Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was there a big difference in academic standard between O-Levels and CSEs?

112 replies

Warburtons2 · 21/08/2021 19:22

I did GCSEs just for the record but I’m interested to know people’s reflections on this and how were people selected to do the exams?

OP posts:
chesirecat99 · 22/08/2021 12:16

I did AO levels too @Seashor. It think the A stands for Alternative. The top sets took maths, English and French a year early then took AO levels the year after.

I've also got another defunct qualification - an S-level (Scholarship-level). Totally pointless as they were meant for people applying for scholarships to university back in the days before grants, which were replaced with student loans whilst I was at college, so scholarships were a long distant memory.

ErrolTheDragon · 22/08/2021 11:31

@sluj

I was part of a pilot scheme for my year and took an exam they were going to call the 16+ in Chemistry. This was 1979. We didn't do anything different for it. I did traditional O levels for everything else being an academic child. 😄 I remember queuing up for my results and being given a separate envelope first. This had a CSE grade 1 for chemistry in it. I do remember thinking "oh no, I only got a cse, I must have fails for the others which were all o'levels". I then got a separate piece of paper with the O levels on, which included an A in chemistry - so I got a cse and an O level grade. I took 2 x AOs in the lower sixth so actually ended up with 11 x O levels and that CSE, not common in those days. I was at a heavily streamed comprehensive school and some of my friends took a mixture of CSE and O level classes. You were streamed for virtually every subject so you could be in the right place for your own strengths without having to be good at everything. It worked well.
I did the 16+ biology so got a 1 and an A. It was a different board to the others so I ended up with 3 certificates - 2 for biology and the remaining 6As and a B on the other. I was slightly irked to not have all the o levels on one certificate. I was in the transition year between the school being grammar and comp, had all the people who'd passed 11+ in the area plus a similar sized cohort from a local catchment. This meant there was an unusual degree of flexibility with quite a few who'd failed the 11+ being moved to the gce sets in the 3rd year (yr9). Those who were weaker at maths did the CSE - it was a 'modern maths' syllabus which included some things that the O level didn't such as matrices. (Iirc my 2 maths A levels, separate pure and applied maths, didn't cover them either despite their usefulness... they're one of the bits of maths I still use all the time now though a hell of a lot easier in code than on paper.Grin)
FuzzyPuffling · 22/08/2021 11:19

And at A level there was a quota system, so regardless of your actual mark, only the top 3% in the whole country (may have got that number wrong, but it was very small) got a Grade A. It really meant something special.

FuzzyPuffling · 22/08/2021 11:16

At the (posh) boys school over the road, if you failed an O level twice you took a different board O level. We all started with Cambridge board.

newnortherner111 · 22/08/2021 10:52

From what I recall in the late seventies there was a significant difference. Some of the pupils in my class who did seven or eight O levels but had one subject they struggled in (often Maths) were put in for CSE as a grade 1 had just become recognised as equivalent to an O level. If I recall correctly, they all got a CSE grade 1.

PaperMonster · 22/08/2021 10:51

I did 16+ maths at school and got a grade 2. So College said I could only do A levels if I did maths again. So I did the 16+ again and got a grade 3.

When GCSEs came in a couple of years later I sat the maths exam without attending classes and got a grade C!! All the equations and formulae I previously couldn’t remember were actually printed in the exam booklet, so I could work things out!!

PaperMonster · 22/08/2021 10:47

1986 was probably when I did my AO. I was at college.

Cookerhood · 22/08/2021 10:30

One girl in my year got 8 As & another 6. I remember the gasp in the assembly when it was announced. This was at a school where no-one did CSEs. It was unheard of to get such fantastic results. I got one A, went on to get BCC at A level & studied a science subject at a uni where you now need A A A.

Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 22/08/2021 09:31

@Seashor

PaperMonster, you’re the only other person I’ve come across with an O A level!!
I also have one !
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/08/2021 08:59

Yes, IMO they must be considerably easier. So many people getting strings of As was very rare.

I did O levels at a very good girls’ grammar school. To get an A (or a 1 as it was then) you generally had to be pretty good at a subject and work hard at it.
IIRC the only girl in our entire year (of around 90) who got all As was a very gifted one who was a year younger than everybody else anyway, who’d passed the 11 plus at 10.

The only school exam she ever failed was the pre O level compulsory music one, because despite the super- brain she was tone deaf!

The only A I got was in French, which I took early. I was very good at it (I was only ever good at languages) and worked hard at it - just wish I could say the same for some other subjects. It took me two goes to just pass O level maths.

sluj · 22/08/2021 08:53

I was part of a pilot scheme for my year and took an exam they were going to call the 16+ in Chemistry. This was 1979. We didn't do anything different for it. I did traditional O levels for everything else being an academic child. 😄
I remember queuing up for my results and being given a separate envelope first. This had a CSE grade 1 for chemistry in it. I do remember thinking "oh no, I only got a cse, I must have fails for the others which were all o'levels". I then got a separate piece of paper with the O levels on, which included an A in chemistry - so I got a cse and an O level grade.
I took 2 x AOs in the lower sixth so actually ended up with 11 x O levels and that CSE, not common in those days.
I was at a heavily streamed comprehensive school and some of my friends took a mixture of CSE and O level classes. You were streamed for virtually every subject so you could be in the right place for your own strengths without having to be good at everything. It worked well.

Ponoka7 · 22/08/2021 08:50

I was always in the top set. I went on to do a degree as a mature student. We wasn't given the option of anything other than CSEs. Our school was one of the worst in Liverpool and later closed. There was no suggestion of us doing A levels or University. Most of the people who went there underachieved.
I was shocked when my DD was behind at school, because of dyslexia, how in Kent and other places a pupil would get intervention at 14 months behind, but in Liverpool it was 2 years eight months. We don't all have access to the same education.

Badbadbunny · 22/08/2021 08:43

@Seashor

I took O levels. Grades A-C were a pass. CSE’s we’re easier and in all honesty worthless unless you got a Grade 1 which was equivalent to a C grade O level. I also have two O/A levels which I think must be equivalent to a current A S .
I have a O grade in A level Physics. It meant you were still at O level standard, so not an A level pass, but not a "U" either.

Nearly all our class got O or U for A level Physics, the teachers was absolutely hopeless. He was some kind of upper class twit - bursting into operatic song or quoting Shakespeare randomly during lessons. He knew the subject, but was clearly bored by teaching it. Most of the lessons were "we're going to do radioactivity today - read chapter 12, make notes on it, do the end of chapter questions" that was the sum total of his "teaching" - just telling us to do it ourselves basically!

SallyOMalley · 22/08/2021 08:43

Ah - here you go: Alternative O Levels, last examined in 1988.

Was there a big difference in academic standard between O-Levels and CSEs?
SallyOMalley · 22/08/2021 08:40

@Seashor

PaperMonster, you’re the only other person I’ve come across with an O A level!!
I thought they were called AO levels? I've got one in Human Biology.
MrsMoastyToasty · 22/08/2021 08:40

I went to a selective boarding school. CSEs weren't an option available to us.
The school would stream us at the end of the 3rd year (current year 9) for maths and English language. If you got over 70% in those exams you were put I the top set and did the course in one year, taking the o level at the end of year 10. You then did AO maths and English literature as a one year course in year 11.
I got 71% percent in both subjects and went into the higher group. I struggled and got a C in both, then failed both AO maths and English literature the following year.
Our school also used a variety of curriculums and examination boards. Mostly the Cambridge board but I also did domestic science with SUJB (Southern universities joint board).

Badbadbunny · 22/08/2021 08:35

@RampantIvy

Given that there are foundation and higher levels for GCSE maths, English and science we don't seem to have moved on much from CSE and O levels.
The more things change, the more they stay the same! That's certainly the case with schools and school exams. Lots of re-arranging chairs on the Titanic but very little tangible "change" over the past 50 years.
FuzzyPuffling · 22/08/2021 08:34

@Seashor

PaperMonster, you’re the only other person I’ve come across with an O A level!!
I've got a couple, including geology.
borntobequiet · 22/08/2021 08:27

@Mathscourses, here are some more. I can’t find any CSE papers.

www.emaths.co.uk/index.php/teacher-resources/classroom-materials/very-old-exam-papers/category/o-level

However I had in the early 1970s a friend who had attended a secondary modern school and had a string of Grade 1 CSEs. She seemed to have a really good understanding of what she’d learnt, and I realised that much of my learning (selective, voluntary aided, Catholic school) had been by process and rote. It took me many years to deconstruct my learning and understand properly.

thegcatsmother · 22/08/2021 08:24

I have O levels and CSEs. I also have a CEE. There was doubt I would pass O level Chemistry and Maths, so I was entered for CSE as well. Good thing too, as I was ungraded in both the O levels. As I got a CSE 2 in Maths, I did a CEE at sixth form, and got a grade that was an O level equivalent. That allowed me to do my degree and later my PGCE.

RancidOldHag · 22/08/2021 05:58

Didn't it used to be that Grammar schools offered O-levels and the Secondary Modern schools didn't really do qualifications

It was never as clear cut as that.

I went to a grammar, and we sat mainly O levels, but in maths and French (setted subjects) the top 2 sets were O level and the lower 2 were CSE. Everyone did O levels for English and for some options such as history and geography, but there were CSEs for some in sciences (everyone had to do at least one).

This was before coursework was part of the assessment - so the maximum number anyone took was 9, up from the 8 when my older siblings did theirs on the old 1-9 scale.

The local secondary mods varied - one had levels of O levels not too different to the grammars but pupils might sit fewer (6-8) the more typical ones had O levels for top sets in some subjects , one was nearly all CSE.

Before CSEs many secondary mod pupils left with no qualifications at all.

Some exam syllabuses were aligned, so it was possible to teach a similar course and decide only later on which exam. Others not so - the O level maths I did included calculus, and was streets away from the CSE.

Auntienumber8 · 22/08/2021 03:03

I have 8 O levels, DH has 10 O levels. He took his when he was 14 and his A levels when he was 16. He is the bigger nerd. As far as I’m aware only 20% of dc sat O levels.

They were all unseen exams and no coursework. My friend fainted in one due to stress on the day.

Mathscourses · 22/08/2021 01:20

@borntobequiet, thank you for linking to those 1967 O level Maths papers.

To me it’s very clear that they are much harder than any GCSE Maths papers I can remember teaching. What I didn’t notice when I took my O level Maths in 1969 is the male bias. In those papers one question refers to a “householder” with no sex specified and eight others use man, boy or male pronouns, for example “ a student......he.... “
There’s no mention anywhere of woman, girl or “she”.

Something else those papers show is the difference between the various specifications although all are O level. That makes it difficult to compare results from people who took both O level and CSE papers in the same subject. The syllabuses (syllabi) presumably weren’t identical and the teachers probably favoured teaching one or the other, depending on what they thought gave their students the best chance.

Etulosba · 22/08/2021 00:54

I did CSE maths. I got a grade one. The paper was ridiculously easy. I finished in half an hour. I got a B at O level. I struggled with calculus.

LangClegsInSpace · 22/08/2021 00:52

@Seashor

PaperMonster, you’re the only other person I’ve come across with an O A level!!
I've got an O A in biological studies. It was a 1 year course after taking biology o level early. It was all about ecosystems and we did loads of field work. Out of everything I learned at school, that course was my favourite and the one I've remembered most from, decades later.
Swipe left for the next trending thread