Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are you really when you're 15 years old?

58 replies

DelphineMarineaux · 22/08/2021 07:50

I've noticed that people seem to treat 15-16 year olds differently depending on the circumstances. Just from Mumsnet alone I have concluded that a 15-16 year old is a CHILD when it comes to paedophilia, but when it comes to sex with peers, getting pregnant, staying out until the early hours a 15-16 year old is suddenly "old enough" to make their own choices that parent's aren't supposed to meddle in. How can you both be a CHILD and be "old enough" to have sex, get pregnant and make decisions about whether or not to keep the pregnancy, stay out late on weekends etc.?

I'm just really confused. Seems like parents "mould" their children's maturity depending on what suits their own agenda. Surely, you can't claim a 15-16 year old is child when, on the other hand, you believe they are old enough to do adult things such as having sex and staying out late?

Just to be clear, I believe 15-16 year old ARE kids and should be treated as such. That's why I'm always shocked to read on here what parents allow their children. Like on one thread people told the OP that asking her 15 year old child to be back home at 21.00 on a Friday night is "too early". Why? Where can the 15 year old realistically go to warrants a longer curfew? It's not like they have access to bars, pubs and whatnot...

Thanks for reading.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 22/08/2021 08:52

16 is the age of consent for both men and women when it comes to sex. Mutual, consensual sex with a partner of the same age - very little point fighting that battle, better to guide with advice on great foolproof contraception, and establishing house rules that don’t necessarily encourage it (door open when boy over etc) and being sure you’re ready.

Sex with a much older partner is much more likely to be coerced, and therefore not consensual, and thus paedophilia comes into play. Whether it’s legally a crime to have sex with a 16-year-old, if you’re a much older adult, it’s certainly morally very dubious. A 15 year old in that situation is definitely all shades of wrong. Even if ‘consent’ is given, the power imbalance makes it almost impossible to guarantee that’s a situation they might not regret.

As to staying out, it’s less about whether 9pm is too early, more about whether your parenting is setting up an atmosphere of hard lines teens of 15 are going to rebel against, or whether you’re creating an atmosphere of respect where negotiation and listening to them is important and valued.

Subeccoo · 22/08/2021 08:52

Just left my 16 in two weeks time year old son overnight for the first time as we had to nip to London for something and staying overnight made sense.
I had no worries doing so but it did feel like a big deal! I wouldn't have done it 6 months ago so there is a bit of a difference I guess depending on just 15 or nearly 16 (or nearly 17 for that matter!)
Can't comment on the sex stuff yet...

StarlightLady · 22/08/2021 08:49

@LoislovesStewie - Exactly! 😘

vivainsomnia · 22/08/2021 08:46

I think what MN fail to appreciate too is that there can be a massive gap in maturity with 15/16yo. I worked years ago with girls of that age who were pregnant or had babies under 2 and been taken away from their families. All the girls had experience some level of trauma in their lives.

Some were incredibly mature, as you would expect a 20+ to be. They coped with looking after a baby amazingly well (and I realised even more after I had my children in my late 20s and struggle a lot more than these girls did), made rational decision, focused on their future and just needed a bit of support or direction to get there.

Others were typical immature girls, unable to look after themselves let alone a child. They acted like 10yo at being told what they needed to do, having tantrums, being defiant, sneaking out to go out, and needed constant supervision to ensure they kept their child safe.

That's why it's more often than not pointless to comment not knowing the child in question.

LoislovesStewie · 22/08/2021 08:43

@Eviethyme

The thing is when talking about paedophilia people arnt talking about a 16 year old having sex with a 15 Yr old. It's adults having sex with kids so in my eyes it's wrong for anyone over 17/18 to have sex with anyone under 16 regardless of consent age.

Say 2 x15 year olds were having sex u wouldn't be massively bothered apart from wanting them to be safe but if a 15 Yr old and a 20 year old had sex then that's different because one is an adult and one is a child til atleast 16 but really I think anyone 20 or over should stick to people 18 and over.

Please can you use the correct version of paedophilia, which is an adult wanting to have a sexual relationship with, or being sexually attracted to a pre-pubescent? Having sex with someone who hasn't reached the age of consent, whatever that age is in your jurisdiction, isn't actually paedophilia. The specific offence will be different depending on many factors, i.e. whether the young person is under 13 or not or whether the perpetrator is in a position of trust BUT it may well not be paedophilia unless a pre-pubescent is the victim. I understand that you might consider me to be pedantic, but I feel we need to use the correct terms.
mstroutpout · 22/08/2021 08:42

I would have thought it's fairly obvious that there's a difference between a 15 year old being mature enough to have sex with another 15 year old, and a 15 year old being groomed sexually by an adult man.

Re the curfew, why not debate that on the thread itself? It's probably already being discussed there (I haven't seen the thread) but there are lots of thing teenagers do after 9pm. Parties, cinema, bowling, I suppose all the stuff adults do but without the alcohol (most of the time we hope!).

I don't think a 15 year old is an adult or a child. They're in between and we need to make allowances for their brains not being fully formed yet whilst giving them increased amounts of freedom as practice for adult life.

AlexaShutUp · 22/08/2021 08:41

It's a difficult age. They're almost adults, especially by the time they hit 16. They can do a lot of adult things - they can work, they can travel independently, they can start to make decisions for themselves about certain things without parental consent. But they're still very young, very inexperienced and potentially very vulnerable.

They are also all different. Some will be incredibly mature and sensible. Others will be very immature and incapable of sensible decision making.

It's a tricky balancing act for parents to be able to give them enough freedom to explore their independence while also keeping them safe. What that looks like in practice will be different for different kids, and of course, some parents will err more on the side of too much freedom while others err on the side of too much control.

Personally, I wouldn't be happy to let my 16yo roam the streets after dark, but I'm happy for her to be out late if I know where she is and if I'm confident that she is safe. I wouldn't leave her on her own overnight at home just yet, because I don't think that would be very nice for her, but I was happy for her to go away for a couple of days with her friends because I trusted them so to be sensible.

Sometimes, I find it really hard to give dd the freedoms that she asks for because I can't help but worry about her. I usually try to ascertain whether my worry is rational or not. If I conclude that it isn't rational and that the risks are very limited, then I let her do what she wants. It doesn't stop me from worrying but I recognise that that's my problem. If I conclude that my concerns are valid and that the risks are too great, then I explain this to dd and she generally accepts it. She might challenge my view and we might debate it for a bit. Occasionally I might change my mind. It's a process of negotiation and consideration. You can't insulate your child from risk completely, as they would never leave the house, so it's an ongoing process of balancing freedom and independence with safety and protection.

There are no easy answers, it's a challenging age. As a parent, I think you have to accept that this phase will inevitably come with a degree of anxiety. You just have to suck that up and get through it.

Lillith111 · 22/08/2021 08:36

Also for the 21:00 curfew. A party at a friends? There are places 15 year olds go later than 21:00

StarlightLady · 22/08/2021 08:35

In addition any woman who is now an adult should remember what it felt like as a teen when hormones were bubbling.

FlumpsAreShit · 22/08/2021 08:33

Surely you can understand there's a difference between being groomed by someone far more developed and worldly wise Vs developing a relationship with someone more equally matched in terms of maturity? That's presumably why the different situations get different reactions.

StarlightLady · 22/08/2021 08:31

I look at them as young women or maybe junior women.

I’m in my early 40s now and became sexually active, with no regrets, around my 15th birthday. My boyfriend was a few months younger. He was a nice boy and did not put pressure on me. If anything l instigated things.

Aside from that, l was quite a “bookish” somewhat shy teen who had strict weekday curfews and didn’t drink or smoke. Elder sister was my guiding light.

Mum was annoyed when she found out, not that l was actually having sex, but that l hadn’t told her and discussed it.

Had he been years older rather than a few months younger, she rightly would have had a lot more to say; there’s no comparison.

Branleuse · 22/08/2021 08:30

Because 15 and 16 is old enough to consent to experimenting with their own peer group if enthusiastically consenting, and noone calls 2 15 year olds who fancy each other paedos, but if an older adult is grooming or exploiting them, then its another matter. They are still vulnerable and protected by law from.this.
Police dont arrest 15 year olds that are going out with each other, but a 17 or 18 year old would be on dodgy ground, and if older than that, the power imbalance is way off

DrSbaitso · 22/08/2021 08:30

It's a difficult age for many reasons. They are mature and immature at the same time.

ChocolateChipBelvitaSoftBake · 22/08/2021 08:30

@GintyMcGinty

Gosh OP

If you can't tell the differences between the examples you've cited then you won't under any of the explanations that people give you.

Can you really not see a difference between staying out late at the weekend and older men having sex with underage girls?

This

I do worry about peoples critical thinking sometimes. Sorry op, I probably come across as harsh and unfair but I have noticed this more in the current climate too with various covid related things and posts like this just confirm my thinking.

Mybalconyiscracking · 22/08/2021 08:29

Neither are fully functioning and responsible adults, but psychologically there was a huge difference in my thoughts about my 15yo’s and my 16 yo’s.
Personally, once my eldest was 16 I trusted her both to sort out contraception and stay out late, but that was who she was. I asked her to wait and she was happy to do so.
My youngest is not interested in either of those things at the moment and does seem more like a child, but I am comfortable with that too.

FawnFrenchieMum · 22/08/2021 08:23

I am all about my DC learning responsibility by gradually giving them more and more freedom. They don’t change from children to adults over night.
Some things i let them make their own mistakes, others I decide they are not mature enough and that as a parent is my right.
Teens sleeping with teens, not ideal but always going to happy. Teens sleeping with actual adults, not ok.
Teen already pregnant, it’s done, can’t change it so they need to start taking more of the adult responsibility they have created.
Asking them to be in for 9pm and then a year later being allow fo stay out all night, not going to end well. Slowly increasing curfew or having special occasions of later curfews, teaches responsibility.

DysmalRadius · 22/08/2021 08:22

Do you really not understand why parents do not want their children targetted by paedophiles, but do want them to develop age-appropriate relationships with people their own age and develop a little freedom and responsibility at a suitable rate?

The fact that you are unaware that turning 16 does change the legal status of a child is probably the root of your confusion.

GintyMcGinty · 22/08/2021 08:17

Gosh OP

If you can't tell the differences between the examples you've cited then you won't under any of the explanations that people give you.

Can you really not see a difference between staying out late at the weekend and older men having sex with underage girls?

Smartiepants79 · 22/08/2021 08:10

I agree there is often a mismatch on here.
In some instances you get these 15/16 year olds talked about as being ‘basically an adult’ and ‘you can’t make them’- phone usage, curfews, relationship choices, school choices etc..
and then other instances - paying their way, being horrible, rude and unkind, clearing up after themselves - were there ‘still so young’ and ‘just kids’
I often feel it’s a difference between rights and responsibilities.
And no, there no real difference between 15 and 16. Legally there is one but a 15 year old doesn’t magically wake up on their 16th birthday a fully functioning and responsible adult.

Eviethyme · 22/08/2021 08:09

I meant I wouldn't be massively bothered **

Eviethyme · 22/08/2021 08:09

The thing is when talking about paedophilia people arnt talking about a 16 year old having sex with a 15 Yr old. It's adults having sex with kids so in my eyes it's wrong for anyone over 17/18 to have sex with anyone under 16 regardless of consent age.

Say 2 x15 year olds were having sex u wouldn't be massively bothered apart from wanting them to be safe but if a 15 Yr old and a 20 year old had sex then that's different because one is an adult and one is a child til atleast 16 but really I think anyone 20 or over should stick to people 18 and over.

Doodledoop · 22/08/2021 08:08

Schools call them 'young people' usually - that. Teenagers. They are maturing. It isn't a binary state where they switch overnight from one to the other.

Physically their bodies will become able to reproduce - become adult by 13 ish. Psychologically brains don't fully mature til 24.

Between those times they are still more vulnerable but need increasing responsibility - but also parental/ legal protections. So yes it is going to look a bit contradictory.

Dozer · 22/08/2021 08:08

Your post is odd: sex offences against 15 year olds, or indeed older teens, are the only example you give on the one hand. Why is that?

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 22/08/2021 08:08

It’s a reflection on the growing level of maturity and their approach into adulthood. The fact that they are given room to make mistakes and have experiences with their peers gives them opportunity to learn within a safer environment.
The alternative would be to have no experiences of the adult world and then throw them into it suddenly on a specific birthday. An 18 year old who has had an 8pm curfew until this point might struggle when they are suddenly legally an adult and permitted to stay out all night.
Teenagers having sex with adults is wrong because of the power imbalance. Teenagers having sex with other teenagers has a much lower risk of that power imbalance which is why it is tolerated.

icedcoffees · 22/08/2021 08:07

Sixteen is the age of consent which makes a huge difference in a lot of ways.