Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this Why We Eat Too Much is a fad?

137 replies

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 14:47

OK - probably provocative title, and I’m not trying to be goady or anything like that.

However, I’m losing weight. Every time I click on a weight loss thread this book is being pushed at people.

I remember this happening with Paul McKenna and more recently some Facebook weight group, then it was all about fasting. AIBU to think it’s another faddy thing?

Will have a look at the threads but does anyone want to convince me otherwise? Smile

OP posts:
SquirryTheSquirrel · 22/08/2021 11:19

You could apply the Jenkinson principles to almost any diet that's based on food rather than meal replacements. SW/WW in fairness do advocate cooking from scratch - you just wouldn't be using 'FryLight' etc. in the recipes. And it would be easy to apply it to low carbing/LCHF - just avoid any 'dirty low carbing' with processed meats.

HighlandCowbag · 21/08/2021 21:47

I don't think it is particularly restricted tbh. I think a modern diet is restricted by what is readily available. Which (and there are stats based on supermarkets available) is dictated by what is cheap to produce for the mass market. And is desirable to the mass market.

Chicken is cheap to raise from egg to a chicken. Packaged in a whole chicken os probably lb for lb the cheapest. But 1 chicken may sell for £4. Butcher that chicken and you may get £6. Mince it and mix with cheap fillers, coat it with a cheap batter and you may get 15 bags of 20 chicken nuggets. At £2 each with an additional cost of 50p (all.made up figures btw). But it's still more profit than a whole chicken to roast. And more accessible to people wanting a quick meal, or with fussy kids.

If I want to buy lunch out, other than a prepared salad not much I can eat that avoids processed or UPF. But at home I can easily make a salad with protein of some sort.

The woe os restricted by supermarkets and takeaways not by what you can eat.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 21/08/2021 21:34

[quote BIWI]@TooExtraImmatureCheddar

These things go in cycles. At one point it was Biwi’s bootcamp, then it was 5:2 and later, Fast 800, that was recommended everywhere. I’ve been here 10 years. Calorie counting is recommended on every single weight loss thread. I personally have tried loads of diets, and I find this one the least effort. Others may differ.

Firstly, the Low Carb Bootcamps are still going here - I started them in 2012, so it's not 9 years on. Hardly a fad!

And second, calorie counting is definitely not recommended on Bootcamp.

I really resent the insinuation that low carbing/the Bootcamp is a fad. It's based on solid science.[/quote]
Sorry BIWI, I didn’t mean to imply that the bootcamp is a fad. I lost 20lb on it post baby 1, and I know it’s still going. I meant that in terms of what’s recommended most, not in terms of what actually works or is backed up by science. Just what’s currently popular on MN.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 21/08/2021 21:18

@CalishataFolkart

Is it just semantics that this is described as not being restrictive but there are foods that are restricted (some carbs, added sugar, “ultra processed”)?
Yes - by 'restrictive' I was meaning in quantity, not type of food.

There is no calorie counting, weighing or measuring involved.

You are 'restricted' in the types of food you can eat - not carbs per se, but refined carbs (including sugar), processed and ultra processed foods. You can have naturally occurring carbs such rice, potatoes and those in fruit.

CalishataFolkart · 21/08/2021 21:14

Is it just semantics that this is described as not being restrictive but there are foods that are restricted (some carbs, added sugar, “ultra processed”)?

HighlandCowbag · 21/08/2021 21:12

Im a serial yoyo dieter. I've been following this way of eating for about 4 months I think. In reality I've cut out most processed food, wheat mostly and sugar. Have lost about 17lbs and don't feel like I am on a diet.

It's not meant to be a diet book tbf, it's meant to be a scientific explanation about why the western world is getting heavier.

Follow it or don't. Makes absolutely no difference to anyone else. Read the book, read around the book and take it from there. But anyone who thinks 30 ingredients in a shake, probably 10 they don't know what they are is healthier and more conducive to long term weight loss than a tuna salad, or a grilled steak with veg wants their bumps feeling.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 21/08/2021 21:02

Eat cake! Eat ice cream!' spiel. People love that promise.

Er ... cake and ice cream don't feature in the Jenkinson diet! You avoid foods with added sugar (or added anything).

As BIWI says, why not read the book before criticising it? I'm sure you could get it from the library if you don't want to spend money on it.

BIWI · 21/08/2021 20:51

Oh, the good old 'Get thin without ever feeling hungry! No foods off limits! Eat cake! Eat ice cream!' spiel. People love that promise

That is so far off the mark, it's not true.

Don't make such fatuous comments.

If you could be even bothered to read the book you'd realise that your post is embarrassing.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/08/2021 20:49

@SquirryTheSquirrel

Calorie counting isn't recommended by Jenkinson, either. Restrictive diets are the opposite of what he recommends - his theory is that restricting what you eat teaches your body to expect periods of 'famine' so you are even more prone to lay down fat to prepare for it.
Oh, the good old 'Get thin without ever feeling hungry! No foods off limits! Eat cake! Eat ice cream!' spiel. People love that promise.
SquirryTheSquirrel · 21/08/2021 20:44

I don't think he addresses the impact of poverty on diet and time. Hard to cook from scratch when you are working long hours.

Yes, that would deserve its own book really.

jewel1968 · 21/08/2021 20:35

To be honest it's reasonable to be wary of another book designed to help people lose weight. Who benefits? Follow the money etc...
I have read it and a lot of it makes sense to me but not all of it. I am interested more from an anti inflammation perspective (arthritis). The main thing that strikes me from the thread I have been involved in is that most people weigh themselves which he suggests you don't. He is trying to get people to think about what they eat more holistically and weight loss should be a happy coincidence. Lots on the thread say they have lost lots of weight so there may be something in it.

I don't think he addresses the impact of poverty on diet and time. Hard to cook from scratch when you are working long hours.

Anyway I think it's interesting and worth a read.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 21/08/2021 20:33

Calorie counting isn't recommended by Jenkinson, either. Restrictive diets are the opposite of what he recommends - his theory is that restricting what you eat teaches your body to expect periods of 'famine' so you are even more prone to lay down fat to prepare for it.

BIWI · 21/08/2021 20:28

It's now, not not 9 years!

BIWI · 21/08/2021 20:27

@TooExtraImmatureCheddar

These things go in cycles. At one point it was Biwi’s bootcamp, then it was 5:2 and later, Fast 800, that was recommended everywhere. I’ve been here 10 years. Calorie counting is recommended on every single weight loss thread. I personally have tried loads of diets, and I find this one the least effort. Others may differ.

Firstly, the Low Carb Bootcamps are still going here - I started them in 2012, so it's not 9 years on. Hardly a fad!

And second, calorie counting is definitely not recommended on Bootcamp.

I really resent the insinuation that low carbing/the Bootcamp is a fad. It's based on solid science.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/08/2021 19:19

Why, if it works, has he made an extremely good living from permanently mutilating people's digestive systems? Is he also campaigning for bariatric surgery to be banned because it's no longer necessary now he's 'found' the answer in telling humans they aren't squirrels? Or is this just another multimillion pound moneyspinner punted out in the knowledge that when it goes out of fashion, he'll still have the reliable income of surgery?

TheWayTheLightFalls · 21/08/2021 18:58

I haven't read the book. I did 5:2 and lost 25kg on it. Will go back to it post-partum. It's sort of irrelevant to me that it's a fad - as in, that it got popular and was suddenly everywhere - because it's something that suits my particular way of eating and thinking. I'd wager that it's the same with all diets/books about dieting/trends - some things will work for some people.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 21/08/2021 18:57

I got a lot of replies urging me over but I was doing a totally different diet and my thread got buried a bit in people being a bit evangelical about it.

I can see why that would be annoying.

Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 18:56

That’s exactly my point @TooExtraImmatureCheddar - I say something similar in my OP.

The spray painted pigeon is a really good thread!

@lazylinguist to give an example, a few months ago I hit maintenance mode and it just was not shifting. I posted a thread about it. I got a lot of replies urging me over but I was doing a totally different diet and my thread got buried a bit in people being a bit evangelical about it.

I get you can’t always predict how threads will go. But it is a bit annoying when you need support!

OP posts:
SquirryTheSquirrel · 21/08/2021 18:54

@Mybalconyiscracking

I eat too much because I am a greedy guts and enjoy eating!
Jenkinson might suit you (that is, if you are looking to lose weight) because there's no weighing or counting - it's all about what you eat, not how much.

It's not a million miles away from low-carbing - it's naturally quite low in carbs but you can eat carby fruit and veg as much as you want - which is great for me as I'm an apple fiend.

lazylinguist · 21/08/2021 18:50

It can be a bit annoying when you want to start or read a thread about weight loss and people keep pushing the same thing. It closes down the conversation.

There are umpteen diets, and umpteen MN threads about weight loss, some of which follow particular diets and some of which don't. Most diets will work if people stick to them. The problem is that most people can't stick to them long term. Hence the lucrative merry-go-round of the diet industry.

You have to find what works for you. Maybe something will, maybe it won't. But why you're particularly picking on a book that seems scientifically pretty reliable, when there are loads of other less convincing-sounding diets out there, who knows!

Mybalconyiscracking · 21/08/2021 18:49

I eat too much because I am a greedy guts and enjoy eating!

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 21/08/2021 18:48

@Rainingonsaturday

Of course it doesn’t upset me.

It can be a bit annoying when you want to start or read a thread about weight loss and people keep pushing the same thing. It closes down the conversation.

But it’s a mild annoyance, certainly not an ‘upset.’

These things go in cycles. At one point it was Biwi’s bootcamp, then it was 5:2 and later, Fast 800, that was recommended everywhere. I’ve been here 10 years. Calorie counting is recommended on every single weight loss thread. I personally have tried loads of diets, and I find this one the least effort. Others may differ.
TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 21/08/2021 18:45

@Rainingonsaturday

It’s not strange at all Biwi. I’ve asked a question and it’s been answered - like literally the whole of the rest of MN.

Start a thread about spray painting a pigeon and it goes in classics, ask whether a diet is faddy and it’s ‘strange’ Hmm (I love the pigeon post but you get my meaning …)

There’s a thread about spray painting a pigeon? I need to read that.
TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 21/08/2021 18:43

@Rainingonsaturday

And believe me, you don’t ‘stuff’ yourself full of protein shakes.
That’s because they taste hideous. But I was really meaning when I was on Team RH and you had to hit a protein target which I could only get by eating so much Skyr I felt sick (because I refused to drink protein shakes).
Rainingonsaturday · 21/08/2021 18:38

Totally, it’s all individual, isn’t it?

OP posts: