Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dad put baby to sleep

109 replies

PlanetTeaTime · 21/08/2021 20:32

Since DD was born 6 months ago, I have nursed her to sleep every single night and for most of her naps (sometimes I can get her to sleep in the car or a sling). She is now teething and has bitten me several times this evening.

After over two hours and several bites, I've told my partner no more, he will have to try to get her to sleep tonight.

He says he can't and he's tried before and he can't do it. He's never tried rocking her longer than 15 minutes before handing her back to me.

Am I being unreasonable to ask him to take over?

OP posts:
HappyDays40 · 22/08/2021 10:11

I had weeks of sleepless nights when I was on leave and just had enough. The sleep deprivation sent me crackers and I handed my son to my husband told him to get on with it and went and slept in the car. I just couldn't stand the noise anymore. I slept so well and it made my husband have to cope and find his own way with our son.

Straighttalking1 · 22/08/2021 09:01

Not at all....Yanbu..My DP used to snuggle ds every evening whilst walking round the kitchen every night until he fell asleep. He did that for 2yrs or until the boy got too heavy.

tinierclanger · 22/08/2021 08:24

Also, sometimes standing and rocking works faster than sitting - if your partner can face it, he could try that..,

tinierclanger · 22/08/2021 08:19

Hi OP. With my baby around this age, who I had always fed to sleep, I started by slipping her off the breast just before she nodded off, just as I could see her starting to go, so she got the experience of falling asleep without the nipple in.

After a few nights of doing that, we swapped and my husband would then take her after a feed but while she was still awake and rock her to sleep, for every night settle. Once she got used to falling asleep in his arms after a few nights, we transitioned to rocking, putting down while sleepy and then stroking her while she went to sleep. She would cry a little but never for long and we never left her alone to cry. We then gradually weaned off the stroking and just sat in the room with her. Then did gradual retreat to the door. Eventually could just put her down and leave her. It was hard work but did work, after about 3 weeks at a gradual pace.

(Just to say, with both my babies I did start out by putting them down in drowsy but awake for the mythical self settle but it never worked)

Beamur · 22/08/2021 08:14

You're doing fine! Although that manual would be helpful..
All babies are different and as long as you're meeting their needs that's what they want. They can't talk so crying is their only way to tell you to keep trying!
I remember being astonished by my friend taking her baby upstairs for a nap, I expected her to be gone 20+ minutes (as I would have been) and she came straight back down! She had the miracle child that literally just went to sleep with zero fuss. Mine was not like that! Some babies are good sleepers, some feed easily, some are always needy and some are very chilled..

EffYouSeeKaye · 22/08/2021 08:01

I can promise you that you are not getting everything wrong and that you will crack this issue, same as you have already with countless others no doubt, and you will continue to do so with the next problem to come along…

The main thing is that you team up on this now. It’s a great time because weaning will be getting more underway and it won’t be all on you to give feeds. Honestly you have done amazingly to get to 6 months of bfing. Sleep and settling babies is tough. Everyone has their own ways and ideas and everyone gets there in the end. You do what suits the three of you best.

Keep going with those chocolate buttons too Wink

Crowsaregreat · 22/08/2021 07:45

What happens when she wakes in the night? Do you always feed to sleep then as well?
If I were you, if look at a night routine that either parent could do, with a final feed that's not in the bedroom.
Biting can be awful and I understand why you want to get away from it, but storming off is not the right thing either!

HurryUpAndWait23 · 22/08/2021 07:27

OP ive been there. I'm still there!

I work shifts and wouldn't get home until nearly 9pm, my husband would have spent the last 2 hours trying to get my breastfed baby to sleep (usually fast asleep by 7pm) this would happen 3-4 nights a week.

Not once did he manage to get him to sleep and he was really consistent and did all the right things.

It isn't always that simply unfortunately.

PlanetTeaTime · 22/08/2021 07:08

Hi everyone, thank you for all your responses I actually really appreciate it. It makes me feel like I'm not alone.

Just for clarity, when I say rocking I meant in our super comfortable rocking chair with accompanying footstool which never gets used, so it really isn't a lot of effort for him to rock her to sleep.

After writing this, I went downstairs, ate some chocolate buttons and returned 20 minutes later to take her back. At the end of the day she doesn't understand and she was getting upset.

You're all right we need to come up with something together and then he actually needs to give it a decent go not moan that it's not working after 15 minutes 🙄

I really do wish this baby had come with a manual because I do sometimes feel like I'm doing everything wrong.

Thanks again

OP posts:
TheNinny · 22/08/2021 00:18

Meant to say at night it’s an even split as DD self settles in cot so we can just bung her inch and run lol. I fed to sleep for the first 6 months as well and then bottle fed to sleep after. She took bottle better from me at first but He was able to do this on nights I couldn’t - illness etc, tiredness, etc. Shen then started taking bottle from him just as easy. She’s a wee guzzler so in the end wasn’t fussed as long ascshe got the goods heh

ExpulsoCorona · 22/08/2021 00:17

If you don’t give them a chance then they’ll never learn.

This comment made me laugh so much. If it were true I'd still be rocking my 13 year old now but funnily enough she can self-settle now and has been able to do so since she was 20 months of age.

OP - Yes he should help and 15 minutes isn't very long. If you are able to, try and go out at bedtime and leave him to it for a bit longer. You'll all get there eventually, I agree with the others who say it is possible for you to feed to sleep and your husband to rock (or any other method you choose as a family). When I went back to work, I was still feeding to sleep. My husband would rock. My mum would rock. My mother in law would pat. Totally possible.

TheNinny · 22/08/2021 00:09

Yanbu. My DD would only fall asleep with me at first but eventually DH was able to do it. Sometimes he’d try for an hour + with no luck but it still gave me a chance for a break. Once I stopped breast feeding at 6 months it became a lot easier and now she goes to sleep at nap time faster for him (I stil rock/sway her for naps at 22 months…🙈) as he can shoogle her more firmly than I can. Practice makes perfect

callmeadoctor · 22/08/2021 00:02

Is the baby his? (clearly he doesn't think so...............................) He needs to step up.

TooManyDinosaurs1 · 21/08/2021 23:59

I'm also breastfeeding a (about to turn) 6 month old. I do the same always feed to sleep. He has also started to bite a little, just like his brother and sister did. You don't need to be dramatic and say I'm done. Simply take them off your boob as soon as they bite. They soon realise that biting = no boob. I had the same phase with them all. The 6 month old hasn't done it for a day or 2 after biting at the end of every feed for a few days, I'm hoping it'll pass.

As for your husband trying for 15 min, that is quite a long period to try to settle a baby, I'd be passing the baby back after 15 min too. You can't do the same thing for 6 months then decide one day "no more" your baby won't just suddenly accept that someone else is going to settle them without feeding. If I was you I'd power through the biting, but let your baby associate removing them from your boob on biting, unless you want your husband to put the baby to bed of course, in which case how about expressing some milk and getting him to do that last feed?

MyMabel · 21/08/2021 23:37

My DP was like this for a while as DD would only settle on me; I ended up annoyed that he wasn’t putting the effort in but then we talked and he felt like it just wouldn’t happen, that he would be distressing DD leaving her crying for so long and generally felt a bit unwanted by her which hurt. Once I thought about it I guess I understand why they give up so easy. Of course they’ve got less patience than us, but patience grows and I found getting angry and fighting/arguing about it never made it any better anyway.

We worked together, we started by DP holding her while I sat with them and spoke/stroked DD’s head/cheeks so she knew I was there but wasn’t on me as such, gradually contact became less and although she did still cry sometimes eventually DP was able to get her down within a reasonable time frame and without stressing.

Babies are really hard work and everyone needs help, be it the person who does the most now or the person who needs help learning how to do more.

Congratulations on the baby!Flowers

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2021 23:28

@MrsJuliaGulia

Why did you start nursing her to sleep every night? You’ve created a rod for your own back there. I don’t think your husband is unreasonable. If the baby is used to being nursed to sleep, she’s not going to want to change that habit.
That's nonsense.
EffYouSeeKaye · 21/08/2021 23:26

@MrsJuliaGulia

Why did you start nursing her to sleep every night? You’ve created a rod for your own back there. I don’t think your husband is unreasonable. If the baby is used to being nursed to sleep, she’s not going to want to change that habit.
Helpful 👍
MrsJuliaGulia · 21/08/2021 23:23

Why did you start nursing her to sleep every night?
You’ve created a rod for your own back there.
I don’t think your husband is unreasonable. If the baby is used to being nursed to sleep, she’s not going to want to change that habit.

Anyusernameleft · 21/08/2021 23:18

No...you need to go out & leave him to it without having you there to hand baby off. Arrange something for a couole of hours with your friends for near bedtime & beyond & turn your ph off...

Positivelyrandom · 21/08/2021 23:14

He. Must. Try. Harder.

miltonj · 21/08/2021 23:14

I feed to sleep most nights and always have done. But both my mum and my husband have put her to bed with a bottle no issue. In fact it's much easier and quicker for them, as she just has the bottle, goes to sleep and then gets put down. Whereas with the breast, there is no stopping point so she wants to stay attached for a long time. Don't let him get out of this!

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2021 23:10

@amiwastingmytime

No no that’s not what I mean. For OP to leave the baby with father, when he physically does not have the same ability to settle the baby, after 6 months of the baby knowing no different, is not only unfair on the father, but very very unfair on the baby. Baby could be inconsolable as it knows no different. In this situation I think OP needs to start training her baby (with husband of course!) to teach and support the baby to fall asleep without boob. Going cold turkey is an option, but could be very traumatising for everyone. The babies needs here are most important. OP needs to work with her husband to help him and baby settle together. Had father been doing it all along, this would be a case of lazy father, but it’s not here, he just isn’t confident enough to see through a very upset baby to sleep.
Do we know for certain the baby would be upset, though? I may have missed it but I didn't think the OP said that.
SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2021 23:06

@BastardMonkfish

By 6 months the 'just put them down and they'll learn to settle' ship has sailed, you need to be doing that from a few weeks old.

It is hard OP, but I can see your DHs POV. He was never going to be able to get her to sleep. You need to have a talk tomorrow about the strategies you are going to use together to help your DD fall asleep without feeding to sleep.

Also if she's taking 2 hours to fall asleep sometimes it helps to try putting her to sleep a bit earlier. She might be overtired by the time you start bedtime routine and then you're buggered before you have even started.

How do you know he wouldn't get her to sleep? Confused

Surely, if it is taking the OP ages, the baby doesn't sleep easily, so I don't see how we can be so sure the OP taking two hours is perfectly fine, but her DP can't possibly manage if it takes upwards of 15 minutes.

Branleuse · 21/08/2021 22:58

I think youre setting them up to fail if baby isnt used to a bottle

emeraldcity2000 · 21/08/2021 22:57

It's tough op. My second was the same and I also snapped one night and made dh help, it took 2 hours but he got him to sleep eventually.

Agree with other posters that you probably need to agree a strategy (when you are both feeling calm) on how you want to change things and what you want to achieve. All parents and babies have different needs and only you will know what is right for you. You'll get a lot of fixed views on sleep training on Mumsnet - the reality is there is almost no good evidence in favour or against so you need to decide what is right for your family. Either way you'll need dh support.

Good luck xxxx