Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are you really when you're 15 years old?

58 replies

DelphineMarineaux · 22/08/2021 07:50

I've noticed that people seem to treat 15-16 year olds differently depending on the circumstances. Just from Mumsnet alone I have concluded that a 15-16 year old is a CHILD when it comes to paedophilia, but when it comes to sex with peers, getting pregnant, staying out until the early hours a 15-16 year old is suddenly "old enough" to make their own choices that parent's aren't supposed to meddle in. How can you both be a CHILD and be "old enough" to have sex, get pregnant and make decisions about whether or not to keep the pregnancy, stay out late on weekends etc.?

I'm just really confused. Seems like parents "mould" their children's maturity depending on what suits their own agenda. Surely, you can't claim a 15-16 year old is child when, on the other hand, you believe they are old enough to do adult things such as having sex and staying out late?

Just to be clear, I believe 15-16 year old ARE kids and should be treated as such. That's why I'm always shocked to read on here what parents allow their children. Like on one thread people told the OP that asking her 15 year old child to be back home at 21.00 on a Friday night is "too early". Why? Where can the 15 year old realistically go to warrants a longer curfew? It's not like they have access to bars, pubs and whatnot...

Thanks for reading.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheSmallAssassin · 22/08/2021 11:58

Do you have teenagers yourself, @DelphineMarineaux?

Once they get to about 15, they're starting to grow up. Teenagers only really learn how to be an adult through experience, so how we treat them changes to let them start getting that experience, allowing them to be in situations where they need to use their own judgement and learn from their mistakes, in a way that is appropriate for them as individuals. There are no hard and fast rules.

Most of us would agree that a sexual relationship with a older person is probably exploitative and likely to be inappropriate.

Griefmonster · 22/08/2021 11:50

@romdowa

This is the problem with 15/ 16 year olds, they are both a child and a young adult... its that awful in-between age and parents have to balance that. They need to ensure that they give them enough freedom so that they can develop and become independent but at the same time they also still need protecting, often from themselves.
Grim view

There is no "problem" with 15/16 year olds.

And they are not young adults. They are older children/young people with developing capacity and some legal rights (if 16).

If you only start working on building independence at age 15 then what have you been doing with them for the last 14 years?! Are you still spoon feeding them and wiping their arses? No (I assume).

MeMumI · 22/08/2021 11:45

I think there's a huge difference between 15 and 16.

My daughter is almost 15, she's about to go into year 10 and us still very much a child. She doesn't play, but still lives in an alternate reality, and is in no way ready to "adult" yet.

Whereas my friend's daughter is 16, about to turn 17 and she's going off to universities to look at open days, works part time, attending music festivals, concerts, the pub, getting ready to learn to drive. Regularly gets the train to London to go shopping. Pretty much ready to move out of home now.

There's a whole load of growing up they do between 15 and 16!

SisterMonicaJoansHabit · 22/08/2021 10:42

My eldest recently turned 14. Apart from being bewildered that in a year I'll have a 15 year old (which feels nuts to me), I'm already seeing a more mature, level headed young person emerging from the child they were.

So I can see for myself now how heading towards 15/16 is very different from 13, and so on. And I'm OK with that. I honestly had no idea what to expect and when, til this year, when I'm actually seeing a difference.

I do desperately hope that my teen doesn't end up round older guys and women. I did, I was that 16 year old with the 23 year old.

It's definitely an in between, no man's land kind of age. Not just a child, but not adult.

ragged · 22/08/2021 10:41

This thread is about opinions. Mine is...

Child = age 12 and below

Age 13-17 is transition to adulthood, it's a long transition because humans are complicated. Increasing responsibility over this period. Within fuzzy safety limits (they have to be fuzzy not fixed), Parents have a duty to let their kids make own decisions & potentially make mistakes during this period which is how you support your kids to learn to make good not bad decisions.

Age of consent = 16 is a sensible threshold.

Adults are still often immature, inexperienced, vulnerable. Learning is life-long, anyway. People need to have opportunity to be forgiven to learn from their selfish mistakes. We should still try to support our adult offspring.

Underhisi · 22/08/2021 10:41

That age group are though very vulnerable to problems created by mixing with older teens.

Underhisi · 22/08/2021 10:34

When I was teaching I noticed a jump in maturity during year 11 and young people who had behaved as children early on in year 10 were noticeably grown up as year 11 progressed. Those who had started gcse groups as being awkward and often being a nuisance, mellowed and even if not wanting to do much work often behaved in a more 'adult' fashion becoming generally more agreeable. I think the 15/16 age group is distinctly different from the 14/15 group.

Todaytomorrowyesterday · 22/08/2021 10:31

I go on more their vulnerability at that age - they more at risk of being taken advantage off. It’s a fine line between being aware of the young person giving them freedom to grow up but protecting them from being taken advantage off.
The brain development also is they more unaware of risks.

Bibbetybobbity · 22/08/2021 10:27

Spot on @Ducksurprise…

SilverTimpani · 22/08/2021 10:18

I think it’s totally reasonable to differentiate between a situation where a 15 or 16 year old is having consensual sex with a peer of the same age and a situation where an adult is grooming them or engaged in sexual activity with them. That’s pretty obvious, right?

16 is the age of consent. A 15yo who is almost 16 having safe, consensual sex with another 15yo wouldn’t cause me, as a parent, to completely freak out. I’d want to know that they were protected from pregnancy and STIs and that both parties had enthusiastically consented, but I don’t think taking an authoritarian approach and telling them they are a child will do much to foster an open, honest and secure relationship between parent and child. And once their 16, you don’t have a lot of power to tell them they can’t do something legal and common.

Totally different situation to anything involving a paedophile. The reason that sex between adults and children is always wrong, regardless of any other factor, is that there is an inherent power imbalance which makes the child easily manipulated by the adult. There can be no true consent, therefore. This dynamic doesn’t exist when you’re looking at two 15 or 16yos.

That’s why people treat the situations differently - because they are completely different.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 22/08/2021 10:11

I think you just know, don't you, when a relationship is inappropriate. If you have a mature, working 23 year old man who wants to date a quite immature, easily led 16 year old, you have to ask yourself what he's getting from that relationship except the potential to control & exploit.

By contrast, if you have a very mature 18 yo who is very independent, maybe working or studying & living away from home, confident and has had a boyfriend before, it may not be remotely concerning for a 24 year old to form a relationship with them.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 22/08/2021 10:04

There's a big difference between 2 consenting 16 year olds taking a carefully considered decision to pursue a sexual relationship, and a much older adult exploiting a teenager. It's about the natural imbalance of power between an older adult and a teen that doesnt usually exist between two teens. Of course a sensible parent will take into account the maturity of their own DC, there will be some 15/16 year olds who are very immature and prone to exploitation by their peers, but thats a judgement call for a parent.

KurtWilde · 22/08/2021 10:02

@GintyMcGinty

Gosh OP

If you can't tell the differences between the examples you've cited then you won't under any of the explanations that people give you.

Can you really not see a difference between staying out late at the weekend and older men having sex with underage girls?

Perfectly put.
dottydodah · 22/08/2021 09:45

If Teens are having sex with youngsters near their own age ,vastly different to being groomed by predatory older men surely? 16 is the age of consent, which to me means consenting to someone in their peer group .not an older guy looking for a youngster to control . Quite clear to me !

hocusspocuss · 22/08/2021 09:41

I was very much a child. Very vulnerable and naive.

My sister, not so much.

Depends on the child.

Ponoka7 · 22/08/2021 09:31

In regards to exploitation and grooming we can't ignore the still sexist societal messages. We don't make decisions in a vacuum and we are influenced by so many factors. Which is why we need black and white rulings.

Ponoka7 · 22/08/2021 09:22

"Because there's not a huge difference between being 15 and 16- Nor 14 and 15."

Young people (which is what I call them) can vary hugely. But in the individual there's a growth in emotional intelligence and a growing maturity in decision making, in those years. If a parent is parenting properly then they will be giving more independence to encourage that more. Which is why 9pm is a bit early for a 15 year old. Young people shouldn't just find themselves free to do whatever they want at 18, without an easing in.
But I agreed that 10 was ok to leave a child to walk home and be in for an hour, on a recent thread. Mine did it. I did think carefully because I had a typical 70's childhood, which was too lax, but think children are over fussed these days. They are far more capable than some parents recognise.

supermoonrising · 22/08/2021 09:18

Late adolescence sometimes continues until 21. The exact ages society puts on certain legal activities "16", "18" are all fairly arbitrary. Thats why the age of consent differs widely even across European countries.

CheddarToldMeTo · 22/08/2021 09:16

Ohhh tricky! I was very very mature for my age but at 15 still recognised that people would see me as a child because of my age. However I was very responsible and mature 15/16 year old and looked much older so got away with more 😂

NoSquirrels · 22/08/2021 09:14

@Ducksurprise

A lot of the discrepancies on MN come from posters who actually have teens and posters who are imagining what they will do when there pre schooler is a teen.
Grin
mstroutpout · 22/08/2021 09:06

@Ducksurprise

A lot of the discrepancies on MN come from posters who actually have teens and posters who are imagining what they will do when there pre schooler is a teen.
This in spades!!!
Ducksurprise · 22/08/2021 09:05

A lot of the discrepancies on MN come from posters who actually have teens and posters who are imagining what they will do when there pre schooler is a teen.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 22/08/2021 08:59

@Lillith111

Also for the 21:00 curfew. A party at a friends? There are places 15 year olds go later than 21:00
Also, cinema, bowling, shopping centre, ice skating, roller blading disco, sports clubs, watching football…

There’s tons of stuff a 15 year old could be doing with friends that would mean getting in after 9pm.

LindaEllen · 22/08/2021 08:59

It's a difficult age. They are neither a child nor an adult - they are an adolescent. They need to navigate the difficult path between childhood and adulthood, meaning that yes they may start to experiment with boyfriends/girlfriends etc, but they still have that youthful vulnerability that means that may still need protecting in other ways. A 15yo girl for example might not understand that it's inappropriate for a 30yo man to ask her for photos - she may think she holds all the cards and he really, really likes her, when in fact the experience we have as adults would tell us otherwise.

I'm not sure why you can't understand the difference between situations.

Branleuse · 22/08/2021 08:53

I dont think its important that paedophilia is colloquially used as a more general term meaning people that seek sex with kids and teens under the age of consent. Those specifically attracted to teens are hebephiles officially i think, but the majority of people that abuse and exploit kids are neither and are opportunists, but we all know what they mean when we call them paedos. We keep the stigma high here for good reason

Swipe left for the next trending thread