Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU princess parties is this what we are inspiring our girls to be ?

239 replies

bottleitsellit · 21/08/2021 15:09

Just been to a Princess birthday party, my first one. So a women acts as your princess of choice with the wig and outfit and runs the party games instead of the parents. I just feel so sad about how all the girls were gushing over it. I suppose I wasn't brought up with princesses as my mum was very much a tomboy and I have lots of older brothers. My girls have fairies, witches amongst their toys just as my DS has dragons, Harry Potter, but we have really haven't gone with princesses as it's a bit old fashioned, a knight on a horse saving you. Maybe it's just me, they will prob now want princess everything 😬

OP posts:
smmanf12 · 22/08/2021 08:58

Many women have both elements to their personality don’t they? Sometimes I like to wear a dress, make up, spend a bit longer on my hair. I might do my nails. Sometimes I like jeans and minimal make up. I like going to spas and being pampered, but I also love going to B&Q and choosing paint and wallpaper.

Lessthanaballpark · 22/08/2021 08:48

Why should little girls aspire to be more like men, and enjoy more masculine things?

Define masculine things

gobackanddoitproperly · 22/08/2021 08:38

Meh. They grow out of it.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/08/2021 08:37

The only reason at certain age, why i wasn't living in the pr8ncess dress my mum made, was because it's difficult to climb trees in them.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/08/2021 08:36

I had barbies. I also had car toys and garages and Merkur toy collection to be envied. I had princess dress, but refused long hair and spent most time in mud covered overalls. I had glittery pencil case in primary, which was usually just used to hit annoying classmates with. Obsession with horses so i got big encyclopedia to flick through and dream about the pretty Palomino, while also reading knowledge magazines for kids and learning how to use axe etc in a forest and thoroughly enjoying it.

Contrary to popular belief, girls can actually manage to have a wide range of things they like.
And one of them can be oprincesses
I hope you all against liking princesses also have your "skin crawl" when boys lay with cars or pretend to be the Hulk🤷🏻 or is it just fluffy and sparkly which isn't ok

DelphineMarineaux · 22/08/2021 07:57

*femininity
*something wrong

DelphineMarineaux · 22/08/2021 07:57

@bottleitsellit

Just been to a Princess birthday party, my first one. So a women acts as your princess of choice with the wig and outfit and runs the party games instead of the parents. I just feel so sad about how all the girls were gushing over it. I suppose I wasn't brought up with princesses as my mum was very much a tomboy and I have lots of older brothers. My girls have fairies, witches amongst their toys just as my DS has dragons, Harry Potter, but we have really haven't gone with princesses as it's a bit old fashioned, a knight on a horse saving you. Maybe it's just me, they will prob now want princess everything 😬
Why would you teach your daughter that there's something wrong with being girly, feminine and enjoying princessy things? Why should little girls aspire to be more like men, and enjoy more masculine things?

I'd rather teach my daughter to embrace her girliness and feminity, and teach her that there's nothing wrong with being a girl, and everything that comes with it. Whether we like it or not, boys and girls are generally biologically wired to be drawn to certain things. Instead, too many people classify this as "gender stereotypes" and try to change nature and biology. Shame on you. Let your girls be girls and your boys be boys. There's nothing to be proud of in being a tomboy or a boy that "enjoys dolls". It is what it is if that's the case, but it's not better than girls that enjoy dolls and boys that enjoy trucks.

saraclara · 22/08/2021 07:51

it's mainly all about little girls looking pretty, dressing in flouncy dresses, making their hair look pretty etc etc etc

Those same little girls see cosmetic and hair products advertised on the TV every day using beautiful models. They see their mothers choose and try on new clothes to look nice, put on make up and make their hair look good in order to look attractive. Yet you think it's a one off princess party that makes them want to look pretty?

saraclara · 22/08/2021 07:45

I'd much rather my daughter have a muddy, forest party or an art party or something less trite and cliched.

But what does SHE want?

Lessthanaballpark · 22/08/2021 07:36

It's all good as long as they're expressing who they really are. Just let them enjoy expressing themselves.

I think it’s interesting that both sides of the argument both want this for their girls but differ with regards to whether that is what is currently what is happening.

One side think princess culture is allowing girls to express themselves whilst the other side thinks it stifles their freedom to express themselves by being the only thing on offer.

Lessthanaballpark · 22/08/2021 07:29

As long as the child is allowed to pick the opposite gendered toy if they choose it's no big deal

I just don’t think most kids have the capacity to do that. Most kids just go along with stereotypes and expectations, especially gendered ones. There was a BBC documentary a while back that really showed that by primary school kids have very clear ideas of what men and women can or cannot do.

Lots of our behaviours are nurtured, doesn't mean it's wrong or has to be changed

That’s true so then let’s drop the pretence that girls are innately drawn to sparkle, nail polish etc and accept that what they are drawn to is girlhood, the specific trappings of which vary according to time and cultures.

In other words, as long as the kid is happy, does it matter if society has influenced them

Absolutely but I would add to that “as long as the kid is happy, free and encouraged to choose their own interests”

I am not knocking Princess culture. Yes I personally hate the plastic aesthetic of it but there is nothing inherently wrong with pink and a lot of the modern princesses have really adapted to the times.

Polkadots2021 · 22/08/2021 07:01

@bottleitsellit

Just been to a Princess birthday party, my first one. So a women acts as your princess of choice with the wig and outfit and runs the party games instead of the parents. I just feel so sad about how all the girls were gushing over it. I suppose I wasn't brought up with princesses as my mum was very much a tomboy and I have lots of older brothers. My girls have fairies, witches amongst their toys just as my DS has dragons, Harry Potter, but we have really haven't gone with princesses as it's a bit old fashioned, a knight on a horse saving you. Maybe it's just me, they will prob now want princess everything 😬
Every little girl has the right to be a princess or wish they were Action Man or anything in between. Doesn't matter if they shatter or completely conform to gender norms, sparkly things, boxing, princesses, trucks, dancing or hard-nosed legal careers. It's all good as long as they're expressing who they really are. Just let them enjoy expressing themselves.
purplebatbear · 22/08/2021 01:26

@smmanf12

Whilst you're absolutely right about the fact that there are lots of princesses on those films that are lore feisty, the bottom line is that at these parties it's mainly all about little girls looking pretty, dressing in flouncy dresses, making their hair look pretty etc etc etc. They often put on affected, simpering Americanised accents (I've suffered through many of these horrendous parties) and they really do make my skin crawl. It's all very affected, very much about appearances and just (in my opinion) cringey.

I'd much rather my daughter have a muddy, forest party or an art party or something less trite and cliched.

saraclara · 21/08/2021 23:36

I don't think there's been a simpering heroine in a Disney film since the Little Mermaid. And even she had her feisty moments. Kids aren't growing up with Snow White waiting on seven men any more.

Kids should have access to dolls, lego, toy cars and everything in between, whatever their sex. And if a little girl wants a princess party, FFS let her have one. It's not going to turn her into a vacuous simpering wimp.

AllTheSingleLadiess · 21/08/2021 23:33

I suspect that our girls are more affected by seeing the important adult women in their lives wear makeup and spend more time on beauty and fashion than their dads. (I'm not saying that all women spend more time on grooming than males or that children live with a mum and dad)

I understand that the standards for grooming is higher when you're a woman but the only people who can end that are grown up women. Men can just wear a suit where as women generally have work clothes in various colours and styles and have to spend extra time and effort doing hair and makeup to simply look what is considered professional. Look at the sort of clothes women wear to get married. A wedding dress is peak princess and I'd understand why little girls think that they want that too. (Luckily ime most girls move away from that pretty quickly )

smmanf12 · 21/08/2021 23:16

@purplebatbear

YANBU I cannot stand Princess parties or, as they get a bit older, Pamper parties. I find the whole thing really quite sexist and I don't encourage them at all. My daughter has never had play makeup or any of that nonsense but has be bought god awful princess dresses by relatives that make my skin crawl. I'd much rather she dressed up as some kick-ass heroine who doesn't rely on any man that most of the sexist Disneyesque tripe!!!!
Makes your skin crawl? Bit dramatic

Also Elsa, Merida and Moana don’t get romantically involved with anyone. Belle turned down Gaston and went to rescue her dad, and Tiana worked her butt off to afford her own restaurant. Not sure if Mulan is classed as a Disney princess but she literally ran away to fight a war by pretending to be a man. It’s just not true to say that they’re all sat about waiting to be rescued by a man.

Phantom1 · 21/08/2021 23:16

Isn't this just a way to sell you something? You extra pay for what would normally be just a birthday party. It seems that this the way to go now. Jacqueline Jossa has these very girly-themed parties with make-up and nail bar stuff around for the girls to play with. See Daily Mail for more info. Blush

purplebatbear · 21/08/2021 23:08

YANBU
I cannot stand Princess parties or, as they get a bit older, Pamper parties. I find the whole thing really quite sexist and I don't encourage them at all. My daughter has never had play makeup or any of that nonsense but has be bought god awful princess dresses by relatives that make my skin crawl. I'd much rather she dressed up as some kick-ass heroine who doesn't rely on any man that most of the sexist Disneyesque tripe!!!!

Bouledeneige · 21/08/2021 23:04

I'm a feminist. My DD loved princesses, barbies and fairies and all that girlie stuff when she was young. She's now 21 and a bold and brave feminist. I couldn't suppress it shaker her tastes nor should I. She was infused by the cultural interests she was surrounded by but she made up her own mind in the end.

Let it be.

Adrianneanneanne · 21/08/2021 22:56

@Lessthanaballpark

Why not leave it up to the child? And if someone does steer their daughter toward princesses rather than something else, so what? As long as they ultimately allow their child to herself with her own interests, there's nothing wrong with choosing some early toys, clothes, and decor on the theme that the parent likes.

This post is full of contradictions. Let the child choose what they want? Steer them to what the parents like?

It’s all very well to say the child will ultimately choose what they like, but how do they know what they like if it’s not a real option for them? Besides children sense what their parents want them to like and act accordingly.

What we should want for our kids is real choice. Not the fake choice to choose between a limited number of options.

I don't think what they said is contradictory. Basically do what we can to avoid stereotypes but you can never avoid that influence 100%

If a parent buys princess dresses for their daughter at Christmas, what does it really matter? If the child likes the toy, it's not harming them in and of itself. Parents mostly do buy gendered toys. As long as the child is allowed to pick the opposite gendered toy if they choose it's no big deal

Lots of our behaviours are nurtured, doesn't mean it's wrong or has to be changed

In other words, as long as the kid is happy, does it matter if society has influenced them

DrSbaitso · 21/08/2021 22:51

@Lessthanaballpark

The most stereotypical female character was Mrs Weasley, and she ruled her family and killed Bellatrix. And Hermione got loads of praise for being so able.

It would be nice if girls didn’t have to be so able all the time.

So we complain when they're passive and the boys do everything, and we complain when they're heroic and save the day. How exactly are we supposed to write women?
mellicauli · 21/08/2021 22:48

I think you need to update your idea of princesses. They do a lot more than be rescued these days..

Lessthanaballpark · 21/08/2021 22:41

The most stereotypical female character was Mrs Weasley, and she ruled her family and killed Bellatrix. And Hermione got loads of praise for being so able.

It would be nice if girls didn’t have to be so able all the time.

Lessthanaballpark · 21/08/2021 22:39

Why not leave it up to the child? And if someone does steer their daughter toward princesses rather than something else, so what? As long as they ultimately allow their child to herself with her own interests, there's nothing wrong with choosing some early toys, clothes, and decor on the theme that the parent likes.

This post is full of contradictions. Let the child choose what they want? Steer them to what the parents like?

It’s all very well to say the child will ultimately choose what they like, but how do they know what they like if it’s not a real option for them? Besides children sense what their parents want them to like and act accordingly.

What we should want for our kids is real choice. Not the fake choice to choose between a limited number of options.

DrSbaitso · 21/08/2021 22:36

@InTheNightWeWillWish

My girls have fairies, witches amongst their toys

Neither of these have a more positive representation of women than princesses to be honest. Fairies tend to be kind, gentle spirits which could encourage girls to buy into the idea they just be kind. Fairies are also portrayed as airheads, ditzy. Witches have historically been portrayed as cruel, ugly, old women. They don’t fit the stereotypical view of a kind hearted, beautiful woman and therefore they must be evil. More recently, I would argue the image of a witch is that of a studious girl who can break the rules (quietly) when the ends justify the means. That’s the bulk of Harry Potter, while the men get to stumble around generally being useless and get praised for saving the day (I’m a Harry Potter fan by the way but aware of the limitations of the book). The other option is the witch gets to be a bit ditzy, a bit clumsy but still generally loveable because she’s trying, means well and is kind (the worst witch and Luna Lovegood spring to mind here).

Just because your children like less mainstream things, doesn’t mean they’re any better for breaking stereotypes.

Be fair. All the characters in Harry Potter had flaws and limitations. That's one reason why the books are so good. Luna clearly got her loopiness from her father, if anything he was ditzier than she was. The most stereotypical female character was Mrs Weasley, and she ruled her family and killed Bellatrix. And Hermione got loads of praise for being so able.
Swipe left for the next trending thread