in whatever way she chooses. Swearing at people in an abusive manner would not be acceptable, however.

She knows that some people don't like swearing and that some may judge people for using certain words, so she is careful what she says around others unless she knows where they stand. But in the safety of her own home? Not an issue

lannistunut · 22/08/2021 13:39

I do swear at home, the children don't. They have never sworn that I have heard, even though we have not said they can't, they just seem to see it as an adult thing I think. But then the adult ones still don't really do it.

I also think they are just more refined than me, they look at me with disappointment at times Grin.

I am firmly pro-swearing myself, but don't do it at work for obvious reasons. Was very happy with that research that showed it was good for blood pressure/stress as now I feel vindicated!

TheSockMonster · 22/08/2021 13:32

Could well have done @Lysianthus

I can’t remember her name, but she had grey hair that she wore in a messy bun and always wore skirts and smart blouses. It was a dedicated sixth form centre in a town beginning with D.

She was quite fierce and, although I didn’t get on terribly well with her at the time, she made quite an impact on me. She pulled me up on my poor attendance and, when I arrogantly retorted that I’d got an A on my mocks and would get an A in my final exams she said that may well be the case, but I wouldn’t deserve it. She also called my bluff and said she could have me chucked off the course anyway! I pulled my socks up, dialled the arrogance down a notch and didn’t miss any more lessons. It was something I needed to hear and she was the only teacher to stand up to me and say it. I remember her very fondly!

scarpa · 22/08/2021 13:28

General swearing was mostly allowed at home from mid-teens but we always knew not to swear at people, in company, at school etc.

Swearing is absolutely no indicator of class, intelligence, education, etc (I know plenty of very posh, educated, intelligent people who swear like you wouldn't believe) as long as it's in the appropriate context.

Me in the office at work: "This website is fucked" - fine.

Me with a long-standing client who's a friend, are informal with one another, on the phone just catching up about a project: "Fucking hell, did you see X?" - fine, the context is there, it's a private conversation, I already know we're comfortable with that.

Me in a meeting with a big client who we're trying to impress: "I've fucked this slide up" - not fine, shows a lack of awareness of context, that's where I'd see it as inappropriate and crude.

JEdgarHoover · 22/08/2021 13:05

[quote secular39]@NeverDropYourMooncup

I'm entitled to my opinion. Swearing like a trooper does not look good at all. If this applies to you, maybe this is something that you can work on?[/quote]
Oh wow

HarrisMcCoo · 22/08/2021 12:49

Does your 13yo swear at home?

Does he f*ck!😂

No he doesn't. I have explained that I don't speak that way so it's unacceptable in the family home, plus we have younger children at home too.

Although, he got his wee swear fix in class reading aloud in English class last week. New novel includes loads of swears.

NiceGerbil · 22/08/2021 12:44

I mean we poke fun at each other and affectionate names but anger/ names meant to hurt we just don't do it.

I love swearing tbh. It's all part of our rich language and whatnot.

I also think sometimes a mild word is more cutting. Eg he's a bit of a Pratt. It's like you can't even be bothered to use a strong word

Watched yes minister last night with the kids and there was berk (pretty rude) and something else... And that's properly classic really clever stuff.

So yes upbringing and all families are different etc.