Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this Why We Eat Too Much is a fad?

137 replies

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 14:47

OK - probably provocative title, and I’m not trying to be goady or anything like that.

However, I’m losing weight. Every time I click on a weight loss thread this book is being pushed at people.

I remember this happening with Paul McKenna and more recently some Facebook weight group, then it was all about fasting. AIBU to think it’s another faddy thing?

Will have a look at the threads but does anyone want to convince me otherwise? Smile

OP posts:
SquirryTheSquirrel · 21/08/2021 18:23

I've lost 2 1/2 stone 'inspired' by this book. I don't 100% avoid the foods Jenkinson doesn't recommend, because I don't see it as a proscriptive diet, but I've cut out all ultra-processed food and cut down drastically on processed food (only have cereal and occasionally bread). I cook most of my meals from scratch now. I feel healthier and the weight has come off albeit slowly, although that might be my age. Struggling to lose the last half a stone so may have to do something more drastic but I intend when I get there to maintain by following the Jenkinson principles.

As pps have said, it's a very sustainable way of eating.

I can only say it worked for me. It won't work for everyone - nothing does - but that's no reason to knock it generally. I don't think much of Slimming World, for example, as a way of eating for me - but if it works for others, great!

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 18:21

It’s not strange at all Biwi. I’ve asked a question and it’s been answered - like literally the whole of the rest of MN.

Start a thread about spray painting a pigeon and it goes in classics, ask whether a diet is faddy and it’s ‘strange’ Hmm (I love the pigeon post but you get my meaning …)

OP posts:
phishy · 21/08/2021 18:20

Agree with BIWI. Strange thread.

inmyslippers · 21/08/2021 18:19

Currently listening to the audiobook. I've spent years dieting. Lose weight then put it back on and more. Sw, ww, calorie counting, meal replacement, fasting, keto, low carb, bro food. If there's a way out this hell you can bet your booty I'll try it

BIWI · 21/08/2021 18:14

What a strange thread to start then!

People who have read the book/do know what it's about have tried to answer you, in good faith.

No-one is pushing anything - we're just trying to answer your questions.

Oh, and it isn't a diet book. It's about the science and then it develops the principles of a diet.

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 18:09

And believe me, you don’t ‘stuff’ yourself full of protein shakes.

OP posts:
Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 18:08

Of course it doesn’t upset me.

It can be a bit annoying when you want to start or read a thread about weight loss and people keep pushing the same thing. It closes down the conversation.

But it’s a mild annoyance, certainly not an ‘upset.’

OP posts:
TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 21/08/2021 18:02

Why does it upset you? If you don’t want to read it then don’t, but you started a whole thread about it, which is weird.

Anyway, I had 3 to 3.5 stone to lose in April. I’ve lost 12lb with this without really noticing - slow but steady, I haven’t counted anything, I haven’t stuffed myself with protein shakes, I haven’t walked 15k steps a day, I haven’t stuck to it 100% either. The main things I took from it were to cut out sugar, wheat and processed oils eg vegetable oil, and any other ultra processed food. I’m still eating bacon. I’m most successful with cutting sugar - have it very rarely these days. But I do have occasional takeaways and I’ve still lost weight.

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 17:52

But we don’t want to read it, Biwi!

OP posts:
Stevie6 · 21/08/2021 17:36

I haven't read the book but know
People who have, it's not for me. I lost my weight doing very strict low fat/low carb and have been at my target weight for 2 years. I use calorie counting now to maintain. It depends on what works best for you individually, I found the all or nothing approach worked best for me

Stevie6 · 21/08/2021 17:32

@Theythinkitsalloveritisnow I had the same thought re squirrels and laughed when I saw your comment

BIWI · 21/08/2021 17:31

@gwenneh

It's a book which is part of an industry which, if the advice given actually worked in a broad sense, would cease to exist.

Barring medical issues, the only way to lose weight is to find a way to eat that means you consume fewer calories than you expend, forever. It means having a detailed picture of your energy expenditure for the day, and an accurate grip on your food consumption. It means doing those two things in such a way that you can do it every day, for as long as you live -- and the diet industry is well aware that most people won't do that with their "plans" so they come back for more.

The more things you need to restrict (don't eat this type of food, don't eat at this time, avoid this or that) the more likely it will fail UNLESS you can keep those things up.

If you read the book and it introduces you to a sustainable way for you to live in a caloric deficit, then terrific.

If you read the book, you'll find a very clear explanation as to why calorie restriction doesn't work in the longer term.
Maddison12 · 21/08/2021 17:26

First ad I seen when I clicked on this thread Grin

To think this Why We Eat Too Much is a fad?
Boombadoom · 21/08/2021 17:17

Reading this thread really hammers home how badly the diet industry has screwed with people’s minds.

Being healthy isn’t about fitting into size 10 jeans. There is more to a calorie than a calorie. You can eat cake all day long within 1200 calories and you’ll feel like shit, your skin will be shit, you’ll sleep like shit etc etc.

Or 1200 calories without even realising that’s all you’ve had in lean proteins, and loads of wholesome fibre in a really balanced diet. Natural weight loss than you don’t even notice, maintenance of your endocrine system and other hormones. I know which i’d rather choose.

The problem is people want to eat shit and lose weight. In which case go back to SW - there’s a reason that business is worth billions and it isn’t because it works. It’s because you fall on and off the wagon 20 times a year for 20 years.

Enjoy!

gwenneh · 21/08/2021 17:01

It's a book which is part of an industry which, if the advice given actually worked in a broad sense, would cease to exist.

Barring medical issues, the only way to lose weight is to find a way to eat that means you consume fewer calories than you expend, forever. It means having a detailed picture of your energy expenditure for the day, and an accurate grip on your food consumption. It means doing those two things in such a way that you can do it every day, for as long as you live -- and the diet industry is well aware that most people won't do that with their "plans" so they come back for more.

The more things you need to restrict (don't eat this type of food, don't eat at this time, avoid this or that) the more likely it will fail UNLESS you can keep those things up.

If you read the book and it introduces you to a sustainable way for you to live in a caloric deficit, then terrific.

Tiredandbored · 21/08/2021 16:55

I've read the book and post on the threads about it as it has worked for me.

However, I'm very aware that it may not work for everyone - just as SW and WW and 5:2 work for some people but not everyone.

What intrigued me about this way of eating was not having to count and weigh everything I'm eating so it has been much easier and more sustainable for me than any other diet I've done.

Consequently I've lost over 2 stones and am confident I can keep that weight off as I'm not finding the diet restrictive or overly demanding.

Not everyone may agree, but I can only speak from my own experience.

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 16:53

Shakes are available although I don’t find them all that filling so I go for porridge, meals, bars. I did what used to be Cambridge, but there are cheaper ones - exante I think.

OP posts:
Meraas · 21/08/2021 16:52

What is a meal replacement? Shakes? Which ones do you use?

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 16:47

I’ve lost 4 stone - still got 2 to go - and I didn’t have surgery, @LineofFruity

I did meal replacements. They aren’t for everybody, but I do find they work for me.

OP posts:
Burgerqueenbee · 21/08/2021 16:47

I enjoyed the book as information rather than using it as a diet method so I can't comment on the efficacy of the diet plan suggested.

It does however say in the book that it isn't you that is doing it wrong when a diet fails, it goes into damaged metabolism and evolutionary reasons why it is hard to be successful, particularly if you have dieted many times.

LineofFruity · 21/08/2021 16:46

I’m reading this book at the moment and finding it utterly depressing as it seems to tell me the only way I can lose weight is surgery. I’ve started googling surgery costs.

No matter what I try, I can’t shift the 4 stone I need to lose (well 3.5 stone to be BMI 24 which Id be happy with).

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 21/08/2021 16:41

@wiltonism

I have and actually I was less impressed by the book than by the threads on here.

Firstly, his main expertise is in gastric surgery, which is great but not actually repeatable unless you are going to get operated on.

He's trying to reproduce the effects of gastric surgery via diet, and I am not sure how straightforward that is.

There is some confused advice in there (don't eat wheat/eat pasta salad; the Japanese diet is very healthy but don't eat tofu).

His big idea - don't eat nuts and seeds so that your body doesn't store fat for autumn is not clinically proven, it's a hypothesis.

Plenty of people on threads on here do lose weight with it, it's a good old fashioned healthy eating plan. I don't, because it's not enough of a change for me. I eat very healthily, just too much of it!

Don't eat nuts and seeds so you don't store fat for autumn? Is the book aimed at humans or squirrels?
Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 16:40

I think I’ve got enough of an idea from the posts above, to be honest. I’m fairly sure it wouldn’t suit me, and I must admit I’m not a massive fan of diet books generally.

OP posts:
NutellaEllaElla · 21/08/2021 16:40

I think there will always be "new" ways of losing weight. They will all work if you can and do stick to them forever. They're all the same but different.

BIWI · 21/08/2021 16:38

Why don't you read it and see what you think?